HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Laaw

379 karma · joined August 6, 2015

submissionscomments
Laaw··on Please scan my towel
How? One of the search terms could easily be topic...
Laaw··on The connection between modern slavery and ecological disaster
I wonder why it is we assume it's even possible to successfully maximize happiness on a global scale.

Has there ever been a time in human history where slavery wasn't the fundamental backbone of a prosperous society?

Laaw··on My next chapter
What devastation? 4chan is absolutely not a "toxic garbage fire of an internet community", and it's not even his concept or idea. He didn't "create" anything in that sense.

He also didn't, "walk away when it became too toxic for anyone to deal with." That sentence is literally too hard to parse, given what's publicly available information about Moot and 4chan.

Laaw··on Slack will soon start testing voice and video chat
Slack has (had) some very serious security problems.

So does Skype though, so whatever.

Laaw··on Israeli soldiers who relied on Waze blundered into a deadly firefight
Wait, are there military "Waze" deployments? That'd probably be pretty useful, yes? In addition to the routing information, a military could have an "enterprise" Waze that contained a bunch of intel marked on a map based on reports from the field.
Laaw··on Google says self-driving car hits municipal bus in minor crash
Yeah, I kind of do. This is not a privacy issue, you're on the road and behaving in a way that's directly endangering me.

You're out in public, operating heavy machinery. Better enforcement of traffic laws would save lives [citation needed].

Laaw··on Wild gorillas compose songs that they hum during meals
"Is it so implausible" isn't really the bar we're trying to reach, though.
Laaw··on Obama Administration Set to Expand Sharing of Data That N.S.A. Intercepts
> They may not "have everyone's data", but they have data on most Americans in one form or another

Where did you hear that? It's not in anything that's been leaked, and the NSA surely didn't say it, so I'm curious where you got that information.

To be fair, I'm assuming you're talking about data collected clandestinely, not stuff like tax information or social security number (obviously the government has that data). If you're just talking about the data that gets generated as part of being a citizen of the US, then yes, the NSA, FBI, IRS, etc. probably does have that information.

Laaw··on Obama Administration Set to Expand Sharing of Data That N.S.A. Intercepts
Folks here do, read the other comments. They think the NSA could give the FBI the data, but just won't.
Laaw··on Obama Administration Set to Expand Sharing of Data That N.S.A. Intercepts
This just isn't true. You can't, on one hand, claim the NSA has everyone's data, and on the other hand claim Apple has a legitimate case against the FBI -- if the NSA had that data, they'd share it with the FBI, and Apple would be tilting at windmills.

Edit: A lot of speculation and guesses in the replies here. If anyone's got actual evidence that the NSA "has data on everyone" or "wouldn't share their intel with the FBI", please post it. Otherwise, why make the claim?

If you all really think the NSA can simply magic their way into an encrypted system, then why even bother? You're flying in the face of every security expert's opinion on the matter. No one with expertise in this area is going to agree that the NSA has data collection ongoing for every person in the US, that's patently absurd. The Snowden leaks showed us what they're capable of, and while it was substantial, it wasn't universal. Not by a long shot, and especially not after so many fixes were made as a result of those leaks.

Laaw··on Microsoft, Google, Facebook Back Apple in Blocked Phone Case
> The highest ranking official who understands this issue is Ted Lieu.

You mean the highest ranking official who agrees with us. It's easy to see how, if you trust the US judicial system, you'd be okay with this. If you think warrants are only given in valid and justified situations, this wouldn't bother you, because this'd only be used for "good".

We know better, but that's probably not the position the head of one of the branches of government (and a scholar of the highest law of the judicial branch, even) finds himself in. Obama probably very much trusts the US justice system.

Laaw··on Just Landed Is Shutting Down
I use FlightAware all the time, but didn't know they pull the data directly from the planes.

I'm guessing FlightAware is one half of the "duopoly" spoken about in the submission.

Edit:

Looks like the cost per 1k queries for flight arrival times is $7.90 USD, which is a Class 2 query @ $0.0079 USD per query at the highest tier [0], but it goes down with more queries. You actually also probably want to pull their "AirlineFlightSchedules" API data to pull initial schedules for the day, which is a Class 1 query @ $0.0120 [0].

How many flights globally, per day? ~100,000 [1]. Once you fall down into their tiered pricing, and use their "15 results per query" rule, it amounts to ~$80. Once there is flight information for each flight for the day, there will likely be periodic update times. There's a firehose feed, but they don't specify pricing, so I'm not sure what the cost is to provide live updates.

If we say 5 updates per flight (total guess), that becomes ~500,000 queries daily of Class 2 data. I'm confident there's a way to batch these, so this comes down to ~33,334 requests, which puts us at ~$181.34 in additional charges per day.

So our daily costs are now about ~$261.34, or ~$7,840.20 per month, assuming they're not pulling data on-demand. This changes somewhat significantly if an app (correctly IMO) only pulls data for flights it's asked about. You get to cut out the $80/day entirely, and only some portion of the $181.34 is actually paid each day. If you consider the ~28,500 domestic flights in the US [2], and if app users only search for half of those, costs drop to ~$162 per day, or $4,860 monthly (plus the unknown cost of the firehose).

So, because of the cost of the data alone, your app will have to pull in a bunch of users. Wait, how many? Let's figure that out, based on an estimation strategy I pulled off of Quora (so it might be wrong) [3]:

Each user checks their flight status 3 times, which takes them ~1 minute overall to read, so we get 2 impressions [3]. I don't really know what these other two things are, but I guess we'll next assume 100% fill rate and eCPM of $3. But that's just per flight. 694 million passengers took flights in the US this year [4], and while I know we're getting into some pretty speculative territory, that's at least 2 flights per person per year, not to mention all the other people who also check on flight statuses of their friends/family. I feel comfortable saying that each person would check this app at least 15 times a year (you'd use it if you had it), or 0.04 times a day, which would give 0.08 impressions per day.

Our calculation is now:

    (0.08n / 1000) * $3 * 1.0 = $0.0002n

    $0.0002n = $162

    n = 810,000
To cover costs for the data alone, you'd need 810,000 users. Even if each person used this app twice as often, you'd still need 405,000 users. That's completely untenable. I'm actually wondering if my math and assumptions are correct...

    [0] http://flightaware.com/commercial/flightxml/pricing_class.rvt
    [1] http://www.garfors.com/2014/06/100000-flights-day.html
    [2] http://sos.noaa.gov/Datasets/dataset.php?id=44
    [3] https://www.quora.com/How-much-ad-revenue-can-be-expected-per-100-000-downloaded-iPhone-iPad-apps
    [4] http://www.transtats.bts.gov/
Laaw··on Confirmed: CMU Attacked Tor, Was Subpoenaed by Feds
You're the second person to claim tautology, but you've both been wrong. "Reality works as I've described" is not tautological. "Reality works as reality works" is tautological. "As I've described is as I've described" is tautological. I'm further asserting, beyond the givens, that what I've described presents a difference from alternative conclusions, and what I've described represents the set of physical laws of this universe, rather than the ideological so-called "rules" of society, which are not enforced via the physical laws of this universe.

We're talking about "rights" in the context of "what can and can't be done", and I'm concluding that what some people are claiming as "unalienable" or "innate" aren't actually so.

It doesn't matter how many people "feel entitled" to anything. It does not seem that the state is "forced" to do anything. The state can choose to act and behave a certain way, but "forced" is simply wrong, as a way to describe how the state behaves. "Influence" is more accurate, certainly.

It may feel "wrong" or "bad", the fact that the state maintains absolute control, but it's true. Only through the grace of the state's benevolence does the influence of individuals or groups matter. The state gives you many ways to move through its control, and is generally benevolent, but not because it has to be.

Laaw··on Just Landed Is Shutting Down
Question about flight data and the middlemen:

Do these middlemen have to strike deals with the various airlines, or are they simply accessing public APIs that generally stink? What order of magnitude, cost wise, do these airlines charge in the deals? Could I, $random_guy, make a deal with $random_airline, for an amount that is sustainable without any special kind of funding?

Laaw··on Confirmed: CMU Attacked Tor, Was Subpoenaed by Feds
That's not tautological at all. Also, it's not really true. There are plenty of rules. What I'm saying is the only "unalienable" rules are the laws of the physical universe. Every other rule is a construct of society and people, and as such, is not guaranteed in the way as stated by the previous commenter.

It's just something I believe is worth keeping in mind when talking about your "right to privacy", specifically. There are many prominent public figures who actually don't believe you have that right at all, and when we remember that rights (as we're referring to them) are granted only by the grace of the state, if the members of the state don't believe you have a right, then you simply don't.

The argument here should be more about whether or not it's in the state's best interest to grant the right to privacy to its citizens, and I think there's a pretty strong argument in favor of that, but simply stating "I have a right!" doesn't illuminate that argument very much.

Laaw··on Confirmed: CMU Attacked Tor, Was Subpoenaed by Feds
I was (and still am) trying to illustrate the "physical reality" that exists independent of the concept of personal liberty.

It can be argued in many different ways, but the actual, consequential mechanisms regarding a person's "rights" are enforced at a legal level, and are done so at the discretion of the state. Reality does work, therefore, as I've described, regardless of what eloquent points you might make about the innate personal liberties each person is "born with". This is my "clear" argument.

Laaw··on Confirmed: CMU Attacked Tor, Was Subpoenaed by Feds
You don't "have" any personal liberties. You are not born with rights, you are gifted them by a benevolent society. That society can easily lose its benevolence, and take your rights away, and there is absolutely nothing you'd be able to do about it.

You might hold a differing view, but the fact is, reality works as I've described. Delude yourself all you want, but your rights do hinge on the imperfect and subjective manner in which your benevolent rulers have granted them to you.

They have not granted you absolute rights, specifically laid out, but they have done better than, "rights.. and stuff."

Laaw··on Justice Department Wants Apple to Unlock Nine More iPhones
There are the exact same checks and balances taking place right now for the iPhone.
Laaw··on The peril of talking to normal people
That's my point.
Laaw··on Justice Department Wants Apple to Unlock Nine More iPhones
There's nothing that makes the digital data on a phone any different or more private than the physical data in a filing cabinet in a home or office, both which require the same level of judicial oversight to obtain (your first point is factually incorrect with regard to this case, as the FBI does have a warrant to search this phone).
Laaw··on The peril of talking to normal people
There was a recent podcast (Freakanomics) that went into some depth about this concept, and it focused on a story about a pencil describing how it gets made, and the millions of people who are involved.

The moral given in the podcast is to "tread carefully" when attempting to fix something, because there are often many moving parts which can't immediately be observed.

http://freakonomics.com/podcast/i-pencil/

Laaw··on The peril of talking to normal people
Yeah, I'm reading this story (and some of these comments), and I have been in language comprehension mishaps before, but only because I was being obstinate (and was aware of it).

I can't think of a situation like this where I couldn't intuit the desired answer the authority questioning me was looking for. I've often chosen not to give that answer for various reasons (I can be a prick, usually), but there's never been a situation to my recollection that I've been genuinely stumped.

Laaw··on Justice Department Wants Apple to Unlock Nine More iPhones
Not the same. This is more like if the FBI wanted access to investigate a space murder and demanded Virgin Galactic to build a special shuttle to allow the FBI's equipment to the station, something only Virgin Galactic can do because they're the only ones who have the key to the space station.
Laaw··on Justice Department Wants Apple to Unlock Nine More iPhones
"The Government" is just a collection of people, and the judicial branch (this judge) is especially distinct from the executive branch (the FBI).
Laaw··on Justice Department Wants Apple to Unlock Nine More iPhones
I know this is going to sound crazy, but there are parallels here between Apple vs. the FBI, and Superman vs. Batman.

Superman represents an unchecked power, and Batman finds this unchecked power to be unacceptable as a risk, in case the power is ever used against humanity.

Is this a subtle marketing ploy from DC Comics‽

Laaw··on Justice Department Wants Apple to Unlock Nine More iPhones
Do you own a home?

Do you own a car?

The executive branch can obtain warrants from the judicial branch to "exploit vulnerabilities" and gain access to these "devices".

Laaw··on Novice pilot skills improved via expert-pilot brainwave patterns
Small sample sizes don't mean low confidence, why do people constantly make that mistake?

What you should be asking about are confidence intervals and reproducibility.

Laaw··on How Google’s Web Crawler Bypasses Paywalls
If they make sending your DNA a requirement of consuming their content, then yes, you send it to them if you want their content. That's their right, as owners of something, to dictate its use.

You aren't entitled to WSJ.com, NBC, or Fox.

Laaw··on Recent Events and Future Changes
Is it really that hard to run an IRC network?

(I say this with experience running infrastructure for an IRC network, albeit orders of magnitude smaller)

Laaw··on Why Apple Is Right to Challenge an Order to Help the F.B.I
The standard is "without undue burden".
← PreviousPage 3 of 10Next →