HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Herring

3,347 karma · joined February 3, 2008

submissionscomments
Herring··on Ilya Sutskever: We're moving from the age of scaling to the age of research
https://metr.org/blog/2025-03-19-measuring-ai-ability-to-com...

He’s wrong we still scaling, boys.

Herring··on Three Years from GPT-3 to Gemini 3
What I'm hearing is "teachers just outside Seattle are doing great, but inside Seattle and the rest of America, they're really not." That's the local cost of living set by the tech sector.
Herring··on Three Years from GPT-3 to Gemini 3
You need a different analysis. Maybe more like this

https://www.census.gov/library/visualizations/interactive/te...

Or this:

> While U.S. teachers make 58% of their counterparts’ salaries, Finnish teachers make 92% of the salaries of similarly educated professions. This trend follows with other countries ranked highly in the World Happiness Report. Teachers in Denmark (ranked #2 in World Happiness) make 81% of their counterparts’ salaries and teachers in Sweden (ranked #4) make 74% of their counterparts’ salaries.

https://www.ednc.org/perspective-how-the-worlds-happiest-cou...

Herring··on Three Years from GPT-3 to Gemini 3
I posted elsewhere you can't just compare across the globe like that. You have to think about cost of living and especially opportunity cost. In the US, teacher pay lags behind similarly educated professionals, which means they get stretched thin and the best with options will leave.
Herring··on Three Years from GPT-3 to Gemini 3
I almost agree, but too many people will take that to mean “we need to do more with less”. It’s a feature of capitalism. Teachers are stretched thin in most places, that’s always the main problem. Are WA teachers compensated about the same as other similarly educated professionals? As cops?

Hire smart motivated people, pay them well, leave them alone, they’ll figure this one out. It’s not hard, anyone can google what Finland does.

Herring··on Three Years from GPT-3 to Gemini 3
That's half true. You have to think about cost of living, you can't just compare across the globe like that. And especially opportunity cost. In the US, teacher pay lags behind similarly educated professionals.

But you're right after a certain point other factors matter more than simple $ per student. Unfortunately one of those factors is teacher pay <=> teacher quality.

Herring··on DoGE "cut muscle, not fat"; 26K experts rehired after brutal cuts
> We went in for liposuction ..

That's so generous it's past inaccurate. If they genuinely wanted a liposuction they wouldn't have hired their local pedophile rapist grifter to do it.

Herring··on Three Years from GPT-3 to Gemini 3
"Thus, a caste system makes a captive of everyone within it."
Herring··on Three Years from GPT-3 to Gemini 3
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_advantage

Modern society benefits a lot from specialization. It's like the dumbest kid in France is still better at French than you.

Herring··on Three Years from GPT-3 to Gemini 3
In theory yeah, but in practice 54% will also vote against funding education. Catch-22.
Herring··on Three Years from GPT-3 to Gemini 3
I think the point is we’re getting there. These models are growing up real fast. Remember 54% of US adults read at or below the equivalent of a sixth-grade level.
Herring··on Three Years from GPT-3 to Gemini 3
Text is very information-dense. I'd much rather skim a transcript in a few seconds than watch a video.

There's a reason keyboards haven't changed much since the 1860s when typewriters were invented. We keep coming up with other fun UI like touchscreens and VR, but pretty much all real work happens on boring old keyboards.

Herring··on We stopped roadmap work for a week and fixed bugs
Or just look at your car. Heated seats are sexy in the short term, but boring old reliability and predictability win out long term.
Herring··on My Life Is a Lie: How a Broken Benchmark Broke America
Is this guy actually trying to justify racism?
Herring··on An Economy of AI Agents
It's hard to predict the future. For example this was a popular article not that long ago - https://www.semianalysis.com/p/google-we-have-no-moat-and-ne...
Herring··on Students fight back over course taught by AI
That's the Baumol effect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baumol_effect

1) Two-Sector Economy: In Baumol and Bowen's observations, the economy is divided into two parts:

- A Progressive Sector: Productivity grows rapidly due to technology and automation (e.g., manufacturing, data processing).

- A Stagnant Sector: Productivity grows slowly, if at all, because the service is labor-intensive (e.g., a string quartet performance, a haircut, K-12 teaching).

2) Wage Linkage: Both sectors compete for labor from the same pool of workers. As productivity gains allow wages to rise in the progressive sector, the stagnant sector must also increase its wages to attract and retain employees.

3) Divergent Cost Impact:

- In the progressive sector, the higher wages are offset by the gains in productivity. The labor cost per unit of output can remain stable or even decrease.

- In the stagnant sector, there are no corresponding productivity gains to offset the higher wages. The labor cost per unit of service must therefore increase.

4) Resulting Price Trend: The prices for services in the stagnant sector (e.g., concert tickets, college tuition, healthcare) must therefore rise and faster than the prices for goods from the progressive sector (e.g., electronics, cars). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baumol_effect#/media/File:Pric...

5) A lot of European countries fund these expensive services through general taxation rather than direct user fees. In the US that's not going to fly, so cost pressure incentivizes orgs to cut corners and reduce quality and automate as much as possible.

Herring··on AI is a front for consolidation of resources and power
Language is a lot deeper than that. It's like if I say "we speak the same language", it means a lot more than just the ability to translate. It's talking about a shared past and worldview and hopefully future which I/we intend to invest in.
Herring··on Grok 4.1
Bro. Listen. Digging through a garbage can and finding half a cheeseburger doesn’t mean you’re smart. It means you’re a raccoon.
Herring··on Republican push to make U.S. census surveys voluntary alarms statisticians
If age is your biggest concern, you should go fight vaccines. Most of them are less than 100 years old too. No telling what the long term prospects are on our DNA. Go ahead, ping me when you’re done.
Herring··on Grok 4.1
It's important to be fair and balanced. For example did you know Hitler was actually a really good painter!
Herring··on Republican push to make U.S. census surveys voluntary alarms statisticians
Athenian democracy ran into two successful coups because of those internal flaws, and ultimately didn't last that long. It's better viewed as a "v0.1-alpha" than a final version

I wouldn't quite say "democracy requires equality". It's more accurate to say "inequality is corrosive". The amount of damage done depends on how much inequality and for how long and what countermeasures are taken (eg redistribution of wealth, expansions of rights, safety nets etc).

Herring··on Republican push to make U.S. census surveys voluntary alarms statisticians
What do you mean median values? Trump 2020 won the most votes of any sitting president ever. Then he won the popular vote in 2024.

Honestly given US history (slavery, individualism etc) I'm surprised democracy has lasted so long here. The Economist rates the US as a "flawed democracy", it has been undergoing erosion for a long time.

Herring··on Where Educational Technology Fails: A seventh-grader's perspective
In my opinion too many people have opinions where they shouldn't. Just import a working system, like Estonia successfully imported from Finland. You don't have the skills to roll your own.
Herring··on A new documentary about the history of forced psychiatric treatment in Spain
Study your history, because that’s an old story. The Puritans who fled England and settled in Massachusetts Bay did not try to establish religious freedom in the modern, pluralistic sense. They just wanted freedom to practice their own religion. They were intolerant of dissent and quickly established their own orthodoxies. Individuals who challenged their religious and civil authority, such as Roger Williams and Anne Hutchinson, were banished. Quakers who arrived later were brutally persecuted, with some being executed.
Herring··on A new documentary about the history of forced psychiatric treatment in Spain
I don't know why you're surprised. This place is primarily about making money.

Businesses are set up like tiny little fascist dictatorships. They are always trying to pay less taxes, evade regulations, layoff workers, monopolize, destroy competitors etc. They don't know anything about the public sphere, or common good, or government, or democracy, or rule of law etc. They suck at that, it goes against all their training and instincts.

Herring··on Microsoft confirms Windows 11 is about to change
I think they know and this is a hail mary. Windows market share has been gradually eroding. They don't intend to go quietly.
Herring··on Hemp ban hidden inside government shutdown bill
I was reading about Austria recently. It's a nice place, but it turns out they have their far-right Nazis in rural areas too. It's pretty common around the world. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urban%E2%80%93rural_political_...

I think the world is still figuring out how to deal with this. The German firewall looks quite interesting. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firewall_against_the_far-right...

Of course things like the electoral college, filibuster, gerrymandering, fptp, lifetime appointments etc don't help.

Herring··on YouTube erased more than 700 videos documenting Israeli human rights violations
No system is perfect. Germany still has a bunch of work to do, sure, but I'd still very much prefer having a firewall to no firewall. Nazis in the US are entrenched - filibuster, gerrymandering, fptp, electoral college, supreme court, presidency, ICE, etc etc.
Herring··on YouTube erased more than 700 videos documenting Israeli human rights violations
Yeah I hope to never say this again, but I'm pretty sure Goebbels was right.

Germany took those lessons to heart. Speech and expression related to Nazism is heavily regulated and subjects you to imprisonment. Demonstrations/rallies are often banned. The Nazi party itself is banned. AfD is being monitored by intelligence agencies and might be banned in the future, etc. They do this defensively when groups demonstrate an "actively belligerent, aggressive stance" towards the democratic order. Because it's like pointing a gun at people in public - it's already violent even if you don't pull the trigger.

Herring··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (November 2025)
54% of American adults read at or below 6th grade levels. If the bot understands climate change, I can't see how dating it would be worse than dating most of my neighbors tbh ...
← PreviousPage 11 of 34Next →