HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

JoelMarsh

528 karma · joined September 9, 2012

Born in Canada, lives in Sweden.

Co-founder of Teller Email Browser — www.tellerapp.com

Blog: www.thehipperelement.com

Author of "The Composite Persuasion".

submissionscomments
JoelMarsh··on Is Facebook “broken on purpose” to sell promoted posts?
A lot of social sites are "broken on purpose" to catalyze monetized features — if the product people are smart.

The problem with Facebook is that they changed an existing feature when people were closely watching it, and didn't offer any opportunities to go with it.

Generally speaking, it is a no-go to "force" people to use features. It just doesn't work, and it makes people resentful.

However, if you structure the features in such a way that it "motivates" users to pay for them, suddenly you get some action.

Facebook should have provided a "carrot" for users in the form of a highly-coveted free spot for posts that genuinely deserve attention. Nobody complains about being able to buy the top spot if you can also earn it for free.

That's what Dropbox does, for example. Buy storage or recruit friends to earn it. All love, no complaints, lots of action.

But Facebook didn't do that, so they get backlash instead. Even the big sites don't really know what they're doing sometimes.

And don't even get me started about how promoted content hurts the general idea of an Edge Rank-driven feed...

JoelMarsh··on Ideas have a 2 week shelf life
In psychology (or behavioral economics) you might hear people talking about "hyperbolic discounting", which is basically the fancy version of "something now is better than something later".

This can also have the effect of making your new idea seem better than doing the same thing next year.

This article is hyperbolic discounting in action, and it is irrational. He has actively changed his method so he gets to feel the rush more often, which also inherently maximizes his impulsiveness.

However, I don't think an article called "Be as impulsive as possible" would have the same ring to it.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperbolic_discounting

JoelMarsh··on Ask HN: What's your startup's analytics setup?
Don't pay for anything!

At least not now: While you may choose to put some money into a serious analytics package in the future (when you get millions of visitors per month and have specific measurement interests), there is absolutely no need to do that when you're small. It's just one more expense to think about.

If you don't know enough to choose one now (which is totally fine!) start with Google Analytics. It's free, it will do your sites, apps, and real-time stuff if you need it, your colleagues are likely to be familiar with it already, and it can cover A/B testing relatively easily.

When you find yourself saying things like "I wish Google Analytics had XYZ feature" or "GA isn't compatible with ABC thing we love" then you'll have a checklist for finding something more appropriate to your needs.

Otherwise, use the tools that come for free with services like Facebook and MailChimp! There are plenty of numbers in those while you're small.

Truly integrating multiple analytics package is — in my opinion — a solid opportunity for a start-up in itself, so if you're looking for a the one-stop-shop you probably won't find it. If you do, let us know! :)

JoelMarsh··on How we designed our logo for $30
Senior designer here...

There is an old adage among designers, which couldn't be more appropriate for this post: "work for free or charge full price; never work for cheap."

Same goes for clients. Get it free or pay full price. Everything else is a rip-off for someone. Or everyone.

As a "we-can-barely-afford-to-keep-the-lights-on" start-up, a logo is the least of your worries. For the sake of avoiding any more "design is only worth $30" posts, follow these steps to create the Minimum Viable Product version of your brand:

1) Pick a font that is easy to read, but has a bit of character — just a bit! Type your company's name in it. That's your logo. Facebook's logo, for example, is a font called Klavika, slightly modified. www.myfonts.com is a good start.

2) Pick any color you like.

3) Pick a second version of that color (lighter, darker, richer, paler, whatever).

4) Use #2 for everything that is important.

5) Use #3 when you need to add some definition to your look & feel.

6) Get back to work. Come back when you can afford to do this properly.

JoelMarsh··on The best interface is no interface
Amazing article. BUT...there are interfaces in all of the simple versions of the examples.

Key + keyhole = interface.

A keyhole that "knows" when the correct key is close = better interface.

Wallet + Money + cashier + cash register = interface.

If you could do NFC without an app & without a cashier, that would be even better.

There is no such thing as "no interface" if something is being accomplished.

Rock + coconut = interface.

Hand + mouse = interface.

Your eyes + my words = interface.

JoelMarsh··on How we increased landing page conversion from 5% to 55%
I find a couple of the conclusions of this article very misleading. A couple of the lesson are great, but I feel the need to point out a few conclusions that are not quite spot-on:

1. Random photos are better than screenshots

Everything is better than straight screenshots. You didn't show what you were using before, but at a dismal 5% conversion I am guessing it was straight screenshots that weren't "posed" on a device or anything? Photos that have relevant content and even a minor emotional effect will say more than your screenshots ever will. I don't think I would call a football and baseball image "random" on a sports site, though. They are more relevant to a sports fan than a screenshot.

2. Large Background Photos Convert Really Well

That is not universally true. The two screenshots you have provided demonstrate the effect of focus in a design, not the effect of background images. You have used a background that is not only relevant, but is high-contrast colors and blurred, which creates a "foreground" out of your form. That will make the user's eyes go directly to the form rather than getting lost in your boring headlines, etc.

3. Inciting curiosity works better than clarity

It's interesting that you interpreted this as "curiosity" rather than benefits vs. features. Your original headline was a classic mistake. "A social network for sports fans" is a useless statement. No benefit, no motivation, no reason to click. "Follow sports together" is inherently more appealing because it describes the benefit of the service and has a social motivation built in. THAT is what you have done. Curiosity is not relevant.

4. Focus on the value proposition for brand new users, not advanced users

Duh. I don't want to be disrespectful, but this is a pure numbers rationale. In any market there will always be a small minority of advanced users compared to the vast majority of basic users. This will be true for every service, ever, unless the only people that could possibly understand the offer are advanced users.

5. Allowing users to sign up with their email increases FB/Twitter sign-ups

This was a good one. It is usually less effective to give people an ultimatum (register or leave) than to give them options to compare (would you rather register with FB or email?). Users will focus on the choice rather than the "yes or no" if you give them useful options to choose from. I once read an example test where more people were willing to pay for an a set of partially broken dishes if they were compared to an incomplete set than if they were sold alone. Same principle.

6. Figure out and optimize for the target demographics that convert the best

In the age of analytics, it is futile to define target audiences before statistics are available. It is much better to do as you have done: launch it and let your target audience identify itself. Good lesson.

JoelMarsh··on The Mail Pilot Public Beta
Upvoted. Sorry to hear about your buyer's remorse, but thanks for paying it and posting your thoughts. Anything more specific? Likes and dislikes?
JoelMarsh··on Mail Pilot announces public beta
I do, too.

Unfortunately, the thing I am usually supposed "to do" with an email is reply to it, in which case, what I actually need is a better way to keep track of my emails overall, and a faster, simpler way to be a part of the conversation. A literal "to do list" solution seems like it would simplify manual sorting, which is treating the symptom, not the cause.

Or maybe that's just me.

JoelMarsh··on Why I'm done with Scrum
Amazing. I'm glad I asked. Thanks!
JoelMarsh··on Why I'm done with Scrum
There seems to be some very scrum-savvy people here. I have used it many times, but I am interested in your thoughts about how designers typically work within that framework. In my experience design and scrum don't play very nicely together. Thoughts?
JoelMarsh··on Black Swan Farming
Great essay. Enlightening, actually. A few somewhat provocative questions:

If you could theoretically "randomize" start up ideas, founders, business models, and every other primary ingredient in current "start-up theory", like a giant multivariate test... would we not see similar results to now?

Or similarly, if you closed your eyes and invested "blindly" how would you expect your results to differ (ROI-wise)?

It seems like investing results more closely resemble a lottery than a predictive model, based on your description.

Sort of a scary thought: what if current investment criteria (and therefore start-up goals) are largely irrelevant?

For example, IQ is distributed in the same way as winners and losers in start-ups. What if that is a key factor,(purely hypothetically, of course)?

In theory, shouldn't "good criteria" for investing generate progressively better results within smaller and smaller samples?

JoelMarsh··on Tray.io - powerful email assistant
I can't decide whether to focus on the interesting aspects/potential of your tool, or the fact that you circumvented the concern I presented, but thanks for the answer nonetheless.

The ease of this tool is inversely related to the need for it. i.e. — the more complex/high volume your inbox, the more you suffer while trying to set it up.

Maybe it would be worth implementing some "starter rules" or a "wizard" that allows the first-timer to leverage many basic rules at once, immediately.

It's the Pinterest approach, if you will. :) "Pick 5 things you like" and then they auto-follow 50 people based on your choices. Voilá! Good first experience.

Remember that features ≠ power ≠ satisfaction.

I apologize for the unsolicited suggestions; you hit my area of interest right in the middle. ;) Good luck with everything and congrats on getting to the alpha in the first place!

JoelMarsh··on Amazon caves in, will remove ads from Kindle Fire for $15 fee
For an individual person to generate 15 dollars of ad revenue based on clicks and impressions, they would have to be pretty active, ad-wise. I think, on average across a whole system of advertising, Amazon will probably gain monetarily, not to mention the user satisfaction.

The target customer for a product like that has a genuine hate on for those ads... if it's worth it to them, it's worth it to Amazon, in my opinion.

JoelMarsh··on Tray.io - powerful email assistant
What is the typical number of rules someone has to write if they get, say, 100 emails per day from any combination of 1000 contacts?

If you have 100 common contacts (as opposed to the other 900 who email once and a while) and I need, say, a rule or two for each to cover the basics... and a rule or two to cover groups of people (because one-to-one emails are the exception in business not the rule)... isn't that hundreds and hundreds of rules?

Not having seen the alpha, that feels like an insurmountable first threshold, UX-wise.

Also, just out of curiosity, other than general ease-of-use (which seems much nicer in your 3 examples), how is this better than typical filters (which I don't use)?

← PreviousPage 3 of 3