HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Herval_freire

97 karma · joined March 30, 2023

https://linktr.ee/herval

Contact info:

Address: 6363 Christie Ave, APT 2302, Emeryville, CA 94608

Phone: (917) 704-0699

email: hervalfreire@gmail.com

Media relations: Michelle Veronese

(https://www.linkedin.com/in/michelleveronese)

submissionscomments
Herval_freire··on Playing with Fire – ChatGPT
>But they have evidence, measurements and a quantitative model etc.

There's no evidence for something that has yet to happen yet. We have a model for increasing temperature but even this is not entirely accurate. Did we predict the heavy rain in CA as a result of warming? The evidence is somewhat solid but there is an aspect to it that is speculative as well. What we do know is that huge changes will occur in climate.

Additionally, Can we make a projection about the climate with the alternative energy initiatives in place? Not an accurate one. We don't have a mathematical model that can accurately predict what will happen. We may have models but those models will likely be off.

The effects of climate change on civilization are the main course here. These claims are basically all pure speculation. We have no idea what's going to happen with rising temperature and how it will change society as we know it. Should we just clamp down on all speculation and doom-saying when it could be a realistic scenario?

For AI there's tons of evidence of about the increase in capabilities. If you want to quantify it into a model though you would have to create some sort of numerical scale. have 1, with logic gates, 2 with math calculations, 3 with chess AI, and so on and so forth. Just at each number in the scale is some milestone of intelligence that must be surpassed by machines.

If you graph this scale on the Y axis with time as the X axis you get an increasing graph, where milestone after milestone is surpassed over time. You may get some AI "winters" but overall the trend is up and from this projection the evidence while still highly speculative is Very similar to the climate model in terms of an increasing projection. If AI continues to increase indefinitely as the projections show you eventually hit the AGI point on that scale.

I mean this is what a model is. Typically common sense is enough here but since you want a model you just do this and boom your common sense is now a numerical model and you have your "evidence" which is plastered with enough technical numbers and graphs to satisfy your desire to feed your rectum with "numbers" and "science" as if that's all there is to logic, reasoning and evidence.

There's your evidence of AGI, just as strong as climate change in terms of projection. We know climate will increase and we know the capabilities of AI will increase over time. And the speculation of the apocalyptic effects to society as a result of powerful AI? Same as the speculation of climate change apocalypse. All made up, but all within the realm of probability and realism.

The difference between climate change and AGI is that AGI had a observable inflection point with chatGPT. The sudden shift was so drastic and jarring that we get a lot of people like you who just want to call everything BS even if it's a realistic possibility. With climate change it's like, yeah apocalyptic temperature changes are just around the corner you'd be stupid not to agree but your still driving your car, and using energy that causes global warming.

It's like we're honest to ourselves with climate, but we don't act honestly because the doom that is encroaching on our society is happening really slowly. Too slowly to make us act. Just handle it later.

With AGI the change was so sudden and drastic we can't even be honest with ourselves. What if I spent years honing my software engineering skills... does all that skill go to waste? I have to lie to myself in order to maintain all those years of time I spent honing my craft. I have to suppress the speculation even if it's a realistic projection.

Herval_freire··on How to be a -10x Engineer
>Yeah that was an interesting read. I like the concept of a -10x engineer because they definitely exist

I don't believe 10x engineers actually exist. Maybe 1.5x, 2x, or 3x engineers exist at most. 10x is a huge exaggeration of human capability.

Get this, say a project takes a year to complete. The concept is saying a 10x engineer can do this in about month. If such a person exists it will be so rare I estimate that most people haven't ever encountered an actual "10x" engineer. Even a 3x engineer is super rare. I can see something like 2x happening where a project that takes a year is done in 6 months. That is rare but plausible.

You also might get a lead who can ramp up the effectiveness of an entire team by say 3x at most. If the size of the team was N, then it's N*3X. If N is like 4 then it's a 12x increase. This is the closest thing to an actual 10x engineer. But it's not actually a 10x engineer here it's just better management.

Herval_freire··on Playing with Fire – ChatGPT
There's potential for manipulation here by the government.

I would qualify your post with open source usage of the model, training algorithms and training data as well.

Herval_freire··on Playing with Fire – ChatGPT
>Innovation can be scary, and at this time, people are making assumptions based purely on things that we do not know.

Here's the thing. Before chatGPT, it was pretty much a given that society was under more or less zero risk of losing jobs to AI.

Now with GPT-4 that zero risk has changed to unknown risk.

That is a huge change and it is a change that would be highly unwise to not address.

I agree that only time will tell. But as humans we act on predictions of the future. We all have to make a bet on what that future will be.

Right now this blog post is writing about a scenario that although speculative is also very realistic. It is, again, unwise to dismiss the possibility of a realistic scenario.

Herval_freire··on Playing with Fire – ChatGPT
Oxygen wasn't invented.
Herval_freire··on Playing with Fire – ChatGPT
>These are fears that we live with and will forever live with, but we can't live lives only in fear.

But we can't lie to ourselves about reality in order to prevent fear either.

The opinions from Elon musk, to Sam Altman to even the person who started it all Geoffrey Hinton are actually inline with the blog post.

Hinton even says things like these chatGPT models literally can understand things you tell it.

Should we call climate scientists fear mongers because they talk about a catastrophic but realistic future? I think not, and the same can be said for the people I mentioned.

I personally think these experts are right, but you are also right in that "we are not there yet". But given the trajectory of the technology for the past decade we basically have a very good chance of being "there" very soon.

Agi that is perceptually equivalent to a person more intelligent then us is now a very realistic prospect within our lifetimes.

Herval_freire··on Tell HN: The ratio of wants-to-be-hired to is-hiring is at a record high 0.94
>It does amuse me that we're still at more people hiring than looking for jobs. It's a stark contrast to other industries, where the power is normally in the hands of employers.

No 0.94 is a sample that comes with a huge margin or error.

It very well could be that the actual ratio is that there are more programmers then jobs.

Herval_freire··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
>You literally picked the closest thing to AI-generated content, soulless statistics-driven garbage, literally the first thing that will be automated by AI in corporate media ;)

I also picked the majority of all content. Generic soulless content makes up 99% of what's out there. Anything more than that is usually a random permutation which is immediately picked up and regurgitated until that unique content itself becomes soulless and generic.

You call it the first thing that will be automated and you're likely right. Another synonym for soulless content that is 99% of all jobs. Do you have 100 coworkers? Well that means 99 of them are gone.

>If there are any people at all with my same worldview (and there are, outside of HN of course), people will want to enjoy creations made by a human, not by a corporate AI. Either way, as I said, the absence of a market does not affect in any way my will to create ;)

Plenty of people on HN share your world view. The problem is both people on or off HN won't be able to tell the difference. They just choose the better content while the people utilizing AI are mum about where that content came from.

For example the post you wrote is obviously written by an AI. You went to chatGPT and told it to craft a specific response to my points. Prove to me you didn't. Prove to me you did. You can't. So what does it matter? I'm talking to you anyway.

Herval_freire··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
No I mean more than an emergency fund. An emergency fund can be part of it, but I think you have to plan more given the greater uncertainties posed by AI.

More than a fund, an alternative.passive income source(s) is another factor. Given the situation now, it makes sense to ramp these side sources up and get them closer to mainline viability.

Herval_freire··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
> There's far too much uncertainty right now to engage in anything like planning.

I agree there's a huge amount of uncertainty. But I think there still must be some sort of plan B. Maybe a sort of nest egg of sorts of what to do in case it all goes to shit.

Herval_freire··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
Who said you would? You'd choose the superior product.
Herval_freire··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
>I'm having a very hard time seeing what could be done (in the possible future we're talking about).

Easy. While industrial automation has largely eliminated repetitive mechanical tasks robotics has not yet advanced to the point where it can replicate the versatility of the human form. The gap is partly closing with 3D printing but this is not moving nearly as fast as AI. Additionally there's just multitudes of construction jobs, maintenance jobs, physical jobs that can't be replaced.

I wouldn't go so far as to call jobs involving physical movement "menial". Think of the machinist and the carpenter.

This is one path. The other path is regulation or resistance. Ban AI usage like how the government bans your right to copy things you own (aka money).

Herval_freire··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
The fact that corporations and businesses will utilize AI to it's maximum extent is completely deterministic. This will happen.

Whether or not humanity in aggregate will launch a delayed immune response against AI via government regulation is not predictable. Regulating addictive drugs has a certain amount of clarity in moral action but regulating technology to prevent job loss is less clear. We didn't regulate calculators for replacing humans did we?

As I said, aspects of aggregate human behavior are deterministic. But I have to emphasize the "aspects" part because there are other "aspects" that are actually not predictable.

Herval_freire··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
Why? What should affect whether something is considered is it's likelihood of happening. If AI has a 99% chance of replacing you, then you'd rather consider the 1% alternative simply because there's no place for you anymore?

If AI will replace you there are steps that can be taken to prevent it from replacing you. This involves things like Resistance or changing what you do into something that can't be as easily replaced.

Herval_freire··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
This is a good point. The civil war like the drug war though are choices made after an inevitable plunge onto the predictable path. Both choices had a high cost and were incredibly hard to make.

It was also predictably a delayed response with varying levels of limited effectiveness.

Herval_freire··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
We lack choice in aggregate. As an individual you have the choice of doing a drug. If I talk about a population of people and I introduce highly addictive drugs to a population of people, then it's almost a guarantee that part of that population will get addicted. In this sense it is not a choice.

For AI, if I introduce AI to a population of people then for sure part of the population will exploit and use AI. Logically speaking in order to compete, others will have to start using it as well.

Herval_freire··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
>1) That is a horribly denigrative view of human creativity, one that simply does not reflect reality.

No it's not. It's a realistic view. Do not discount a view just because it's not inline with positivity. Only the realism of the view should be considered. And unfortunately it does reflect reality.

There's a huge amount of data supporting my viewpoint. Most of the content right now on the internet in books and in movies are generic human generated content. The very existence of this content is indisputable evidence for this.

Also you can't discount the trajectory of AI technology. The progress of the last decade is indicative of progress for the next decade. It the trend continues, logically, the only outcome is that the AI surpasses us.

>2) I kind of don't care: creativity always was and always will be about humans wanting to create something, the satisfaction and excitement of writing down a fanfic you've been thinking about for the last 3 weeks, the emotion of bringing your thoughts to life. Even with endless AI-generated content, I will never stop using my imagination (regardless of whether there will or won't be a market for it, and regardless of whether it may be worse than, say, dostoevskij's works), and the same holds true for every other creative individual on this planet, and I feel sorry for the people that never felt the feeling of creative excitement, and would rather waste years of their life consuming soulless content.

Good for you. It's good to exercise your creative brain and be excited about it. My comment isn't about this at all. It's simply about how your and other peoples content could become indistinguishable and inferior to AI. You can be creative all you want, it doesn't mean other people will care or want to consume the creative products you produce.

Herval_freire··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
Fearful of becoming a prompt carver? Let's be real, that is the least of their fears.

Fearful that a prompt carver can replace 10 artists is the more realistic fear here. That is the essential trajectory being plotted out by this technology and the trajectory described by the article.

Herval_freire··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
It could one day be possible for AI content to be so superior to human content that it becomes distinguishable.

We may actually be identifying human content by how inferior it is to AI generated content. It could be happening already.

Herval_freire··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
You're failing to account for the trajectory of this technology where AI easily produces content indistinguishable and superior to human content.

When such A I content becomes cheap and pervasive then AI will suddenly turn into a mirror to humanity. It will show us that "hand crafted" content is itself part of a bland and mechanical content generation algorithm.

Herval_freire··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
No it's not healthy in my opinion. A drug addict doesn't exactly have a choice when he uses drugs.

Aspects of human behavior in aggregate are so predictable it's basically deterministic.

If AI one day matches or surpasses human intelligence it is obvious humanity will exploit that AI as it already is doing now. There is no actual "choice" here. Just an illusion of it.

Herval_freire··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
Given the progress, current trendline point to a possible future where AI content is indistinguishable from the "human touch". AI content may even be preferable and better than human produces content.

People are reacting to AI as it is right now without projecting where this technology is going in the future. Given the rate of progress in the past year, the scenario I describe is a possibility that is insane not to consider.

Herval_freire··on Thinking hard makes the brain tired
The real cure for burnout is labor unions. Given how long this thread is and the recent layoffs, it's pretty much time.
Herval_freire··on The Contradictions of Sam Altman
> Why not both?

This is not a good idea. There is a conflict of interest here. The fundamental goal of government is regulation, the fundamental goal of a business is profit.

Both the morals of government and corporations are therefore very different. I call them Guardian and Commercial Syndromes respectively. When you combine these two syndromes you create monstrous hybrids.

Allow me to elucidate:

An entity in the Guardian syndrome values honor and uses forceful tactics to maintain order and regulation.

An entity in the Commercial syndrome values money and tries to use whatever means possible to gain profits through trade agreements.

You don't want a commercial entity to have the power to enforce things and you don't want a government entity to desire profit. Both hybrids lead to bad things and it's the root of corruption in the world today.

You know how the old medieval English Nave formed? So many pirates lurked off the coasts of medieval England that London merchants went to the expense of financing a fleet of fighting ships and gave it to the Crown.

Why give it to the Crown? Because you don't want some commercial entity running the Navy using methodologies that circumvent trade agreements and violently funnel trade and profit to a singular commercial entity. You need an entity outside of the commercial sphere; An entity in the Guardian Syndrome. If a commercial entity controlled the Navy you get something similar to the Mafia or Yakuza; Basically organized crime.

Only the government should enforce the laws of AI because there is in theory no conflict of interest. But practically speaking the US government is pretty heavily hybridized already (See military industrial complex). Still it's the best option.

Herval_freire··on Generative AI set to affect 300M jobs across major economies
>Well, that's the capital equipment case then. Is it really a general intelligence if you don't let it be general? It can't handle every possible scenario for you that way.

Humans are most useful to other humans as happy slaves. Autonomy only is good for humans as individuals. If we create useful agi of course we will bend it to our will. There is no incentive to make AI as a separate competitor other than an experiment. Either way this is hypothetical.

>If your theory is that someone will program an AGI for the specific goal of making you unemployed, sure that could happen. But it sounds more like warfare than economics to me at that point, so I can't comment cause I don't know too much about that.

No it's cost saving. I don't want to employ someone who I have to pay. This is capitalism. I save money by using AI.

>Where's the data? That was pure theory there, I didn't make any empirical claims.

You don't need to cite your sources. It's obvious you're getting your conclusions from data. You use the words "in practice". I agree with you on how the data plays out.

>It's important to do this because approximately all AGI doom on the internet comes from Big Yud, an internet cult founder who thinks you can predict the future by thinking about it really hard and doing probability theory in your head without needing to check any assumptions. Which is why he thinks AGI is going to enslave him, because it's on a computer so it can do math exponentially faster, never mind that it can't do real world experiments to test anything.

No it's not. AI doom saying comes from everywhere. See: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qpoRO378qRY (the godfather of modern AI, is concerned about doom). Either way, you shouldn't counter something with extremities that are simply opposite in nature. You should counter something you disagree with, with actual truth, Even if that truth doesn't fully dismiss the idea and calls only for naunce.

Herval_freire··on Generative AI set to affect 300M jobs across major economies
>If the AI "takes over", as in it's a fully sentient agent, then claiming humans will be unemployed isn't technological unemployment but rather is the lump of labor fallacy

This claim was never made. The only claim I made is that you can't claim AI increases jobs. My opinion of it is that the situation is so unpredictable that people should prepare for both scenarios.

>That's because the AIs are just more people.

And unconvincing. If agi replaces labor it will be constructed with a singular incentive to serve it's master as the primary directive. It can be a an economy of slave labor replacing us. The situation is too untenable to just rely on your own hypothetical. Other scenarios like mine must be considered.

>which doesn't substitute for labor and in practice increases employment by making labor more productive.

Again over reliance on data. Your argument doesn't counter my claim. It's just regurgitation your original claim.

>Remember, the real world actually exists, and logic problems don't, which means logic problems are free to be incorrect because nothing is requiring them to exist in possible worlds.

So according to that logic we should make millions of atomic weapons and distribute it for free to everyone? No.

Data only tells a story for specific scenarios and can function as a rough predictor for hypothetical scenarios.

To refine predictions of hypothetical scenarios you need data AND logic. Blind application of data to all hypothetical scenarios is wrong.

Remember the real world only exists in the past. A huge portion of the world is an unrealized quantum uncertainty in the future. Navigating the future involves using data from the past as well as logic.

Your argument suffers mostly from being too specific. It doesn't address the fuzziness of the future and the fuzziness of the evidence/logic. You anticipate one thing playing out and you plan for that but realistically a good prediction and plan is one involving a multitude of likely scenarios.

Herval_freire··on Generative AI set to affect 300M jobs across major economies
>Automation increases employment. Technological unemployment is a myth.

This is not true. It is historically true but every iteration of new technology changes society differently.

You can't blindly rely on historical data you need to use common sense and logic as well. Historical data says nuclear bombs killed less people then cars. Therefore cars are more deadly then nuclear bombs.

Does that work? No. It obviously doesn't. Just like you can't say that AI will cause a rise in employment. You're ignoring the common sense scenario. Can you even work out exactly what people will be employed as once AI takes over? Likely you don't, you're just being impractically data driven.

Herval_freire··on Generative AI set to affect 300M jobs across major economies
Yeah. It really depends whether the technology has the capability to replace devs.
Herval_freire··on Generative AI set to affect 300M jobs across major economies
There's no raw data on ubi in an largely automated economy.

It's too radical of a change to know how well it would work. Communism, in theory, worked as well too but in practice there were unanticipated side effects.

Herval_freire··on Generative AI set to affect 300M jobs across major economies
It's a snake eating its own tail situation.

Corpos need a wealthy consumer base in order to sell things and remain profitable. But to do that they have to collectively pay laborers higher wages because laborers are basically the consumer.

An individual corporation lowering labor costs in an economy of high wages benefits with greater profits so this strategy is logical. But if corporations act on this collectively they damage themselves. Most corporations, however are built upon short term gains. So they are unlikely to have the foresight to act wisely. It's the tragedy of the commons.

The tragedy is this, when a corporation hires AI and lowers labor costs he is acting rationally according to a cost benefit analysis. But this logic applied collectively becomes suicidal. It is ultimately rational and logical action that damages us. That it the tragedy.

Best solution I've heard of is ubi. But I'm not sure how it will play out in practice. I think government job creation might be better.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →