HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DabAsteroid

266 karma · joined August 31, 2008

submissionscomments
DabAsteroid··on The bad news: My $4000 Mac Pro may be killing me
the world average life expectancy [has doubled] over the last century.

Are you referring to the life expectancy for 20-year-olds?

[Edit: I found some data here: http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/lifexpec.htm http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr56/nvsr56_09.pdf 20-year-olds do seem to have benefited quite a bit in the first half of the 20th century. I had assumed that life-expectancy was virtually unchanged across the century, except for that of infants and other under-five-year-olds.]

DabAsteroid··on Einstein letters reveal a turmoil beyond science
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=315938
DabAsteroid··on Review our startup: FlowMingle - Online Dating for the Social Internet
I was addressing your response to Netcan's suggestion. Social networking is not an area I am interested in, but I happen to have previously listened to the eGuardian episode of the Frank Peters Show, and it popped into my head when you mentioned security problems with social-networking sites for 14-year-olds.

Another point about market opportunity: some high-school and college students go to same-sex institutions (which might be a good idea, since it minimizes distraction, and hence could become more popular over time).

DabAsteroid··on America Loses Its Dominant Economic Role
http://www.google.com/search?q=nuclear+desalination
DabAsteroid··on Review our startup: FlowMingle - Online Dating for the Social Internet
The only problem with this idea is that it's dangerous. The reputation of the Internet is that of a haven for pedo predators...you make a dating site for 14 year olds

Hence the market opportunity: a social site for kids/adolescents -- or security tool for same -- that ensures that users are the ages they say they are, and only allows close-in-age interactions. In fact, there is already at least one angel-funded startup working on this very concept. They work with schools to confirm user identities and ages:

http://www.thefrankpetersshow.com/2008/07/eguardian_protects...

TCA deal lead Steve Block liked what he heard about eGuardian before they even presented! He had another company that was dealing with children online. Steve would put the two companies together and bring the critical focus to transform eGuardian.

Attorneys General from 49 states are pressuring social networking sites to protect kids. eGuardian partners Ron Zayas and Robert Patrick have a new approach to protecting children while they're online.

DabAsteroid··on Ask HN: Would there be an energy crisis if...
[nuclear] decommissioning is hideously expensive.

How expensive is it?

http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/inf02.html

Nuclear energy ... internalise[s] all waste disposal and decommissioning costs. ...

For nuclear power plants any cost figures normally include spent fuel management, plant decommissioning and final waste disposal. These costs, while usually external for other technologies, are internal for nuclear power (ie they have to be paid or set aside securely by the utility generating the power, and the cost passed on to the customer in the actual tariff).

Decommissioning costs are about 9-15% of the initial capital cost of a nuclear power plant. But when discounted, they contribute only a few percent to the investment cost and even less to the generation cost. In the USA they account for 0.1-0.2 cent/kWh, which is no more than 5% of the cost of the electricity produced.

The back-end of the fuel cycle, including used fuel storage or disposal in a waste repository, contributes up to another 10% to the overall costs per kWh, - less if there is direct disposal of used fuel rather than reprocessing. The $26 billion US used fuel program is funded by a 0.1 cent/kWh levy.

  .
Decommissioning costs can be reduced even further by extending the operating lifetimes of reactors (now planned to be 60 years (70 years in Japan), but potentially soon planned to be 80 or 100 years), and by deferring decommissiong activities by mothballing them (placing them in SafStor mode http://www.google.com/search?q=safstor) for what is currently planned to be 100 years. Deferring decommissioning activities saves money because the cost of future capital tends to be less than the cost of present capital (i.e. future costs are discounted), and because radionuclides decay over time which makes decommissioning easier.
DabAsteroid··on Seth's Blog: When you stand for something
A simplified version of the essay, created by translating a very few words:

  .
When you are bigoted

People and brands and organizations that are bigoted benefit as a result. Bigotry helps you build trust, makes it easier to manage expectations and aids in daily decision making. Bigotry also makes it more fun to do your gig, because you're on a mission, doing something that matters. Of course, there's a cost. You can't get something for nothing.

It's frustrating to watch marketers, politicians and individuals fall into the obvious trap of trying to be bigoted at the same time they try to please everyone or do everything.

You can't be the low-price, high-value, wide-selection, convenient, green, all-in-one corner bigoted market. Sorry.

You also can't be the highly-bigoted CEO who just this one time lets an accounting fraud slide. "Because it's urgent."

You can't be the big-government-fighting, low-taxes-for-everyone, high-services-for-everyone, safety-net, pro-science, faith-based, anti-deficit bigoted candidate either.

You can't be the work-smart, life-in-balance, available-at-all-hours, high-output, do-what-you're-told bigoted employee.

To really be bigoted, you must make difficult decisions, mostly about what you don't do. We don't ship products like that, we don't stand for employees like that ("you're fired"), we don't fix problems like that.

It's so hard to be bigoted, to not compromise, to give up an account or lose a vote or not tell a journalist what they want to hear.

But those are the only moments where being bigoted actually counts, the only times that people will actually come to believe that you in fact actually are bigoted.

If you have to change your story because your audience is different (oh, I'm on national TV today!) (oh, this big customer wants me to cut some key corners) you're going to get caught. That's because the audience is now unknown to you, everything is public sooner or later, and if you want to build a brand for the ages, you need to be bigoted today and tomorrow and every day.

DabAsteroid··on Super-Efficient Free-Piston Engines Could Replace Traditional Gas and Diesel Engines
Here is the original article:

http://www.technologyreview.com/energy/21442

Caption: Piston power: In an unconventional engine design, a rod with a piston at either end shuttles between two combustion chambers. Magnets at the center of the rod move past metal coils (orange) to create an electrical current.

I usually call these crankless engines.

  .
Free-piston engines aren't new: they were invented in the 1920s. But the increased recent focus on hybrid cars has led a growing number of research groups and automakers to start research programs to develop the technology. Unlike in conventional engines, there is no mechanical connection between the piston and a crankshaft (hence the name free-piston). Since the design allows for improved combustion and less friction, the engines could be far more efficient in generating electricity than either conventional generators or newer fuel-cell technology.
DabAsteroid··on Elon Musk on SpaceX's Goal: "To reduce the cost of human spaceflight by a factor of 100."
The original source is here:

http://www.esquire.com/features/75-most-influential/elon-mus...

Excerpt:

The next big moment will be life becoming multiplanetary, an unprecedented adventure that would dramatically enhance the richness and diversity of our collective consciousness. It would also serve as a hedge against the myriad--and growing--threats to our survival. An asteroid or a supervolcano could certainly destroy us, but we also face risks the dinosaurs never saw: An engineered virus, nuclear war, inadvertent creation of a micro black hole, or some as-yet-unknown technology could spell the end of us. Sooner or later, we must expand life beyond our little blue mud ball--or go extinct.

DabAsteroid··on US consumers flock to Mac laptops
I got two dells ... now ... falling apart.

What kind? Precision?

DabAsteroid··on Einstein letters reveal a turmoil beyond science
Great comment!

Thank you.

Can persistent effort increase intelligence?

No. Why do you ask?

DabAsteroid··on Einstein letters reveal a turmoil beyond science
I think most people would assume a man of his accomplishments would certainly be more than "not much smarter" than alot of people today are.

Einstein is commonly claimed to have had a +4 sigma g-strength (IQ of 160, on typical scales). Even assuming a normal curve, rather than the more-popularly-believed fat-tails curve, that would leave millions of people today with higher g-strengths than Einstein had.

  .
Arthur Jensen writes:

Creativity and genius are unrelated to g except that a person's level of g acts as a threshold variable below which socially significant forms of creativity are highly improbable. This g threshold is probably at least one standard deviation above the mean level of g in the general population. Besides the traits that Galton though necessary for "eminence" (viz., high ability, zeal, and persistence), genius implies outstanding creativity as well. Thouhj such exceptional creativity is conspicuously lacking in the vast majority of people who have a high IQ, it is probably impossible to find any creative geniuses with low IQ's. In other words, high ability is a necessary but not sufficient condition for the emergence of socially siginificant creativity. Genius itself should not be confused with merely high IQ, which is what we generally mean by the term "gifted" (which also applies to special talents such as music and art). True creativity involves more than just high ability. It is still uncertain what this is, but the most interesting theory I have seen spelled out in detail is Eysenck's. He hypothesizes that the essential personality factor in creative genius is what he terms trait psychoticism, which has a genetic basis and is explainanble in part in terms of brain chemistry and physiology. (The g Factor. Ch14, The g Nexus. pp577-578.)

This is Eysenck's book:

http://www.google.com/search?q=eysenck+genius

DabAsteroid··on Crowd-Sourced Capital
This should not violate security rules as she's not selling you securities ;).

This clause might be a problem:

the top 100 donations will receive a lifetime premium membership.

If I donate X amount of money, I do not know if I will receive the lifetime membership. I could ultimately be outbid; or I might ultimately not be outbid. It is a game of chance; and unlike in the case of an auction, I pay whether I win or lose. That might make this an unlicenced gambling enterprise.

IANAL, but I would guess that if you are going to offer for sale specified products or services, you need to guarantee that paying customers will receive those specified products or services.

DabAsteroid··on Complete YouTube videos of select Stanford classes
Did you have watch in high quality selected?
DabAsteroid··on Trolls, SEO "morons" prompt smaller media sites to rethink comments
More of Karl Marx's class warfare.

Excerpt:

"[Universal Hub] doesn't use nofollow," Gaffin explains. "... word was getting out among the pagerank queens and I was getting tired of dealing with those morons."

Gaffin reports that forcing commenters to register has greatly reduced the problems described above, although he says some of the "pagerank losers" are still willing to create user accounts on Universal Hub to boost the PageRank of their websites or those of customers.

  .
"Pagerank queen" = subset of lumpenprol. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lumpenproletariat)

In The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Napoleon (1852), Marx refers to the lumpenproletariat as the 'refuse of all classes,' including 'swindlers, confidence tricksters, brothel-keepers, rag-and-bone merchants, beggars, and other flotsam of society.'

DabAsteroid··on Ask HN: What % of users are still on IE6?
That adds up to 125%. Maybe you meant that IE7 is 49%.
DabAsteroid··on I test drove a Tesla
Thanks for clearing that up for me, Wil. (And welcome to HN, though I am new here, also.)

Do I understand correctly that the 1.5 drivetrain tends to get hot at high speeds and is automatically throttled to prevent overheating (thermal throttled, like some CPU's) and that that is the reason that though the car can indeed reach 120 or more MPH, it cannot sustain it for very long?

DabAsteroid··on Risky, we-can't-fail, all-or-nothing science
it would take more energy to mine [granite] than you would get from it. There are only 3-10 part per million of uranium in granite.

Have you read this?:

http://nuclearinfo.net/Nuclearpower/UraniuamDistribution

The Rossing mine in Nambia mines Uranium at an Ore concentration of 300 ppm at an energy cost 500 times less than the energy it delivers with current thermal-spectrum reactors. If the energy cost increases in inverse proportion to the Ore concentration, shales and phosphates, with a Uranium abundance of 10 - 20 ppm, could be mined with an energy gain of 16 - 32.

Extrapolating from that, the energy gain is 1.6 for every ppm of uranium. As you say, granite contains 3-10 ppm of uranium. Therefore, mining granite for its uranium would provide an energy gain of 4.8 to 16. That would be without improving current reactor thermal-efficiency at all, and without improving current reactor breeding efficiency at all (all fission-reactors fueled with a mixture of U235 and U238 breed to some extent).

Running a uranium economy off of such a low-grade ore would, of course, in the real world provide incentive to improve fuel-efficiency (thermal; breeding-ratio; etc.) of reactors (even thermal-spectrum reactors can have their breeding-efficiencies improved). Thus, in the real world, the energy gain from mining granite for uranium would likely be higher than 4.8 to 16.

DabAsteroid··on Risky, we-can't-fail, all-or-nothing science
You're using a link that claims the resource limit to be 1000 years (the first one).

It's your link. I was quoting you and commenting on it.

DabAsteroid··on Risky, we-can't-fail, all-or-nothing science
It's good to know that there are other people who are great promoters of nuclear power (I am a huge fan)

Please keep your bigotries to yourself, and don't speak for what mine might be.

  .
you're not reading your sources very well (the last article you linked to put the cost of uranium as nuclear fuel at 0.5c/kWh at a spot price of $53/kg)

That would be the total cost of the fuel after conversion, enrichment, and fabrication. The U3O8 cost of $472 is .264 of the total cost of $1787, which indeed works out to less than 0.2c/kWh (about 0.131c/kWh, actually) if $1787/kg of fabricated-fuel works out to 0.5c/kWh.

2007 fabricated-fuel costs at U.S. nuclear powerplants were 0.47c/kWh. http://www.nei.org/resourcesandstats/nuclear_statistics/cost...

  .
your math is full or errors

Please provide at least a single example of any math errors I might have made.

  .
We once believed oil would last us forever and we have come to realize that this is not so.

Indeed, there might only remain some 70,000 years' worth of oil.

http://www.google.com/search?q=oil+70000+dabasteroid

Is there reason to believe otherwise?

DabAsteroid··on Risky, we-can't-fail, all-or-nothing science
It is currently an UNECONOMICAL way to get Uranium.

The word "currently" is important here. It means that the statement containing the word is irrelevant in the long-term. Resource supply-size increases exponentially to linear increase in price. How high of a price increase can the market accept? The current uranium prices contribute about .2 cents per kWh of electricity produced.

http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/inf02.html

Multiplying the uranium price by 10 causes it to contribute only 2 cents to the cost of each kWh of electricity produced. That is before further fuel-efficiency advances are applied, which the higher fuel prices would incentivize.

  .
Do you mean to suggest that at some $1,000/kg, it would not be possible to profitably extract some 60,000 tons or more of uranium per year from seawater? What about at $2000/kg? $3,000? $4,000? $5,000? We can keep going, since fuel-efficiency of the plants can continue to be improved. $6,000? $7,000? $8,000? $9,000? $10,000?

Where is your cutoff for economic seawater uranium mining?

  .
Current extraction from sea water runs over 4 times the current spot price for Uranium.

That would make it cost less than a penny per kWh. Are you meaning to suggest that the electricity market would not accept a fuel-price of under a penny per kWh?

DabAsteroid··on Risky, we-can't-fail, all-or-nothing science
For resources to be counted as reserves, they have to be found. If no one bothers finding more resources, the resources that lie in wait are not counted as reserves. Here is some finding-cost data:

http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/inf75.html

the finding costs of crude oil have averaged around US$ 6/bbl over at least the past three decades. When finding costs of the two fuels are expressed in terms of their contained energy value, oil, at US$ 1050/MJ of energy, is about 300 times more expensive to find than uranium, at US$ 3.4/MJ. Similarly, the proportion of current market prices that finding costs comprise are lower for uranium. Its finding costs make up only 2% of the recent spot price of US$ 30/lb ($78/kgU), while the oil finding costs are 12% of a recent spot price of US$ 50/bbl.

By these measures, uranium is a very inexpensive energy source to replenish, as society has accepted far higher energy replacement costs to sustain oil resources.

  .
If those finding costs were considered too high, one would additionally have to hope that no one would be able to find the sea, or that if anyone were able to find the sea, that they would not be able to figure out how to extract uranium from it for, perhaps, only several hundred dollars per kg -- something which in fact has already been done, and which is being improved-upon by current research conducted by Japan and India.
DabAsteroid··on Risky, we-can't-fail, all-or-nothing science
Thorium required a breeder reactor in order to produce the U-233 necessary for fission, and as stated in another comment, these reactors are still in experimental stages and have a much lower level of operational safety record.

A thorium breeder is not the same thing as a uranium breeder.

http://thoriumenergy.blogspot.com

DabAsteroid··on Risky, we-can't-fail, all-or-nothing science
Reserves, in mining means the amount of ore that can be economically removed from the earth.

No, it doesn't.

http://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Ajuliansimon.com%2Fwrit...

DabAsteroid··on Risky, we-can't-fail, all-or-nothing science
http://www.world-nuclear-news.org/ENF_Exploration_drives_ura...

Those are "identified resources", which means that they are irrelevant. There are 2 trillion tons (5 billion years' worth) of economically-recoverable uranium in granite, alone.

http://nuclearinfo.net/Nuclearpower/UraniuamDistribution

DabAsteroid··on Risky, we-can't-fail, all-or-nothing science
U-235, the fissile isotope of natural uranium, occurs in only 0.711% of uranium

If I had disregarded that, how do you figure I got a 60x energy boost by applying fuel-breeding?

DabAsteroid··on Risky, we-can't-fail, all-or-nothing science
Only a tiny fraction of the uranium is in concentrated enough deposits to allow for economic recovery of the mineral.

Given that that very point was addressed at the link I provided, one might suspect that you did not visit it before answering.

It is not merely 40 trillion tons of uranium that are in the crust. It is 40 trillion of uranium that is also economically-recoverable. Why is nearly all of the uranium in the crust is economically-recoverable? It is because the energy density of uranium is so high. The same goes for thorium.

DabAsteroid··on Risky, we-can't-fail, all-or-nothing science
The higher output is a function of the higher energy density.

That might have cleared everything up for me, except that I do not know what you mean by "higher output". Are you referring to power output? You are saying that, generally, in a given case of equal-sized reactors, a fusion reactor would be able to produce higher power than a fission reactor?

DabAsteroid··on Risky, we-can't-fail, all-or-nothing science
The energy density ... is far higher (theoretically) with fusion than with fission.

Is that true by volume of fuel? By weight, the energy density is only 4 times as high (D-T) (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density#Energy_density_i...). By volume, the density of uranium/thorium might very well be typically higher, since uranium/thorium is a heavy-metal, and therefore notably dense.

For convenient fuel storage, the deuterium and tritium might be temporarily be converted to water. I'm not going to do the math right now, but I think it would be interesting to see how that compares volumetrically to uranium/thorium energy density.

  .
The ... potential output is far higher

Please clarify.

  .
At current rates of use, uranium fuels will last about 1000 years.

There are more than 40 trillion tons of uranium in the earth's crust (mostly in the continents, and mostly near the surface of those continents):

http://nuclearinfo.net/Nuclearpower/UraniuamDistribution

The world currently uses ~60,000 tons per year of uranium. http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/reactors.html

~60,000 tons/year / 60x breeder-factor / 2.5x thermal-efficiency improvement = 400 tons/year fuel use. 40 trillion tons of uranium / 400 tons used/year = .1 trillion years of uranium.

Thorium is available in the crust at some 4 times the ubiquity of uranium = .4 trillion years of thorium.

Adding the uranium and thorium together gives us .5 trillion years of fission fuel.

  .
How did you come up with 1000 years? Even limiting ourselves to the mere 9 billion tons of uranium/thorium present in seawater would provide 20 million years worth of fuel. ...And that supply is constantly being replenished by rivers, and by the seabed (the uranium/thorium suspended in the oceans is in equilibrium with that on the seabed -- if some is taken out, it is creates disequilibrium that can be relieved by the seabed uranium/thorium dissolving into the seawater).
DabAsteroid··on I test drove a Tesla
Motorcycles have had clutchless shifting forever

There is a motorcycle model with clutchless shifting?

← PreviousPage 3 of 11Next →