HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

CogitoCogito

3,566 karma · joined March 22, 2017

submissionscomments
CogitoCogito··on Zelensky leaves White House after angry meeting
[flagged]
CogitoCogito··on Zelensky leaves White House after angry meeting
> My understanding is that a deal was in place.

Have you seen the deal? Or are you just speculating? For all we know, Trump actually told Zelensky the US would provide security guarantees to set up this spectacle. Or maybe in fact the deal was never in place and Zelensky was just repeating for the hundredth time what it would take for Ukraine to sign a deal and then Trump and Vance flipped out when hearing something they already knew was a cornerstone to his terms?

Presumably we'll never know what actually went down. But we do know that Trump and Vance act like weak little children and are totally incapable of actually mediating between the parties in this war. In the future, they should have the decency to stay out of this discussion and let adults do the talking.

CogitoCogito··on Zelensky leaves White House after angry meeting
Trump could have just told Ukraine they weren't going to support them anymore. He didn't need to have a public press conference and publicly act like a petulant child demonstrating how truly pathetic and weak his leadership really is.

The fact that you aren't upset by the way Trump and Vance acted is incomprehensible to me. How are you not ashamed that they are leading the US?

CogitoCogito··on Zelensky leaves White House after angry meeting
You are aware that Trump has _not_ stopped this war right? He has floated certain some possible agreements with Ukraine, but his terms have not been agreeable to the Ukrainians. If Trump actually wants Ukraine to come to an agreement with the US, he'll have to come up with a deal that is acceptable to them.

So yeah up until now Trump has done _nothing_ to stop this war. He's really only proved to all the US' supposed allies, that the US is not trustworthy. At this point, Trump should just shut up and stop pretending like he's trying to reach some peace agreement. He should just stop sending funds to Ukraine as he obviously wants to do and just leave the discussion because he's really no longer relevant.

CogitoCogito··on Distributed systems programming has stalled
I couldn't disagree more. My principle is to write systems extremely simply and then distribute portions of it as it becomes necessary. Almost always it never becomes necessary and the rare cases it does, it is entirely straight forward to do so unless you have an over-complicated design. I don't think I've ever seen it done well when done in the opposite direction. It's always cost more in time and effort and resulted in something worse.
CogitoCogito··on US government struggles to rehire nuclear safety staff it laid off days ago
> Neither of us really know Twitter's financial position, given it's now private.

Then why are you making any argument that it was a success?

> There was a lot of waste at Twitter. Given that headcount was cut by 80%, and advertisers are returning, I'd suggest it's doing fine.

Why would you suggest it's fine? Without knowing their exact costs, debts, revenues, etc. you know _nothing_. Why would you suggest it's doing fine when knowing nothing about it's financial position?

CogitoCogito··on US government struggles to rehire nuclear safety staff it laid off days ago
I would actually agree with you on that in the case of Twitter, but in what sense is that comparable to the current situation? Unless you mean that Musk is succeeding by destroying a bunch of American assets (i.e. the agencies) and then being lauded for this destruction. I could see that value once again going to Musk (and Trump), but in what sense would that value not be lost by your average US citizen? It's not like Musk bought these agencies before destroying them, he's just destroying them. He's no longer burning his own house down for life insurance, he's burning your house down for life insurance.
CogitoCogito··on US government struggles to rehire nuclear safety staff it laid off days ago
What do you mean when you say "it's an effective strategy"? It's hard to say for certain since Twitter is now private, but it certainly seems to have lost value since Musk took over. What would "work in the public sector" entail for you?
CogitoCogito··on Gulf of America name change in the U.S.
In the Czech Republic at least, Google Maps now shows "Mexický záliv (Americký záliv)". I'm not sure which countries still see the original name other than Mexico.
CogitoCogito··on Gulf of America name change in the U.S.
But this isn't a territory dispute this is just an internal US name change.

Here in the Czech Republic it now shows up as "Mexický záliv (Americký záliv)". Why are they adding "Americký záliv" in a parenthetical? It's not like the executive order has any effect outside the US. Why would they change the name in any way anywhere but in the US? By what reasoning would they change the name in the Czech Republic but not in Mexico? US official naming means nothing to Mexico just as it means nothing to Czech Republic.

CogitoCogito··on It's not a crime if we do it with an app
I honestly don't believe this is the case. I think Americans would largely support increased fines for corporate malfeasance. I think it much more likely that the large fines aren't assessed because those in the position to be fined also as a rule have more influence over the system itself. Though the result is the same in the end I guess.
CogitoCogito··on It's not a crime if we do it with an app
I agree the correct answer is fines, but I disagree that the government should concern itself with whether or not the company decides to take it out on employees who don't deserve it. It's up to the company to decide how it should be run. As long as the government disincentivizes the actions by making the fines high enough, that is good enough.
CogitoCogito··on It's not a crime if we do it with an app
I guess if our goal were to stop this sort of corporate behavior, we would remove the requirement of a crime being intentional for corporations.
CogitoCogito··on 'I grew up with it': readers on the enduring appeal of Microsoft Excel
To add my own anecdote, I've needed to use a lot of spreadsheets the last couple weeks and quickly became annoyed that different cells could have different fonts (which would sometimes happen when I was pasting in data). Of course I quickly learned to just paste in everything unformatted, but I thought to myself "why would anyone want to set fonts per cell?" I guess I just don't get out enough.
CogitoCogito··on What’s new with our in-house load balancing service
I don't think there are many people who will confuse an in-house load balancing service used at dropbox with a brokerage even if both are called Robinhood. Similarly, I don't think that people will confuse said brokerage with an old character of English folklore (and no I don't think it's the space that's important).

Context matters. There simply isn't a risk for meaningful confusion here. So what's the issue exactly?

CogitoCogito··on I attended Google's creator conversation event, and it turned into a funeral
You could maybe consider directing these questions to the author of the article? Given the context, I'm sure he'd appreciate the feedback.
CogitoCogito··on Jury awards American Airline $9.4M from website behind 'skiplagging' hack
> There is nothing rational about maliciously misleading someone in a business transaction.

Honestly at this point I think you're just being purposefully obtuse. Of course it's rational for customers to but a ticket A -> B -> C if they want to fly A -> B and the ticket A -> B -> C is cheaper than the ticket A -> B. What's irrational is for airlines to price their tickets that way.

> You absolutely can: Just walk up to the nearest ticketing counter on your way out the airport and let them know you won't be flying. Simple, done. You might still get blacklisted, but you are presumably okay with the consequences.

Once again you seem to just be willfully obtuse here. Being blacklisted is quite obviously a cost. Passengers being blacklisted means that _rational_ customers doing this won't tell the airline. If the airline didn't want passengers to skip the final leg of their flight without telling them, they could simply allow the customer to notify them without extra costs. They choose blacklisting (or charging to to "change" your ticket to not take the final flight) and this is the result.

I mean I get that you work in the airline industry and hence align your arguments to those that profit the airlines, but you really should accept that the airlines are knowingly creating this environment and that customers are just reacting exactly as you'd expect.

CogitoCogito··on Jury awards American Airline $9.4M from website behind 'skiplagging' hack
> If skiplagging becomes more common, airlines will ultimately raise prices for everyone to make up for the inefficiency and everyone loses. Screw that noise.

How would everyone lose? Bans against skiplagging allow airlines to divorce their ticket prices from the costs of the underlying service. If airlines were say not allowed to ban skiplagging, they would be forced to price their tickets more in line with the underlying costs (on competitive routes anyway) so we should expect some routes' ticket costs to decrease.

CogitoCogito··on Jury awards American Airline $9.4M from website behind 'skiplagging' hack
Airlines choose these ticketing policies and customers react to them rationally. If the airlines allowed customers to notify them that they won't be taking the final flight without any extra costs, then they wouldn't have to worry about no-shows like this (they could even resell the seat).

The airlines are choosing their pricing mechanisms and can live with the consequences.

CogitoCogito··on Routine dental X-rays are not backed by evidence
Tradeoffs.
CogitoCogito··on Large language models reduce public knowledge sharing on online Q&A platforms
> was instead a social shaming that cut so deep that the message you wrote is still burned verbatim into their memory after all these years?

Maybe that was the point?

CogitoCogito··on The Miraculous Resurrection of Notre-Dame
> Do you think a walkable garden at the top of a cathedral would be respectful of the christian faith or do you think only other religions deserve respect?

Personally I find nothing disrespectful about putting a walkable garden on top of a cathedral.

> Put it this way: you put your walkable gardens on top of christian cathedrals, I build up tennis courts on top of mosques and swimming pools on top of synagogues.

I don't understand what you compare a hypothetical walkable garden on a cathedral to a tennis court on a mosque or a swimming pool on a synagogue. I think it better to compare a walkable garden on a cathedral to a walkable garden on a mosque or a walkable garden on a synagogue. Whether that is disrespectful is up to the individual.

CogitoCogito··on 47-year-old Voyager 1 fired up thrusters it hasn't used in decades
So obvious! But _no_ I haven't done this even though I have messed up remote servers where this would have helped. A bit embarrassed I didn't think of it myself, but thanks for the tip nonetheless!
CogitoCogito··on The biggest diamond in over a century is found in Botswana
For me the value is the intelligent commentary produced by such a story.
CogitoCogito··on Cars Are Now Computers, So How Long Will They Get Updates? Automakers Can't Say
How so? Swapping parts can still result in people's deaths. That is what concerned you right?

Besides it's not like people have only "swapped parts". People have basically entirely rebuilt engines and many other systems in the car. You are underselling what what has commonly always been done.

So yeah, I don't really feel like you've answered my original question:

> Haven't third parties been repairing cars for all automotive history?

CogitoCogito··on Cars Are Now Computers, So How Long Will They Get Updates? Automakers Can't Say
Haven't third parties been repairing cars for all automotive history?
CogitoCogito··on Why is Sweden paying grandparents to babysit?
Almost everyone in Scandinavia during the Viking age were farmers. Only a very few were Viking warriors. So I'm guessing that the vast majority of Scandinavians lived quite similarly to all other farmers of the times at northern latitudes.

Also I'm pretty sure that modern Swedes have more in common to modern North Koreans than either do to the Vikings. They lived in such different times and cultures that I don't really think it makes sense to compare them. Maybe you could ask how cold dark winters affected Vikings and how they affect modern Swedes, but even then the winters were much harder for Swedes 100 years back than they are today when the country is much richer. So really the inhabitants 1000 years back might as well be considered aliens compared to the Swedes of today.

CogitoCogito··on Congress accidentally legalized THC six years ago
I said I was leaving, but maybe I'll just pop back into to clarify that I did _not_ misunderstand you. When I initially responded and later said "live and let live", I definitely included living with "loud, neon-light colored storefronts in otherwise residential areas". If someone complained about e.g. about a house's color or Christmas lights I would tell them the same thing. Personally (I don't mean this as an attack, I just honestly am telling you my opinion) I find busybodies like you to be the worst kinds of neighbors.

As an aside, if you don't want loud, neon-lighted signs, you should just push for a ban on loud, neon-lighted signs. I'm not sure what it has to do with THC products.

CogitoCogito··on Congress accidentally legalized THC six years ago
People buying THC products doesn't affect me, it affects them.

That said, I don't plan on being drawn into this discussion any further. Keep fighting the good fight I guess.

CogitoCogito··on Congress accidentally legalized THC six years ago
Live and let live? But yeah of course people can also try to get these "unpleasant" things banned, if they don't have anything better to do with themselves.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →