192 karma · joined May 27, 2023
We understand that people with schizophrenia have delusions which result from their condition. Those delusions often cause them to feel unsafe. We are compassionate and seek to treat the the underlying causes, not by joining in on their delusions. Gender dysphoria is much the same--transgender activists love to confound the issue by conflating dysphoria and intersex, but these are two entirely separate conditions. I have empathy and compassion for people struggling with dysphoria, and that expresses itself in my desire to help them get better.
This is the one I use https://www.avaccess.com/products/4ksw21-dm/
I heard something similar from the extreme right about the 2020 election. The idea was that Trump gave a false sense of hope and “winning” but never came through on his promises, so it was better for voters to have a president that explicitly opposed their values than one who shared them in name only.
> This was before US political party polarization had seemed to hit the sports team extremist fandom levels that elected Trump.
This is putting the cart before the horse. There was already a lot of polarization, but Trump was elected for his rhetoric around immigration. His supporters continued despite his constant failures to support him to own the libs or whatever and because he was good at bloviating as though he was always just about to get around to doing what they wanted.
> In this particular case, I'm not aware that post-Trump things have yet worked out for the college student revolutionaries. Voters are polarized, in a very dumbed-down way, distracted with extreme sports team rivalry petty behavior, rather than getting much progress on the supposedly driving values.
This has almost nothing to do with Trump himself, except that the initial reaction to him in polite society was so extreme. There was constant fear-mongering about how he was going to throw everyone in concentration camps and make Handmaid’s Tale a reality. None of which is really new, but it was ramped up hard for Trump. It’s not a bug but a feature of American politics. It reinforces the two-party system and pushes out the need to actually deliver things voters want. They can both just run candidates based on stoking fears of the other one. Arthur Finkelstein really pioneered the technique. I think that’s beginning to break down now. You see a lot more cross pollination with the “anti-woke left”, TERFs, and so on than you did in 2015.
I find it disturbing that certain words become verboten, so people swap them out with sarcastically infantile euphemisms, then that language becomes increasingly normalized outside of those platforms.
I was looking up a local court case and found some true crime video covering it using this language. Hearing a detailed, lurid account of a horrific crime presented in a professional tone but peppered with infantile euphemisms was extremely unsettling.
We’ve always had this to some extent, with reporters using language like “he called them the n-word” but it just keeps getting ramped up. I preferred when they would just say that the details were too sensitive to discuss or something similar.
I wholeheartedly agree with liberals that indigenous minority groups, and some others with special circumstances, like Blacks in the US, should receive special protections to preserve their identities and safeguard their interests in the face of a situation where they don’t have the numbers to counteract majoritarianism. I also think that the founding people of a nation deserve similar recognition. My father is from an immigrant family. My mother has ancestors who fought in the Revolutionary War. They have qualitatively different relationships with America on that basis. He comes from an aspirational, urban, working class family, she from a well-established, rural, petit bourgeois family, and they have qualitatively different relationships with America on that basis, too. Solving one problem doesn’t require giving up on the other.
A return to the original meaning of tolerance is warranted. Which is learning to cooperate despite differences, not erasing them. And, importantly, it’s a two-way street, not a struggle session in which one side is made to atone perpetually for real or perceived past sins.
There’s a point where these differences disappear, but they’re surprisingly durable. Just read Albion’s Seed and you can see how smaller ethnic differences between groups of English colonists are still at work in the political landscape today.
People like playing with language, and use understatement regularly. Unlike “I’ll just have two beers”, where it’s obvious to any child who has learned to count that this is the case, when kids regularly see people around them say “I’ll just have a couple of beers”, they assume couple is another word for an indeterminate small amount like few. When they later learn of other uses of “couple” they assume these are unrelated.
Islamic culture is definitely highly influential on Europe and in turn was highly influenced by European culture, and that kinship is worth acknowledging unlike this whiny confrontational Islamophobia narrative which holds no water when you actually look into the historical context. But this whole self-flagellation thing never been about actual mutual appreciation of different cultures.
It’s socially conservative. Why the hyperbolic language? It’s only “extreme” when juxtaposed with the political expressions of “polite society”, not America at large, which skews conservative on social issues.
> propaganda
Everything is propaganda, as everything is political. We just call things propaganda when it’s the kind we disagree with.
> directly participated in multiple criminal conspiracies
I’m sure the police in this town would say the same of the newspaper in question.
> never produced anything even vaguely resembling journalism
Well that’s not true on its face. I find a lot of it cringy, but even when I find that they don’t merit the conclusions that PV comes to (which is quite often), they are quite transparent.
I’m somewhat familiar with Calhoun’s studies if that’s what you’re referencing, but I don’t think they’re perfectly applicable to human societies where there’s no outside force maintaining everything for us. Reproduction slows, accompanied by economic stagnation and infrastructural failures, and all of a sudden we’re not in our little mouse utopia anymore. These little collapses aren’t necessarily bad. It’s artificially pushing onward in the name of GDP that I think leads to even bigger collapses down the road.
Assuming that fertility decline is irreversible, this would mean that you should have specific examples of entire populations that have died not of disease or conquest, but reproductive ennui. I don’t think so.
Fertility rates tend to fluctuate in relation to stressors like resource availability.
> No little girl who grows up seeing few, if any women, have children will think to herself "I want 2.1 when I grow up!".
Why not? Baby booms are very real. This is normal human behavior.
Edit: Just one example would be the short-lived COVID baby boom. Remarkable how responsive people are to changes when you think that this is mathematically impossible.
1. I was a precocious kid, and as much as it might rub people the wrong way, there’s nothing wrong with being proud of yourself for that and bringing attention to it. The downside is that you can (at least some of us) have one hell of a shock once you’re out of the wunderkind age range and you’ve made that a core part of your identity.
2. Different standards are warranted with youth. That was a big reason why I prefaced everything with my age growing up. Programmers are notoriously nitpicky and curmudgeonly, but they do tend to have a special place in their heart for youthful curiosity and enthusiasm, and are more willing to give constructive feedback to someone in that phase than a mature adult who won’t just RTFM. I know I feel that way.
Right, I understand that in the context of this specific quote, but the article implies that claim.
> Give it a photo of a black person to search on and you're probably getting a black person as a match, but the likelihood that it's actually the same person is lower than it would be if you were searching for a white person.
Lower, but by how much? The number given here is six in all. It feels very premature to use probably in that sentence. (Edit: misread that as you’re probably going to get a match)
> The quote doesn't say it's increasing arrest rates for black people, but arrest rates for innocent black people.
I meant this quote from the article: “facial recognition leads police departments to arrest Black people at disproportionately high rates.”
But I agree. It seems that there is a disparity in accuracy, it’s very unclear on how much of one but so far it appears that we’re talking about a fraction of a percent. We only have a sample size of six to draw on. We don’t know the demographics of the districts this has been employed in, and it seems strange to assume that they’re the same as the American population at large. I mean the first example is from Detroit.
I don’t see how this relates to simple facial recognition. It doesn’t appear that they’re scanning for “criminal physiognomies” but for specific facial matches.
Furthermore, it seems that this whole line of argumentation implies that facial recognition software may be mistaking innocent Black people for non-Black perpetrators, which I don’t see any evidence for. How does this increase arrest rates for Black people if AI just can’t tell them apart? In all likelihood, the person who got away is also Black.
But that web isn’t the one we’re dealing with anymore. We’ve moved from documents to applications. Like tabindex, I’m sure browsers or frameworks will gradually find ways to make any element behave link-like in every way. Which isn’t really a bad thing, it’s just development of the core idea of the web.
My exact claim, which has been consistent and clear, is that they are at higher rates. You're the one intentionally dodging context. Of course given their much smaller number they can easily be much more predisposed to such acts and still make up a minority of those who actually commit them. Why do you keep trying to muddy the waters like this? It's a pure strawman, a hallmark of bad-faith argumentation.
---
> This paper was published in 1992. Back then, societal attitudes towards homosexuality were far worse. Given that, I don’t buy the argument that this was any kind of standard deferential nonsense towards liberalism. Even many liberals didn’t like queers back then; you didn’t need to walk on eggshells.
Academia is very different from real life, especially the fluffier "sciences".
---
> In the preceding section you say that posting a link doesnt make a claim; and now you say it does make a claim.
More rhetorical nonsense. I've never said either. I have personally made claims, and posted a few links related to said claims.
> Did you have any comment about that?
Cool. This is your one actual substantial criticism.
---
> I’d be happy to read a textual version of that information and respond to it.
I'll summarize. The humor unfortunately gets lost in the process.
Foucault, who provided the philosophical foundation for Queer Theory, wanted to abolish age of consent laws all the way down to infants. (Not mentioned: his alleged rape of Tunisian boys).
Gayle Rubin, author of the founding text of Queer Theory, Thinking Sex, dedicated half of said document to defending pederasty and compared pedophilia to a preference for spicy foods.
And Queer Theorists ever since (he specifically provides examples for Pat Califia and Judith Butler) have consistently reaffirmed this defense of pedophilia.
Aside from Queer Theory, which the video focuses on, on the more conventional gay rights side of things, you have celebrated poet Allen Ginsberg, Harry Hay (mentor of Will Roscoe, inventor of "two spirit"), David Thorstad, &c. all involved with NAMBLA. That's quite a resumé. But I know, as I'm sure you do, how frankly such topics are acknowledged and discussed internally within the gay community. How commonly such things as nonmonogamy and pederasty are understood to be inherent to the condition, how much trauma is widely acknowledged as a contributing factor, how well it's understood that the "Will and Grace" pop culture personas and the "born this way" slogans were just pretty lies that were necessary to placate those evil Others.
After writing this up, I did stumble across a transcript of the video here: https://borazansesli.com/2020/12/16/queer-theory-pedophilia-...
I try to be even-handed, so yes, I included a liberal-leaning wiki entry which synthesized sources bolstering my claim and refutations of them, with an obvious editorial slant toward the latter. I apologize for that?
---
> I mean, consider the first line of the abstract: "Previous investigations have indicated that the ratio of sex offenders against female children vs. offenders against male children is approximately 2:1"
Why leave off the second half of that sentence? "while the ratio of gynephiles to androphiles among the general population is approximately 20:1."
That is a fine example of cherry-picking!
> But what should we make of the final line of the abstract: "This, of course, would not indicate that androphilic males have a greater propensity to offend against children."
Now take a look at the preceeding sentence: "This suggests that the resulting proportion of true pedophiles among persons with a homosexual erotic development is greater than that in persons who develop heterosexually."
The final line is just boilerplate CYA we don't want to suggest anything bad about homosexuals language at odds with the rest of the paper. Standard deferential genuflection for any research that contradicts liberal priors.
> I mean, it seems like the study is actually stating that despite an over-prevalence of homosexuals in the pedophilic group, that they still don't make up the majority of pedophiles?
Who made that claim? I certainly didn't.
---
> What do you make of the remainder of that same line from the abstract: "but studies directly assessing the association between these diverse types of maltreatment and sexuality cannot disentangle the causal direction because the sequencing of maltreatment and emerging sexuality is difficult to ascertain."
I only claimed correlation, not necessarily causation. But, come on, leaving out the whole preceding section of the abstract is hilarious:
Our study used instrumental variable models based on family characteristics that predict maltreatment but are not plausibly influenced by sexual orientation (e.g., having a stepparent) as natural experiments to investigate whether maltreatment might increase the likelihood of same-sex sexuality in a nationally representative sample (n = 34,653). In instrumental variable models, history of sexual abuse predicted increased prevalence of same-sex attraction by 2.0 percentage points (95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.4, 2.5), any same-sex partners by 1.4 percentage points (95% CI = 1.0, 1.9), and same-sex identity by 0.7 percentage points (95% CI = 0.4, 0.9). Effects of sexual abuse on men’s sexual orientation were substantially larger than on women’s. Effects of non-sexual maltreatment were significant only for men and women’s sexual identity and women’s same-sex partners. While point estimates suggest much of the association between maltreatment and sexual orientation may be due to the effects of maltreatment on sexual orientation, confidence intervals were wide. Our results suggest that causal relationships driving the association between sexual orientation and childhood abuse may be bidirectional, may differ by type of abuse, and may differ by sex.
---
My friend, your refutation skills need a lot of work. You're listing random sentences that you think confirm your priors, without actually reading them at all. By the way, I can't help but notice your lack of response on the connection between queer theory and pederasty. I thought that video was both humorous and informative, and very easy to fact-check. How about you?
Increased lesbian domestic violence rates
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domestic_violence_in_lesbian...
Increased gay pedophilia rates
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1556756/
Childhood trauma
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3535560/
A fun video on queer theory and pedophilia
There’s quite a lot of information on such things. It’s not hard to dig into. I agree though, it is disgusting.