HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

JohnFen

36,061 karma · joined December 10, 2018

submissionscomments
JohnFen··on "I'm Embarrassed on Behalf of the Tech Industry"
If you're in the US, you can skip the registration. The warranty applies even if you don't register it. They try to convince you to "register" so they can fill out their marketing database.
JohnFen··on "I'm Embarrassed on Behalf of the Tech Industry"
They could just print out their own menus instead of having them professionally printed. Then they can cheaply change the menus any time they like.

I've seen a number of restaurants (including high-end ones) do this, and it's fine. Far superior to a QR code.

JohnFen··on Hope You Like RCS
You don't have to use Google Messages. There are several other options available. I use and like Textra, but don't know if it's the best option.
JohnFen··on Would you quit sleeping if you could?
For my entire life, I've wished that sleeping and eating were optional recreational activities.
JohnFen··on Ask HN: How would you feel if we nationalized Google?
> I always find it funny how people insist Google is getting worse despite no evidence that this is the case.

I suspect that, like me, people claiming Google has become worse have the only evidence that really counts: their own personal experience.

JohnFen··on Ask HN: How would you feel if we nationalized Google?
I think that huge corporations such as Google are effectively an integral part of the US government at this point anyway.
JohnFen··on AI Hasn't Replaced Interpreters But It Has Degraded Their Working Conditions
This is my real employment-related genAI fear. Not that there will be no jobs, but that the jobs are going to suck a lot more.
JohnFen··on Ask HN: How would you feel if we nationalized Google?
I'd be opposed to nationalizing Google. There are way too many downsides.

I think, if we're going to be heavy-hitting about this, the more proper thing to do is to force Google to split their search off as a separate, independent company that has additional business requirements imposed on it to rectify the issues.

But I really think that, if search is the worry, the market will eventually achieve its own kind of balance and you'll find an acceptable alternative to Google's that restores much of what has been lost. For me, that's already the case.

JohnFen··on Tell HN: GitHub refuses to remove cracked copies of my software after a month
You should discuss this with an attorney that is experienced with IP law to see what your options really are. IP law is very complex and sometimes very surprising. You need expert legal advice, not advice from the HN crowd.

As an aside, I thought that "cracked" software meant software that has had the copy protection or other access control bypassed or removed, not the alteration of the software functionality itself. If your software was actually cracked then you may have some fairly heavy law in your favor. For better or worse, bypassing access controls (even weak or simple access controls) gets special legal attention.

JohnFen··on Software developers are not okay
> AI doesn't care how we feel. Neither do table saws. Both are tools that exist, and we have the option to use them or not.

Of course. That you felt this was necessary to say makes me worry that I've misunderstood your point. I thought you were saying, basically, "suck it up, buttercup". That a dev should be perfectly happy using the new tools because they don't really change the goal. Specifically this line:

> Well, yes, it has, and the question is not whether you are okay with it or not, but, rather, how are you going to adapt to the enviroment you inhabit that just changed ?

My response is that the question absolutely is whether you are OK with it or not. The question of adaptation only becomes relevant once you've decided that you are (or that you are willing to have faith that you will be).

> If you just enjoy the sheer problem solving dimension of software development, and never intend to ship or use anything, and want to do pure research, go ahead.

That's not at all what I was saying. What I was saying is that these things are multidimensional, and to boil them down to just one thing (be it shipping or anything else) oversimplifies and thus distorts the view of developer satisfaction, and to treat it as unidimensional will make it very hard to understand or address any issue of dissatisfaction.

One of the "goals" of being a dev, be it individual or on a team, is indeed to ship a good solution. But that's very far from the only legitimate goal.

JohnFen··on What Would You Do If Your Employer Could Destroy the World?
If my employer was making something that they believed had more than an infinitesimal chance of destroying the world, but they continued working on it anyway, I'd consider them basically evil and would get out as fast as I could.
JohnFen··on Software developers are not okay
> The goal for developers, either alone or in teams, is the same as it ever was ... ship a useful product.

I think this is an oversimplification. It's a variation of the response to the complaint that "devs are just being turned into managers now" with "but they're still making things, and isn't doing that why they became devs?"

I'd argue that, in this scenario, they're not. If I make a product specification and hand that off to another person to make something to that specification, I haven't made that thing, the other person has.

To reduce the job to just shipping things seems like an oversimplification to me because there's a reason why devs chose software engineering as the means of doing that. Why not make something else in a different field entirely? There has to be something about creating software that fulfills needs beyond just shipping.

It's a bit like saying the purpose of company is to generate profit. That's true, but it's so much of an oversimplification as to be misleading. If the point is just profit, why does the company make whatever it is they make, rather than make the thing that is the easiest to maximize profit doing?

It's because there is a lot more to it than just that. Oversimplification distorts reality and makes it difficult to really understand the situation.

> the question is not whether you are okay with it or not, but, rather, how are you going to adapt to the enviroment you inhabit that just changed ?

For a whole lot of people, the question really is whether or not they're OK with it. If they can't be OK with it, then there's no point in adapting to the new environment. It will make them unhappy. Better to escape and find something else that has a chance of being fulfilling.

That said, we're not (yet, anyway) actually in a world where all software development involves outsourcing to genAI. A huge number of software development positions have yet to be changed at all. They aren't really in the silicon valley/forest circles, but they do exist.

JohnFen··on Altman: `World should accept some bad things happening' for the benefits of AI
> Most people in all human history owned the land they farmed.

I would argue this isn't actually true, though. Agriculture itself is a relatively recent thing in the human timeline, and centralized government developed simultaneously with it. Many argue that agriculture actually led to centralized government because it necessitated the concept of owning land, which requires some sort of centralized authority.

For a lot longer than that, nobody really owned the land and the economic systems were much more like socialism (in the economic sense, where the means of production is not owned privately) than capitalism.

JohnFen··on The Old Personal Web Is Going Quiet
> If you’ve let a personal site lapse, or come close, I’d like to hear why.

Not lapsed, exactly, but I took mine off the open web because of genAI crawlers. I don't want to contribute to training, and I couldn't find any reliable way to keep them out, so I didn't really have any other option.

JohnFen··on People who refuse to let their gadgets die
Modern gadgets tend to be rather inferior to older gadgets (and greatly inferior if you value privacy and data security). Keeping the old ones going for as long as possible is a rational thing to do.
JohnFen··on "I'm Embarrassed on Behalf of the Tech Industry"
In hindsight, the horrible ribbon was really the first big sign that our industry had completely lost the plot with UI design.
JohnFen··on "I'm Embarrassed on Behalf of the Tech Industry"
> I don't want to scan a QR code and scroll a menu on my phone

I've reached the point where I just refuse to do it. If the restaurant isn't willing to give me a menu, then I leave and don't return. There are other restaurants.

JohnFen··on "I'm Embarrassed on Behalf of the Tech Industry"
> it solves nothing for end users

It's not just that it solves nothing for end users. That would be tolerable. It's that it actively makes things worse for users.

JohnFen··on Altman: The world should accept some bad things happening for the benefits of AI
Money is a helluva drug.
JohnFen··on Anthropic wants your thoughts on AI
I guarantee that Anthropic doesn't want my thoughts on genAI.
JohnFen··on Are any of your neighbouring countries a current enemy?
I live in the US. As near as I can tell, my government considers all of our neighbors to be a current enemy.
JohnFen··on Calling AI 'other intelligence' better describes the advent of a new lifeform
But those weren't claims of fact, they were speculations of the future.
JohnFen··on Accept 'bad things' in return for benefits of AI, says Sam Altman
> Yes, there are people who shoot/stab/${kill_method} other people but they are prosecuted as criminals

Ideally, yes, but what is to be done when we're in the situation where people get to actively harm others, but are immune from consequences just because they're wealthy, powerful, and/or executives of corporations?

JohnFen··on Accept 'bad things' in return for benefits of AI, says Sam Altman
But not every technological advancement provided benefits that were in excess of the costs.
JohnFen··on Accept 'bad things' in return for benefits of AI, says Sam Altman
> They want power.

More money equals more power.

JohnFen··on Does Costco Cause Cancer?
I hate that phrase because correlation absolutely implies causation. That's the problem that deceives people.

I prefer "correlation does not mean causation" or just "correlation is not causation".

JohnFen··on Altman: `World should accept some bad things happening' for the benefits of AI
Capitalism is not defined by trade. Trade exists in all economic systems. Capitalism is defined by ownership of the means of production.
JohnFen··on Calling AI 'other intelligence' better describes the advent of a new lifeform
A new lifeform??

The claims just keep getting crazier (and more dangerous). This is an extraordinary claim. Where is the extraordinary evidence?

JohnFen··on Poll: What do you use personal AI bots for?
I don't. I haven't found a personal use for them that provides net positive value to me.
JohnFen··on Will America Spend 9% of Its GDP on AI? The Industry Is Counting on It
> So, hypothetically speaking, why would you hire an expensive plumber if you knew some random person wearing AR glasses and getting tips off an AI assistant was 1/3rd the price?

Because I'd trust the plumber so much more. Not just in terms of doing the job at hand, but also knowing that I have some sort of recourse if they were negligent.

I wouldn't trust a random person wearing AR goggles and using an AI assistant at all. I'd fix it myself long before I'd even entertain that idea.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →