HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Chardok

1,156 karma · joined March 1, 2017

submissionscomments
Chardok··on Mark Zuckerberg's Facebook hearing was a sham
If you have any doubts that this wasn't a sham just look at how well FB stock did yesterday.
Chardok··on How Genetics Is Changing Our Understanding of ‘Race’
This concept of a "race", in terms of genetics, makes sense for classification purposes, just like all taxonomical classifications of living things.

The difference here, is that people are taking this genetic concept of "race" and trying to prove their racist points, which always misses the point entirely. It would be a non-issue if the word "race" wasn't so politically charged.

Quick edit for 2 easy examples: People with African descent are more likely to have sickle cell anemia, due to the resistance the gene provides against malaria.

People with European descent are more likely to have cystic fibrosis, due to resistance it provided from cholera and typhoid.

Chardok··on Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour
This article practically comes off as apologetic for Facebook and absolutely ignores the point of outrage for a lot of people. Great example of language designed to lead.

"Facebook, of course, lets you target exactly those boring, old demographic qualities" - just boring old mundane everyday Facebook. No worries here

"To be clear, what Cambridge Analytica did was somewhat worse" - Just a bit worse, but not too far from the norm

"Facebook no longer allows anyone to do this, thankfully, and hasn’t for years" - this has been a non-issue for years, what are you worried about?

Chardok··on The Myth of Authenticity Is Killing Tex-Mex
The best part of the "great American melting pot" for me is the fusion of cuisines. Trying to knock a restaurant or food because it isn't "authentic" is completely missing the beauty of the different combinations of flavors and styles that arise. Texans know the difference between Mexican and Tex Mex, and can enjoy both without having to act like one is superior.

By the way if you've never had brisket chili I highly recommend it.

Chardok··on Facebook’s Surveillance Machine
>Saying "just quit Facebook" is like saying "just stop making phone calls" or "just get rid of your mailbox" or "just stop reading emails"

I don't agree with this analogy. Phone calls and physical/electronic mail are a technology, not a corporation. While I'm sure Facebook would like to be there, as it stands a Facebook account is nowhere near the importance of phones/mail to function in a modern society. In fact, I truly hope it does not reach that point, as a central authority like Facebook can choose to blacklist your accounts entirely. (https://techcrunch.com/2018/03/18/facebook-has-suspended-the...)

>"Leaving" Facebook is close to impossible. They track you and keep a profile on you no matter what.

This is mostly dependent on data being fed by your friends and family. Unfortunately, you enjoying events and sales is contributing to this "shadow profiling".

Chardok··on Facebook has suspended all social accounts of Cambridge Analytica whistleblower
This fact alone should be reason enough to leave Facebook for good. Facebook's goal is to be the middleman for all communication, and why the hell would you trust a corporation that can blacklist you from all of their platforms with a snap of a finger?
Chardok··on Facebook’s Surveillance Machine
It seems incredibly bizarre to me that the author says that.

She lists all the privacy and user trust violations, future social health concerns, but then says leaving Facebook isn't viable?

I have little faith in the US government regulating Facebook's privacy and data mining and even less faith that Facebook would take any action on behalf of its users privacy. Leaving Facebook is the only viable solution.

Chardok··on America’s technological hegemony is under threat from China
It is almost a punishment to try to better yourself in America, and our society will certainly suffer from it.

Why try to get a degree that doesn't guarantee any sort of employment, but does guarantee a large financial burden that follows you even beyond bankruptcy? It is absurd how short sighted our higher education system is here.

Chardok··on Reddit holds the secret to fixing Facebook
What I meant was that the numbered score they had next to every post was 0, which is incredibly atypical for that to show up on the front page.

And yes, Reddit removed the ability to see the number of upvotes/downvotes on any item a few years back. Just another way for them to obfuscate the actual results of a post.

Chardok··on Reddit holds the secret to fixing Facebook
If this article was 5-10 years ago, I would have agreed with most of it, but as it stands you are absolutely correct.

The Reddit algorithm now is incredibly opaque with constant tinkerings that make me think the "voting" is more of a placebo button on the front page. In recent memory, there were a few incidents of /r/The_Donald fully populating the front page, all with 0 upvote scores, which came off suspiciously as if they were deeply messing with the voting system.

Where it used to be a platform where you could be assured there would be minimal censorship, it is now commonplace to "shadowban" users who go against the narrative and the rules are arbitrarily enforced to ban subreddits. (Check out /r/shitredditsays for a subreddit that constantly breaks site rules but still stands unopposed)

Reddit is obviously striving for constantly more advertising friendly platform and it has been demonstrated multiple times upvotes are easily bought and advertisers are constantly sneaking in posts disguised as users to do their "viral marketing"

No, author, Reddit is moving right towards the direction of Facebook rapidly. It is only a matter of time before they begin to lock out content behind a login page, you can already see the transition today.

Chardok··on Prove you are not an evil corporate person
Funny we just saw Eric a few weeks ago rambling on about China overtaking us in AI (https://www.investopedia.com/news/china-will-overtake-us-ai-...)

Seems like he might be trying to prime the US into accepting Google's participation in warfare.

Chardok··on Hey Microsoft, Stop Installing Apps on My PC Without Asking
Unfortunately any workaround we find has been "broken" with the subsequent Windows update, meaning Microsoft is actively working against any fixes for it.

I would love to be proven wrong, but the only way I know for sure is upgrading to the Enterprise or education editions.

Chardok··on China Will Overtake the US in AI, said Alphabet's Eric Schmidt
Yet another US tech billionaire practically fetishizing China for their devotion to technology over people...

Sure, I can certainly get behind greater funding for scientific research and education for our benefit, but China is certainly not a country I would like to emulate whatsoever.

My biggest question is, what is the meaning and implication of China "dominating" the AI industries? China overtaking the US in military and commercial might? This honestly seems unlikely.

And a follow up question is, besides government funding, what else is China doing to secure AI dominance? Putting human rights and regulations on the back burner would appear give them a competitive advantage - but is this worth the cost of privacy and freedom for the average citizen?

'"Shockingly some of the best people are in countries we won't let into America,' he said. "Iran produces some of the smartest and top computer scientists in the world. I want them here. I want them working for Alphabet and Google. It's crazy not to let these people in."'

Well now I am not following this logic at all. What is China doing to make working there more attractive? I would imagine the US looks a lot more attractive than China in terms of freedom and safety regulations.

If anyone has a copy of the AI report in English I would greatly appreciate it.

Chardok··on An ER visit, a $12,000 bill – and a health insurer that wouldn’t pay
I am so fed up with the healthcare situation here. It is absolutely terrifying how this is remotely legal or even acceptable.

The game theory is plainly there: people are going to question or refuse to seek emergency treatment simply because they will be afraid of the cost. Now you get to add the stress of which type of care you should be getting, in the middle of a fucking scary medical emergency!

Chardok··on Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’t happen again
Kim Dotcom raid video is here - https://www.theguardian.com/technology/video/2012/aug/08/kim...

RIAA SWAT Raid in Atlanta - http://www.nytimes.com/2007/02/18/magazine/18djdrama.t.html

Those are the two biggest ones I can think of, but both are examples of literal deadly force used for copyright violations.

Chardok··on Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’t happen again
I am honestly sick of hearing "but no one will create anything without copyright" as if money was the sole motivator that made doing anything worthwhile.

To be fair, I think copyright has its place as a minimal safeguard for artists' work, but in its current form it is entirely too aggressive and lasts way beyond its scope should cover. Copyright should not be reason to send SWAT raids to people's homes, just as much as it should not cover 70 years after the artists' death.

I am certain that if we seriously rolled back copyright, our art would still thrive, albeit perhaps less AAA content.

Chardok··on Legal Marijuana Isn’t the Boon Small Businesses Thought It Would Be
This is interesting for the fact of watching a black market item go to retail and the expectations of "street" price versus actual market price might have been just too high.

There will certainly be a niche market for gourmet, organic, homegrown and cared for buds, but for the remainder of products: oils, waxes, edibles, infusions - you are not going to notice the difference between a small business and a larger growing operation except on price.

It seems rather obvious when you think about it though. I would compare cannabis to produce rather than beer/wine/spirits, in the sense that your small growers are going to have a tough time competing with giant farm operations, and will really have to differentiate themselves in specific ways to actually make it worth while.

Chardok··on Gamers Want DMCA Exemption for ‘Abandoned’ Online Games
With data rot beginning to creep up on old media this will certainly become an increasingly larger problem. https://kotaku.com/why-some-video-games-are-in-danger-of-dis...
Chardok··on Goldman Sachs Is Setting Up a Cryptocurrency Trading Desk
> maybe regulation could incentivize better data protection practices and pro-consumer behavior.

Perhaps I am too cynical but given Equifax is still fresh on my mind I really have doubts the US government will do anything but pass laws to make sure they are getting taxes from cryptocurrencies.

Chardok··on Big data meets Big Brother as China moves to rate its citizens
What really frightens me is how Tim Cook and Zuckerberg swoon head-over-heels for a country that implements such an aggressive top down control of their citizens as this program.

I have already become acutely aware of self censorship, especially with posts associated with my name, out of expectation of something similar making its way into the US. Heck, I would not be remotely surprised to find out Facebook already has a working prototype to associate and score people based on their connections.

Chardok··on How the US Pushed Sweden to Take Down the Pirate Bay
CGP Grey also did a fantastic video on the history of copyright and Disney's constant involvement. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tk862BbjWx4
Chardok··on Brain abnormalities found in victims of US embassy attack in Cuba
Pure amateur speculation here, especially given the lack of facts, but I wanted to bring up these two studies here on white matter changes.

https://utdallas.edu/~sxv140030/Published/134.pdf

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496540/

Could be possible an unknown infectious vector altering gene expression on the central nervous system?

Chardok··on Ajit Pai is right
Honestly I would have no issues with this if we actually had competition. My state forbids local municipalities from forming internet companies, so I am left with a single speed from cable company or a single speed, half of the cable companies, from ATT with data caps.

I can guarantee the cable company will all of a sudden charge more, for the same service, by tacking on tiered plans, while doing nothing to upgrade reliability, bandwidth, or really anything. Why would they? Where can one go, when ATT will do the exact same thing.

Ajit is wrong, based on the assumption that the free market will correct this issue.

Chardok··on Ajit Pai is right
Well what else are they going to do? Send comments to the FCC? How did that work for them?

Ajit is absolutely ignoring the majority message and there is absolutely nothing your average citizen can do about it. They can't vote on it, and the 3/5 Republicans have already made up their mind a long time ago.

Just to be clear, I think the personal attacks are wrong and uncivilized, but I understand that when there is no civilized outlet for people, they are going to act out.

Chardok··on US government approves 'killer' mosquitoes to fight disease
Except this proposal is widely accepted in the scientific community with hundreds of ecological studies behind it, where as the Four Pests was just speculation by a guy who likely never studied any modern biology.
Chardok··on US government approves 'killer' mosquitoes to fight disease
I am also wondering how mosquito populations are affected by increasing human populations. I can imagine with a lot of left out garbage collecting standing water plus being a food source could have given mosquitoes a unnatural advantage.
Chardok··on Comcast Tries to Derail Fort Collins Community Broadband
But Colorado is unique in that town and cities in the state have been able to vote locally on whether to overturn this ISP-lobbying-for-law

Once again Colorado has impressed me on the level of pragmatism they show in their state laws. They have been looking very politically healthy compared to the rest of the US, in my opinion, and I think it is going to pay off for them in the near future.

Chardok··on U.S. Consumer Bureau Loses Fight to Allow More Class-Action Suits
Agreed. The biggest issue I have with the parent comment is that the current Congress is unabashedly selectively enforcing the legality of these regulatory agencies, with a suspicious emphasis on helping corporations.
Chardok··on FCC eliminates rule requiring a local presence for AM/FM/TV broadcasters
Anyone who has been actively listening to the radio or watching local TV broadcasts for the past 10-20 years can probably already attest to the bland homogenization and conspicuous corporate take overs (I immediately think of this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TM8L7bdwVaA); it seems like this is the next logical direction for them.

Personally I detest this and miss the flavor each city brought to its local media, instead of the same stations playing the same 30 songs repeatedly, but with phone music streaming becoming so popular I cannot see a lot of people being outraged by this.

Chardok··on U.S. Consumer Bureau Loses Fight to Allow More Class-Action Suits
This is certainly the most important point. You cannot function in society without internet, a cell phone and some sort of transportation, and most if not all force you to sign away rights that should be guaranteed to all US citizens.

Unless you are wealthy enough to do without or fine being homeless, this means you are living under a sub-government that the rules are set by corporations.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →