HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

EdgarVerona

695 karma · joined February 9, 2012

submissionscomments
EdgarVerona··on Ask HN: How do I switch from being a passive consumer to an active producer?
I think this is important. Someone else mentioned that this isn't helpful for what he asked, but I think it is - I think it's important that we understand that working is not passive. If you're working 40 (or in some of our cases, 50, 60, 70) hours a week, you are devoting a significant portion of your life to creation.

I agree with the points others made about how to avoid burnout, find things you're passionate about etc... but I hope the question asker understands that what they're doing does have value. The value may be labor - which, indeed, is undervalued in society compared to actually being the controller/owner of the product on which work is being performed - but it is creating value just the same.

Now, if you reach a point where you want all of that value to be creating to be yours and not mostly someone else's, or if you find you have energy to spare to start working on side projects, then you may be ready to move from putting labor into other people's products to putting labor into your own. But there's no shame in working hard and earning a paycheck, and devoting the other time in your life to doing whatever it is that makes you happy. (and if what makes you happy ends up being creating a side project that turns into something where you control your own product, that's great!)

EdgarVerona··on Let them paste passwords
Just yesterday, I ran into a site that was doing this for the first time in years. It annoyed me to the point where I used the console to override it and allow pasting again.

Password managers are a thing. Please don't force me to type out 32 random symbols twice while I sign up for your service.

EdgarVerona··on The 10 most harmful jobs (2015)
I think part of their assertion is that even being able to play the game for free isn't necessarily a good thing. It's an interesting problem, one that I am still on the fence about myself.

You see companies that are trying their best to make their games compulsive but not fulfilling. Or companies that aren't trying to do that but do so anyways. Games that consist entirely or nearly entirely of extrinsic motivators; at what point are we playing these games because we are genuinely entertained, and at what point has it become a compulsion leveraging our psychological vulnerabilities? At what point is something that we perceive to be enjoying actually harming us? And if there is a point at which that occurs, what can we do about it?

I struggle with this question on both sides of the fence: as a consumer and as a producer. It is complex, and sometimes this very question keeps me up at night. The question is so much more complicated than "am I having fun," or even "do I perceive that I'm getting value out of this."

Sadly, I don't have any answers. Just a lot of doubts.

EdgarVerona··on How Did GM Create Tesla’s Dream Car First?
I don't see how this is getting "his wish, in the worst way".

Wasn't one of their stated goals "to accelerate the advent of sustainable transport?" (https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-our-patent-are-belong-you)

It sounds like that goal is finally starting to become successful. We should all be grateful at the economic pressure Tesla applied to change the market. I hope that our next milestone is to see more EV sold than Combustion vehicles.

EdgarVerona··on Original Diablo Pitch Document (1994) [pdf]
Where they're talking about the small, randomized packs of items... it almost sounds like they were intending a CCG in video game form originally?
EdgarVerona··on Signs that you're a bad programmer (2012)
I agree. It is similar to that old phrase "perfect is the enemy of good." Sometimes what an idea needs is something minimal that gets the product out there and tested, shipping and selling in the real world. Sometimes the most financially effective programming isn't elegant, but rather something quick and dirty, transitory and ugly: something meant to be used and improved on or discarded for something better if and when time allots for it in the future.
EdgarVerona··on Signs that you're a bad programmer (2012)
Yes, that is the worst part to me. I worked at a place once, many years ago, where a Lead software engineer came in and started what I could only equate to a turf war. He'd set people up to get them fired, call competent engineers who made a mistake out as being idiots, etc.

One time, he assigned me work - and never mentioned that someone on another team had been assigned the exact same work. He wanted to see me do it faster than the other guy so that he could fire the other guy. So when I completed it, and he used it as ammunition against the other guy (even though the other guy had done a perfectly good job it turned out). I stood there helpless and ashamed that I'd been used as a weapon for someone to tear another good programmer down.

A couple of months later, the company began to lay people off and that lead bolted for the door. I did too, but I was just glad to not have to work in such a hostile environment anymore. So much anxiety.

EdgarVerona··on Signs that you're a bad programmer (2012)
I agree with other's statements about not judging prematurely. I feel like every software engineer I have ever run into (including and especially myself) has done some or all of these things at one point or another. We all have bad days, we all have poor judgment sometimes. Giving people the benefit of the doubt in cases of lapsed judgment seems like it would create a far less hostile work environment. If it's systemic, it's one thing... but let's try to avoid a witch hunt mentality. Everyone's going to have off days.

The only one whose legitimacy as an antipattern I would question however would be this one:

>"Bulldozer code" that gives the appearance of refactoring by breaking out chunks into subroutines, but that are impossible to reuse in another context (very high cohesion)

I think it is useful to break up complex logic into discrete methods that represent some logical step in the overall algorithm. If they're private methods, I feel like that can add to the readability of the algorithm rather than having it be in one monolithic chunk. I've seen two camps on this - keep it inline vs. make private methods for discrete steps, and I find the latter to be more readable when I look through code (my own or someone else's).

There is a limit to that, of course. If you end up with a tangled tree of methods, that could work against readability... but even then, if you took that tangled tree and made it a single monolithic method, how often would that actually end up being more readable?

EdgarVerona··on 808 Cube
(Note, this is just my take on it - I don't know its real intent, but this is what seemed feasible and fun to me when I tried it out)

To me, the entertaining part was that you couldn't see or use the non-visible sections unless you rotated them into view: that is, unless you altered your original mix.

It makes the Rubik's Cube analogy come together (because without something to force you to vary it, it'd just be freely inputting what you wanted: and at that point, it'd just be a bad mixer interface).

I don't think it was meant to be convenient to use, but instead entertaining and emergent via treating it more like a Rubik's Cube than a mixer.

EdgarVerona··on 808 Cube
That was awesome! Very enjoyable to play with.

EDIT: I also feel like many people here are looking at this with an unintended lens: it doesn't look like it was meant to be a convenient interface for mixing a specific beat. It's meant to be more Rubik's Cube than mixer, and if you look at it that way it's an entertaining experiment!

EdgarVerona··on The Calculus Trap (2005)
I feel like Calculus was very eye-opening for me, personally, and I felt like it was a refreshing finisher to the traditional math courses. When you're in the lower level classes, it's often hard to see where the practical applications are going to start coming around... for me at least, Calculus was where it all came together. I started to see just why I'd taken so many years of math: they all built up to this very practical and fundamental set of mathematics. That isn't to say that there's not a place for other math courses - of course! But Calculus in particular is the "money shot" of math, in my opinion. The applications are firm, and build the fundamentals of physics among other subjects. If I hadn't taken Calculus, I don't think I'd have been as positive about math as I ended up being. That's just my two cents, however.
EdgarVerona··on Where should I start learning Assembly?
Yes! I came in here to recommend that one as well. He does an excellent job of not only talking about the mechanics of the language, but also the system components to which the mechanics directly relate: and he does so in a way that is both easy to understand and thorough. Such a good book.
EdgarVerona··on Ask HN: How many vacations do you take a year?
I'm a 32 year old software engineer living in the U.S. Last year my company (in the most amazing extension of generosity I'd ever seen at any employer) gave everyone the last two weeks of the year off. Prior to that, I'd never had a vacation longer than a week in my professional career.

It's a funny thing - no one's twisting my arm to not take vacations, but I've always felt something akin to "I don't deserve a vacation" (for lack of a better description). I have known many co-workers in my career who have had similar anxiety about taking days off, as if we'll be perceived as not adding value if we're taking vacation.

My current employer's giving of a mandatory 2 week vacation is only now starting to make me realize that employers (at least good ones, like my current employer) don't feel that way at all, and that feeling of inadequacy is in my head.

This year? Well, perhaps I'll take a real vacation. I get 10 days allotted for vacation per year (so 2 weeks), and perhaps if I can find a good time to do so I'll take them consecutively and get a really good vacation - or at least, I won't feel guilty if I take two one-week vacations.

EdgarVerona··on Ask HN: I want to take a vacation and code; where should I go?
Agreed - the cruise idea is fantastic. I went on a cruise and only had programming as a secondary objective (secondary to hanging out with my girlfriend), and even when it wasn't top priority it was still much easier to get it done there.

Cruise ships have a lot of relatively quiet nooks where you can camp out somewhere with a beautiful view of the ocean and just code all day if you want. If you get a balcony room, you could just park yourself there the whole damned trip and take up their free room service for food (just remember to tip them very well at the end if you do this!).

EdgarVerona··on Why I won't do a startup and (probably) neither should you.
I don't know if I'd go so far as to say "Corporate" can be fun, but definitely working with other people can be fun if they're passionate, motivated, and intelligent. The corporate world can be a real crap-shoot on that: sometimes you land in an amazing environment, and sometimes you land in one that looks amazing but under the surface there's a bunch of back-stabbing jerks. And sometimes even a single person can turn it from the first category to the second. (story time!)

I experienced this third category about 5 or so years ago. This one guy came into a company in a senior position, and almost immediately started trying to get people he didn't like fired. He'd pit people against each other, having them do the same assignment to see which one would do it quicker... he'd call people out in meetings for being terrible coders who should be fired (some of his accusation I happened agreed with by coincidence - but most of them were unfairly leveled, and directed toward competent people that he pictured was in his way). He'd talk to senior management telling them about people who he thought should be fired, and they listened. Admittedly, we lost a couple of bad developers: but we also lost good developers who just happened to rub him the wrong way.

That kind of experience isn't just negative, it's scary. He never leveled his gaze at me, but mostly because I realized that he was seeing no negative repercussions for his actions early - and was even being praised for it - and thus tried my best to avoid being in situations where I had to work alongside him.

On a side note, I still feel bad about not speaking up about this and trying to fight him and/or get him fired to save those who worth saving. At the time, I had just gotten married and I was the only breadwinner - going up against him felt like it would be suicide. So I kept my mouth shut, and I do still feel bad about that to this day. I'd like to believe that, were this ever to happen again, I would speak up... but honestly I'm not sure. It's hard to stand up when the consequence of failing is that you'd probably be the next one on the chopping block.

Anyways, I digress. Corporate can be fun - it can also be hell. If you land in the former category, consider yourself lucky (I do now!). And if someone tries to ruin that, don't be a coward like I was: stand up and fight. Because it's not going to get any better if everyone is too afraid of being fired to keep the culture healthy.

EdgarVerona··on Leaving it on the field. No more side projects.
Oy, aye - I feel you on that. Hang in there. I wish that I had more solid advice to give, though perhaps seeing that someone else came to a similar conclusion is helpful - I know that it has for me.
EdgarVerona··on Leaving it on the field. No more side projects.
I had a similar experience to you: I used to do a ton of side projects. About three years ago, I started working at a job where I had a very long commute, and that combined with attempting to continue those side projects burned me out hard. I started leaving programming to what I did for my day job, and if I had the hankering to continue programming I'd just stay at work later.

After a couple of years of that, I admittedly feel mixed about it. I do feel like I've regained some of my lost personal life - though it was too late to save my marriage, particularly since in that first year or so after I came to the realization above I simply ended up working until late in the evening instead - deferring personal projects by simply replacing them with other work and not with maintaining my relationships. Once she left, I finally realized that I not only needed to cut out these side projects, but I also needed to maintain some kind of reasonable work-life balance. (it took me a long time to get to the point where I can accept that this failure of mine caused the dissolution of our marriage - I always viewed my programming and work as a way of making sure that there would always be food at the table and that she'd always be able to do whatever she wanted, but in retrospect it wasn't worth much when she was the only one sitting at that table, and when it didn't seem like she had a partner at all. It took me a long time to be able to say that.)

I now feel a bit less burnt out, and have a desire to start side projects again - but at the same time, I don't want to go back to spoiling the rest of my life for it. I honestly can't figure out how I can resolve the three and still have time to sleep.

So anyways, I sympathize with your situation. Sadly, I don't have any good answers. All I know is that there must be a way to find a good balance, and that I have thus far been unable to find it - and I don't know about you, but my failure to do so has cost me a great deal.

EdgarVerona··on Jury: Newegg infringes Spangenberg patent, must pay $2.3 million
Oh! Okay, this explains a great deal.
EdgarVerona··on Jury: Newegg infringes Spangenberg patent, must pay $2.3 million
We're not bummed out because the cryptosystem is broken, but rather that every victory for a faulty patent is a victory for the system around which faulty patents are allowed to thrive (and strangle out others). Regardless of the tech behind the "patent" and whether it's feasible or not, it's another situation where a dubious patent has wrung money out of someone by exploiting our vulnerable system.
EdgarVerona··on Jury: Newegg infringes Spangenberg patent, must pay $2.3 million
If they've built up knowledge and experience, they ought to prove it by rendering verdicts that make sense. Maybe it's just a case of confirmation bias on my part, but it feels like they've got their heads firmly lodged up their asses over there.
EdgarVerona··on Jury: Newegg infringes Spangenberg patent, must pay $2.3 million
Wow, pardon my french, but what the fuck is this article. This sounds like a paid advertisement. "The company, owned by Erich Spangenberg, of Dallas, is seeking a reasonable royalty of $5.1 million." How much did they get paid for that line?
EdgarVerona··on Jury: Newegg infringes Spangenberg patent, must pay $2.3 million
Indeed, he might as well have said "No other country would let me get away with the shit I'm pulling over on people right now." This whole situation is quite disappointing. Kudos to Newegg for trying, at the very least.
EdgarVerona··on Mint sucks, so why aren't there any real competitors in that space?
Interesting! From that link, it sounds like they're paying a large sum of money to use someone else's integration solution. That could be an option - I wonder just how much money they are shelling out. (and whether Intuit is said integrator!)
EdgarVerona··on Mint sucks, so why aren't there any real competitors in that space?
I agree - though I don't know which solution would be better (standardization of industry APIs as I propose, or a FOSS project to build and maintain a system that could hit all of these systems).

I think a mix of both would be best, though both are also wrought with many more difficulties than we have gone into here. For example, just a couple that come up off the top of my head:

* API Standardization issues

- Many of these companies likely have custom sets of data that they expect, validation rules, their own auth procedures that they'd be hesitant to let go of etc... - Smaller companies (such as in my ECSI example) would likely shy away from the costs of creating such an API for their own services, thus still resulting in the need for custom solutions - Larger companies would also hesitate to change - either due to their own org/system complexity, or just a desire to not spend money on something that doesn't feel core to their business. Healthcare integration standardization is severely hampered by this, for example. - Many of these companies may actually be charging for access to their data backend, which would still thwart the use of standardized APIs even after they were adopted.

* FOSS System Issues

- To create the integrations, companies would have to actually both expose it to you and allow you access. The creators of the FOSS system would have to somehow convince these companies to essentially open up their systems to the world. That would be fantastic I think, but it would be very tough to convince companies. - You'd need a large number of dedicated people to the cause - and not just developers to create and maintain the integrations, but also people with the skills needed to negotiate with the businesses for whatever kinds of back-end deals have to occur to keep the integration online and functional on the financial institution's side. So far, we've been good at finding an army of excellent developers to drive FOSS - for this kind of integration pursuit, the FOSS movement would also need to be good at finding an army of excellent businessmen, lawyers, etc... that would be as dedicated and available as the software development force (I'd be all for such an expansion of scope in the Open Source movement) - The "charging for access" issue above would still be a problem here.

Now, none of these are reasons not to do it - merely a statement of risks and a peek into the scope and effort needed for such an approach. It's not something I'd ever have the time or energy to lead the charge on personally, but kudos to whoever could rally the army (and the political will) needed to make it happen.

EdgarVerona··on Mint sucks, so why aren't there any real competitors in that space?
I totally agree that it would be possible, but very difficult to get properly funded. I have to admit that I'm not sure that I'd pay for it either, unless it truly gave me something special that I couldn't already deduce myself from the kind of data Mint gives. I can't envision exactly what kind of feature would drive me to pay for it, but I don't doubt that there's something I'm not currently able to imagine that would motivate me as such.
EdgarVerona··on Mint sucks, so why aren't there any real competitors in that space?
Note that this is just my gut opinion on it, imagining the nightmares I've seen in healthcare integration and contrasting that with what I see as an end user of Bank integration. I've not actually seen the business deals and effort in the backend as a developer in the latter case, but as an end user of Mint I've seen missing integrations that hint strongly at the difficulties they must experience.

I think the reason why is because it's a pretty large integration undertaking. To compete with Mint at this point, you'd have to offer similar levels of integration with banks, credit card companies, investment companies etc...

The problem is that there are literally tens of thousands of these companies, each exposing their own APIs and each with their own unique caveats as to data they require, throttling limits, back-room deals for access, hesitation to even let people access their systems etc.

For an anecdotal end-user example, I have an account with one provider who refuses to cooperate with Mint in integrating - ECSI. This is a small lending company for student loans, one of thousands of such companies. They decided for reasons that are not publicly available to not even allow Mint to integrate with them anymore, after having let them do so for the first couple of years. What sorts of negotiations were occurring in the back end between these companies, and what caused it to fall apart? The public doesn't know, but needless to say there was some level of custom integration effort for them, some level of business negotiation, and then finally something fell apart and made customers mad as a result. Now, all of this integration work and business negotiation had to happen between Mint and ECSI - and that is just one of the tens of thousands of companies out there. It is a very tall order to ask a new company to come forward and make that much upfront work in order to get on par with Mint so that it can start competing.

The real fight that would make more innovation in the field would probably have to start with getting companies to standardize and expose their APIs without (or with common and well understood) strings attached. If this happened - as has been struggling but slowly improving in the Healthcare field - it'll become more feasible for a company to realistically compete with Mint. And then you can get to those enhanced features that Mint suffers for want of. (however, at that point Mint's significant engineering force could be redirected from integration efforts to these same features, and then you'll find yourself fighting against a much larger machine now bent on feature improvement)

EdgarVerona··on Here's how I deal with users who steal
Kudos, that's great! I think that's a very cool option - I feel like there's a lot of musicians out there who are dirt poor, trying to find a way to break through. It'd be interesting for you to offer the option to scholarship accounts to donate later - and then see which ones actually make it big enough that they decide to pay you back for your service!
EdgarVerona··on Knockout v3.0.0 released
Very cool, many thanks!
EdgarVerona··on Knockout v3.0.0 released
I totally agree with you, 100%. I can't lie, it made me sad when I saw the team starting to turn against Knockout, as the benefits it brings in the points I made above (as well as consistency and maintainability, as you brought up) are real - and often frontend projects suffer greatly for want of these very benefits.

I've never been good at convincing people of things, however, so it's been an uphill battle - one that I lost a lot of ground on early, and I feel like a lot of our frontend codebase suffered as a result. I do feel like they're slowly starting to warm up to the benefits of it now that they've had some maintenance problems with the current approach, but that's similar to sending an innocent man to prison for several years before discovering he's innocent - it'll take a while to undo what's been done, if it can be undone.

Now, none of this is to say that they're bad developers. They make amazing UIs that I couldn't even conceptualize (me being a backend jockey who is terrible at making things look good). It's hard for someone to hear about an entirely new approach to what they've been doing for 5-10 years and to accept it off the bat, so I don't blame them at all. I do still hope that they'll come over entirely to the concept. We'll see what happens. :)

EdgarVerona··on Knockout v3.0.0 released
Oh, I've not even heard of Durandal, I'll have to check that out! (Strangely enough, the word "Durandal" has an historic importance at our company, so it'll be humorous to present this to them if it turns out to be useful for us. ;) )

Indeed, my solution for (2) is to say "hey, let's make a real set of ViewModel objects". I have an internal-only project that I built myself, which was basically a fairly complex experiment in using Knockout - and making the ViewModel objects myself really made a difference in how the whole application felt, it felt great. But it was a hard sell - one that I lost - when I tried to sell them on it in general.

And indeed, I don't know if I'll ever find a solution around (5). I feel like it's a small price to pay for the benefits personally, but it is a price to be paid. :(

← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →