HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

EdwardCoffin

1,760 karma · joined February 20, 2007

submissionscomments
EdwardCoffin··on Fitting an elephant with four non-zero parameters
I listened to the whole series with Dyson some time in the past year. It was well worth it. I also listened to the series with Murray Gell-Mann [1] and Hans Bethe [2]. All time well worth spending, and I've been thinking of downloading all the bits, concatenating them into audio files, and putting them on my phone for listening to when out on walks (I'm pretty sure the videos do not add anything essential: it's just a video of the interviewee talking - no visual aids).

[1] https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLVV0r6CmEsFxKFx-0lsQD...

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LvgLyzTEmJk&list=PLVV0r6CmEs...

EdwardCoffin··on Fitting an elephant with four non-zero parameters
Freeman Dyson recounts the episode [1] that inspired this paper in his web of life interviews (prepositioned to the fitting an elephant bit) [2]

[1] https://youtu.be/hV41QEKiMlM

[2] https://youtu.be/hV41QEKiMlM?t=118

EdwardCoffin··on Ask HN: Which astronomy textbook for beginners?
The topic of the currency of Meeus's book came up on stack exchange [1]. The consensus seems to be that there's no replacement yet, but that there are some better ephemerides available - but figuring out how to use those rather than the ones in the book is difficult for someone not familiar with this stuff (like me).

[1] https://astronomy.stackexchange.com/questions/53967/modern-e...

EdwardCoffin··on Ask HN: Which astronomy textbook for beginners?
I have the same Meeus book. It's been a while since I read it, but my impression was the signs of longitudes being turned around was not unique to his book, but was rather a convention throughout astronomy, so you could expect to find whatever other books you're recommended would have the same convention.

When I was contemplating my own implementation from that book my sketchy API design just included a mandatory extra parameter to accompany such numbers, which would explicitly indicate whether the astronomical or other sign convention was to be used.

EdwardCoffin··on Db2 is a story worth telling, even if IBM won't
The article opens by stating the author had overlooked mentioning the iSeries (aka AS/400) version of DB2 in a list of DB2 versions. My understanding is that the iSeries DB2 was really more a marketing name applied to the iSeries database.

Here are a couple of supporting quotations out of Frank G. Soltis's book Inside the AS/400 (both from page 120). Soltis was the chief architect of the AS/400:

IBM selected the name DB2 for OS/400 to reflect that it is part of the IBM DB2 family of relational database products. The family resemblance among these database products exists primarily in their external tools and their support for distributed database facilities. The underlying support is quite different in each case, and the AS/400 may well be the best in the group. The DB2 name does help alleviate the perception that the AS/400 does not have as robust a database as other systems.

...

I was opposed to naming the AS/400 database until | had a meeting with a large manufacturing customer who was moving from another system to the AS/400. In the meeting, the technical people asked me what database | would recommend for the AS/400. | blurted out, “DB2/400,” a name being circulated in internal discussions. Immediately, the people in the room began to nod and make comments like, “Oh, that’s a very good database.” Considering that these people worked for another division in IBM and they didn’t know the AS/400 had a database, it was obvious to me that we needed to name it.

EdwardCoffin··on A Thousand Primers, Not Just One
Here's Stephenson from an AMA on reddit twelve years ago [1]:

Q: My ultimate goal in life is to make the Primer real. Anything you want to make sure I get right?

Neal Stephenson: Kids need to get answers from humans who love them.

[1] https://old.reddit.com/r/Fantasy/comments/vdt11/i_am_neal_st...

EdwardCoffin··on Researchers invent 100% biodegradable 'barley plastic'
Generally avoiding plywood isn't actually useful advice for someone with even a serious problem with gluten: "simply touching gluten will not harm an individual with celiac disease." [1]

The above source does continue: "...there can be a risk of ingesting airborne gluten, which is usually caused by flour. It is also important to remember not to prepare gluten-free foods in spaces where there is a risk of airborne gluten, as particles will settle on the food, making it unsafe for those with celiac disease to eat." [1] Perhaps you meant to imply something more in this line, that say the sawdust from cutting plywood could be a potential problem if food is nearby?

In the same spirit as your apology, let me apologize for assuming that your original advice was sarcastic commentary about people who are gluten-free rather than genuine though ill-informed advice.

[1] https://www.beyondceliac.org/gluten-free-diet/cross-contact/....

EdwardCoffin··on Researchers invent 100% biodegradable 'barley plastic'
People with celiac disease have to go to great lengths to avoid things that have even the possibility of cross contamination. I can easily imagine that the processing that wheat straw goes through is not stringent enough to ensure that no wheat grains are not inadvertently included.
EdwardCoffin··on Researchers invent 100% biodegradable 'barley plastic'
The commenter was clearly concerned about wheat-derived food containers. Is plywood now used in making such now, and I missed it?
EdwardCoffin··on A systematic review of autopsy findings in deaths after Covid-19 vaccination
Five of the nine authors are apparently employed by The Wellness Company, which is in the business of holistic mail-order supplements. Of the other four, one is an independent physician, one is at a cancer clinic, one apparently retired. The remaining author, (the corresponding author), is cited as being at the University of Michigan School of Public Health, but I cannot find him listed in their faculty. The paper was apparently submitted last year though, so perhaps he has since left.

I should also note that the corresponding author provides a gmail address for correspondence, not his university email address.

EdwardCoffin··on Whitney Stratifications and Intersection Homology (2023) [pdf]
I'm a little more charitable on such things than I used to be, because it is hard to know why they overlooked the typo. For example, in this case it might be that they actually use a tool called signular [1] and so added that to their spelling dictionary.

[1] https://stackblitz.com/edit/signular

EdwardCoffin··on Tail Recursion Elimination (2009)
A counter-argument to the idea that TRE is merely an optimization: Why Object-Oriented Languages Need Tail Calls, by Guy Steele [1].

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20091206042608/http://projectfor...

EdwardCoffin··on Reversing Choplifter
Someone reverse-engineered Robotron and found bugs in that too [1].

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20130714200334/http://www.robotr...

EdwardCoffin··on Štar: an iteration construct for Common Lisp
A couple of years ago I finally started to understand the Waters series facility [1], which was offered as an alternative to Loop. It's a bit finicky, and the error messages are often mystifying, but I have come to quite like it for some more complicated looping situations. The thing that finally made it accessible to me was a blog post by Joe Marshall, Series tips and tricks [2]

Ironically enough, once my use of it advanced enough, I found myself writing producing forms which are just a restricted form of Loop invocation - Series turns out to compile down to Loop. It's just that I (and others, apparently) find Series expressions more pleasant to deal with than Loop expressions.

[1] https://www.cs.cmu.edu/Groups/AI/html/cltl/clm/node347.html#...

[2] http://funcall.blogspot.com/2022/07/series-tips-and-tricks.h...

EdwardCoffin··on High performance array programming in Petalisp
I was a bit surprised to see no mention of StarLisp [1]. Is this just a fundamentally different approach? I can imagine that targeting modern machines rather than the Connection Machine would be very different, but I thought the notations used in StarLisp were nice and could be reused.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/*Lisp

EdwardCoffin··on Goodyear Inflatoplane
Neal Stephenson's novel Seveneves [1] included something like this (early in part 3), and it being inflatable wasn't even the coolest thing about it.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seveneves

EdwardCoffin··on The Deuce Editor Architecture (2014)
I don't really see the relevance of either of your comments here.

Your first comment suggests that people interested in the Dylan language's text editor Deuce could try it online, then you give links to an editor that is a layer on the Ace editor whose only relation is that it is also named Deuce - it is not the editor being discussed.

This might have been a simple misunderstanding, but your second comment makes me think that you realize it is not the same editor, but claim that it was inspired by the editor under discussion. Looking at the links you've provided gives me no reason to believe the authors of the other Deuce even knew about the one under discussion.

I think it is pretty disingenuous to leave that first comment up, directing people to try the editor out without mentioning that it is in fact a totally different editor.

EdwardCoffin··on The Deuce Editor Architecture (2014)
I do not think this is the same thing. The links I posted were about the Deuce text editor for the Dylan programming language, which was implemented using DUIM, the Dylan successor to CLIM (itself a successor to Dynamic Windows). The links above seem to be for a different editor that just happens to also be named Deuce. Perhaps it was inspired by the other Deuce, but since none of the citations make mention of it I think the name is just a coincidence.

Edit: in the course of revisiting the links I posted, I found the expansion of the acronym Deuce: Dylan Environment Universal Code Editor. I didn't find confirmation that it was implemented in DUIM (successor to CLIM, successor to Dynamic Windows which I believe ZWEI used), but I am pretty sure that is so.

EdwardCoffin··on An Exploration of SBCL Internals (2020)
I understood it came about due to RMS wanting the source for the printer driver for the Xerox 9700 - nothing to do with Symbolics.
EdwardCoffin··on WD Ultrastar Transporter: Briefcase with 368TB of NVMe SSD, 128GB RAM, 1300W PSU
Jim Gray talked about this idea in an ACM Queue interview in 2001 [1] calling it a TeraScale SneakerNet box:

Another option is to send whole computers. I’ve been sending NTFS disks (the Windows file system format), and not every Linux system can read NTFS. So lately I’m sending complete computers. We’re now into the 2-terabyte realm, so we can’t actually send a single disk; we need to send a bunch of disks. It’s convenient to send them packaged inside a metal box that just happens to have a processor in it. I know this sounds crazy—but you get an NFS or CIFS server and most people can just plug the thing into the wall and into the network and then copy the data.

[1] https://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=864078

EdwardCoffin··on Breaking Silos
I liked his book, The Humane Computer, when I read it in 1999. I don’t know how well it has aged. It’s still on my shelf, so perhaps I will try to reread it.
EdwardCoffin··on Breaking Silos
About a year ago I read the OpenDoc specifications [1] (which for some reason are not linked to from the Wikipedia entry on OpenDoc). What struck me was how much of the complexity was to allow different vendors to provide differing amounts of services for comparable components - all sorts of fallback mechanisms for rendering the product of one spreadsheet component if you have a less complete spreadsheet component, for example.

[1] https://www.omg.org/technology/documents/vault.htm - under Retired Specifications at the bottom of the page, under Compound Presentation & Interchange

EdwardCoffin··on Breaking Silos
Jef Raskin's Canon Cat [1]?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canon_Cat

EdwardCoffin··on How fuzz testing was invented (2008)
Wow, thanks for all the links. I hadn't realized you really meant book - I thought by their book on Higher Order Software you meant Hamilton's and Zeldin's paper Higher Order Software—A Methodology for Defining Software [1], which I managed to get through the local university library.

[1] https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/1702333

EdwardCoffin··on Subroutine calls in the ancient world, before computers had stacks or heaps
I'd recommend you read Guy Steele's blog post Why Object-Oriented Languages Need Tail Calls [1] and perhaps the essay by William Cook [2] and the discussion over on Lambda the Ultimate [3]

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20091206042608/http://projectfor...

[2] https://www.cs.utexas.edu/~wcook/Drafts/2009/essay.pdf

[3] http://lambda-the-ultimate.org/node/3702

EdwardCoffin··on Hellandizing (1998)
You'd probably be interested in their set of slides on techniques for constructing robust software [1]. It talks about this issue, among others. For one thing, the processors could easily be in different states due to resources each has access to, so the same code could behave differently on different processors. Another topic they touch on in the slides is the notion of having multiple implementations of the same program, with compatible inputs and outputs but different implementations written by different teams that did not communicate.

[1] https://www.fastonline.it/sites/default/files/2019-06/Robust... (I couldn't find a version on the stratus website any more, but this appears to be the same as the one I downloaded from their site many years ago).

EdwardCoffin··on How fuzz testing was invented (2008)
Do you have a link for Higher Order Software perhaps? I couldn't find it on htius.com
EdwardCoffin··on Computing with JavaScript's Undefined (2020)
I believe the microprocessor from Steele's and Sussman's paper Design of a LISP-based microprocessor [1] used Peano numbers.

[1] https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/359024.359031

EdwardCoffin··on Symbolics Sunstone Development Plan (1987) [pdf]
iAPX 432 [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_iAPX_432

EdwardCoffin··on Symbolics Sunstone Development Plan (1987) [pdf]
Rekursiv [1], though I'm not sure how viable it really was. Edit: it's been discussed [2] here a few times before, and had an extremely colourful history.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rekursiv

[2] https://hn.algolia.com/?q=rekursiv

← PreviousPage 3 of 18Next →