HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

IAmBroom

2,759 karma · joined March 3, 2025

submissionscomments
IAmBroom··on Wealth Inequality in America drawn to scale
Disclosure: I work for a fully employee-owned company.

Frankly, I can't think of a fairer way for a company to be guided. If we choose, we can vote to hire (shudder) Elon Musk to run our company - or someone actually competent and trustworthy, from outside the employee pool.

By our charter, no one may own more than 1% of our total stock. Our collective decisions - effectively democratic representation, like the US - help decide our success. Demogoguery is almost impossible (unlike the US). Every worker is vested to some degree in our success, thanks to stock gift policies (and of course we can choose to buy more stock than that low level).

IAmBroom··on Wealth Inequality in America drawn to scale
The person you are replying to exempted 401ks - which no one is suggesting taxing, anyway, and it would be 100% politically impossible.

They're still wrong, but your argument is a non-sequitur.

IAmBroom··on Wealth Inequality in America drawn to scale
Antibiotics don't cure cancer. That doesn't mean we shouldn't administer them where they are effective.

Also, you are strongly implying the USSR taxed the wealthy disproportionately. They did not, so your entire argument is silly.

IAmBroom··on Wealth Inequality in America drawn to scale
Reality doesn't follow the promises of Trickle Down - and especially not your bizarre variation.

Most jobs in the US are from small businesses. That means billionaires create fewer jobs than Mom & Pop owners (even owners who may be able to afford really nice cars and houses).

Go back to school.

IAmBroom··on Wealth Inequality in America drawn to scale
Your hypothetical "but if unicorns were real, would they win the Derby?" is a distraction.
IAmBroom··on Wealth Inequality in America drawn to scale
So now you are slut-shaming as an economic policy?
IAmBroom··on Evidence of a spying operation by ICE against left-wing social movements
Laws aren't moral. These laws are bad, and shouldn't be enforced. They should be changed, but we don't have the political will to do so, so "rounding up all the brown people and shipping them to Mexico" is not the second-best option.
IAmBroom··on Evidence of a spying operation by ICE against left-wing social movements
Friction of paperwork. Not saying it's right, but it's a reason.

Also, you are shifting the blame for immigrants getting arrested to the owners. That means the employees are actually blameless: they are caught between seldom-enforced laws and a need to thrive and feed their families.

IAmBroom··on ICE Is Running One of the Largest Anti-Left Surveillance Ops in US History
In a functioning, pro-democracy country: yes.
IAmBroom··on Three new discoveries in mathematics, computer science, and physics
I don't think study of fundamental particles is hamstrung by physical research. Higgs bosons were theorized long before they could be verified (very recently) to exist. Hawking Radiation has not yet been observed.

Testable, purely theoretical hypotheses are partly how the field advances. Proof is often quite difficult & expensive.

IAmBroom··on A Man from the Future: Why Johnny Can't Stop Abstracting
"The LM style" is nothing more than an amalgam of pre-existing human writing style components.

It's like complaining that humans have begun writing in the same language as Claude's English output.

IAmBroom··on A Man from the Future: Why Johnny Can't Stop Abstracting
A former optical engineering prof was the first person to build a raytracer on a computer (using a rudimentary spreadsheet, probably Lotus 123). To minimize memory usage, he rewrote the Zernike polynomials as [0:N-1] from the traditional [1:N] form.

Still today, you have to a priori know which system is being used to know what Z(2) refers to, because of his influence. And it was a trivial raytracer - but not compared to cosine lookup tables.

IAmBroom··on Just imagining a workout can make you stronger (2016)
Half of us were right.
IAmBroom··on A Man from the Future: Why Johnny Can't Stop Abstracting
I myself lean more to Jaguar-Paw's Wager...

I can't prove that Huitzilopochtli doesn't exist, so I occasionally eat a hobo's still-beating heart, just in case.

IAmBroom··on Wikipedia's Cleanup of AI-Generated Content
They already have that. Look around in this thread.
IAmBroom··on Should Police Wipe a Criminal's Cellphone Before Returning It?–U.S. vs. Stathas
Better analogy: if you smuggle cocaine by plane, you don't get the plane back after they remove all the drugs.
IAmBroom··on Wikipedia's Cleanup of AI-Generated Content
No, there aren't. Ring shanks have ridges, not threads.
IAmBroom··on Solar power is becoming bigger than nuclear
Your first paragraph is nothing but an ad hominem. You lost all credibility there.
IAmBroom··on Three new discoveries in mathematics, computer science, and physics
An interesting take. I would nuance it a bit:

Your "reductionist sciences" I would instead phrase as "exact sciences", where the input variations are known (even the most generous particle theory only has a 'few' fundamental particle types, such as up-quarks and photons) and their interactions are either well-known (Fermi Principle is apparently inviolable), or reasonably expected to be known someday (exact relationship of gravitons, IF they exist, with other particles).

The "inexact sciences" use either truly infinite, or practically uncountable, inputs - such as the possible shapes of a single protein, which affects the outputs.

You could criticize this grouping by saying the number of particles in the Universe is practically uncountable, but sufficiently accurate statistical models can be built (a galaxy exerts <this much> gravitational force). We can't do the same with the "inexact sciences": we can't predict how a mole of protein will react with a mole of enzymes, without physical testing. OK, maybe for some very low levels of complication this could be reliably predicted, but in general it may be a !P problem.

IAmBroom··on Three new discoveries in mathematics, computer science, and physics
> I would trade (as if I have any say lol) every single breakthrough they have made in math/CS for _any_ good progress towards a universal cancer cure (very theoretical, I know).

> I'm kinda hoping they are investing just as much into that type of research.

The money would be better spent trying to breed a flying unicorn, because that's remotely possible.

"Cancer" is not "a" disease. It's a symptomatic description: cells in your body multiplying beyond a limit that is healthy for you.

What you are asking for would be like asking for a universal cure for headaches. What if your headache is caused by a tumor? Or a nailgun injury? Or psychotic hallucination?

IAmBroom··on Three new discoveries in mathematics, computer science, and physics
> the NS problem is not physics and not predictive, it happens at scales smaller than molecules, so it doesn't occur in real fluids

1. How is it not physics? It's goal (as laymen me crudely understands it) is to determine if a singularity could be physically realized in a perfect liquid.

2. Why does it happen at scales smaller than molecules? Unless it requires properties that a liquid made of particles sized like real atoms cannot achieve, I don't understand.

TY.

IAmBroom··on Three new discoveries in mathematics, computer science, and physics
I disagree completely. Hawking Radiation has never been proven to exist, which is why Stephen did not earn a Nobel for it.

Merely providing a mathematical possible solution that satisfies all known behaviors would be a tremendous step forward.

We don't actually "know" anything about EM, by example, except how to describe its behaviors in all physically observable instances. Radios work reliably with current. Supernovae behave comprehensibly. Photons carry predictable energies. However, long before we knew there were supernovae, or even photons, Maxwell said pretty much all we know about EM behavior.

IAmBroom··on Three new discoveries in mathematics, computer science, and physics
It was not a formal statement.
IAmBroom··on Three new discoveries in mathematics, computer science, and physics
Your comment made me think of Daffy Duck numbering his feathers, in case they ever got blown off his body by explosion.

Maybe Wolverine should consider naming his cells...?

IAmBroom··on How to grow a cacao tree at home (2024)
> I bet that it tastes 1000 times better than the processed cacao.

That's like assuming pure hydrogen tastes better than the oxidized stuff in water.

IAmBroom··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
> In bloated organizations, there is a lot of fat to cut.

A tautology, and therefore devoid of information.

If you had claimed "In very large organizations...", you might have been saying something.

IAmBroom··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
Management at a certain level speaks with the legally binding authority of the company. Management at any level carries some legal authority.

You can't say, "Well, we hired a new CEO, so all those old agreements are null and void."

IAmBroom··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
You literally said: "There has never been a time in last 40 years..."

So now you are claiming that AI has been causing tech layoffs for 40 years now?

IAmBroom··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
Either every doctor, nurse, firefighter, teacher, FBI agent, reverend, and social worker I know is wrong, or you are.
IAmBroom··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
With all due respect, you're a kid, and not very knowledgeable about the world of careers that differ from yours.

Now, go code something nice.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →