HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Emma_Goldman

1,588 karma · joined August 17, 2017

submissionscomments
Emma_Goldman··on Why is the nuclear power industry stagnant?
> "Actually, Germany did not have a long term increase in coal/gas due to the nuclear shut down but a decrease"

> "Gas production did grow but mainly to offset declines in coal"

This is dishonest at two levels.

First, nuclear power fell and, at the same time, renewables and gas sharply rose in Germany's energy mix. Power is fungible. It is not as if power generated by renewables substitutes for nuclear, but power generated by gas doesn't. Germany had to add up it's energy inputs to meet 100% of its needs, and it used both sources to do so.

Second, everyone in Germany knew they were supposed to get rid of coal by 2030. That's the international deadline for coal in advanced economies. But the national phase-out law, until very recently, was eliminating coal at a far slower pace - aiming towards a terminal date of 2038. One reason why was the decline of nuclear.

Emma_Goldman··on Ancient civilisation under eastern Turkey estimated to be 11k-13k years old
Apparently, new evidence discredits the idea that the site was built by hunter-gatherers:

"New insights from several deep soundings excavated... have exposed the weaknesses of the temple-narrative, meaning that a revision of the popular scientific view is now unavoidable (Fig. 1). Specifically, the latest observations relate to the existence of domestic buildings and the harvesting and distribution of rain-water at Göbekli Tepe."

https://publications.dainst.org/journals/efb/article/view/25...

Emma_Goldman··on Who owns Einstein? The battle for the world’s most famous face
I would say this has >50% chance of being the right answer. I would also treat Gandhi, Mao, Che, and a few 'celebrities' like Cristiano Ronaldo and Leonardo DiCaprio as contenders.
Emma_Goldman··on New York rolling out noise law, listening tech for souped-up speedsters
Seems like a superpower to me. Light sleeping was probably great 50,000 years ago, when other human tribes might raid you in the night, and when big cats might be lurking in the darkness. Back then, heavy sleepers were effectively free-riders: the light sleepers would act as an alarm for the whole tribe. But, today, it's a fairly serious maladaption.
Emma_Goldman··on New York rolling out noise law, listening tech for souped-up speedsters
I used to wear earplugs, but I find that the bose sleepbuds are more effective at blocking out sound. The problem I found was that earplugs let in deep, bass sounds - like the thud of the floorboards in the flat above me as my neighbour jumps up from bed in the depth of the night. Apparently because low frequency sounds travel well through bone, reaching your inner ear sideways. See here:

https://earplugstore.typepad.com/got_ears_get_informed/2020/...

Which earplugs do you use though?

Emma_Goldman··on New York rolling out noise law, listening tech for souped-up speedsters
I think part of the issue is that there's a wide distribution of sleeping sensitivity. I'm a very light sleeper, and I find that a bad night sleep can ruin an entire day of work. Which is partly because I write for a living, which I really can't do well when I'm groggy. But for how many people are those two things true? I don't think many. A lot of people aren't light sleepers, and a lot of light sleepers aren't fazed by a bad night of sleep.
Emma_Goldman··on New York rolling out noise law, listening tech for souped-up speedsters
It can, and it's a good point. But I get up at 7:30, and the hour before that can be noisy. Really, in a city, the last tranche of people go to bed at 2am, the first tranche rises at 6am. That's only four hours of quiet unfortunately, and even that can be interrupted.

In the future I will prioritise quiet when picking somewhere to live. I'm just a light sleeper and it kind of sucks. In evolutionary terms, it's heavily maladapted to city life.

Emma_Goldman··on New York rolling out noise law, listening tech for souped-up speedsters
Police helicopters tend to be heavily concentrated in cities. A better metric might be population. The US population is only about 5 times bigger than that of the UK. It therefore has 20x more police helicopters per capita.
Emma_Goldman··on New York rolling out noise law, listening tech for souped-up speedsters
We are talking about cars that, as someone in this thread pointed out, can be louder than jet engines. Whose noise can travel over a mile. That thunder around at night. In comparison, skating isn't that loud, and it's a daytime activity anyway. Maybe you've had some bad experiences - are people skating directly beneath your window?
Emma_Goldman··on New York rolling out noise law, listening tech for souped-up speedsters
Couldn't disagree more about skateboarding. It's usually just friends hanging out having fun, it's a very leisurely, social past time. It hardly produces any noise, so I have no idea why you've listed it on this thread.
Emma_Goldman··on New York rolling out noise law, listening tech for souped-up speedsters
I've never heard a police helicopter at night in the country where I live (UK). I rarely see or hear them at all.

Edit: After googling, it looks like there are about 2000 police helicopters in the US, but only 20 in the UK. As far as I can tell, there are the same number of police helicopters in LA as across the whole of the UK.

Emma_Goldman··on New York rolling out noise law, listening tech for souped-up speedsters
This makes wonder. I recently moved to the middle of a loud city, so I bought a pair or bose sleepbuds that drown everything out by playing background noise while I sleep - the sound of waves, actually. Is this low-level sound any less of a stressor than traffic, though? It's constant and calming so I fall asleep. But maybe it's not good for me, and leads to lower quality sleep anyway.
Emma_Goldman··on New York rolling out noise law, listening tech for souped-up speedsters
I thought about this recently. I'm occasionally woken up by souped-up cars in the early hours of the morning. You can hear them from maybe from a mile away. They must wake up hundreds, even thousands of people on late night joyrides. It's incredible that it's legal. Why allow something which is entirely pointless to cause such mass public nuisance?
Emma_Goldman··on Doe Invests Half a Billion to De-Risk Cheaper Energy Storage
Well, Biden's legislative climate agenda has collapsed. They have to scrape together whatever money they can from existing budgets.

Also, the idea is really to give private actors just enough money and support to get them going:

"Funding should not just support technology field testing but also allow developers to better understand the critical commercial side, “helping formulate the market mechanisms that are going to enable long-duration storage to survive and prosper on the grid.”"

Whether it's true or not, economists like to claim that there's a multiplier effect in cases like this, where every $1 if public investment creates >$10 of private investment.

Emma_Goldman··on Limb lengthening surgery is becoming more popular
Being a chattel slave is orders of magnitude worse than being short. That you are not able to see that suggests that, perhaps, your personal struggles and disappointments are warping your judgement. You are 'catastrophising'.
Emma_Goldman··on Limb lengthening surgery is becoming more popular
These kinds of power law statistics describe sexual attraction and activity, but that selects for different characteristics than long-term relationships - where things like intelligence, honesty, reliability, etc., come to the fore.

It shouldn't need to be said, but Tinder is not representative of all human relationships.

Emma_Goldman··on Tax the Land
Democracy empowers a majority, or sometimes a plurality. It is not necessarily the case that whatever that bloc of voters wants respects the rights and interests of other citizens. Hence the possibility of a 'tyranny of the majority'.

It may be, as in this case, that homeowners actively try to protect their asset by excluding non-homeowners from the market, perhaps by obstructing the construction of new houses, or by supporting the inflation of house prices. Is that a good situation just because it is sanctioned by a majority?

In liberal societies, there are side-constraints on what a demos can sanction - it cannot, for example, curtail the free speech of individuals. There is no reason why that should not be the case with respect to certain basic means of life, like housing.

Emma_Goldman··on Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay afloat
It's worth pointing out that the LRB was also subsidised by the money its editor inherited, Mary-Kay Williams, for most of its history. But it's certainly flourishing today, to the point that it releases articles faster than anyone can possibly keep up with. I keep track of a lot of magazines and journals like the LRB, and many of them are in a similar upswing. But none of them are purely literary, and indeed, the LRB probably best described as a journal of ideas - of history, geopolitics, politics, economics, and so on. Literature has an important be delimited place.

In a way I'm not sure there's a decline as much as a consolidation, where a dozen or so major outlets reach a level of prominence that everyone wants to write for them, and a scale such that they can diversify across subjects to suit most tastes. While I know many people interested in the LRB, I know few if any interested in purely literary magazines - which can often be niche and inward looking.

Emma_Goldman··on Are Today’s Portraitists Better Than the Old Masters?
For me, a large part of what makes the art of the past so captivating is its historicity. It reflects and intervenes in a context - politically, intellectually, economically, artistically - radically different to our own. Looking at great art from the past is an insight into different ways of thinking and being, and different moments in history. Reducing art to technique misses this.
Emma_Goldman··on Biologist decided to disavow his own study
In my experience in academia, albeit not in the sciences, dishonesty far from the main problem. There is a big difference between fundamental research of wide and lasting interest, and research that ticks enough boxes to be published. Because the second is a lot easier to do than the first, and is what an academic's performance is judged on, everyone ends up spewing out mediocre papers that, intellectually, take us nowhere. Research becomes degraded as a means to the end of a career.
Emma_Goldman··on Coinbase’s philosophy on account removal and content moderation
In substance, it goes back to the original philosophers of the modern state: Jean Bodin and Thomas Hobbes. That was in the 16th and 17th century.

Also important is that the state has a monopoly on legitimate violence. It has social license by virtue of exercising violence to uphold social order. In the case of the economy that means its macroeconomic management to ensure stability and the public good. Clearly crypto woefully fails by that standard.

Emma_Goldman··on Militarized Dolphins Protect Almost a Quarter of the US Nuclear Stockpile
The phrase 'an act of war' means an act which intends to and/or actually does give the target casus belli. I took it for granted that you knew that.

See, for example, the OED reference:

'An act by one nation intended to initiate or provoke a war with another nation; an act considered sufficient cause for war.'

https://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/oi/authority.20...

Emma_Goldman··on Militarized Dolphins Protect Almost a Quarter of the US Nuclear Stockpile
This made me laugh.

Sabotage, border clashes and airstrikes happen all the time without constituting acts of war that give casus belli to their target. A basic legal condition of a just war is that it is proportionate and embarked upon as a last resort: launching a war because a dolphin you trained was killed is neither of those, as sad as it might be.

Emma_Goldman··on Show HN: Meetup with other travelers in a new place
I think this over-states the case. There's a lot of reasons to meet up with other travellers. Unlike locals, they are free in the weekdays and often don't have any fixed plans, and want to - yep - travel. Travelling with other people is usually more fun than by yourself or just with one or two others. Also, depending on where you visit, travellers are often very internationally diverse. It can be a great opportunity to meet a highly cosmopolitan cross-section of people.

The fact you're with other people doesn't mean you can't meet and interact with the local people and culture. It's also possible to spend time with travellers one day, and locals the next day. The point is they're not mutually exclusive.

Emma_Goldman··on Show HN: Meetup with other travelers in a new place
Great idea. I would offer two suggestions.

One, two of the six people currently registered on the site live in the locations they cite - they aren't travellers at all. Seems like that would undermine the USP of the site and confuse travellers. Looking at Paul's picture, his use of the wink emoji, and the fact he's bragging about his job (inadvertently or not), make it look like he's using the site to meet women. That could be a big problem.

Second and relatedly, you need to a way to stop abuse. Up-voting and moderation will be needed in some form. But also some basic safety guidelines, i.e., always meet in groups and in public places.

Emma_Goldman··on How Y Combinator Changed the World
What a strange way of conversing with people. I never suggested that and you must know that I don't think it, so why say it? It shows bad faith.

I think that ceteris paribus the lower housing rents are the better. How to help bring that about is an interesting policy question. I suspect that socialisation is the best option, but increasing the stock and rent controls could work.

If we return to the specific case of AirBnb and my original suggestion, the aim would be twofold:

1. Limit AirBnb rentals to reorientate the housing stock away from rich international tourists to locals.

2. Tax AirBnb rentals to subsidise local housing.

I would point out that Barcelona has already done (1).

Emma_Goldman··on How Y Combinator Changed the World
You seem to believe that all market transactions are socially beneficial, whereas I do not. A market transaction might benefit the rational utility of transacting parties despite incurring yet greater harms on third parties. I, like most people, am not a value monist who believes rational utility is the only good, and if we take this yet larger perspective then a very wide range of market transactions create net social harms.

'Renting' in its essence does not involve doing anything: it does not mine resources, manufacture use objects, or provide a service. Rich people buy up scarce assets and then charge a fee for their use. The return has no correlate in any socially useful activity - it is 'profiteering'. AirBnb means it is often more profitable to buy properties and rent them to rich international tourists rather than to locals. This creates the further, perverse effect of pricing out residents from their own cities. Given than I am a democrat and think societies should be run by and for the people, I think this is obviously remiss.

Emma_Goldman··on How Y Combinator Changed the World
AirBnB is an interesting case. On its face it seems socially rational, given that many rooms are unused or heavily under-used, to match them with people who want rooms in that location. The problem is, of course, that it increases rental profiteering, and that it caters to rich international tourists, not residents.

Is there a way to enjoy the benefits of AirBnB without those pathologies? Governments, either locally or nationally, could issue AirBnB rental licenses, limit the supply to prevent gross gentrification, and tax the income and use it to subsidise housing costs elsewhere in the affected locations.

Emma_Goldman··on Poll: Did you know that HN allows you to make polls?
That's probably not healthy. HN is a very niche subculture whose interests aren't at all representative of what's happening in the world.
Emma_Goldman··on Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future
I think this is a bit of a straw man. Yes, people sometimes do things that aren't in their rational self-interest, even capaciously understood. But we are talking about a specific scenario.

The question is: would the President, told of an imminent asteroid collision large enough to destroy human civilization, and knowing this information would leak if she did not announce it, elect to hide this information for a month until after the midterms for no particular reason?

You say "They thought the plan to break it up and mine it would work." At the time of the decision of whether to announce the existence of the asteroid, and create a plan, there obviously was no plan. So no, she didn't think that.

>"Likewise with trump, who had worked to dismantle the existing pandemic playbook[0] took for granted how well our medical response would be. He regularly disregarded expert opinions, or simply did not speak with them[1]. He even worked to make it difficult for states to get help, because he lost the vote there[2]."

Again, this isn't the point. Even Trump never tried to deny the existence of COVID. Clearly that would not have worked and would have exploded in his face.

← PreviousPage 6 of 17Next →