HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

George83728

544 karma · joined April 27, 2023

submissionscomments
George83728··on Jared Diamond: A Reply to His Critics
I agree that he forces facts to fit his model, but that doesn't make the book racist. The entire point of his book is that environmental circumstances, not racial or cultural characteristics, explain the circumstance of European dominance in the modern era; this is explicitly anti-racist. (Inb4 Kafkatrap: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36265324)
George83728··on Army tested 'germ warfare' on NYC subway (2015)
It's not about which kinds of the crimes are greater; it's about which kinds of crimes have a more proximate impact on the success or failure of a community. Obviously the secret irradiation of people is a worse crime than vandalizing all the public spaces of a building, but if that irradiation goes unnoticed by the community at that time, then it will have much less effect on property values / etc than petty vandalism.
George83728··on Jared Diamond: A Reply to His Critics
Wheels sturdy enough to carry light loads are easier to fabricate than wheels sturdy enough to carry heavy loads. Similarly low-speed wheels are easier to create than wheels suitable for a chariot pulled by a galloping horse.

So the thousands of years gap between heavy carts and chariots vs wheelbarrows, isn't something you can explain by citing insufficient technology or unsuitable environmental conditions. I think it all comes down to nobody had that idea yet.

George83728··on Jared Diamond: A Reply to His Critics
No ear protection... most people not yet accustomed to guns would probably react about the same way.
George83728··on Jared Diamond: A Reply to His Critics
It's easy to level a charge of reductionist when the book is presenting a model for why things happened a certain way, instead of just describing what sort of things happened. GG&S is all about the why, and is therefore inherently reductionist.
George83728··on Jared Diamond: A Reply to His Critics
He argues that because technology transfer was difficult in the Americas, the ancient Mexican wheel never found it's way to the Andes where it may have been combined with suitable pack animals. That much is fairly plausible. But he goes further than this: he also argues that because ancient Mexican wheels weren't combined with pack animals, wheels could offer no practical utility to ancient Mexicans and this explains why the wheel wasn't put to practical use in the Americas. This is too far, he's forcing the data to fit his model.

The relevant passage:

> While wheels are very useful in modern industrial societies, that has not been so in some other societies. Ancient Native Mexicans invented wheeled vehicles with axles for use as toys, but not for transport. That seems incredible to us, until we reflect that ancient Mexicans lacked domestic animals to hitch to their wheeled vehicles, which therefore offered no advantage over human porters.

It has nothing to do with pack animals. Pack animals are not and never were a prerequisite for putting wheels to practical use. Across all of humanity, perhaps as few as two individual people ever had the idea to invent the wheel; at least once in China and at least once again in Mexico; all other uses of the wheel plausibly descent from these two instances of invention. So obviously the wheel wasn't an obvious invention, and neither were practical applications for the wheel obvious, except seemingly so in retrospect. Chariots appeared about 4000 years ago, but wheel barrows only appeared about 2000 years ago. You can't explain that gap with environmental circumstances. The gap is explained when you realize these aren't obvious inventions. Searching for environmental reasons for the invention or non-invention of such things is folly, because the greatest hurdle to clear is simply having the incredible luck of somebody on your continent having such an idea in the first place.

George83728··on Jared Diamond: A Reply to His Critics
I never bought into the claims that Jared Diamond is some sort of racist; he book is plainly anti-racist and anybody who says otherwise probably never read it. Honestly.

That said, some of Jared Diamond's arguments are really lame.. just poorly thought out. For instance, is claim that the use of wheels for transportation is in some way gated by the availability of pack animals. This guy has never used a wheel barrow I guess... of course he has and mentions them much later in his book, but dismissing the point as a "puzzling non-invention". This realization doesn't seem to have him question his earlier assertion that wheels for transportation would only be invented where pack animals are available.

I think it's got nothing to do with pack animals, and the truth is that wheelbarrows, and wheels for transportation generally, are one of those inventions that are obvious only in retrospect. Even after you've invented wheels on toys, it isn't necessarily immediately obvious that wheels could have practical applications as well. A very small handful of people in the history of humanity had this idea and most people never did (and just copied it from other people). It's not because of geography or ecology, just shear dumb luck.

George83728··on Army tested 'germ warfare' on NYC subway (2015)
> b)pressured them into a lot of military spending simply because they felt they had to do so because of how much we were spending and all our sabre-rattling.

Yes, that was the Soviet (Russian) perspective. They felt pressured to keep up with the US. But the flipside is that the inverse was also happening; America spent tons of money developing new weapons and capabilities because the Russians were doing the same. For instance, the F-15 was developed into the air superiority fighter that it is because the Mig-25 was (mistakenly) believed to be similarly capable.

Too often the "Soviets were afraid of America" narrative is used to suggest that America was an aggressor and the Soviets were hapless victims of this aggression, forced to spend by America. But the truth is that both sides were doing this to each other, and besides, the whole of it was arguably started by aggressive Soviet expansion before and after WW2, for instance the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact in which the Soviet Union conspired with the Nazis to divide up Poland, Russia's subsequent refusal to allow Poland to become independent after the war, and the persistent Soviet threats to invade western Europe and incorporate France, the UK, etc into their "union". The "Soviet Union" was a farce of a union, a fig leaf over Russian imperialism.

George83728··on Army tested 'germ warfare' on NYC subway (2015)
But what's the connection between radioactive contamination and the failure of Pruitt-Igoe? Wikipedia doesn't seem to mention any contamination issues, but says that deteriorating building maintenance and social conditions (crime, poverty, segregation, etc) were to blame. Radiation didn't vandalize the elevators or mug residents in the hallways.
George83728··on Army tested 'germ warfare' on NYC subway (2015)
I haven't heard of this before, but a web search brought up this: https://ahrp.org/a-national-scandal-aids-drug-experiments-on...
George83728··on Army tested 'germ warfare' on NYC subway (2015)
Use of the term dates back decades, and it's popularity accelerated through Bush the Younger's reign (for obvious reasons I think, Bush was widely perceived as an idiotic puppet, a theatrical figurehead for the real government (e.g. Cheney and co.))

https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=deep+state&yea...

George83728··on Apollo will close down on June 30th
If you don't want to be recorded, then don't have phone calls with people who live in one party consent jurisdictions. This is common sense.
George83728··on Apollo will close down on June 30th
He needs to sue Steve Huffman personally for defamation. Steve has been a known lying snake for years and it's long past due that somebody make him pay for it.
George83728··on Nanoplastic Ingestion Causes Neurological Deficits
You can buy glass bowls with glass lids.
George83728··on US CDC sets first federal target for ventilation of indoor air to lower risk
I know there's a smoke situation going on and that filtration is the only possible solution to such smoke. However in the general case I do not want to breath filtered air in buildings, I want fresh air, straight from outside, ideally coming through the nearest window with a screen in front of it to filter the bugs and nothing more.

There are two big problems with doing this: allergies and temperature. I think both of these problems are resolved when you simply acclimatize people to outdoor air. Maybe people spend few years uncomfortable until their body gets used to it (and until people learn how to dress appropriately for the season) but in the end we'll all be healthier if we're breathing fresh air instead of stale recycled air.

George83728··on Clearing 500k feral cats from New York’s streets
Dogs are a lot better at hunting rats. The city should breed and release thousands of rat terriers if they mean to get serious about their rat problem.
George83728··on Clearing 500k feral cats from New York’s streets
Could you really induce a cobra problem if the only reward were a burger? Raising a few hundred kittens every year just to eat a steady diet of burgers doesn't seem very efficient.
George83728··on Proposed SEC order to freeze, repatriate Binance.US assets
Is this a joke? There isn't a gas station in this country that will refuse to sell booze to a homeless broken down and busted up alcoholic that begs for change right in front of the gas station. Except of course, the gas stations that legally aren't allowed to sell booze to anybody in the first place.

Dealers have no morals. Even the law that bartenders aren't allowed to serve drunk people is an absolute farce. Walk into any bar in this country and you'll find drunk people being served alcohol.

George83728··on Tell HN: "I don't care about cookies” extension bought by Avast, users jump ship
As far as I've seen, they all do this using a transparent element placed over the page.. which I filter away.
George83728··on “Fractureiser” malware in popular Minecraft mods and modpacks
A lot of people use accessibility mods that suck to go without. Not having ItemScroller causes me physical pain after just a few minutes of clicking around in chests.

I'm just going to stick with 1.19 and the mods I downloaded several months ago until this matter is sorted out.

George83728··on Wildfire Smoke in Northeastern US Visible on GOES East Images
> the deep blue queer tree-hugging west coast.

I take it you haven't spent much time out in the sticks of Oregon or Washington.

George83728··on Tell HN: "I don't care about cookies” extension bought by Avast, users jump ship
Why answer the question at all? I use uBlock Origin's cosmetic filters to simply delete the prompt from the page. I nether accept nor decline, and I've never run into problems with this.
George83728··on Scientists Guide Lightning Bolts with Lasers for the First Time
A quagmire is something you get stuck in, it implies a sort of stagnation. A slurry is what happens when you really stir up the shit.
George83728··on Royal Navy says quantum navigation test a success
> Wouldn't it be enough to send some small thing connected by thin wires or wirelessly to the submarine (lasers, ultrasound, whatever) that could aquire location and communicate it?

They do, using either tethered buoys or 'buoyant cable antennas' (the cable is the antenna and is itself buoyant) They can use these without coming to periscope depth, or even slowing down.

George83728··on Royal Navy says quantum navigation test a success
What's the difference between measuring accelerations and measuring gravity?

I think with any INS system, if you want to be very accurate you need charts of gravitational anomalies. So these seem like one and the same to me.

George83728··on Russia’s population nightmare is going to get even worse
Uh okay, but neither is Ukraine.

What does this have to do with the point that the US and EU did in fact essentially shrug at the 2014 invasion of Ukraine? Are you disagreeing with that?

George83728··on Apple Safari 17 beta release notes: JPEG XL support added
I wonder how Apple found a way around the allegedly insurmountable problem of supporting and maintaining this feature. Google, I have been told, just doesn't have the resources to do the same.
George83728··on US urged to reveal UFO evidence after claim that it has intact alien vehicles
Maybe so, but presuming such a visual hallucination phenomena exists, who said it's limited to aliens? xpe didn't say it only manifests as UFO sightings. Besides UFOs, you've got tons of people claiming to see big foot, ghosts, monster fish, angels, ball lightning, etc...
George83728··on Russia’s population nightmare is going to get even worse
It was basically a shrug; for instance the 2014 invasion wasn't enough to cancel NS-2. Lots of people, Europeans particularly, continued to do business with Russia. In doing so, they were funding the full scale invasion that followed. Only after Feb 2022 did the international community get a bit more serious about sanctioning Russia.

Also the shrug at 2014 wasn't unprecedented. The world also shrugged when Russia invaded Georgia 6 years before that in 2008.

George83728··on Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children (2014)
> Their civilisation was destroyed as thoroughly as possible

Ehh, we still remember they exist. How many other civilizations have been so thoroughly eradicated that we don't even remember them at all?

← PreviousPage 4 of 13Next →