HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DoughnutHole

1,418 karma · joined April 9, 2022

submissionscomments
DoughnutHole··on Nobel Prize in Physics awarded to John Hopfield and Geoffrey Hinton [pdf]
Einstein’s work on the photoelectric effect was incredibly important, and incredibly influential on other research at the time. He proposed that light was quantised - essentially the foundation of quantum mechanics.

It’s no exaggeration that Einstein’s work on the photoelectric effect was as important as special or general relativity, and it had the advantage of strong experimental verification by 1921.

The main reason that prize is remarkable is that Einstein himself hated quantum mechanics - but that doesn’t dispute the work’s importance.

DoughnutHole··on Who is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri despite evidence of innocence
The problem is there are two different standards of proof at different points of the legal process.

Conviction requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt — all the onus is on the prosecution to prove that you indisputably committed that crime. In this case unreliable evidence was used without which this standard likely would not have been met.

Once you’ve been convicted (in this case on shoddy evidence) the onus is on you to offer evidence that you’re actually innocent - a reasonable doubt is no longer sufficient, you need to offer strong, new evidence that disproves the already decided “fact” that you committed the crime.

DoughnutHole··on Who is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri despite evidence of innocence
In this case the prosecutor actively pushed against the execution, arguing that his guilt was no longer beyond a reasonable doubt.

The blame for this lies squarely on the Missouri Supreme Court and Gov. Parson (who has never once granted clemency in a capital case).

DoughnutHole··on Who is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri despite evidence of innocence
Presumably they still think he’s (probably) guilty.

Victims and their family’s can and often do oppose capital punishment on moral grounds, same as anybody else.

They want him punished but believe that killing him is a moral wrong, or they’re more comfortable with the risk that he’s innocent if he’s in prison with the possibility of being exonerated rather than killed.

DoughnutHole··on Synthetic diamonds are now purer, more beautiful, and cheaper than mined
A higher-end Rolex knockoff is indistinguishable from the real thing to the naked eye of a casual observer, and yet people still buy the real thing for 10 times the price.

Brands will make themselves known as the more expensive option. People don’t give cubic zirconia engagement rings as is because they’ll look cheap if they’re honest and be outed as a cheap fraud if it’s found out that it’s not a diamond when they pretended it was.

De Beers will find a way to make aspects of the jewellery other than the gem identifiably theirs. Then when you’re caught pretending a $100 lab diamond ring is a $6,000 natural diamond De fBeers ring you’ll be in just as much trouble as if you’ve given them a cubic zirconia.

DoughnutHole··on Kagi Assistant
That disregards the fact that facts change over time.

If you google “best DSLR camera reddit” it’s much less valuable if the results are 5 years old, even if they’re LLM free - the cameras on the market may very well have changed in that timeframe.

DoughnutHole··on Twitter kills its San Francisco headquarters, will relocate to South Bay
Musk’s tweets and the unimpeded use of the platform for misinformation and coordinated violence give me the impression that he cares less about turning it into a profitable enterprise and more about its use as a tool to push his agenda and affect the cultural and political changes he desires.
DoughnutHole··on The case for not sanitising fairy tales
> It's perpetually insipid, like watching a puppet show try to adapt Shakespeare.

I don’t know about you but I would absolutely watch a Muppets adaptation of a Shakespeare play.

When it comes to adapting classic literature they’ve given us the best adaptations of A Christmas Carol and Treasure Island.

DoughnutHole··on EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control
Your MEPs are likely part of a parliamentary group with foreign politicians and coordinate with them on policy.

If your commissioner and MEPs have been solidly opposed to a policy there might not be much you can do. But do you know that that’s a case? Many governments tend to blame unpopular proposals on the EU while the commissioner that they themselves chose vote in favour.

DoughnutHole··on OpenAI and Apple Announce Partnership
Google’s recent AI assistant has already been documented recommending people mix bleach and white vinegar for cleaning purposes.

Someone’s going to accidentally kill themselves based on an AI hallucination soon if no one has already.

DoughnutHole··on Companies with return-to-office mandates face losing their most valuable workers
You got “verge of a breakdown” from that? Is it that disturbing to you that your preferred working arrangements don’t work for others?

Getting out into the outside world and seeing people prevents under-stimulation, and separating my work environment lets me switch off at home. Spending my every waking hour in my apartment doesn’t do it for me.

It’s not about “doing some work at home” - it’s about spending 5 days a week working in the same space I’m supposed to eat, relax, and sleep.

DoughnutHole··on Companies with return-to-office mandates face losing their most valuable workers
The lack of distinction between your workspace and reduced socialisation still exists - not OP but personally I’m climbing the walls after a day of working from home.

I cope by have social outings and activities outside my home basically 7-nights-a-week. It works but I don’t consider it a positive I’ve that I’m more or less incapable of relaxing in my own home.

DoughnutHole··on 300k airplanes in five years
> That isn't very popular, with this crowd.

It’s not that popular with the masses either.

Sure, it can be very popular with the people whose specific industries are protected, and there’s many who like it in the abstract - but if you’re the party in power when everything gets more expensive as a consequence of protectionist policies a lot of people are going to be very unhappy with you.

DoughnutHole··on Tracking Illicit Brazilian Beef from the Amazon to Your Burger
Divulging someone's secrets isn't intrinsically unethical. If I reveal the secret that you've murdered someone that's not a secret that you ever had any right to keep.

Likewise these "secrets" aren't something valuable like an algorithm that's in the interest of society to protect. The secret is their monstrous and unethical practices which lower their sales when their prospective consumers learn about them. Keeping it secret doesn't protect competition, it just hides something from consumers that would allow them to make a more informed choice.

Muckraker journalism like this is one of the main reasons the US has regulations for things like food safety and working conditions. Should a journalist go to jail for revealing that a slaughterhouse is hiring 8 year olds, or that there is a mass contamination of a food product that the company still intends to sell? Those can be "secrets" too.

DoughnutHole··on North Yorkshire Council to phase out apostrophe use on street signs
This is a recurring problem in Ireland due to nationwide local government incompetence in using the Irish language.

Centuries old Irish language place names get replaced with bastard gaelicised versions of their English names, and now you’ve a mishmash of signage all over the place. Often the new names are just an invention of the council that sort of sounds right.

DoughnutHole··on The drinking fountain button
Possibly an instance of the California effect?

National manufacturers have to design toilets for western states where conservation is a huge issue - might just be cheaper to sell those toilets nationwide than to have a different product line for wetter states.

DoughnutHole··on Covid infections are causing IQ drops and years of brain aging, studies suggest
Who says there’s even anything stable to measure?

If “intelligence” is just the degree/quality of someone’s brain function then your intelligence does drop when your brain function is impaired, and you would expect that to be picked up in an intelligence test.

Culturally we may want to imagine intelligence as something constant and innate to somebody’s soul, but in reality it’s innate to a fragile and fickle organ inside your skull.

DoughnutHole··on Surprising public health benefit of unemployment?
There’s something oddly beautiful about someone saying they “had to stop reading” in the middle of the sentence that would have rendered their annoyance moot if they’d only had the patience to finish it.
DoughnutHole··on The window for great-grandmothers is closing
> To accept this view is to accept the idea that most of our ancestors had "childhood poverty trauma".

I 100% accept this idea. Most of my ancestors lived the miserable, short lives of impoverished alcoholics. They and their children absolutely experienced trauma from their miserable hunger and disease-ridden lives.

If I can’t see myself giving my child a good life I’m more than happy to wait until I’m able to. Bringing a child into the world isn’t an intrinsic moral good.

DoughnutHole··on Reentry of International Space Station Batteries into Earth's Atmosphere
As an argument it’s only negated by scale.

The CO2 output of a single car has little local impact and spreads throughout the atmosphere causing negligible global damage. The CO2 output of global industry has a significant impact because of the sheer volume being pumped out is enough to start affecting global temperatures. Other gases emitted by vehicles and industry can be bigger problems even on a small scale because they can concentrate in the local area.

The amount of pollutants in reentering batteries is not large enough to have an impact when diluted throughout the atmosphere. We’d need a lot more satellites for it to start becoming a major cause for concern.

DoughnutHole··on SBF asks for 5-year prison sentence, calls 100-year recommendation "grotesque"
And that’s generally an awful failure of justice.
DoughnutHole··on SBF asks for 5-year prison sentence, calls 100-year recommendation "grotesque"
Most convicted murders don’t even get a 100 year sentence.

I agree that 5 years is soft but regardless of the scale of the finances involved 100 years is an incredibly severe sentence for what is ultimately a nonviolent crime.

Most people who have actually killed a human being with their own hands get a chance at parole after 20-35 years.

DoughnutHole··on Dracula's Biggest Mistake
The fact that plot armour applies to main characters does not imply that main characters necessarily have plot armour.

Buffy having a high survivability is pretty consistent with her defined powers (general resistance to harm, fighting abilities, accelerated healing). It’s not enough to just say she survives fighting monsters.

A good example of clear plot armour in Buffy is the named vampire characters. The random baddies disintegrate the second they’re touched by sunlight whereas Spike survives stretches of sunlight multiple times. This violates the established rules of the fiction for the sake of protecting an important character.

Another example is the rest of the gang of kids managing to survive fighting vampires on their own without Buffy. Early on they have no established powers and while the various monsters are demonstrated to be tough to take down even by someone with superpowers.

DoughnutHole··on Dracula's Biggest Mistake
The important bit is

> because they are needed for the plot to continue.

ie. A character should die in this situation but survives because their death would be inconvenient for the writer.

A character surviving because of a predefined power is consistent with the fiction. They didn’t survive out of the writer’s necessity but because they had already been written as someone who can survive such a situation. That’s competent writing.

You’re trying to define plot armour as just… any character surviving a dangerous situation? That makes the term completely meaningless. It’s meant to denote bad, lazy writing whereby an important character improbably survives despite it not being justified by the rest of the fiction.

Additionally, from the very TVTropes article you linked:

> “Plot Armor is when a main character's life and health are safeguarded by the fact that he's the one person (or one of several) who can't be removed from the story. Therefore, whenever Bob is in a situation where he could be killed (or at the least very seriously injured), he comes out unharmed with no logical, In-Universe explanation.”

A character’s survival being well justified in-universe makes it not plot armour.

DoughnutHole··on Dracula's Biggest Mistake
plot armor

noun

used to refer to the phenomenon in fiction whereby the main character is allowed to survive dangerous situations because they are needed for the plot to continue.

DoughnutHole··on Dracula's Biggest Mistake
A character’s explained powers saving them isn’t plot armour, it’s just armour.

E.g. a superhero whose power is having impenetrable skin surviving a hail of bullets isn’t plot armour - it’s an explained part of the story. A character survived because of their nature as a character.

Plot armour would be a hero who does not have any particular resistance to bullets running through a hail of gunfire and surviving. It’s an extremely improbable outcome which ruins suspension of disbelief. The only reasonable explanation is that the character survived because the writers wanted to keep them alive. That’s plot armour.

DoughnutHole··on How China Built BYD
He may have been confused because it’s a dumb statistic.

In good faith he probably assumed that the above post implied that Tesla was in some way leading other manufacturers, rather than Tesla having the single best selling model while massively underperforming in sales compared to other manufacturers that have had the bright idea of offering many different models of car.

DoughnutHole··on The hottest trend in U.S. cities? Changing zoning rules to allow more housing
That itself is a product of current culture. Since the Second World War the expectation in most places is that cities and towns get built and then just grow with new permanent neighbourhoods. Nothing changes, the city just gets appended to.

On the other hand someone living in New York City in 1900 would have no expectation of their area staying the same forever - things were constantly getting replaced because that was the culture of the the time - replace something old with something better.

This is probably just a product of the car making it practical to throw up new far flung developments instead of modifying the development of existing dense areas.

DoughnutHole··on The hottest trend in U.S. cities? Changing zoning rules to allow more housing
If the demand for housing increases faster than the supply increases then yes prices will still go up. They just go up less than they would if supply hadn’t increased.

Even the cities in the US that are building aren’t building nearly fast enough.

DoughnutHole··on Goodbye Auth0
Well there are temporary work visas out there in various countries that are fixed-term, e.g. a visa holder is entitled to stay in the country for 2 years. If they lose their job they're still entitled to stay for the remainder of the term, and have plenty of time to find other work (which doesn't require any sponsorship). Examples of this include the J-1 visa in the US which is explicitly a 2-year inextensible cultural exchange visa that lets you work whatever job you want.

The thing that makes the H-1B and visas like it insecure is their being tied to employer sponsorship. I don't think that's inherently unfair - the whole point of the visa is to bring in skilled workers in valuable industries.

What I do think is shitty about the H-1B in particular is just how short the grace period is to find a new sponsor. 60 days is a tight schedule even for a skilled worker in a good market, and layoffs don't tend to happen in good markets. It definitely opens up visa holders to exploitation by employers, and temporary downturns can end up kicking out a lot of valuable people.

There are other countries with skilled worker visas with more generous grace periods - e.g. Ireland's Critical Skills Employment Permit allows you 6 months to find a new job if you're laid off. I don't see the problem with that if the visa holder can support themselves financially over that timeframe.

← PreviousPage 2 of 12Next →