HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

LawTalkingGuy

194 karma · joined August 11, 2022

submissionscomments
LawTalkingGuy··on Arrest made in SF killing of Bob Lee – alleged killer also worked in tech
You're wrong. Verbal assault is assault, and is violence, because it leads to the reasonable expectation of violence. You don't know if the crazy person threatening to kill you will actually try to do it so you have to imagine that they will.

--

Sorry Dang, you're right.

LawTalkingGuy··on In the battle between Microsoft and Google, LLM is the weapon too deadly to use
The proper solution is to have a plan (with contingencies, etc) and follow the plan. Otherwise the solution is guaranteed to be political and thus stupid.

Politicians are going to be worried about perception of the appropriateness of their actions, not the correctness of those actions.

LawTalkingGuy··on Yes, it's OK to be mad about crime in San Francisco
> But what is the proposal? Arresting people and incarcerating them for petty crimes?

What's an honest counter-proposal? "Allowing" minor crimes, or requiring people to simply let thieves take some of their things?

So, of course, yes. Arrest people for any crime that hurts other people, because the other option is that those others suffer or they need to defend themselves. Both of which are unfair and unproductive.

> you can't mandate a homeless person with mental health issue "go" to rehab, you can only lock them up

We aren't talking homeless, they're already easily helped.

We're talking the incurably anti-social and dangerous. People who routinely hurt their neighbors or damage their spaces and things. And yeah, you totally can mandate rehab - you lock people up and require rehab to leave.

We already have to lock them up anyways so if they choose not to benefit from or are actually incapable of participating in rehab then yeah you just leave them perpetually locked up in the lightest containment possible. It's generally easier and better, for them and us, than some "free to die on the streets" nonsense anyways.

And rehab is only much of the issue - many people are simply "ill" and are never going to get fully well. They don't need punishment, and have no substances to kick, but they still need fair and firm containment.

LawTalkingGuy··on Yes, it's OK to be mad about crime in San Francisco
> Give me the context in which pooping anywhere, any number of times seems reasonable to punish with significant jail time.

Sure, even doing it just once if I were to do it in your living room. Or in front of your house, if I had a reasonable alternative.

> Yes, there should be some form of discouragement from this but making sure people have access to a toilet seems a lot easier.

Okay, so you are fine with arresting anyone who simply won't use the provided toilet? Great.

What if I don't put the toilet right in my yard, but put the toilet over there somewhere, so you're not all up in my space? Why is 'right here' the magical place where people must camp and poop?

> Jail does not help people. It is statistically shown to make their lives materially worse, make them less healthy and make them more likely to commit further crimes.

That's far from true in all contexts. Unhoused criminals on the streets of a modern drug city face incredible risk from being left to live in the camps, and jail doesn't necessarily mean supermax anyways.

> Treatment sure, I'm all for it. Even when it doesn't work.

How wonderfully liberal.

I'm for forcing people into the treatment that's proven to work rather than kindly letting them die horribly.

LawTalkingGuy··on Yes, it's OK to be mad about crime in San Francisco
> Why is the conversation not about jailing a landlord who evicts someone in mental health crisis?

What a commie answer, to blame the person who has actually supplied something because they can't keep providing forever.

Why not jail the neighbors, who obviously refused to start a go-fund-me to pay for the apartment?

Why not jail facebook employees for not making it mandatory to view said go-fund-me to pay for the apartment?

Why not jail the elementary school teacher who took a job in a different town many years ago, thus depriving the poor victim of a different path in life.

Why not simply jail anyone with more than the homeless person, to achieve full societal equity?

LawTalkingGuy··on Yes, it's OK to be mad about crime in San Francisco
> what is a bigger moral crime:

* To make things worse in a reactionary panic when doing less would have been better.

> fund someone who doesn't need help, and who will take advantage of it

That's not actually my primary, or even top-20 concern. I only fear accidentally giving them things that ultimately hurt everyone.

Giving people clean drugs actually hooked more people and not arresting people for "victimless crimes" led to more "victimless" deaths.

> The root cause is poverty, mental health, drug addiction, or all of the above.

Okay, but how does taking people off the street hurt all or any of those goals?

I'm not saying junkies should be in maximum security but I think mandating that they go to rehab is better than giving them the choice to stay in the street.

LawTalkingGuy··on Yes, it's OK to be mad about crime in San Francisco
No, he's claiming those sources are shit because they don't recognize what everyone in SF knows - that crime reports aren't taken and thus they can't be counted.

> "Below is a look at the total number of crimes reported to the San Francisco Police Department over the past five years."

Those "studies" aren't hard data, they're pure propaganda.

LawTalkingGuy··on Yes, it's OK to be mad about crime in San Francisco
> literal years in prison for taking a shit where they "shouldn't"

No, and you know that's not what anyone is saying. Shitting in public, or in other people's private areas, shouldn't have zero consequences simply because the ultimate consequences sound harsh out of context.

And yes, because jailing someone who has sunken to pooping on the street is generally an important part of their treatment plan. Not letting people live in squalor is actually kindness, even if the alternative is enforced.

> such harsh measures in secret

Oh my. Are you serious? Harsh measures? Some people try to raise children without rules and they always do more harm than good. Especially trying to avoid such simple rules about reasonable boundaries.

LawTalkingGuy··on Mass layoffs and absentee bosses create a morale crisis at Meta
> cryptocurrencies invite undesirable people and events.

Many early adopters are salty that nobody would listen to us and investigate the criminals we were pointing out all along.

> cryptocurrencies invite those who think it's a good idea to use them as a proxy to evade securities laws or KYC rules, luring in gullible morons in the process and leading to loss of money

Generally the criminal schemes that actually took everyone's money were so simple as to not even be securities scams. The complex non-deliverable defi contracts were something people were playing around with to make prediction markets and other useful things.

> when you can't get a new halfway-decent GPU for years because scalpers buy up all the stock then the market has fucking failed

Okay, seriously, what system would actually create more cards here, some command economy where gaming is allocated a higher value than other activities? How does the company know how many fabs to buy/lease to prepare?

> promoting outright Third Reich Nazi symbols and edgy far-right memes

I don't see a lot of value in some censorship system that makes that enforceable. Should books not have been invented until we developed a technology to make it impossible to say mean things?

LawTalkingGuy··on Emergent abilities of large language models
There's things which small models can't do, and where obviously a large model works better. Not emergence, I agree.

I think they're using emergent for a different category of things - still things that a small model couldn't do, but specifically which a large model can just do without any of the work we thought we'd have to do for that ability.

Or at least, that's how I see emergent being a useful term, both in a behavior and a value context.

LawTalkingGuy··on Emergent abilities of large language models
> They need balanced examples of verbally expressed knowledge modesty to do this better.

This is generally pretty easy, with ChatGPT at least, in my experience.

Langchain uses this prompt: "The following is a friendly conversation between a human and an AI. The AI is talkative and provides lots of specific details from its context. If the AI does not know the answer to a question, it truthfully says it does not know."

Also, just don't ask it for things it couldn't possibly know without making it up like medical citations.

This is more for where you want your "AI" assistant to say it does not know how to book a reservation rather than pretend that it can.

LawTalkingGuy··on Emergent abilities of large language models
> "Ask" it about [...] sound plausible.

Yeah, that's because the API is /completions not /answers.

We, as devs, need to know what we can do with text completion and what it's not good for.

> But for anything that's hard and matters, it's a parlor trick unfit for use.

Sure, you can't just ask it to synthesize a new drug and cite relevant sources.

But you can ask it to take a text like "the guy with the red house rides a bike, ... who has solar panels?" and spit out a testable proof if your language of choice. Sure, you then have to pass that to Wolfram, or Heroku, but so?

You can have it summarize a list of product differences, but focusing only on physical UI issues, and making it clear to only summarize, not extrapolate, from the sources you provide.

You can have it take unclear and incorrectly written free-form user input and select from a list of intentions, what the user most-likely wants to do and write an explanatory log-line, or flagging a user for more direct QA oversight and maybe help.

LawTalkingGuy··on Replacing my best friends with an LLM trained on 500k group chat messages
> but are the hallucinations always wrong to the same degree

No, but yes largely because you're asking the same types of questions with the same rough parameters, so it'll make up roughly the same sort of thing (ie, citations) again.

The issue is that the LLM is trained to generate plausible words, not to recite which piece of training data is also the best source. If you want to make an app using "AI" you need to target what it can do well. If you want it to write citations you need to give it your list of references and tell it to use only those.

> I'm imagining an investigator with reams and reams of information about a murder case and suspect. Then, prompting an LLM trained on all the case data and social media history and anything else available about their main suspect, "where did so-and-so hide the body?". Would the response, being what's most probable based on the data, be completely worthless or would it be worth the investigator's time to check it out?

That specific question would produce results about like astrology, because unless the suspect actually wrote those words directly it'd be just as likely to hallucinate any other answer that fits the tone of the prompt.

But trying to think of where it would be helpful ... if you had something where the style was important, like matching some of their known, or writing similar style posts as bait, etc wouldn't require it to make up facts so it wouldn't.

And maybe there's an English suspect taunting police and using the AI could let an FBI agent help track them down by translating cockney slang, or something. Or explaining foreign idiom that they might have missed.

Anything where you just ask the AI what the answer is, is not realistic.

> Would the investigator have any idea if the response is worthless or not?

They'd have to know what types of things it can't answer, because it's not like it can be trusted when it can be shown to not have hallucinated, it's that it is not and can't be used as a information-recall-from-training tool and all such answers are suspect.

LawTalkingGuy··on At Stanford law school, the dean takes a stand for free speech. will it work?
Well okay, if you think violence isn't significantly occurring then help draw that line anyway.

Even just crowding beyond capacity into a room, or shoving signs in front of speakers, or blocking people's way, would be treated as a crime if it was done to interrupt a stockholder's meeting. Do you think these actions are okay in protests or do you think they should be stopped?

How close, how many, and how loud, would the people be allowed to be? Are they allowed to shove into every elevator with you to deny you any potential "platform" to talk, or are they limited to only disrupting sanctioned meetings? Can they follow you home at night, or to the movies?

Can they simply scream incoherently, or are they limited to actually speaking words to be treated as protestors? Are amplified sirens allowed, and when?

Given that masked protestors have and frequently do attack people at rallies, and threats are easily implied from masked people screaming at you, would you be fine asking police to follow the usual (pre 2010) rules on masking at political events and either unmask people or make them leave?

And lastly, are these rules that you think are reasonable and should apply in both directions, regardless of which side protests what?

LawTalkingGuy··on Xylazine, a dangerous new drug fuelling Canada’s opioid crisis
> the problem with the breakaway reformations we have seen is that they often tend to deal with the “true scotsman” fallacy, where they double down on rules and regulations in the bible just to be worthy and a “true” Christian ... Instead of the movement to a more universal “love thy neighbor” seems a more fitting approach

It feels that's exactly what you did though. Pick a favored feature and declare that people not doing it predominantly that way are wrong.

> if it’s truly universal as Christianity claims.

Even if they believe that you should love the sinner I don't see where their traditions say they should lay down and let themselves be victimized because they can't regulate people they "love".

> “true” Christian, sometimes coupled with a “holier than thou” attitude. (Obviously generalizing centuries of history here)

Those centuries of history led to here, where in a country founded largely by Christians on Christian principles, you're allowed to say you don't think any of them are doing right. And you and I - total heathens, receive no threats, no hate.

LawTalkingGuy··on Xylazine, a dangerous new drug fuelling Canada’s opioid crisis
> There is absolutely no valid reason we can't treat people with suboxone

You're absolutely 100% right about this. This should be the first part of any treatment, to make it easier to separate the druggie from the drug camp and then come off, if possible, at a reasonable time as decided on by them and their team. This is one of the cores of the Portuguese system, to use some drugs to wean people off the dangerous ones.

> This could all be 'fixed' if people didn't have a subconscious need to make people 'pay' for doing things they feel are wrong.

I know some people like this, but I see more people saying this in that we shouldn't forgive the violent and non-drug related crimes people committed while resisting being removed from the streets. They don't want them not treated, but they want them jailed instead of released once they're clean. It's hard to argue - I've personally helped two old female shopkeepers chase thieves out of their store. Threatening and obviously disrespectful and non-needs related thieves too, not someone simply trying to take a bottle of water and food.

LawTalkingGuy··on Xylazine, a dangerous new drug fuelling Canada’s opioid crisis
> yet instead you have people fighting over the stupidest things in the bible just to be “right”, creating tons of denominations that make no sense at all.

Isn't that what we want? People laying our their reasoning and their ideology on paper, and leaving a parent group whose actions they can't condone? This is the calling them out. Compare and contrast to ideologies and areas where people who published these opinions would be killed for their heresy.

No doubt many/most of the sects are stupider than what they broke away from, but sometimes, critically, they are vastly superior. I'm not religious but for example I can recognize the value of Martin Luther's reformation.

LawTalkingGuy··on Xylazine, a dangerous new drug fuelling Canada’s opioid crisis
> we have places like the Salvation Army that would rather have folks die instead of giving a trans person shelter

Honest translation: they told a man that there was plenty of space for men in the men's shelter, but that they could not enter the women's shelter.

And why would that be?

https://reduxx.info/trans-serial-killer-who-targeted-women-w...

https://www.womenarehuman.com/male-transgender-boasts-of-har...

https://www.womenarehuman.com/male-trans-pedophilia-rape-his...

> passing laws to ban trans folks

Name one. One single such law. The proposed laws are to return to enforcing sex-based policies. Males weren't welcome in female washrooms, sports, shelters, or prisons before but were forced in by the intentional conflation of identity with physicality.

If you mean bills enforcing no drugging or surgery of minors, well we're being assured that doesn't happen so the laws obviously don't matter.

> and take rights away from queer people in general

Again, name one. What right?

There's a lot of conflation going on, claiming parents want to ban drag shows when they want to ban all sexual shows - burlesque as well - in public places where children might go. Nobody is coming for the drag queens, etc.

But, thank you for being clear that you're talking about TQ+ laws and rights, instead of tying them to LGB sex-based rights as if the rainbow is monolithic in politics. Lesbians face street violence for saying that lesbianism is female and demanding the right to male-free spaces.

LawTalkingGuy··on Xylazine, a dangerous new drug fuelling Canada’s opioid crisis
It's the common lie, not the common name. I can't get the politicians or the newspaper to change, imho because they don't want it to, but I'll take it up with whoever uses it by showing them how it's not true. Once you realize Portugal uses the law to enforce their "decriminalization" you can't in good faith keep supporting or even repeating the lie yourself. It only takes that first recognition of being mislead before you can find your own references and see what the street-level reality is.

Our cities, SF, Vancouver, Portland, Seattle, LA, Victoria, etc know they're distorting the meaning by claiming it's what Portugal does. They've been told that they're wrong in this by journalists with experience in Portugal and by the very architect of the Portuguese system and they refuse to choose other language or admit that they are in actuality enacting the exact opposite to Portugal.

LawTalkingGuy··on Xylazine, a dangerous new drug fuelling Canada’s opioid crisis
And yet the architect of the Portuguese anti-drug response explains how the courts and police are used to enforce this "decriminalized" system.

Vancouver has taken away the police's ability to confiscate a drug that has just killed someone, or to arrest the dealer. This is directly opposite of what Portugal does, dishonestly borrowing the words without their original meaning or critically the other 90% of the Portuguese response like actual rehab in a drug-free society.

LawTalkingGuy··on Xylazine, a dangerous new drug fuelling Canada’s opioid crisis
Portugal didn't decriminalize the way Vancouver decriminalized drugs or SF decriminalized shoplifting. They merely stopped giving criminal records to people who chose and completed rehab, but they still certainly use the police to apprehend any public drug user.
LawTalkingGuy··on At Stanford law school, the dean takes a stand for free speech. will it work?
No, they most certainly didn't refuse to engage. Exactly to opposite.

Also, if you watch the video the entire thing was staged - the students shut up on command - to get that lady dean up on stage where she could present her prepared speech about how valorous it was for her and them to shut him up. Pure hypocrisy.

LawTalkingGuy··on At Stanford law school, the dean takes a stand for free speech. will it work?
> the students' rights are obviously more important

The students rights aren't being infringed. They can spend all 365 days of the year saying what they want, everywhere they want, except in that one room for two hours.

To imply that they have a right to amplified shrieking over the speaker to state their point, you're doing what you accuse the other side of doing, insisting that free speech is a right to be heard.

The students deserve the same treatment the invited speaker deserves - a guarantee that they can speak and be peacefully heard - somewhere. Universities have many rooms and the students can have their own.

LawTalkingGuy··on At Stanford law school, the dean takes a stand for free speech. will it work?
Sure, heckle and hold counter-events. But the current state of university mobs today is literally closer to murderous than insightful.

SFSU let Riley Gaines be beaten and held against her will by the braying mob. New Zealand let Posie Parker and a bunch of old ladies be attacked be assaulted by shrieking thugs. There's nothing of speech in their actions, just terroristic political violence against the enemy.

> you’re free to buy / rent your own private venue

Actually, no you're not. The mob will blockade even an entirely private event held off-campus, or in a public square with permit, etc.

LawTalkingGuy··on At Stanford law school, the dean takes a stand for free speech. will it work?
No, speech needs to be hearable by those who would choose. You're free to shout your own counter-message, but from far enough away that you're adding signal not noise.

Similarly, trying to form a barricade and keep people from reaching the speaker and hearing them is an attempt to silence their speech.

LawTalkingGuy··on Bob Lee, former CTO of Square, has died after being stabbed in San Francisco
No one single measure can be used to fix everything, but to imply that enforcement isn't part of the solution is silly.

Ultimately though, you have to change the culture. Make thieves seem pathetic and mean rather than rebellious and cool.

LawTalkingGuy··on Bob Lee, former CTO of Square, has died after being stabbed in San Francisco
If your needs are met but wealth inequality drives you to crime you're merely a thief.
LawTalkingGuy··on Teen-age fentanyl deaths in a Texas county
Only sometimes, like when someone ODed or tried to sell right in public. And of course that didn't do much if any good overall because Vancouver didn't do anything else that Portugal does - like limiting the almost endless supply of cheap fentanyl. Even when they seized drugs it was a mere matter of minutes and a few dollars to get more.

Vancouver/BC didn't have decent recovery programs, and not enough capacity even in the bad programs, and critically - no legal capacity to force someone into them even if they did. People can be detained for up to 72hrs and "dried out" but that merely lets some of the detox pass, it's not at all related to kicking the drug and recovering from addiction. Even when they want to be clean the city usually houses them in a drug hotel where peer pressure drags them back in.

Arrest and seizure are valid tactics, Portugal proves it, despite Vancouver failing to apply them properly as part of a holistic program.

LawTalkingGuy··on Teen-age fentanyl deaths in a Texas county
Okay, now that you did some work and have questions I can help.

> what would the criminal record be

Public intoxication, possession, etc.

> everything I saw previously was correct and they indeed decriminalized all drugs

They haven't decriminalized public usage. You can have your small amount of drugs if you do it in private and are discrete.

> This goes against the claims that you previously made that they did not have a decriminalization

It's a system of not giving you a criminal record by using the mere threat of the criminal justice system for force you to voluntarily enter rehab. So you have to do what they say but then they don't label you a criminal and they sort of pretend you went into treatment on your own.

In the words of the guy who invented and runs their system:

"There are a lot of myths around the Portuguese model that, for instance, we just liberalize you do whatever you want, nobody cares ... It's important to say that using drugs in Portugal is still prohibited under the law ... If somebody in Portugal starts injecting heroin in public [...] he would be arrested and conducted to the police station. The substances would be apprehended. If they have more than the amount that is calculated on the basis of personal use he undergoes criminal procedures as before. If he has less than that amount he would be intimated to present himself to the commission. It's not a court, it's not a formal institution, but he will be confronted to discuss his drug use with professionals. It's mandatory, with a little bit of muscle you have them in front of you. We can try to understand what is happening with this person. For each hundren people that is conducted through those commissions, ten of them are problematic users." -- João Goulão - National drug coordinator for Portugal - https://twitter.com/ShellenbergerMD/status/16412220666858455...

This next part is where you have to read between the lines a bit. They don't come right out and say that they can't arrest junkies for junking in public - you have to understand that they wouldn't pass a bylaw to make it happen if they didn't need to which means that in the rest of the cities they would not arrest and move them proactively.

Here's a typical article about Vancouver BC's decriminalization - https://archive.is/f2Q0k

"Police forces across British Columbia are finalizing training on new drug laws that will limit or entirely cease their interactions with people who use drugs as the province becomes the first in Canada to decriminalize simple possession."

"While many police departments have in recent years moved away from arresting and recommending charges for possession alone, officers will now also stop confiscating illegal drugs"

"at least one city is preparing to introduce a new bylaw that would re-engage police if people use in certain public spaces."

From which we learn that 1) they won't be able to arrest at all for drug possession, 2) they won't even be able to confiscate dangerous drugs, 3) they won't even arrest people for public use (unless cities pass a bylaw overriding the province.)

In Portugal they will arrest, and will confiscate, and will use legal powers (if you push them to it) to detain you. In Vancouver they can not arrest, can not confiscate, and will not engage the criminal justice system at all.

Portugal is saving lives by using the courts, Vancouver is getting worse with every loosening. Seattle and SF are roughly the same as Vancouver.

LawTalkingGuy··on Teen-age fentanyl deaths in a Texas county
Killing a few people with your supply is an actual sales tactic called 'Hot Shotting' (a term for a lethal dose). When dealers cut and package for delivery they'll make a few extra strong and give them to well-known junkies who will then overdose and potentially die, in the process proving who's selling strong drugs. "That must be good stuff, Kevin died from it and they barely revived Sue."

Not only are street drugs inherently unsafe, the dealers view their customers as so expendable they're willing to kill them for advertising.

To fix this we've got to switch to government supply, but only when we simultaneously wipe out the illegal supply and suppliers, so that we don't simply compound the problem. Our interventions are like antibiotics. They lose their power over time when misused. They're best employed heavily in a cocktail and used fully.

← PreviousPage 5 of 19Next →