HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

JohnPrine

84 karma · joined December 21, 2020

submissionscomments
JohnPrine··on Effective Altruism’s obsession with AI safety helps bury bad behavior
> AI doom cult seems to think the worst outcomes are near certainties without really backing that up

What are you basing this on? There have been tons of arguments written about why these worst outcomes are likely. Read Bostrom's Superintelligence for example, or Yudkowsky's Intelligence Explosion Microeconomics.

JohnPrine··on Effective Altruism’s obsession with AI safety helps bury bad behavior
Would you rather we wait until AIs are actually posing a threat for us to study ways to align them with human values? Tons of money already goes into fighting climate change and basically everyone on earth is aware of the threat it poses. The AI safety field is only about a decade old and is relatively unknown. Of course it makes sense to raise awareness there
JohnPrine··on Madison Square Garden Uses Facial Recognition to Ban Its Owner’s Enemies
that's a much harder problem to solve tho
JohnPrine··on FTX to file for U.S. bankruptcy, CEO resigns
Diminishing returns don't apply for SBF - his life's goal is to fund effective altruist charities, so each billion is as valuable as the last as long as there are good projects to fund.

I don't think people are comprehending how tragic this whole situation is (acknowledging that it's SBF's fault). This collapse put the brakes on a powerful force for good, and lives that would have been saved won't anymore.

JohnPrine··on TikTok videos leave teens thinking they have rare mental disorders (2021)
I think what you're saying is true and I appreciate it
JohnPrine··on Using GPT-3 to explain how code works
there is certainly loss in the compression of perception to language
JohnPrine··on France bans veggie ′steaks,′ ′sausages′ to describe vegetarian products
Excuse me, what?
JohnPrine··on France bans veggie ′steaks,′ ′sausages′ to describe vegetarian products
The dictionary describes the way words are used by people; it doesn't prescribe the way words must be used. If the way people use a word changes (e.g. if people start using the word "sausage" to also refer to these vegan products), the dictionary changes. You don't change the law to match the dictionary
JohnPrine··on Belief in AI sentience is becoming a problem
> The truth is, until we can define consciousness; we can't possibly reproduce it on a binary logic playback device (aka a "computer").

There's nothing stopping us from reproducing consciousness before we fully understand it. Evolution created consciousness via random search; I don't think you can argue that evolution "understands" the consciousness it created

JohnPrine··on Jupiter CEO Quits $68B Firm to Sit at the Beach and ‘Do Nothing’
I don't understand all of these abbreviations
JohnPrine··on DeepMind: A Generalist Agent
Agreed. People think of the best case scenario without seriously considering everything that can go wrong. If we stay on this path the most likely outcome is human extinction. Full stop
JohnPrine··on ‘Electric’ chopsticks that make food seem more salty
Japan has the developed world's highest life expectancies and yet the Japanese eat double the amount of recommended salt per day. To me that seems sort of inconsistent with salt being a great health risk
JohnPrine··on U.S. surgeons transplant pig heart into human patient
Yeah!
JohnPrine··on Ask HN: How do you have fun without alcohol?
weed
JohnPrine··on Ask HN: I’m New to Computer Science and Engineering. Any Advice?
A good way to do this is to become a teaching assistant in the classes you want to go more in-depth on
JohnPrine··on GPT-3 APIs are now in public beta
I strongly disagree with you. We have no idea how to align a superintelligence to act for the benefit of humanity. Your plan would only cause faster and faster advances in AI tech without corresponding advances in AI safety research which would be catastrophic
JohnPrine··on Microsoft and the Metaverse
Sooo many people already live a virtual life in a virtual world by using social media, netflix, youtube, etc for hours and hours every day. Imagine a VR platform where you could have a virtual living room and hang out with your friends while doing those same activities. Imagine the headset is so light as to be hardly noticeable and the resolution is indistinguishable from reality. You don't think people would want to use that?
JohnPrine··on Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because Facebook is boring
By this logic Facebook never would have gotten funded in the first place. What makes you so sure the metaverse concept will fail?
JohnPrine··on Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because Facebook is boring
Yeah, that money should go to the government instead! Because the government never wastes resources right?
JohnPrine··on Redditors are right about the unfairness of the market
If you granted me ownership of the account and then denied me access, I could take you to court. Stock ownership is a legal agreement. If the leadership of the corporation doesn't act in the shareholders' best interest, they'll be replaced with someone who does.

Stock markets have worked for 400 years. Don't you think that makes it less likely that they're ponzi schemes?

JohnPrine··on Redditors are right about the unfairness of the market
The difference is that these companies actually have real assets, and holding stock legally grants you fractional ownership over them. Your hypothetical is more like an Enron situation where shareholders are told that there are assets behind their stock that really don't exist. That's why the stock price plunged when the fraud was revealed, and why my net worth doesn't budge when you grant me the account.

As a thought experiment, do you think that your ownership of a company is also meaningless if there are only 2 shareholders? What about 3 shareholders? At what point does breaking a company up into fractional shares become a ponzi scheme?

JohnPrine··on Redditors are right about the unfairness of the market
This disregards the time value of money. If I'm 80 years old, $100,000 today will have more value to me right now than $1 million paid out over 30 years.
JohnPrine··on Redditors are right about the unfairness of the market
When you're confused that very few knowledgable people agree with your model, it's usually an indicator that your model could be wrong.
JohnPrine··on Redditors are right about the unfairness of the market
Can you read my comment here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28721310 and let me know if it clears up my explanation?
JohnPrine··on Redditors are right about the unfairness of the market
Stocks represent ownership in a company. Apple has $200 billion in cash currently. Owning a share of Apple quite literally means that you own a share of that $200 billion.

It's useful to think about this in terms of a company's tangible assets because it provides a lower bound on the price of a share (assuming the company has no debt). If the Apple share price ever dropped so low that the sum of all the shares was worth less than $200 billion, a savvy investor could just snap up all the shares and effectively purchase 200 billion dollars at a discount.

Any premium on the price of a share beyond the company's assets comes from either the dividends that you expect to be paid out as a result of owning that stock, or from an expectation that the company's assets will grow in the future (so that share will entitle you to part ownership of $300 billion instead of $200 billion, for example).

JohnPrine··on Redditors are right about the unfairness of the market
Can you read my comment here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28721310 and let me know if it makes sense to you?
JohnPrine··on Redditors are right about the unfairness of the market
I don't quite understand. Suppose a company has a bank account with $1000. I own shares equating to 25% of the company, worth $250. The company has a good quarter and the bank account grows to $2000, but it doesn't pay a dividend.

How should the growth of the bank account affect the price of my shares? Under the model of stock pricing you described, the price wouldn't increase and it would take a fool to buy them from me for more than $250. But the bank account of which I own 25% of the shares has doubled in value, so it wouldn't make sense to me that the share price wouldn't change.

JohnPrine··on Redditors are right about the unfairness of the market
They are accessible to a regular shareholder through the ability to sell the shares
JohnPrine··on The Road to Self-Reproducing Machines
My understanding is that von Neumann recognized that science would produce these types of weapons eventually, and so pushed hard to reach an equilibrium state of non-use of nuclear weapons under Mutually Assured Destruction (the dude did found modern game theory). So I think it's a bit disingenuous to say that he tried to start nuclear war.
JohnPrine··on Why is it so hard to be rational?
Sure. In the past, I've been a person with a strong desire to be right in every situation. If I thought I was right I would be very willing to stubbornly argue my point, without any consideration of the counterpoints that were presented to me. Rationality is in part about understanding that every piece of knowledge I have is probabilistic - that there's a chance that each belief I have is wrong, and that I need to be able to let go of a belief if I encounter enough counter-evidence. I'm sure you've met people who can't be swayed from a belief no matter what you tell them, and you know how difficult it can be to get along with those people. Internalizing the methods of rationality have helped me transform from one of those sorts of people to a more reasonable one whom people have a more pleasant time interacting with.

As a specific example, I made a comment to my roommate last winter about how I thought his girlfriend's hyper caution around COVID was limiting my personal freedom. I realized that I had been crass and apologized to him, but he told his girlfriend anyways and it caused a great deal of tension between the three of us. My own girlfriend told me I should apologize to her. I believed I had nothing to apologize for since I hadn't said anything to her directly, I didn't believe my roommate should have repeated the comment to her in the first place, and I had apologized to him for it already. My girlfriend gave me reasons why an apology was in order, though, and I assigned a lot of weight to her reasoning since I know her to be a more sensitive and emotionally intelligent person than myself. I was able to let go of the belief in my own righteousness and write a heartfelt apology which did wonderfully to mend the relationship.

A previous version of me would have clung to the belief that I was in the right, and either not apologize or write a half-assed apology that would do nothing to fix the situation. The current version of me which strives to be rational was aware of my own biases, recognized that my internal map may not match the territory, and was willing to update based on the evidence from my girlfriend's greater authority on emotional matters.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →