HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

CogitoCogito

3,566 karma · joined March 22, 2017

submissionscomments
CogitoCogito··on Congress accidentally legalized THC six years ago
> Well it's not just indicative of that. It's also indicative of the lack of regulation for something that didn't exist previously. The shops could exist in a less-unpleasant way... just, nobody has forced them to yet. It's coming, though. Everyone is pissed.

I suppose people could also just get used to them.

CogitoCogito··on Supreme Court rules ex-presidents have immunity for official acts
This is at least the second time in this thread you've said something like an official act can't violate someone's constitutional rights "by definition". I'm wondering what definition you refer to.

That said, it's obviously a false statement. By your argument, the president ordering flight 93 to be shot down on 9/11 would not be an official act. You might now retort something about extenuating circumstances, but really that would only show you to be entirely wrong about your original assertion.

I recommend you edit your posts to correct your mistake.

CogitoCogito··on Psychedelics are challenging the standard of randomized controlled trials
> How do you study mind-altering drugs when every clinical-trial participant knows they’re tripping?

Are there really no protocols for research in which participants can tell whether they have received a certain drug or not? I mean sure I think that double-blind is best for research, but are there really not other cases in which they deal with the patients knowing?

Edit:

> By striving to cleave the drug’s effects from the context in which it’s given—to a patient by a therapist, both of whom are hoping for healing—blinded studies may fail to capture the full picture.

Okay I see the issue is that patients not being blind to the treatment is (thought to be) necessary for the treatment to work. Okay yeah so that means it's hard to make the participants blind in anyway. Still I'm surprised there aren't approaches to deal with this. Of course it might mean by definition double-blind trials aren't possible, but then again maybe that's not always appropriate. I can see the pandora's box being opened by allowing drug studies to bypass these restrictions though so I guess I see why people don't like it.

Later in the article:

> In an email, an FDA spokesperson told me that blinded RCTs provide the most rigorous level of evidence, but “unblinded studies can still be considered adequate and well-controlled as long as there is a valid comparison with a control.” In such cases, the spokesperson said, regulators can take into account things like the size of the treatment effect in deciding whether the treatment performed significantly better than the placebo.

CogitoCogito··on A man ordered to hide his boat painted the boat on his fence
Yeah I'm having trouble understanding how /u/db48x's logic doesn't apply equally well to all political systems. Maybe the next time someone complains to me about Biden's policies, I should just respond that they don't understand freedom.
CogitoCogito··on EU countries must implement right to repair laws within two years
Apple should just sell those crates to anyone for a reasonable markup. Then those people can provide repair services to others independent of any oversight of Apple.
CogitoCogito··on Suddenly There Aren't Enough Babies. The Whole World Is Alarmed
> So the ones who are not producing any kids by choice are consciously offloading their old-age care and hence act selfishly.

When my father was dying, I out of all his children was able to help him the most since I don't have children of my own. Clearly I could devote my life to helping old people and do more overall good for that group, then just producing children (who may or may not do so). In fact, I could make the claim that "the ones who *are* producing kids by choice are consciously producing more work for future generations to do hence acting selfishly". That position would be similarly asinine.

But sure if you understand there is no inherent good to parenting and it's basically just people doing what they want to do (well when having the children by choice anyway), then I guess you maybe show a little humility. I may someday have children, but I'm under no illusion that I'd be doing the world a favor.

CogitoCogito··on Suddenly There Aren't Enough Babies. The Whole World Is Alarmed
It's interesting to see this comment downvoted. I'm honestly curious as to the thinking here. How are parents having kids because they want them not acting selfishly?
CogitoCogito··on Suddenly There Aren't Enough Babies. The Whole World Is Alarmed
How haven't these problems _always_ existed? What do they have to do with drop in overall population? If change is the problem, then both population growth and movement of populations are already problems and always have been.
CogitoCogito··on Suddenly There Aren't Enough Babies. The Whole World Is Alarmed
Are you saying it's selfish to not have kids? Other than accidental parents, I've never met any who didn't have kids because they wanted them. How were they not acting selfishly?
CogitoCogito··on European Accelerationism
I’m pretty sure all Western European countries have been multi-ethnic for the last 25 years. Certainly all I’ve had any experience with (Sweden, Germany, France, UK, maybe more).
CogitoCogito··on Coding interviews are stupid (ish)
Yes and such a system makes hiring so much easier because mistakes cost much less. But the US ties things like healthcare to employment so a company that has a reputation for firing people after hiring them (however legitimate) would probably be one people would avoid. In Sweden, for example, I’ve found interviews so much more reasonable. Then again, I had healthcare there regardless of employment.
CogitoCogito··on U.S. libraries are battling high prices for better e-book access
> The future envisioned by DRM is an attempt to deal with the problem of copying through structural rather than legal means. Would an update to the law restrict DRM by putting transferability requirements in place (that is, any DRM scheme needs to have the option to irreversibly transfer the content)? Would it put further DMCA-style restrictions on attempts to circumvent DRM?

Sounds fine to me. I don’t think that publishers should be allowed to interfere with transferability by technical or legal means.

CogitoCogito··on Mitt Romney Reveals Twisted Reason Why Congress Moved to Ban TikTok
I wouldn’t go so far as to say that US media should be owned by Americans, but I do wonder if it makes sense to allow foreigners to have ownership if their own countries don’t allow the same kinds of rights as well. Bringing China up, I don’t really see why Chinese media should be allowed more access to American markets when they don’t reciprocate.
CogitoCogito··on Stack Overflow and OpenAI are partnering
I’m not totally seeing your point. Being paid allows you to spend more money. I agree with that statement.

Many countries have managed to separate healthcare coverage from your current employment status with better results and at lower costs than in the US. The US should learn from others solving problems better.

Also healthcare has been tied to work in the US since long before the ACA.

CogitoCogito··on Stack Overflow and OpenAI are partnering
I understand that. That’s exactly the problem.
CogitoCogito··on Stack Overflow and OpenAI are partnering
I think the real problem is that in the US health insurance is tied to employment.
CogitoCogito··on Amazon CEO Andy jassy broke federal labor law with anti-union remarks
> Like many NLRB administrative law judges, the judge here has done nothing outside of work for the NLRB. It is no surprise that he found a violation here and it will also be no surprise when he is overturned on appeal.

Are you making the argument that his extensive experience in his profession is a bad thing?

CogitoCogito··on Amazon CEO Andy Jassy violated labor law with union comments, NLRB rules
I can't give you a clear answer, but this seems to have all the case history:

https://www.nlrb.gov/case/19-CA-297441

And the document "Administrative Law Judges Decision" in that case history seems to be the actual decision:

https://apps.nlrb.gov/link/document.aspx/09031d4583d193b2

I guess the section "III. DECISION AND ANALYSIS" is what you're interested in.

CogitoCogito··on Recruiters are going analog to fight the AI application overload
I got my current job from it.

No idea which experience is more typical.

CogitoCogito··on The Guide to Git I Never Had
The git book has a good section on the intervals of git which helps you understand the program overall:

https://git-scm.com/book/en/v2/Git-Internals-Plumbing-and-Po...

CogitoCogito··on Freedom to Roam
The freedom to roam in Sweden and Norway is already limited and not absolute. No one supporting such freedoms had been arguing the freedom should be unlimited. You never needed to make this point because it was obvious to everyone in the conversation.
CogitoCogito··on Harvard applications drop 5% after year of turmoil on the Ivy League campus
Sounds like a good thing:

> The Cambridge, Massachusetts-based school received 54,008 applications for the class of 2028, according to the Harvard Crimson, the campus newspaper. The undergraduate college at Harvard University accepted 1,245 of those applicants, giving the incoming freshman class an acceptance rate of 3.59% — the highest admission rate in four years, the publication noted.

CogitoCogito··on Freedom to Roam
> Freedom to roam does not need to be freedom to enter people's garden. At least in Norway, the law requires you to stay a minimum distance from dwellings, and has a variety of requirements to ensure you're not a nuisance.

Sweden has similar restrictions.

CogitoCogito··on Freedom to Roam
Do you only support laws if there exist no downsides no matter how small? Has there ever been any such law?

That said, if we don’t companies engaging in those kinds of practices, it seems more practical to ban those practices than to remove all rights to access entirely.

CogitoCogito··on Freedom to Roam
I’m confused why you think this would put you at increased risk. You are allowed to defend yourself against threats today. Why do you think that would change?

Though you are also speaking as if people camping on your land away from your dwelling are necessarily threatening. If that is something you believe, you might want to reflect and ask yourself why.

CogitoCogito··on Freedom to Roam
We’re talking people walking across or camping on your land and in both cases staying away from any residences where people actually live. How would you even know someone is trafficking?
CogitoCogito··on Freedom to Roam
So if the law were changed to remove said liability, you would support a freedom to roam in the US?
CogitoCogito··on I'm a Tenured College Professor. I'm Quitting. Here's Why
Are the arguments wrong?
CogitoCogito··on Freedom to Roam
Why?
CogitoCogito··on Cloudflare CEO sues over free-roaming fidos at his ski resort paradise
I’m personally fine with it.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →