HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Herring

3,347 karma · joined February 3, 2008

submissionscomments
Herring··on U.S. government has lost more than 10k STEM PhDs since Trump took office
I hope so.
Herring··on U.S. government has lost more than 10k STEM PhDs since Trump took office
Any sources on that debunking? I can't say I've seen anything like that, but I'm open to read about it. Intuitively any societal problems like cost of living will feed into the far-right recruitment narrative that the elites are incompetent. All kinds of incumbents lost ground worldwide after Covid. And last I read the consensus is housing is a big contributor to the far-right issues in Denmark and the Netherlands.

But sure, if you want to add "break up big tech" and "regulate social media" to the shopping cart I'm absolutely up for it.

Herring··on U.S. government has lost more than 10k STEM PhDs since Trump took office
I want you to go to your favorite frontier LLM and ask how much it would cost the US to implement Vienna-style public housing. Figure in paying off current homeowners to get their support. Restrict it to major cities where housing is the worst, just to make it easier. I bet you it's well over $10T long-term. Iraq was $2-3T long term. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_cost_of_the_Iraq_War
Herring··on U.S. government has lost more than 10k STEM PhDs since Trump took office
Yes it's a taxes issue, because that's how you pay for European-style safety nets. And again that's probably not enough either, cause Denmark/Netherlands are having issues with housing causing the far-right to surge. So you probably need Vienna-style public housing too. The US is so far from the correct solutions you're not even on the same planet.
Herring··on U.S. government has lost more than 10k STEM PhDs since Trump took office
The problem with these threads is everyone wants to complain about Trump, but support drops drastically when you talk about policies that actually help buffer against the far-right. Eg implementing robust safety nets and low inequality, to reduce status anxiety and grievance. How many of you software engineers want to sign up for high taxes? It's basically tragedy of the commons.

Economics on its own is probably not sufficient either. You probably also need widespread unionization, a Cordon Sanitaire, and probably German-style intelligence surveillance of the far-right too.

Herring··on Porting 100k lines from TypeScript to Rust using Claude Code in a month
Good catch. I should really look at the code before commenting on it.
Herring··on Porting 100k lines from TypeScript to Rust using Claude Code in a month
I think the point is that's where all the big tech companies say we're heading. I can't say I endorse it, but the OP who just left it running for a month seems to like it.
Herring··on Porting 100k lines from TypeScript to Rust using Claude Code in a month
We don’t read assembly either any more. The sexy new programming language for 2026 is English.
Herring··on AI code and software craft
Ordinarily yes I’d love to overthrow the bourgeoisie (check my history, I live in flagged threads), but this time I think this thread is really just about the evolution of the profession.
Herring··on AI code and software craft
Can it get me a job if I get laid off (networking)? Can I crash on its couch for a while? It might displace tv/netflix, which yes is a huge market, but I don't think much more than that.
Herring··on AI code and software craft
This argument is basically just the 1800s Luddite vs Industrialist argument recast for a new age. Group A thinks quality is about human agency, and that machines are being used to bypass the apprenticeship system and produce inferior goods. Group B thinks efficiency is the highest priority, and craft is just vanity. Of course as we know we went a third way, and human roles just shifted.

I think one promising shift direction is humans do NOT like to talk to bots, especially not for anything important. It's biological. We evolved to learn from and interact with other humans, preferably the same group over a long time, so we really get to understand/mirror/like/support each other.

Herring··on Porting 100k lines from TypeScript to Rust using Claude Code in a month
Yeah and he claims a pass rate of 99.96%. At that point you might be running into bugs in the original implementation.
Herring··on Porting 100k lines from TypeScript to Rust using Claude Code in a month
I think the plan is for Claude to maintain it. He hasn't read a single line of code.
Herring··on Yes, It's Fascism
Yeah Americans don't want to face that their culture is the problem. Trump is still slightly more popular than he was at this point during his first term

https://www.natesilver.net/p/trump-approval-ratings-nate-sil...

They'd have to change the fundamental nature of business. Most US companies are run like tiny little fascist dictatorships, which is a great training ground for the real thing. The relationship between capital (owners/management) and labor is usually adversarial with "at-will" employment. Contrast in Norway, where businesses operate within a 3-way Agreement (Trepartssamarbeidet) - a formal cooperation between the government, employers' associations, and trade unions.

Americans would have to change capitalism too. The most reliable way to prevent the rise of the far right is to implement robust safety nets and low inequality, to reduce status anxiety and grievance.

But even in this thread they don't want to do that.

Herring··on White House alters arrest photo of ICE protester, says "the memes will continue"
It's so tricky. You can do most things right like Denmark/Netherlands, then you mess up just one (housing) and the far-right surges. Now you can't import immigrants to deal with your aging population, which means you're on a timer.

Or your neighbor goes far-right (US, maybe eventually Germany/France) and suddenly they start objecting to your internal policies (eg regulating big tech).

Or Russia+Covid combo suddenly inflating all kinds of prices, and again the far right surges.

I think it's going to be a dramatic few decades.

Herring··on White House alters arrest photo of ICE protester, says "the memes will continue"
Reminder that the most reliable way to prevent the rise of the far right is to implement robust safety nets and low inequality, to reduce status anxiety and grievance.

Europe found that out the hard way, and America is in the early stages of realizing it.

Herring··on De-dollarization: Is the US dollar losing its dominance? (2025)
Maybe recheck how exposed your country is. It's really bad for Canada, since ~77% of all Canadian goods exports are headed to the US. It will take a long time for them to diversify. Same with Mexico and Taiwan, and to a lesser extent Vietnam and Ireland.

Honestly as an American I'm just happy to see some open talk and movement by world leaders. This breakdown has been clear for at least 10 years, maybe 20 if you're smart, but nobody did anything. I hope Europe can learn to work with China here. I don't think the whole system is dead, they just need to find other dance partners.

Herring··on Is liberal democracy in terminal decline?
Maybe I misspoke, I mean it's an institutional+cultural failure. Looking forward, if we're to ever get out of this, it'll need something real big. Like another great depression leading to FDR's New Deal. Or Europe's hundreds of millions dead in two world wars. Heroism from individual congressmen isn't gonna cut it.
Herring··on Is liberal democracy in terminal decline?
They had no choice. Trump literally rewrote the republican party in his image. Congressmen who weren't falling in line got fired or forced to retire. Many many times, eg see Liz Cheney. The last time a purge like this happened was at the time of the Civil War. Even super-popular FDR tried taking out conservative democrats but wasn't successful (democrats don't have that kind of tribal discipline).
Herring··on Anthropic Economic Index report: economic primitives
Well if it ever gets to be a full replacement for phds, you’ll know cause it will have already replaced you.
Herring··on European lawmakers suspend U.S. trade deal
That's kind of a question for your priest, but I'll give it a go.

https://data.worldhappiness.report/chart

I like to spend a lot of time at the World Happiness Report because it gives me a better sense of economic well-being. You can't just look at GDP, you need a sense of which countries are burning human capital to fuel GDP and generate billionaires. That's a very common short-term tactic, so the WHR gives you a better sense of long-term political stability. Unhappy populations tend to vote for strongmen.

It's basically impossible to get to Finland-levels without bringing everyone along. Not just internally like getting rid of 996, but also including neighbors like Taiwan/Ukraine cause corruption tends to leak back in. Imagine if Bush had spent the Iraq war trillions on high speed rail/free college/ housing. Instead we got ICE.

Herring··on European lawmakers suspend U.S. trade deal
Bullies hate this one weird trick.
Herring··on 'The old order is not coming back,' Carney says in speech at Davos
Dude trump is NOT a temporary blip. His approval rating right now is slightly higher than it was at this point in his first term.

Last time it took a great depression to convince Americans to actually care about each other (socialism-lite), and I expect nothing less this time around.

Herring··on 'The old order is not coming back,' Carney says in speech at Davos
I genuinely love the speech but scanning the WHR, Canada has been dropping in happiness almost as fast as America.

https://data.worldhappiness.report/chart

They would have gone right-wing in Carney's election if not for Trump meddling. He needs to get those cost of living issues fixed ASAP, probably starting with housing.

Herring··on De-dollarization: Is the US dollar losing its dominance? (2025)
He is pissed. Damn. This will take a very long time to clean up… Assuming it’s reversible.
Herring··on Europe could 'weaponize' $10T of US assets over Greenland
Nope never been to Montana, so it appears you are being misled by a literal red herring.
Herring··on 'This is sell America' – US dollar tumbles as globe flees US assets
It's not gonna work. Dems have been meeting Republicans in the "center" for a long time. Republicans just go further right. You think conservatives like Obama?

It's not a rational thing. Like you said "Biden housing immigrants in hotels" and the implication is that he personally spent trillions on it and the sky is falling.

You need to train people to switch their brains back on, because it's a national security issue. All kinds of policies from free college to a shorter work-week so they have less stress and more time to think. Again, just copy what Western Europe does. They went through it before.

Herring··on 'This is sell America' – US dollar tumbles as globe flees US assets
Yeah.. that's how tribalism works. Dems don't really understand the kind of blank-check popular backing that Trump has.

Studies have shown for a long time the human brain is frequently wired to prioritize group loyalty over factual accuracy. Probably something left over from when we were living in caves in small groups. Trump understands it extremely well. He just has to bring up immigrants and their brain reasoning centers turn off and they start frothing over Haitians eating dogs. Prior to Trump, most white Americans only encountered this if they brought a black girlfriend home.

After Obama, Trump literally rewrote the republican party. Congressmen who weren't falling in line got fired or forced to retire. Many many times, eg see Liz Cheney. The last time a purge like this happened was at the time of the Civil War. Even super-popular FDR tried taking out conservative democrats but wasn't successful (which btw is one of the main reasons we didn't get stuff like universal healthcare in the 1930s; southern democrats decided it was a threat to segregation).

That probably shows us how to stop it: wait for a massive failure like WW2 or the Great Depression, then implement strong safety nets, media, education, etc pretty much everything Western Europe is doing & more (eg housing).

Herring··on Europe could 'weaponize' $10T of US assets over Greenland
I've met all sorts of very rational people, but when you bring up immigrants their brain reasoning centers turn off and they start frothing over Haitians eating dogs.

You have to know how to trigger it, cause Trump knows it extremely well. Studies have shown for a long time the human brain is often wired to prioritize group loyalty over factual accuracy.

Prior to Trump, most white americans only encountered this if they brought a black girlfriend home.

Herring··on 'This is sell America' – US dollar tumbles as globe flees US assets
Yep, he's still slightly more popular than he was at this point during his first term.

https://www.natesilver.net/p/trump-approval-ratings-nate-sil...

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →