479 karma · joined May 6, 2019
They wanted to broadcast a film. Not an advertisement. Not a campaign ad. A film. This is what gets lost in most common discourse about the Citizens United case. Had the court ruled otherwise in the Citizens United case, it would have given the Federal Government precedent to ban films for political reasons. The other reply by Dharmab is also very useful. The effects of ruling another way on the Citizens United would have impacted not only the medium of film, but also the publication of books, and all other media. Imagine not being able to publish a book critical of a candidate before an election. Yet that would have been the result of ruling otherwise. It's probably worth actually watching the oral arguments of the case: https://www.c-span.org/video/?288797-1/citizens-united-v-fed...
https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/amazon-godaddy-boots...
Littlestymear linked a map in another reply to my comment that seems to break it down purely by population in clusters of 250,000: https://xkcd.com/2399/
That map still suggests that clusters of blue in highly urban areas are surrounded by clusters of red in "less urban" areas, and never the opposite. Rural, or less urban environments have different cultures than highly urban environments, and this is readily observable.
>They also do not reflect movements that are fundamentally leninist in organization, where a small cohesive nucleus of activists defines the agenda and directs action.
I'm afraid I'm not sure what you mean by this. Please be more explicit.
>Without a Fox News stoking and directing anger, there is no "red rage", and Fox people are urban people.
This is a misconception. One blames the media for the information purveyed rather than the sorts of people amenable to Fox's viewpoint in their news. If there was prima facie no distinction between those who adore Pres. Trump, and those who despise him, prior to their exposure to Fox News, then this might be a tenable position, but given that there are two different demographics, both of which have access to Fox News and yet react distinctly differently to it, tells us that there are other factors at play.
>What is true is that nowadays people can live in socially-isolated bubbles that do not communicate with other bubbles. This is not a function of geographical location, though, but hyper-personalized media consumption.
And yet geography seems to be at play in which media bubble you end up in, as do a number of other factors. Perhaps the media bubbles are as much a function of existing divisions as the exacerbated divisions are of the bubbles?
This is what I find so disturbing about the Parler fiasco. Every tech person I know has interacted with AWS directly at some point. Everyone any of us knows has interacted with something reliant on AWS. What's the percentage of web services that run on AWS now? It's well over a third IIRC. AWS is essentially indispensable at this point. It might very well be called a technological utility.
Moreover AWS's core market has, historically, been startups. Parler, being a startup, was in their core group of customers, dealing with a service that had effectively become ubiquitous among startups. They were an American company, with a CEO and investors and users and capital.
Being a B2B service, bordering on a technological utility, rather than a B2C online community like Facebook or Twitter, the idea of AWS banning users seems almost a category error. The idea of AWS banning an American startup would have been unthinkable to me before it happened.
EDIT: Moved some phrases around for clarity.
Parler has filed a lawsuit alleging precisely the opposite, and alleging further that, due to Amazon's contract with Twitter, Amazon's actions were a matter, not of TOS, but of anti-competitive action, especially given that "Hang Mike Pence" was trending on Twitter at the same time that Parler was getting kicked off of AWS. Anyway, I don't know the specifics of how Parler was moderated, so I won't comment further on the matter.
What I do see is a company whose mission was not explicitly political, but whose clientele was largely composed of the faction who lost the most recent election losing critical infrastructure, to the point that their service is effectively dead, even as myriad other companies move to denounce the faction who lost the most recent election. That is disturbing.
I tend to think of it as more along the lines of feedback loops. It's like supply and demand. It doesn't really matter which comes first, so long as both exist commensurate to one another.
This is one from 2016 and is red-blue binary. It is perhaps the most illustrative: https://blueshift.io/election-2016-county-map.html
This makes peaceful resolution very difficult, as we're dealing with two groups who largely live apart from one another, with different geography, culture, and social mores. I think it's important to emphasize, there are a lot of people who genuinely believe that systemic voting irregularities influenced our last election, to the point of having changed the outcome, and don't view Joe Biden as having been legitimately elected. Furthermore, they believe that the courts, especially the Supreme Court, refused to even hear their case, and that Congress would in no way give their grievances with the process an open debate, before accepting results they viewed as fraudulent. This puts them into a position of desperation. The videos of people being arrested at the airport do not help: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lxwJ5HXSzuA
Given the geography. I expect to see red-hats (Trump people) going into the cities where the blue-hats (centrists) and the black-hats (Antifa/BLM) live, and then retreating into the rural areas, where supportive sheriffs are more likely to run interference against other law-enforcement agencies. To some extent, this is what we already saw at the Capitol Building, as well in places like Kenosha where people like Kyle Rittenhouse came from out-of town (albeit within reasonable driving distance) to the city where violence was occurring.
EDIT: better link
EDIT 2: The phrase "I've thought a lot about this" suggests that one has thought more of themselves thinking about the issue, than about the issue itself. As such It has been removed.
I think it's especially bad for startups. Parler was a startup that was rapidly growing, a real startup with an actual ceo and actual investors, and AWS yanked the rug out from under them, and I doubt they'll be the last. I wonder how many promising companies that would otherwise be able to exist because we cared about their products and not their politics are likely to stop before they start, or else die early due to this environment.
Too many movies, not enough life.
Not wanting to be sheltered is fine, and if the author can genuinely make it as a full-time writer, more power to him, but the reason his family has status is because his parents (and their parents probably) worked for it. Being a writer is a high status position if successful, but "wanting to get into more trouble" is silly. What the author is really saying is "I watched [insert x movie about honors student who works super hard and never has any fun deciding to cut loose] and want to live that in real life." And the thing that the author missed is: those are just movies. In real life, when you go crazy, that has consequences. Skipping out on financial security for the sake of art is a difficult choice, with actual sacrifices involved. Though it's probably easier if you come from a family that can pay full tuition at Princeton.
You could use this to syndicate blog posts, sort of like RSS, except each entry is JSON and could be viewed as it's own page rendered by it's own renderer (carried by a CDN and cached by the browser), or by the renderer of the users choice.
I absolutely agree with the paying for no ads model, as I really, really like that model. The premium subscription was totally worth it, and the app with ads can be truly unbearable in comparison (but not so unbearable that I'm going to start paying them again).
Honestly, nothing scares me more than losing all the code and all the technology we've developed in the past 70 or so years. There's been so much advancement, but it's also transferred in such a way (institutional knowledge, propietary software, proprietary hardware, etc.) that it's super easy to lose. If we preserve open hardware and software, then we could rebuild in the case of civilizational decline and the accompanying knowledge loss, something which we would neither be the first nor the last to experience.
It's essentially a problem of distributed timers and distributed transactions.
(If anyone has any resources on how similar problems have been solved in the past, I'd appreciate it.)
EDIT: It should be obvious that github being "code google" is not great for freedom. It's brilliant on the part of Microsoft, in the same way that securing a monopoly on OS's 20 years ago was brilliant. With the cloud-backend->web-frontend being our new defacto operating system, Microsoft is set to achieve this once again. Azure and GitHub synergize really well together. At this rate, the default way to deploy open source code will be VS Code -> .NET 5 -> Github -> Azure, and we will be at Microsoft's monopolistic mercies once again, enthralled to the cloud instead of running our own software that we own (even if we don't understand) on our own hardware that we own (even if we don't understand), and maintaining some semblance of ownership over our own computing and communication with one another via these computers.
>One of the streams in question was a rebroadcast of Trump’s infamous kickoff rally, where he said that Mexico was sending rapists to the United States. Twitch also flagged racist comments at Trump’s recent rally in Tulsa.
Oh, it was a channel for campaign rallies. That makes more sense.
But this puts us into deep hot water so far as content platforms go. This is removing the campaign content of a sitting president. For a platform to be unfavorable to on candidate over another as a matter of policy (whatsoever the official stated reasons may be) politicizes the platform, moves them into being "not a platform but a publisher". If there is to be any investigation of electoral meddling, it should be into the political bias of technology companies, and if Trump wins another term, that is likely exactly what will occur.
Madness. I wonder what would happen if the NRA started defending encryption as a second amendment issue, as encryption technology has historically fallen under munitions export control legislation.
I've never gotten that offer (or applied, for that matter), so I don't know what I'd actually do in your shoes. But if I got the offer, and thought that I could really do it and give my all, then I would. The kind of credibility you get is the same sort that you get having gone to Stanford, or Harvard (also things I haven't done). It's proof-of-intelligence, if not proof-of-intelligent-life. Do you have other offers at places that are more in line with your morality, or a start-up that's just burning in your soul to be born? If not, I'd take the Facebook job.
EDIT: The above was not fully considered. I think the original article makes a really good point about this:
>Splitting an application into microservices gives finer-grained allocation possibility; but do we actually need that ? I would argue that by having to anticipate the traffic for each microservice specifically, we will face more problem because one part of the app can't compensate for another one. With a single application, any part (let's say user registration) can use all allocated servers if needed ; but now it can only scale to a fixed smaller part of the server fleet. Welcome to the multiple points of failure architecture.
Having a monolith where each feature is deployed separately according to feature flags makes some sense in that you have one codebase, deployed modularly, like microservices, but you still leave yourself open to the "multiple points of failure arhitecture" as the author describes it. In addition, the feature flags idea doesn't really remove the deployment disadvantages of the monolith, unless you're willing to have different parts of your horizontally deployed application on different versions.