HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Grahf

10 karma · joined July 4, 2016

submissionscomments
Grahf··on Show HN: Paranoia – Get a cold, adversarial review of your code
Author here. Good question! /review is great for a quick pass on something you're still writing. I use it daily.

There are things it doesn't do well though. it can't take into account different priors. Built in reviews run on the same model family that wrote the code, so a subagent gets you fresh context and the same blind spots. Paranoia runs the review on another vendor's CLI. Here, Codex and Claude. For example, in my own work the same vendor declared converged and the other came back ten minutes later with two fatals and twelve majors on the same doc.

There's memory. Built in reviews are stateless, so round six happily re-reports round one's bug in a new spelling and nobody's any the wiser. Here the reviewer registers the defect class as a regex, the server re-runs it every round with git grep, and a computed trailer won't call it done while it still matches.

It's more expensive to set up, though, and require a subscription to both ChatGPT and Claude to get the most out of it. Not worth it for small changes, worth it for critical changes that are hard to walk back. For a fully automated harness, assuming you have max subs on both sides, it's perfect for making sure the agent is getting things right.

Grahf··on Dark side of a Valley software engineer
Indeed. Your salary is relative. If you're earning 3-4x more but have to pay 3-4x more on all your expenses, are you really richer? Factor in long hours in general, unpaid overtime, crunch times, a poor work/life ratio in general, etc. It seems like the scales are balanced all wrong.

That's my perception as another tech worker living in the UK. I'd love to hear an argument as to why that isn't the case.