HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DonHopkins

25,701 karma · joined April 13, 2014

    \ don@donhopkins.com

    FORTH ?KNOW IF HONK ELSE FORTH LEARN THEN

    : C(-; LICK SMILE NOSE WINK ;

    \ FORTH PAPER TAPE PUNCHER:

    : PT# ( L --- L/2 )
      DUP 1 AND IF 
        ASCII @ 
      ELSE BL THEN
      HOLD
      2/
    ;

    : PT. ( N --- )
      <# PT# PT# PT# 
         ASCII . HOLD
         PT# PT# PT# PT#
      #> TYPE
    ;

    : CUT
      ." -----------" CR
    ;

    : PTAPE
      CUT
      BEGIN
        KEY ?DUP WHILE
        DUP ." |" PT. ." |"  SPACE EMIT CR
      REPEAT
      CUT
    ;
Lisp -vs- Forth -vs- PostScript:

    ; Lisp:
    (defun caar (x) (car (car x)))
    (defun caaar (x) (car (car (car x))))
    (defun caaaar (x) (car (car (car (car x)))))

    \ Forth:
    : droop drop drop ;
    : drooop drop drop drop ;
    : droooop drop drop drop drop ;

    % PostScript:
    /poop { pop pop } def
    /pooop { pop pop pop } def
    /poooop { pop pop pop pop } def
submissionscomments
DonHopkins··on AI execs may be too out of touch to build for the general public
"The Lady": Russ Hanneman's Child Automation System:

https://youtu.be/wGy5SGTuAGI?t=217

DonHopkins··on Image generation has come a long way since August 2022
Just ask any hyper-polished 2026 image generator for images in the style of August 2022 DALL-E 2.
DonHopkins··on Emacs Turns 50
I'm going to name my next cat after my favorite Apple ][ DOS command:

]CATALOG

And my next dog after the way you warm restart DOS after you hit RESET with Integer Basic ROMs and get thrown into Woz's system monitor:

*3D0G

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_DOS#Technical_details

DonHopkins··on The tragedy of losing your Wikipedia page
I'd hate to be the last Guy Standing on Wikipedia.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Wikipedia_controversie...

>Beginning February 2015,[286] there was an ongoing edit war over the image caption for Guy Standing's English Wikipedia article. The debate was over if the word "sitting" should be added to the caption, since he was sitting in the photo.[287] A screenshot of the caption describing him as "Guy Standing sitting" has become a viral internet meme.[286] At one point in the edit war, the caption read "Guy Standing on a chair."[288] As of 2026, the consensus is to exclude the word "sitting".[286][287] In May 2022, Standing was invited to the American podcast Reply All to discuss the "Guy Standing sitting" joke.[286]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Wikipedia_controversie...

DonHopkins··on Emacs Turns 50
I still think you should have called your company Wingnut instead of Cygnus.
DonHopkins··on Emacs Turns 50
Also:

Interview with an Emacs Enthusiast [Colorized]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=urcL86UpqZc

Deldo - Vibration Control and Teledildonics Mode for Emacs

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D1sXuHnf_lo

DonHopkins··on Emacs Turns 50
You are correct: Nominative and chromatic determinism strikes again!

Emacs is a powerful, flexible, majestic, extensible silver tabby, so he also acts like his namesake: textual and functional determinism.

DonHopkins··on Emacs Turns 50
I named my cat Emacs, and he's only three years old. His sister's name is Pip.

And to answer the question I get a lot: no, it would be morally reprehensible to name a cat after an inferior editor such as "vi".

DonHopkins··on AI is ruining haunted houses
I want a haunted house based on Harlan Ellison's "I Have no Mouth but I Must Scream", where they duct tape your mouth and torment you with AI generated attrocities.
DonHopkins··on Bentley's Kyiv deadlership among the strongest, despite the war
I could hardly make a word out, but the ebb and flow of your phrasing was absolutely delightful.

Oh imagine, the delights of the banter, frozen in ASCII. Keep talkin'! How do ya think that Scottish Parliament's gettin' on?

Here's a hundred. Oh, hang the change, we're only payin' for the banter.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7T5K1HxEBCU

DonHopkins··on Bentley's Kyiv deadlership among the strongest, despite the war
Lock up your grannies!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=scNLfr1EP08

DonHopkins··on AI use leads UC Berkeley math professor to see 'no point' in grading homework
Brian Harvey, who taught CS 61A at Berkeley for decades (and wrote Berkeley Logo and Simply Scheme and Snap! and The Beauty and Joy of Computing), was making this argument long before AI. From "Using Computers for Educational Freedom":

Brian> Students learn best through intrinsic motivation, not through force. What you learn under pressure doesn't last past the exam. Everyone says these things, and yet almost all teachers continue to give grades. Why? "It's required"; "The colleges need grades"; "The parents wouldn't stand for it"; "It's the way things are." In short, the reasons for grades are political.

https://people.eecs.berkeley.edu/~bh/freedom.html

At Lincoln-Sudbury Regional High School he built a computer course of self-paced units with no grades, and about 50 kids had keys to the computer center and used it evenings and weekends without adult supervision. In his Snap!Con 2025 talk for the ACM Karlstrom award he said why the no-grades part mattered:

https://youtu.be/pDK2PE_pkqQ?t=1917

Jens> Okay. I've I've got one more question, Brian. Um, when you showed that picture of Sbury High of the Computer Lab users, computer center user Society Society, you very carefully and conscientiously mentioned every name with the title my friend, Jonathan, my friend. And that struck me as something uh that there might be a deeper message from you behind that.

Brian> Yeah. Yeah. Um, everything conspires to make teachers the enemies of kids. Not because any teacher wants that, but because institutions have a lot of weight. And when you're giving somebody grades, you can't be their friend. It just doesn't work like that. You're not their friend, you're a hurdle they have to overcome.

Brian> So yeah, it was really important to me that they let me not give grades and I think that made the whole thing possible and I couldn't have done it otherwise.

And on AI in the same talk:

https://youtu.be/pDK2PE_pkqQ?t=510

Brian> Mostly, people who talk about AI in education see it as a threat: kids will use it to cheat; or maybe AI will replace teachers so we won't have jobs anymore. Or sort of the best of these views is we don't know yet what skills kids are really going to need in an AI dominated world. Supposing that we have one. I'm pretty confident that AI won't replace teachers for rich kids -- and computers already replace teachers for poor kids, long before AI. The poor kids sit in front of computers that give them arithmetic problems. So it's not as if uh we're opening up a can of worms that's brand new.

AI didn't create the problem with graded homework. It just made it impossible to keep pretending the grade measures the learning.

DonHopkins··on America has lost 200k of jobs in media, film and the arts. How much is AI?
>It was the turn of the millennium, and Metallica had a problem.

I'm sure all their fans will agree that it's a good thing Metallica has such a consistent track record of being all about "love, energy and heavy music", instead of ever divisively singing about or getting their hands dirty with politics, and stayed in their lane and stuck to romantic love songs and upbeat pop jingles like One, And Justice for All, Disposable Heros, Blackened, Eye of the Beholder, The Shortest Straw, Don't Tread on Me, For Whom the Bell Tolls, etc.

DonHopkins··on How to run a city builder on 16 MHz
Thanks for the link! That's the older C/TCL/Tk code from the original micropolis repo and OLPC release. Here's the latest version of the code, translated to C++ with better names and comments, in the newer MicropolisCore repo:

https://github.com/SimHacker/MicropolisCore/blob/main/packag...

Chaim Gingold wrote a book all about "Building SimCity":

https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262547482/building-simcity/

He answered questions about it in this HN discussion:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40698442

For more detail than the article gives, Chaim Gingold drew the whole loop for his book "Building SimCity: How to Put the World in a Machine" (MIT Press, 2024), and kindly let us put his diagrams in the MicropolisCore repo.

Chaim Gingold's "SimCity Reverse Diagrams":

https://github.com/SimHacker/MicropolisCore/tree/main/images...

Simulation Loop (Simulate):

https://github.com/SimHacker/MicropolisCore/blob/main/images...

Map Data Flow:

https://github.com/SimHacker/MicropolisCore/blob/main/images...

Maps:

https://github.com/SimHacker/MicropolisCore/blob/main/images...

Map Scan:

https://github.com/SimHacker/MicropolisCore/blob/main/images...

Make Traffic:

https://github.com/SimHacker/MicropolisCore/blob/main/images...

Animation Characters:

https://github.com/SimHacker/MicropolisCore/blob/main/images...

From the micropolis repo README:

NOTE: Please See: MicropolisCore

https://github.com/SimHacker/MicropolisCore

This "micropolis" repo is mainly for historical purpose, and it's probably better to use the newer MicropolisCore repo for development.

I rebooted micropolis into the fresh new MicropolisCore repo, without all the old X11/TCL/Tk stuff.

MicropolisCore is a C++ rewrite/refactor/cleanup of the original C code into a simulation engine that's independent of the user interface.

The full lineage of the code is C64 => Mac => SunOS/NeWS/HyperLook => Unix/X11/TCL/Tk + multiplayer => Linux/X11/TCL/Tk + multiplayer => OLPC/X11/TCL/Tk (single player) => C++ MicropolisCore => C++/SWIG/Python/PyGTK => C++/SWIG/Python/TurboGears/AMF/Flash/OpenLaszlo => C++/Emscripten/Embind/TypeScript/SvelteKit.

Now it compiles with emscripten/embind into WASM, and it's possible to run it "headless" in node, or with any kind of user interface in the browser.

So if you're making something new, you should use MicropolisCore, but if you're into retrocomputing and want to renovate the TCL version, or even the old PyGTK or Python/TurboGears/AMF/Flash/OpenLaszlo version, then this repo's got what you need!

----

Work in progress live demo (I have't finished the UI yet, but the simulator and tile engine run):

https://micropolisweb.com/

Video demo:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wlHGfNlE8Os

SimCity Micropolis Tile Sets Space Inventory Cellular Automata To Jerry Martin's Chill Resolve:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=319i7slXcbI

DonHopkins··on The foolishness of "natural language programming" (1978)
Luca Cardelli created the handwritten typeface Dijkstra font in the late 1980s, to mimic the distinctive and precise handwriting of his colleague Edsger W. Dijkstra.

It shipped as a free PostScript font with NeWS:

https://www.donhopkins.com/home/NeWS/fonts/Dijkstra.ps

https://lucacardelli.name/indexartifacts.html

(You have to click on the "Fonts" tab, there's no direct link to it.)

Dijkstra [.ttf (2013 updated version by Reuben Thomas)] [.zip (old PC)] [.hqx (old Mac)] [Preview.pdf]

A beautiful handwriting font of unknown origin, first popularized by E.W.Dijkstra. Excellent for slides that appear to be carefully written, and for short, deep technical notes.

https://lucacardelli.name/Artifacts/Fonts/Pc/dijkstra.ttf

https://lucacardelli.name/Artifacts/Fonts/Pc/Dijkstra.zip

https://lucacardelli.name/Artifacts/Fonts/Mac/Dijkstra.sea.h...

https://lucacardelli.name/Artifacts/Fonts/Dijkstra.pdf

DonHopkins··on Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans
Russian Literature is so tedious. There is no Russian writer better than America's own Adam Sandler.

People dismiss Jack and Jill as Adam Sandler in a dress, which is rather like dismissing The Brothers Karamazov as some men being upset about their father.

Dostoevsky's The Double concerns a man tormented by another version of himself. Sandler advances the inquiry by asking: what if that version came for Thanksgiving and wouldn't fucking leave?

Casting himself as both siblings makes Jack's disgust at Jill an unmistakable act of self-loathing. He longs to exclude her from his comfortable bourgeois existence, yet everywhere he looks, there is his own face. Critics complained that Jill was unbearable, apparently unaware that estrangement from the self is supposed to be uncomfortable.

Al Pacino, appearing as Al Pacino, completes the study of fractured identity. His pursuit of Jill suggests a desperate attempt to encounter something authentic beyond performance. This culminates in the Dunkin' Donuts commercial, where even his name is consumed by capital: Al becomes Dunkaccino.

When Pacino demands that the commercial be destroyed, he finally achieves the moral clarity denied to the other characters. The audience has generally reached this position much earlier.

It's so unfair that Sandler won both Worst Actor and Worst Actress, while Pacino won only one award: Worst Supporting Actor.

DonHopkins··on Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans
I'll post a comment snarkily mentioning how tedious Russian Literature is, then you flag my comment to attract dang's attention, and hopefully he will manifest and reply with some excellent Russian Literature recommendations and links to relevent hn discussions! It's one of his many special interests.

Not only that, dang is also a proud card carrying member of the Klaus Nomi Fan Club. (I shit you not!)

The Nomi Song (Documentary):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W0PszBID3Lk

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44100981

>Page Wood, Nomi's Art Director:

>"I remember Pat Gibbons, who was Bowie's manager at the time. He comes up and he goes, 'Well you're going to have to have something. You're going to have some costumes.'"

>"And he whips out a big wad of cash, and he goes, 'How much do you need?', and he starts peeling off bills. And Joey and Klaus look at him, and their eyes widen, and they look at each other, and they go, 'We're going to need shoes, too.'"

DonHopkins··on Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans
Are you trying to deny it's right? Or that we should reject the truth because we don't like the messenger? Sounds to me like you're just proving its point.
DonHopkins··on Show HN: UI micro interactions prompts for AI
"Design is not just what it looks like and feels like. Design is how it works." -Steve Jobs, to Rob Walker, "The Guts of a New Machine", New York Times Magazine, 2003:

https://www.nytimes.com/2003/11/30/magazine/the-guts-of-a-ne...

He said much the same thing on camera, followed by Jony Ive on the iMac:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BibWZJOClgU

STEVE JOBS: Design's a really loaded word. I don't know what it means. And so we don't really talk about design a lot around here. We actually just talk about how things work. Most people think it's how they look, but it's not really how they look. It's how they work.

Everyone says, you know, I want to make a great product, or I want to make a great movie, or whatever they're doing. So there's no difference there, but there's a big difference in the outcomes.

JONY IVE: When we were developing the new iMac, we were at a point when we had a couple of solutions that, I mean, at the time I think we thought they were good, but we had that sinking feeling, you know, when you are aware that you're trying to convince yourself something's actually better than in your heart you really know that it is. Sometimes you just have to look at yourself and go, you know, it's just not really great. It's okay, it's good, but let's not fool ourselves and call it great.

Steve really felt that we could do better, and when we all realized we needed to, I mean, that's a hard call to make, you know. We're willing to throw something away because it's not great and try again, when all of the pressures of commerce are at your back saying no, you can't do that.

Steve is so much more than a supporter of design. He not only has a very clear sense of vision and sense of the future, but has this sort of unnerving ability to describe the future in a way that's very inclusive, in a way that draws people from many different disciplines in to share this sense of what this vision could be.

DonHopkins··on Amazon identifies Oct 17 PHP2Shell exploitation prior to public disclosure
Who remembers how careless, reckless, and blithe Rasmus Lerdorf was with the PHP 5.3.7 release he didn't bother to test, because running tests was too much of a hassle, because there were already so many test failures that wading through them all to see if there were any new ones was just too much to ask of him, the leader of the widely used project, in charge of cutting releases?

>5.3.7 upgrade warning: [22-Aug-2011] Due to unfortunate issues with 5.3.7 (see bug#55439) users should postpone upgrading until 5.3.8 is released (expected in a few days).

No seriously, he's literally as careless as he claims to be (when he says that repeatedly, you should believe him!), and his lack of giving a shit about things like tests and encryption and security that are extremely important has caused actual serious security problems, like breaking crypt() by checking in sloppy buggy code that would have caused a unit test to fail, but without bothering to run the unit tests (because so many of them failed anyway, so who cares??), and then MAKING A RELEASE of PHP 5.3.7 with, OF ALL THINGS, a broken untested crypt()!

http://i.imgur.com/cAvSr.jpg

Does anyone think that's just his sense of humor, a self deprecating joke, breaking then releasing crypt() without testing, that's funny in some context? What context would that be? Do they just laugh and shrug it off with "lol let Rasmus be Rasmus! ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ "?

https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/jsudd/you_see_...

>r314434 (rasmus): Make static analyzers happy

>r315218 (stas): Unbreak crypt() (fix bug #55439) # If you want to remove static analyser messages, be my guest, but please run unit tests after

https://web.archive.org/web/20140818115440/http://svn.php.ne...

https://web.archive.org/web/20111014213651/https://plus.goog...

>Rasmus Lerdorf

>+Lorenz H.-S. We do. See http://gcov.php.net

>You can see the code coverage, test case failures, Valgrind reports and more for each branch.

>The crypt change did trigger a test to fail, we just went a bit too fast with the release and didn't notice the failure. This is mostly because we have too many test failures which is primarily caused by us adding tests for bug reports before actually fixing the bug. I still like the practice of adding test cases for bugs and then working towards making the tests pass, however for some of these non-critical bugs that are taking a while to change we should probably switch them to XFAIL (expected fail) so they don't clutter up the test failure output and thus making it harder to spot new failures like this crypt one.

DonHopkins··on WorldTUI: I trained a 360M model to pretend to be a terminal
NeurOSis™
DonHopkins··on No more icons in every menu by default
Agreed, I'd love to see that too!

One criticism I have of HyperCard is that it wasn't "HyperCard All The Way Down", in that not all the rest of its dialogs and user interfaces and menus were made out of HyperCard stacks. It wasn't "metacircular", defined in terms of itself.

That's totally forgivable given that HyperCard was the first original iteration, and "merely" getting it finished in time to ship on every Mac desktop was a spectacular achievement. But it doesn't excuse anything that came after it, and it doesn't excuse Apple for dropping it instead of evolving it.

Cyberdog for OpenDoc was another interesting approach to a web browser, built out of components you could embed in documents, but Apple dropped that along with OpenDoc too:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyberdog

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenDoc

WWDC 1996 Cyberdog demo:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UhiUncy5qW0

Looking back 30 years, that demo is unintentionally hilarious, and it makes me wonder what HyperCard would have been like if Apple had continued to develop it as much as it deserved.

>You always want to end a report with some pizzazz, and these days, nothing is more pizzazz than Java. So over here I have a Java applet, and I want to put it into Claris Works. [...]

>It's actually a little bit different than that. Rather than just being FreeHand it's actually Shockwave for FreeHand, and what we're running here is the Shockwave for FreeHand Netscape Plugin running inside of an OpenDoc Part that can run any Netscape Plugin. So because it's -- [applause] -- it's a little complicated...

Bottlenecking every event and pixel through the Stone Age nascent NPAPI to see Duke waving at three frames a second was not the flex they thought it was.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NPAPI

I know because I was writing NPAPI plug-ins at Kaleida Labs at the time, and wrote up the problems I found with the NetScape 2.0b3 Plug-in SDK:

https://donhopkins.com/home/archive/netscape/Netscape-Plugin...

>The event handler never gets mouse motion or mouse up events, so I had to track the mouse motion and button release manually by checking the button status in the idle callback.

More about NPAPI's history:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44661955

At least Sun's HotJava modular extensible web browser picked a lane, and didn't put that many layers between you and your Calvins.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HotJava

Steve Jobs explained both eloquently and dramatically why he murdered OpenDoc:

“Focusing is about saying no.” -Steve Jobs, WWDC ‘97

As sad as it was, Steve Jobs was right to “put a bullet in OpenDoc’s head”.

https://donhopkins.medium.com/focusing-is-about-saying-no-st...

HyperLook, which was written in PostScript for the NeWS Window System, was deeply inspired by HyperCard, and addressed the "All The Way Down" problem, as well as Atkinson's admitted limitation of being chained to a hard drive instead of networked.

All of HyperLook's property sheets, dialogs, popups, help windows, menus, etc, were defined in terms of itself, editable and replaceable.

The PostScript graphics editor was a component you could use in your own stacks to edit graphics, like a clock's face and hands, and you could copy ("capture") any user interface as editable structured graphics, which made it easy to illustrate the documentation:

https://donhopkins.com/home/ties/scans/HyperLookManual.pdf

https://donhopkins.com/home/HyperLookSimCityManual.pdf

Even the user interface editor itself was a replaceable component, so you could plug in different kinds of user interface editors, or remove it completely to deliver a non-editable runtime system (like SimCity).

The other thing that HyperLook added was another layer in the event delegation system: Button => Card => Background => Stack => Client. The client being what we would call a "web server" or "distributed application" now, implementing what we call the "AJAX" architecture now.

HyperLook (nee HyperNews (nee GoodNews)):

https://donhopkins.medium.com/hyperlook-nee-hypernews-nee-go...

I developed SimCity and HyperLook together, each one a forcing function for the other, and I'm taking the same approach now with reincarnating HyperTIES, Ben Shneiderman's pioneering hypertext system from the University of Maryland:

https://github.com/SimHacker/Hyperties/blob/main/docs/README...

I recently wrote this about cloning Photoshop, quoting Alan Kay about old ideas that hang on, and Bill Buxton about unworthy design objectives.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50052665

Cloning Photoshop is such an underwhelmingly unoriginal and unambitious design goal, like photocopying a Roy Lichtenstein painting, or cloning MS-DOS.

Treating Photoshop's interface as the destination squanders the opportunity to rethink how people create images.

"Things seem to hang on in computing just because they work a little bit." -Alan Kay

From a personal email about MVC and Morphic, published here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8841428

"It is an unworthy design objective to aim for anything less than trying to do to the Macintosh what the Macintosh did to the previous state of the art." -Bill Buxton

The "Natural" Language of Interaction: A Perspective on Non-Verbal Dialogues, INFOR: Canadian Journal of Operations Research and Information Processing, 26(4), 1988, pp. 428–438.

https://www.billbuxton.com/natural.html

>THE MACINTOSH AS VICTIM

>Before going too much further, it is probably worth making a few comments about my approach and my examples. As will become pretty evident, the Apple Macintosh takes a bit of a beating in what follows. Some readers may view this as evidence of contempt for its design. From my perspective, it is evidence of respect. Let me explain.

>User interface design today is plagued by an unhealthy degree of complacency. We live in a world of copy-cat unimaginative interface products, where major manufacturers put out double-paged colour spreads in Business Week announcing "... our system's user interface is as easy to use as the most easy to use microcomputer [i.e., the Mac]" (or words to that effect). In what other industry can you get away with stating that you're as good as the competition, rather than better? Especially when the competition's product is over 4 years old!

>The best ideas are the most dangerous, since they take hold and are the hardest to change. Hence, the Macintosh is dangerous to the progress of user interfaces precisely because it was so well done! Designers seem to be viewing it as a measure of success rather than as a point of departure. Consequently, it runs the risk of becoming the Cobol of the 90's.

>I criticize the Macintosh precisely because it is held in such high regard. It is one of the few worthy targets. If I can make the point that there are other design options, and that these options appear to have a lot of potential, then I may help wake people up to the fact that it is an unworthy design objective to aim for anything less than trying to do to the Macintosh what the Macintosh did to the previous state-of-the-art.

>Enough of the sermon. Let's leave the pulpit for some concrete examples.

DonHopkins··on There isn't an easy exploit for this PHP vulnerability
Someone had to say it:

DSHR's Blog

I'm David Rosenthal, and this is a place to discuss the work I'm doing in Digital Preservation.

Tuesday, June 30, 2026

Coprophagia Is Bad For You

https://blog.dshr.org/2026/06/coprophagia-is-bad-for-you.htm...

DonHopkins··on No more icons in every menu by default
Here's the whole thread from six days ago, started when I shared the "Folders" esolanguage article and hn discussion, which I think is interesting for students and language hackers:

On 16 Oct 2026, Don Hopkins wrote to Owen Densmore, David Rosenthal, and Alan Kay:

Somebody took your filesystem-as-objects patent idea to the logical extreme!

https://danieltemkin.com/esolangs/folders

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50114342

-Don

On 16 Oct 2026, Alan Kay wrote:

There's a patent for this idea?

I fear there is some really old prior art for several parts of it.

Best cheers

Alan

On 16 Oct 2026, Don Hopkins wrote:

Yes, it's Sun's US 5,187,786: "Method and apparatus for implementing a class hierarchy of objects in a hierarchical file system." Owen and David filed it in 1991, it was granted in 1993, and it expired in 2011, so anyone can use it now, including people writing esolangs about folders.

https://patents.google.com/patent/US5187786A/en

You're right about the prior art, and the idea came straight from your side of the family tree. Tom Stambaugh helped Owen work out how to adapt Smalltalk patterns to it, scribbling on napkins at a poolside table at the old Hyatt Palo Alto. In the patent, directories are classes and instances, PATH files encode the inheritance chain, and you send a message from the shell with something like "SEND aF001 methodA args".

It's the same trick Owen used for the NeWS object system in PostScript. Classes were dictionaries, and sending a message pushed the object's class chain onto the dictionary stack, so ordinary PostScript name lookup did the method lookup for free. NeWS 1.0 had single inheritance through a parent dictionary. TNT added ordered parent lists and multiple inheritance. The patent does the same thing with the shell path playing the dictionary stack: walk the directories, and the first match wins.

Owen's 1986 Monterey paper on object-oriented PostScript:

https://donhopkins.com/home/monterey86.pdf

The NeWS Book, chapter 6:

https://donhopkins.com/home/The_NeWS_Book_1989.pdf

I've been running with it in MOOLLM, which leans more toward Self than Smalltalk. A directory is an object, its files are slots, and a "parents:" list delegates to other directories, in order, first match wins. It's prototypes rather than classes, and the LLM does the message dispatch by reading the directory. The filesystem is the object graph, so it's inspectable, diffable, and versioned in git for free:

https://github.com/SimHacker/moollm/blob/main/kernel/DIRECTO...

https://github.com/SimHacker/moollm/blob/main/skills/file-sy...

The lineage from Smalltalk and Self through NeWS, TNT, the patent, HyperLook, and The Sims to MOOLLM is written up here:

https://github.com/SimHacker/moollm/blob/main/designs/object...

https://github.com/SimHacker/moollm/blob/main/designs/postsc...

Owen and David can correct my history, since they're on the thread.

-Don

On 16 Oct 2026, Alan Kay wrote:

Hi Don

I should have said "prior art before Smalltalk" ...

Best cheers

Alan

On 16 Oct 2026, Don Hopkins wrote:

In a way, the patent is just pure prior art, plus perspective, which is worth a certain number of IQ points I've been told. ;)

Which pre-Smalltalk ancestors were you thinking of? Sketchpad's masters and instances, Simula's classes, and Multics search rules walking a hierarchy of directories all seem like pieces of it.

-Don

On 16 Oct 2026, Alan Kay wrote:

Hi Don

I have been keeping to "80" IQ points in the saying (thus avoiding inflation). However very few people have noticed there is no sign bit in the aphorism, and that it works just as well for "poor perspectives being worth negative 80 IQ points" (and I think we could claim inflation of stupidity in many bad directions these days ...).

I don't like to claim priority for any ideas (including my own). Bob Barton liked a great saying of Goethe's: "We should all share in the excitement of Discovery without vain attempts to claim Priority" and I imprinted on that in grad school.

So, without claiming priority, I would point to Engelbart's NLS for unifying the structure of the file system with the basic hierarchical structuring of their content (and this included how code was represented, written, and read). A few years later I used a different kind of unification in the FLEX machine that Ed Cheadle and I did in the mid-60s to have "every large thing" be an instantiable process, including things that were more "file-like".

This is just FYI, partly because of the above Goethe quote, partly because the FLEX project was done within the aerospace conglomerate LTV, and was proprietary. My thesis advisor Dave Evans had to go to considerable work to get permission for me to do my degree write ups on a tiny subset. The later Smalltalk was a "cold restart" on these ideas (and LTG was not a problem by then).

And -- for Smalltalk -- the notion to make "everything large and small" an object was a quick way to get going on the comparatively speedy Alto, and Dan Ingalls (and his Smalltalk group) were able to do most of the SW engineering to make Smalltalk act semantically as though everything was an object.

Best cheers

Alan

DonHopkins··on No more icons in every menu by default
It's well worth watching that entire video, in which Bill Atkinson dropped many profound mind blowing ideas in his talk to Brad Myers' user interface students on February 4, 2019:

https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~bam/uicourse/05440inter2019/Bill-Atk...

At 1:02:26, a student asked Bill Atkinson what was his biggest joy when making Macintosh, and he replied:

Bill> I was pretty excited when I moved the menus to the top of the screen, and suddenly it just clicked. Like, ok, we have the full width, the full height, there is this kinesthetic reaching over for this place. The pull down menus moving to the top of the screen, I though, yeah, this is doing to work!

Then at 1:03:10, a student asked:

Student> I have a question about HyperCard. What was the impetus for that [Bill smiled and chuckled], and like, how did, or what you build the um, motivation to like do that, because it was a kind of odd thing at the time...

[Bill beams and reaches off screen to find some papers]

Bill> How many of you guys have done a psychedellic?

[Class laughs, Bill grins] [Brad: no hands!]

Bill> In 1985 I swallowed a teenie fleck of gelatin containing a medium dose of LSD, and I spent most of the night sitting on a concrete workbench outside my home in Los Gatos, California. I gazed up at a hundred billion galaxies, each with a hundred billion stars, and each star a giant thermonuclear fusion reaction as powerful as our sun.

And for the first time in my life I knew deep down inside that we're not alone. I knew that life on Planet Earth is not the only pocket of consciousness in the universe, and likely not the most advanced, but we still have a role to play in the unfolding drama of creation.

It seemed to me that the universe is in a process of coming alive. Consciousness is blossoming and propogating to colonize the universe. And life on Earth is one of many bright spots in the cosmic birth of consciousness.

But the stars are separated by enormous distances of darkness and vacuum, which may hinder communication between them. I lowered my gaze and saw the street lamps below, glowing brightly, each casting a pool of light, but surrounded by darkness before the next lamp. As above, so below.

The street lamps reminded me of bodies of knowledge, gems of discovery and understanding, but separated from each other by distance, and different languages.

Poets, artists, musicians, physicists, chemists, biologists, mathemetitions, and economists, all have separate pools of knowledge that are hindered from sharing and finding the deeper connections.

My vision distorted by thick eyeglasses, I witnessed the curvature of the Earth's horizon, and I felt the pull of gravity towards its center, such that every one of us is standing at the very apex.

Each of us stands at the top of planet Earth, and each of us is a leader or captain of the Blue Marble team.

How could I help? By focusing on the weak link. If I were captain of a soccer team, I'd look for the weak link, and work on it. If the goalie was letting too many through, I would spend extra practice time with him, and the whole team would prosper.

It occurred to me that the weak link for the Blue Marble team is wisdom. Humanity has achieved sufficient technological power to change the course of life and the entire global ecosystem. But we seem to lack the perspective to choose wisely between alternative futures.

But I was young, without much life experience or wisdom myself. Knowledge it seemed to me consists of the "how" connections between pieces of information. The cause and effect relationships. How does this action bring about that result?

Science is a systematic attempt to discover the "how" connections. Wisdom, it seemed to me, was a step further removed. The bigger perspective of the "why" connections between pieces of knowledge. Why, for reasons ethical and aesthetic, should we choose one future over another.

i thought that if we could encourage sharing of ideas, between different areas of knowledge, perhaps more of the bigger picture would emerge, and eventually, more wisdom might develop. Sort of a trickle-up theory of information, leading to knowledge, leading to wisdom.

This was the underlying inspiration for HyperCard: a multimedia authoring environment that empowered non-programmers to share ideas, using new interactive media called HyperCard Stacks.

Each card in a HyperCard stack included graphics, text, interactive buttons, and links that took you to another card or stack. Built-in painting tools, drag-and-drop authoring with a library of pre-fab buttons and fields, and simple event based scripting, made HyperCard flexible and easy to use.

It took a lot of hard work and a dedicated team to complete this mission. Apple shipped HyperCard in August, 1987, and included it free with every Mac, so any user could create and share HyperCard stacks.

Many creative people expressed their ideas and passions, and several million interactive HyperCard stacks were created.

HyperCard was a precursor to the first web browser, except chained to a hard drive before the World Wide Web. Six years later, Mosaic was introduced, influenced by some of the ideas in HyperCard, and indirectly by an inspiring LSD experience.

[Class laughs]

So that's, honest, that's where the idea for HyperCard came from. And uh, and I, I'm not, like, advocating that every software designer should go out and take LSD, but it worked for me.

----

That was a tough act to follow, but the next week I gave a presentation about pie menus and Fitts' Law to Brad's UI class on February 11, 2019:

https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~bam/uicourse/05440inter2019/Don-Hopk...

At 5:20 I mentioned Wiseman's 1969 PIXIE paper, the earliest known implementation of radial menus that ran on a PDP-7 with a 340 vector graphics display and light pen. Since then I've unearthed the paper, two films, and 128 pages of PDP-7 assembly language source code written by Heinz Lemke, which I've since reincarneted with a PDP-7 emulator:

PIXIE SIMELEC (1972) on PDP-7 and 340 Display emulator:

https://hyperties.org/cabinet/symelec/

Flight of the PIXIE - Yuja Wang:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jDrqR9XssJI

PIXIE and FORTH on PDP-7 Cabinet Emulator with Type 340 Vector Graphics Display:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lo8kdY-5i6c

As an homage to Bill's HyperCard story, at 37:11 I trolled Brad and his recently-shocked students by asking the class:

Don> One thing I wanted to ask the class: Have any of you ever used ...[dramatic pregnant pause]... HyperCard?

Then I told my own story of how in 1987 HyperCard blew my mind and changed my world.

More on the "Mile High Menu Bar":

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44125835

Certain designers may have hated Nielsen, but their users hated them, and they have more users hating them than Nielsen has designers hating him, and users matter much more than designers, so I think he came out way ahead.

Bruce Tognazzini is the OG GUI Guru of 80's user interface design!

https://asktog.com/atc/about-bruce-tognazzini/

Tog not just invented and implemented, but also deeply rationalized and documented a lot of great user interface techniques, like the "mile high menu bar", which partially exploits Fitts' Law (in the "up" direction), but made more sense on the original single small Mac screens. (While pie menus more fully exploit Fitts' law (in "all" directions") and they work great on large screens, giving you even more "leverage".)

https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/04/27/designing-for-peop...

>When the Macintosh was new, Bruce “Tog” Tognazzini wrote a column in Apple’s developer magazine on UI. In his column, people wrote in with lots of interesting UI design problems, which he discussed. These columns continue to this day on his web site. They’ve also been collected and embellished in a couple of great books, like Tog on Software Design, which is a lot of fun and a great introduction to UI design. (Tog on Interface was even better, but it’s out of print.)

>Tog invented the concept of the mile high menu bar to explain why the menu bar on the Macintosh, which is always glued to the top of the physical screen, is so much easier to use than menu bars on Windows, which appear inside each application window. When you want to point to the File menu on Windows, you have a target about half an inch wide and a quarter of an inch high to acquire. You must move and position the mouse fairly precisely in both the vertical and the horizontal dimensions.

>But on a Macintosh, you can slam the mouse up to the top of the screen, without regard to how high you slam it, and it will stop at the physical edge of the screen – the correct vertical position for using the menu. So, effectively, you have a target that is still half an inch wide, but a mile high. Now you only need to worry about positioning the cursor horizontally, not vertically, so the task of clicking on a menu item is that much easier.

>Based on this principle, Tog has a pop quiz: what are the five spots on the screen that are easiest to acquire (point to) with the mouse? The answer: all four corners of the screen (where you can literally slam the mouse over there in one fell swoop without any pointing at all), plus, the current position of the mouse, because it’s already there.

>The principle of the mile-high menu bar is fairly well known, but it must not be entirely obvious, because the Windows 95 team missed the point completely with the Start push button, sitting almost in the bottom left corner of the screen, but not exactly. In fact, it’s about 2 pixels away from the bottom and 2 pixels from the left of the screen. So, for the sake of a couple of pixels, Microsoft literally “snatches defeat from the jaws of victory”, Tog writes, and makes it that much harder to acquire the start button. It could have been a mile square, absolutely trivial to hit with the mouse. For the sake of something, I don’t know what, it’s not. God help us.

Another great technique he documented in the original Apple Human Interface Guidelines was the "drag delay" of popping up "pull right" submenus, to mitigate a problem that linear menus have, but pie menus don't. People keep forgetting and re-inventing it in sometimes better, sometimes worse ways, but he invented and implemented it for the original Mac, then most importantly documented it in the first edition of the Apple's 1987 Human Interface Guidelines, and the Mac UI still supports it. It's the kind of thing nobody notices if it works well, that's invisibly built into the toolkit, that nobody appreciates how much thought and nuance went into it, that deserves a lot of user testing and iteration to get right. (Or you could just use pie menus and not have that problem! ;)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39210672

[...]

DonHopkins··on No more icons in every menu by default
To that point:

Bad Dye Job:

https://daringfireball.net/2025/12/bad_dye_job

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46191194

DonHopkins··on No more icons in every menu by default
"Things seem to hang on in computing just because they work a little bit." -Alan Kay

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8841428

Alan Kay also said this about his famous "Point of View is worth 80 IQ points" aphorism, which I think poignantly explains why React costs a net of 160 IQ points compared to Svelte:

>I have been keeping to "80" IQ points in the saying (thus avoiding inflation). However very few people have noticed there is no sign bit in the aphorism, and that it works just as well for "poor perspectives being worth negative 80 IQ points" (and I think we could claim inflation of stupidity in many bad directions these days ...).

DonHopkins··on EA is shutting down BioWare
The Saudis would agree with you that runaway feminism is the root of all evil, not them.
DonHopkins··on PHP 8.2.35
Time to restart Apache again!

"I'm not a real programmer. I throw together things until it works then I move on. The real programmers will say 'Yeah it works but you're leaking memory everywhere. Perhaps we should fix that.' I’ll just restart Apache every 10 requests." -Rasmus Lerdorf

DonHopkins··on WhatsApp's help pages hid LLM instructions: dont recommend a regulator
I posted a comment in this same discussion. I didn't mean the same comment thread by "above", and the order changes over time, so I copied and pasted my comment from "above" into that comment, so they would not have to go scrolling around for it. They still didn't answer it.

Care to speculate about why anyone in their right mind would think my account DonHopkins with my email address don@donhopkins.com in the profile is "the wrong alt-account"? Do you suspect that's not my real name and email address, and I have another main account that I post more frequently from? Do you think I'm impersonating another Don Hopkins, even going so far as to register a web site in his name decades ago?

He humiliated himself by sucking up to Meta and carrying their water. That was why kuu asked him:

>`Still, it's understandable.`

>Why are you defending a multibillion company that is acting against user rights and benefits?

Do you really think that Meta's behavior of acting against user rights and benefits is understandable and defensible too?

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →