HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Infinity315

247 karma · joined March 26, 2022

submissionscomments
Infinity315··on US Reps Lead Democratic Resolution Opposing A.I. Bubble Bailout for Big Tech
Just because I am anti-propping-up-the-stock-market does not mean I am a communist. I am a liberal who believes in capital markets.

For the 10%, the stock market crashing just means cutting back on primarily discretionary spend - think no new car and maybe not buying the family new iPhones every year - they're not in any danger of going hungry, especially if they have any sense.

There are plenty of arguments to be made for infrastructure projects, for example, why not build out more power generation and transmission?

Infinity315··on US Reps Lead Democratic Resolution Opposing A.I. Bubble Bailout for Big Tech
Propping up the stock market to fuel consumer spending is extremely regressive. The top 10-20% make up ~50% of consumer spending. [1] Effectively you're giving the wealthy a risk-free bet with huge payoff if it succeeds. If that bet succeeds it consequentially means a ton of job displacement which will mostly affect the other 90%.

1. https://www.wsj.com/economy/consumers/us-economy-strength-ri...

Infinity315··on What Adobe v ArtCraft teaches us
Yea, the article is littered with Claudisms. You can see the: "it's not this, it's that."
Infinity315··on GPT 6.1 Sol: Near-Astra intelligence for a fifth of the price
I'm not an OpenAI simp, but how anyone can have any opinion on the performance of these models in less than a day - let alone a few hours - is beyond me.
Infinity315··on Discovering Cryptographic Weaknesses with Claude
Keep in mind for Anthropic the goal for them isn't necessarily to solve a problem but to demonstrate/measure the innate capabilities of their model. Many results would be a lot less interesting/impressive for an LLM to accomplish if researchers smuggled in key premises or ideas within their prompt.
Infinity315··on Claude Opus 5
This is useful to me since I delegate most coding tasks to Opus and use Fable for planning.
Infinity315··on Datacenters in space aren't going to work
So many ideas involving AI just seems to be built off of sci-fi (not in a good way), including this one. Like sci-fi, there are little practical considerations made.
Infinity315··on Reasoning models reason well, until they don't
What? Fundamentally, information can only be so dense. Current models may be inefficient w.r.t. information density, however, there is a lower bound of compute required. As a pathological example, we shouldn't expect a megabyte worth of parameters to be able to encode the entirety of Wikipedia.
Infinity315··on This blog is running on a recycled Google Pixel 5 (2024)
I thought recycle was the breaking down of the device into its constituents (mostly to recover precious metals or other base materials). In contrast, reuse is where the device is kept mostly intact and used for other purposes such as this. Just breaking things down requires considerable amounts of energy through the sheer logistics of it relative to just reusing it.
Infinity315··on A.I. researchers are negotiating $250M pay packages
It might make more sense to think of in terms of expected value. Whilst the probability may be low, the payoff is probably many times the $250M if their startup becomes successful.
Infinity315··on What is the richest country in 2025?
That's measuring desirability--or at least immediate desirability, which is sometimes related but distinct from wealth.

It also quickly becomes meaningless as people risking life and limb tend to flee to the nearest stable country. For example, Syrian refugees for the most part tended to stay close to their home country with the majority fleeing to nearby Turkey, Lebanon, Jordan, and Iraq--or, moving elsewhere within Syria.

Measuring wealth of a country by measuring how many refugees it takes in is like projecting future revenue/success of a convenience store by measuring how many people come into the store during an active-shooter situation.

Going by your metric, it would suggest that a Pole is wealthier than a Brit because Poland has nearly 1 million Ukrainian refugees to the UK's .25 mil.

Infinity315··on The $25k car is going extinct?
A similar argument could be made for any safety feature that adds cost to vehicles--literally, all of them. If a death is preventable and adds on a relatively inconsequential amount to the cost of a vehicle, then it is the morally correct choice optimize for safety.
Infinity315··on Chatbots are replacing Google's search, devastating traffic for some publishers
Can you answer the question?
Infinity315··on Chatbots are replacing Google's search, devastating traffic for some publishers
How do you define what is needed? The vast majority of reporting does not affect one's own behaviour at all. For example, consider the Snowden leaks, I guarantee you the vast majority of people did not even attempt to modify their own behaviour at all in light of this new information--despite having read or heard about it.

I'd argue that this reporting was still needed, despite it having very little material impact on one's life.

Infinity315··on Chatbots are replacing Google's search, devastating traffic for some publishers
We still need people on the ground reporting on these things. AI can't (yet) have connections and conversations with relevant parties. Many interviews would not be possible without a reporter developing a rapport with the interviewee beforehand.
Infinity315··on Low-background Steel: content without AI contamination
Just ask any person who works in teaching or any of the numerous faulty AI detectors (they're all faulty).

Any current technology which can used to accurately detect pre-AI content would necessarily imply that that same technology could be used to train an AI to generate content that could skirt by the AI detector. Sure, there is going to be a lag time, but eventually we will run out of non-AI content.

Infinity315··on Circuit breaker triggered in Japan for stock futures trading
Then the solution is targetted tariffs such as the ones they placed on BYD, not across the board tariffs.
Infinity315··on Circuit breaker triggered in Japan for stock futures trading
For many people, sure. I can always find exceptions to the rule. I am talking statistically. Fact of the matter is, the bottom 20% QoL has improved significantly, correct?
Infinity315··on Circuit breaker triggered in Japan for stock futures trading
> That short sighted western leadership were so eager to ship off manufacturing jobs to China has been a disaster for the west.

In what way are you quantifying this? Would you agree that the quality of life has improved significantly compared to the 1980s or whatever period you want to compare to?

Infinity315··on Circuit breaker triggered in Japan for stock futures trading
The types of manufacturing jobs which would be a step up would be high-tech and high gross-margins manufacturing (which we already do), not whatever crap China is producing. If you want the quality of life of a Chinese manufacturing worker - which is still much worse than that of a retail worker in America - sure. There is no basis in reality that the kind of jobs Chinese manufacturers would yield a higher quality of life for a blue collar worker.

Furthermore, those kinds of jobs are not long for this world. They're inevitably going to be automated away and the replacement jobs robotics maintainers are not ever going to be in numbers great enough to replace those manufacturing jobs. It's beyond stupid especially when you consider that the labor market was already incredibly strong at ~5% unemployment.

Infinity315··on Circuit breaker triggered in Japan for stock futures trading
We do not want manufacturing jobs, they suck. America has an amazing thing going on where we can trade 1s and 0s in exchange for physical goods. We have an infinite renewable resource which costs nearly nothing to reproduce infinitely. We have a defacto monopoly on technology and digital services.

I understand the national security reasons for having a domestic commercial manufacturing base. However, there is ZERO economic reasons to bring back manufacturing jobs.

Infinity315··on Circuit breaker triggered in Japan for stock futures trading
For whatever reason, people did not believe Trump would be this crazy. In fact, people in the stock market still do not believe he is this crazy. If they did, the stock market would drop much lower. From what I've heard from people in finance, the bond market is indicating some economic growth this year. If this goes on, expect a financial crisis which rivals that of the Great Depression.

It's not a lack of foresight, it's just that they do not believe him or believe that someone will stop him. People have just misread Donald Trump and his intentions.

Infinity315··on Is there now a generation of users who never worked with files?
Yes, but the author (probably) implemented their save system where the client sends the entirety of the save data to the backend; meaning a lot of redundant information is sent.

Ideally, the client should only push changes to the backend and thus avoid the issue of sending redundant data entirely. This means re-implementing their saving solution, which is probably not trivial to do as you also have to deal with the issue of migrating existing save data to your new solution (which might mean some significant upfront costs).

The author didn't address this directly, but what they could do is just implement the autosave anyways and just deal with sending redundant data. But... this probably is quite expensive as the cost incurred per user is proportional to the size of the save data multiplied by the frequency of auto save.

Infinity315··on Pro bettors disguising themselves as gambling addicts
Stock options have legitimate uses. Like all tools, it can be misused.

Stock options can be used as a tool to hedge against risk.

Infinity315··on Ask HN: Why is ChatGPT so bad at electronics?
This is unsurprising since from what little I know about electronics, I know the ESP32 is pretty common. I know very little about electronics. So if I know it's common, it's for sure in the training data of ChatGPT.
Infinity315··on Learning to Reason with LLMs
No, this is just how Microsoft names things.
Infinity315··on When Heat Turns Deadly
It doesn't seem like the wet bulb model accounts for ratio of surface area and volume.

The instrument they use is the sling psychrometer, a long cylindrical tube [1]. If I had to hazard a guess, the ratio of surface area to volume is much higher for the bulb than it is a human.

Evaporative cooling is a function of surface area--more surface area => more cooling capacity. I'd be curious to see how accurate the model if the surface area to volume ratio were more human-scale.

1. https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/sling-psych...

Infinity315··on Inductive or deductive? Rethinking the fundamental reasoning abilities of LLMs
I think the results still tell us something.

Discrepancies in mathematical ability between the various bases would seem to suggest memorization as opposed to generalization.

Infinity315··on Inductive or deductive? Rethinking the fundamental reasoning abilities of LLMs
The term 'reason' is being overloaded here.

The type of 'reason' a cat uses is different from the 'reason' used in math

The information a cat uses is incomplete whereas the information used in math and logic is theoretically all accessible.

The reasoning a cat uses allows for inconsistencies with its model because of its use of incomplete information whereas no inconsistencies are permissible in math and logic.

Formally speaking, math uses deductive reasoning whereas the cat uses abductive reasoning.

Infinity315··on Looming Liability Machines (LLMs)
So at this point are you admitting fully that you have no evidence for your claim? Your entire bet is conjecture?

> That does not mean the hypothesis is true, it only means you haven't falsified it.

Correct. You can't prove a negative, you've only just figured this out? After I listed TWO simple examples that could be found in an introductory philosophy class?! In the Wikipedia article consisting of a couple of paragraphs I linked you?

PLEASE JUST READ. PLEASE JUST READ. PLEASE JUST READ. PLEASE JUST READ.

You can't prove negative statements. I want you to admit this so I know you understand, now repeat after me: "You can't prove negative statements."

I know this is likely wasted on you, but here goes:

You can't prove the hypothesis: "There does not exist an unobservable teapot in the orbit of Jupiter."

For the SAME reason I can't prove the hypothesis: "LLMs can never eventually be used for generating good incident reports."

For the SAME reason I can't prove the hypothesis: "God doesn't exist."

For the SAME reason I can't prove the hypothesis: "A unicorn does not exist at the center of the Earth."

I fully admit this in the comment you've supposedly read.

This is why the burden of proof lies on the person making the positive claim (this is you).

Page 1 of 4Next →