HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Emma_Goldman

1,588 karma · joined August 17, 2017

submissionscomments
Emma_Goldman··on Intellectual Loneliness
Develop questions you want to answer and then find the books that will help you to do so. If you have an active interest in a book you'll get a lot more out of it.

Don't just read books because they have a good reputation in general.

Emma_Goldman··on Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future
>Trump new about the severity of covid and downplayed it for quite some time

Trump neither tried to hide the existence of COVID from the public nor thought it would topple civilization and kill him personally. He downplayed it and the risk it posed, but that is a different order of lying. Trump said exactly as much as he thought he could get away with, and no more.

>There absolutely can be some fanatical base that will construct shared delusional propaganda to avoid the realization that they've been conned.

Sure, but COVID-deniers are a fringe and any political calculus that depends on denying COVID is therefore bound to fail. It is equally clear that denying the existence of an earth-shattering asteroid makes no political sense.

Emma_Goldman··on Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future
Let me take a couple of specific examples. Upon being told that an asteroid large enough to destroy human civilization was on course to hit the earth in 6 months, the President decided that it would make strategic sense to delay announcing or acting on the threat until after the midterms - a month or so later. This was conspicuous for the fact no reason was given, which had to be the case as it makes no sense.

Collective threats of this kind have historically created a rally-around-the-flag effect the helps incumbents. Even a venal politician would not assist in the imminent destruction of the planet from which they themselves could not escape. Obviously information of that magnitude of importance would leak, as it did in the film. Meaning its only effect would be to crater the President's support when it became clear they hid the truth. Even an amaetuer political observer would understand all this, let alone a Whitehouse team that won a Presidential election.

Or how about the manner in which the astronomers announced their discovery? They went to the NYT, who inexplicably decided that they would forego running the biggest story in human history. Instead, they helped arrange for the astronomers to announce their discovery in a 2-minute segment on an infotainment news show. Neither the NYT, nor the astronomers, nor anyone would think that was a good idea. It would never, ever happen. During the interview, one of the astronomers got upset because the talk show hosts were nonchalant about the news of the possible end of civilization (!?). Returning to the NYT offices, they're told that the journalists were able to confirm their findings with well-respected third party scientists, but that because one of the astronomers got upset in air, they weren't going to run the story - again, easily the biggest story in human history, which anyone could appreciate at such.

The upshot of this never-ending string of implausible plot points is that the film ends up obfuscating how real politics works. It dumbs politics down and makes it trivial to make an easy joke, making it part of the problem that it ostensibly satirises.

Emma_Goldman··on Idiocracy: A disturbingly prophetic look at the future
I have to disagree. It attempts to satirise today's mass media by exaggerating its influence on politics to the point at which it revolves around little else, succumbing to what it is supposed to be objecting to: the idea of politics and politicians as trivial. The plotline was so wildly implausible that it ended up saying little about the real world.

Also, the asteroid threat is not a good analogy for climate change, as it is supposed to be. Climate change is so difficult to deal with because its effects are uncertain, long-term and unevenly felt. None of those issues hold for an asteroid that will, per the plot, destroy the whole of human civilization in 6 months with 99.9% certainty absent intervention.

Emma_Goldman··on Tardigrades walk like insects 500k times their size
The basis for believing this is the inference that because the physical world insofar as we have knowledge of it obeys physicalist principles, so must the human mind.

But we can't really claim to know based on our investigation of the mind itself. If we entertain theories of consciousness like dualism, monism or emergentism, it seems unlikely that we have the categories of understanding and analysis to decisively confirm or deny them.

Emma_Goldman··on 20 year study of global wealth demolishes the myth of ‘trickle-down’
No it doesn't, the case for such a scheme depends on two kinds of arguments: (1) intrinsic arguments that people have a right to a portion of collective wealth, to the means of life, or to the means of being able to freely spend their time as they see fit; (2) and instrumental arguments that it would rebalance the power of capital over labour, lead to various positive social outcomes, and tame the plutocracy that is ruining Western democracies.

If your standard is 'responsible spending', the counterfactual baseline is keeping this money in the hands of the wealthy. For obvious reasons - diminishing marginal utility, the breakdown of the social compact, the corruption of politics - I don't think they would spend a dollar on the margin any more 'responsibly'.

What about shared infrastructure projects? I'm not suggesting this ought to replace the state, simply that global wealth can be equalised without reallocating that wealth to the state to spend.

Emma_Goldman··on 20 year study of global wealth demolishes the myth of ‘trickle-down’
>'Should we trust the government to spend the money more wisely than the folks who earned it'

This is a false opposition. Taxed money does not have to be spent at the point of the state. A sovereign wealth fund could raise funds from wealth taxes and assign a share to every citizen in the country. It could then use its interest-bearing assets to pay out a dividend to all shareholders every year. It could be run by an independent but publicly supervised body - like the Norwegian wealth fund - and the money would be disbursed straight into the bank accounts of citizens.

In any case we live in democratic societies in which legislated changes to the structure and distribution of wealth would then bind politicians via the rule of law. We do not have to depend on the individual virtue of politicians. On the margin I would generally prefer states whose remit includes the public interest to spend another dollar than I would private entities ruled by financial profit.

Emma_Goldman··on Aphantasia
I think there is a confusion that visualisation must be photo-realistic. I can visualise the entire city in which I live in my head, and fly around its streets, parks, and landmarks in a handful of seconds. The map is fully accurate and the broad-brush image is. But if I stop and focus on any one detail, I cannot always remember exactly what lies there. Clearly my memory depends on filling this in 'as-if' to sustain my vision, and I think this is true in general. We don't have memories that can zoom in to ever greater microscopic detail, and we don't have every detail of a picture, but this doesn't stop us from imagining.

It's similar to the way in which when we're presented with words that are jumbled up apart from their first and last letter, our brain fills in what's happening. Vision in general is not just the mechanical encoding of sense data from light. It is as much psychological as physiological. We see the world in stable colours and contrasts because our mind controls for illumination and processes the colour of one detail relative to the whole picture. I think our mind's eye depends on similar kinds of psychological support.

Emma_Goldman··on U.S. sets goal to drive down cost of removing CO2 from atmosphere
CO2 no, but spatial imaging is already being used to help create systematic databases of fossil fuel assets.

See: https://www.cgfi.ac.uk/spatial-finance-initiative/

Emma_Goldman··on U.S. sets goal to drive down cost of removing CO2 from atmosphere
Carbon Tracker calculates that the majority of coal plants in Europe are already cost negative.[1] They live off uncompetitive tariffs and subsidies. Germany's reverse auction for coal plants over the last year ended up accepting a lot of very low bids, as coal owners were desperate to get out from under stranded assets. Even they were widely criticized as over-priced given the state of the industry.

[1] https://carbontracker.org/cop26-a-chance-to-reset-and-elimin...

Emma_Goldman··on U.S. sets goal to drive down cost of removing CO2 from atmosphere
>Neither is long haul travel, particularly.

Aviation and shipping make up 5-6% of GHG emissions, not a trivial amount. Aviation is projected to expand several-fold by 2050 which, in the context of decarbonisation, means it will take up a progressively larger fraction of global emissions over time. It will be one of the last and greatest challenges - which is exactly why it will require offsets, carbon capture or otherwise. The aviation's offset market, CORSIA, is already one of the most developed in the world. Your optimism about electrifying aviation is not shared by the industry.

Emma_Goldman··on David Graeber’s Possible Worlds
>It begins with by questioning "why did Rousseau wrote about inequality if 100 years before no one in western culture cared about it"?

I really hope he doesn't say that because Rousseau is just the high point of a debate about luxury and sociability that runs throughout the whole eighteenth century. He and others like him were influenced by travelogues from the New World describing natives as living simply and equitably. But he was equally influenced by the objective conditions of early modern capitalism, ancient Stoicism, and Christian writings about greed and pride. He wrote his own 'Confessions' in tribute to St.Augustine, after all.

I like Graeber, and he has a truly original mind, but he doesn't have the best reputation in academia for being 100% scholarly.

Emma_Goldman··on USC pushed a $115k online degree – graduates got low salaries, huge debts
In the UK, 90% of masters programs work that way. Admissions criteria for international students are a lot lower, because they can charge them what they like. It's where they make a lot of their money.
Emma_Goldman··on Podcasts are my new Wikipedia
I couldn't agree more. To me, the single greatest downside of the internet age is sensory overload. I find that having the time to reflect, be in the moment, and savour experience, is so important. When I get into those habits, and spent a lot more time offline, I feel more fulfilled.
Emma_Goldman··on The simplest of slumbers
I don't think this is likely. It's well known that caffeine disrupts sleep and that you therefore need to spend more rather than less time in bed to get the same rest.
Emma_Goldman··on Hegel Today
'Continental' philosophy never went anywhere, it was only sidelined among certain parts of the Anglophone academy. The analytic-continental distinction is nonsensical to begin with, given that one is a style, the other a geography.
Emma_Goldman··on Pre-industrial workers had a shorter workweek than today's (1991)
You can't because if you don't organise production to maximise profits you'll be beaten by the competition that does. If you set up a commune and put aside time for democratic meetings and communal recreation, and make work easier and more pleasurable to do, then you'll produce less per hour worked. Companies that don't do those things will get the contracts. Also, you'll be selling into a market whose demand is dominated by the rich and the imperatives of capitalism.
Emma_Goldman··on U.S. house prices are rising exponentially faster than income
I don't understand why this would just be a supply-side issue, rather than a huge demand-side issue given asset price inflation consequent from QE, the expansion of private credit and the financialization of housing over recent times. Or indeed a distributional issue given that we are now living in a new Gilded Age, of poverty amidst plenty.

A lot of housing problems result from the uneven and combined development inherent in capitalism. Physical and human capital floods to major sites of economic activity, leading to a positive feedback loop benefitting a small number of major cities. The rest of the country becomes a hinterland, sucked dry of business and anyone who has the option of leaving. In the UK, where I live, this is the major underlying cause of Scottish independence, and now the increasing calls for Welsh independence, and even Northern independence. The economy is asymmetrically built around London. That in turn makes it increasingly difficult for normal people to live in London (e.g. nurses and teachers). Zoning isn't going to fix that.

Emma_Goldman··on The Internet Archive transforms access to books in a digital world
'Demos' means the common people. IA is democratising because it distributes knowledge to anyone and everyone with internet access, instead of just the rich or the global minority with access to major libraries.
Emma_Goldman··on U.S. house prices are rising exponentially faster than income
A great thought experiment, though not necessarily an entirely fictional one. Social housing schemes, and proposals for 'universal basic services', are common enough and ought to be the positive side to the deflation of the housing market.

Mortgages currently dominate the average person's life.

Emma_Goldman··on Not Belonging to the World: Hannah Arendt Holds Firm
I read Eichmann in Jerusalem a while back and it was a good read, but I was surprised to find the basic thesis disproven by ten minutes of research. Arendt wants to argue that Eichmann's evil is banal in origin, not malicious or ideological. But in interviews with Eichmann while he was in Argentina, he openly confesses to being a fanatical and long-standing anti-Semite, and to seeing the Holocaust as the eradication of an inferior people.

More recently, I read what is supposed to be Arendt's magnus opus and one of the greatest works of political philosophy of the last century, The Human Condition. I was surprised to find, given the reputation, that it was a conceptual mess. Arendt builds much of the book around a distinction between 'work' and 'labour', but they are neither mutually exclusive nor clearly specified. Her attempt to argue otherwise just leads to compounding error.

That aside, I do like Arendt's short book 'On Violence', which is simple but powerful.

Emma_Goldman··on Amazon warehouse employee in Poland dies at work
Amazon is certainly worse than the average company domiciled in the US, but it is quantitatively and not qualitatively different. Capitalism requires employers to extract as much work out of employees as possible, lest competition overtake them.
Emma_Goldman··on Learning about writing by seeing only the punctuation
I like the idea, when I'm about to start writing I often prepare by reading an exemplary author. I focus above all on their form, how they begin, pace and punctuate sentences. But I think the tool, while interesting, isn't quite as helpful - just seeing the punctuation by itself is gobbledegook to me.
Emma_Goldman··on “Progress” by Aldous Huxley (1928)
I have read a lot of interwar British political writing. That was the style, unfortunately. I am always amazed how badly most of the leading thinkers of the age - just a hundred years ago - wrote.
Emma_Goldman··on Depressed People See the World More Realistically
I'm not a positivist, and I think much of life should be approached in the vein of Wittgenstein's Philosophical Investigations. By which I mean, as meaning-making tied to real activities within socio-historically specific forms of life. But that doesn't mean you ought to abdicate one's critical faculties and wilfully enter into self-serving delusions. I can understand and appreciate nationalism, for example, without accepting its constitutive myths as fact, or losing sight of its role in sustaining collective delusions. In fact, I would say that you cannot fully understand it without that clear-sightedness.
Emma_Goldman··on Depressed People See the World More Realistically
This is arrant nonsense.

If you adopt a perspective of totalising scepticism then, of course, you will shrink into a solipsistic disbelief of everything. But the fact there is no Archimedean foundation of knowledge doesn't mean we ought to treat all truth claims equal. There are logical and mathematical truths that are a condition of the world being intelligible to us, and that structure the internal working of nature insofar as we can understand it. We can have justified beliefs about many things, but we cannot have a justified belief in God, which requires dogmatic faith.

Also, there are glaring internal contradictions in the major world religions. If God is good and omnipotent, then why is there pain and suffering? How can God be one and three things at the same time, as the doctrine of the Trinity tells us?

Emma_Goldman··on World food prices hit 10-year peak – FAO
QE has been going on 10 years in the West and almost 30 years in Japan without serious inflation. It is not clear that we are witnessing general inflation rather than inflation within particular sectors affected by the global energy and supply-chain crisis.
Emma_Goldman··on US has already lost AI fight to China, says ex-Pentagon software chief
https://archive.is/3YA1L
Emma_Goldman··on Pope Francis and Other Christian Leaders Are Calling for Bold Climate Action
Why reduce the question to economics? A significant reason why developing countries continue to rely on coal power, for example, is political: energy insecurity, state tariffs, vested interests. At the same time they expect the global North, that is responsible for the greatest share of historic emissions, and has reaped its rewards, to help them. The North's failure to do so is a political issue, not a merely economic one. We will not reach net zero by 2050 without major state investment, regulation and international cooperation.
Emma_Goldman··on Many believe it's time to do away with lawmakers making stock trades
Very cool. It would be good if you could overlay Congress' returns with the returns of the market, or a median institutional investor, for comparison. Also, to disaggregate investments by asset class, active/passive funds, etc., so we can really figure out what's going on. Those things make a big difference. I realise this is a passion project though, and that's probably too much work.
← PreviousPage 7 of 17Next →