HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

LawTalkingGuy

194 karma · joined August 11, 2022

submissionscomments
LawTalkingGuy··on Teen-age fentanyl deaths in a Texas county
No, because the drugs are only given out in the context of dying in the street. There's absolutely no provision for people who are addicted through accident, for instance, to achieve some safe supply while tapering off to avoid the street.

And the government has decided that drug users are on palliative care, that they're never expected to improve, so they can be given drugs that are likely to end or destroy their life without any concern for recovery. That sounds 'caring' but in areas without this assumption they actually do rescue many people from this death, making the 'caring' cities into uncaring hellholes for the addicted - where they go to die on the streets of a preventable death.

There is no fear of 'famine' because the people who are being given drugs are being given drugs for the rest of their life. There's no fear of running out because even if the government stopped the supply the street drugs are only a few dollars.

What these excess drugs do is 1) increase the amount of drugs the person is taking and/or 2) get sold outside of the drug cities, both of which increase the scope of the problem.

Also, druggies don't need money because they can just take whatever they want from stores and at most will be forced to give the item back. They're given food and shelter and drugs and can steal any luxury under $1000. (Not that they'd be punished above that, but the stores aren't required to sit and accept it - they can apply reasonable force to recover their goods.)

LawTalkingGuy··on Teen-age fentanyl deaths in a Texas county
What issue do you have that makes you incapable of searching for references and yet still able to whine about that incapability online? And what are you actually looking for a reference for? That there are drug encampments? That some cities have literally made it legal to buy and sell Fentanyl?

You have been told something exists, that's 95% of the way there. Now go to a search engine and type 'vancouver drug decriminalization' and 'Portugal drug treatment' and read about the issue.

You're trying so very hard to use me to justify your ignorance and to be insulting in the process.

LawTalkingGuy··on Teen-age fentanyl deaths in a Texas county
My source is my eyes. I drove through the local drug camp recently and saw a dealer dealing within a stone's throw from police in their car, and junkies passed out just steps from him. There's a ton of evidence, but you could search for it if you really wanted and you didn't.

What I haven't found is a single short and simple article that explains for ... people like you, that what Vancouver/Seattle/Portland/SF and Portugal mean by decriminalization is not the same.

LawTalkingGuy··on A Response to Jacob Kaplan-Moss’s “Incompetent but Nice”
> when in your next sentence you admit that a week task has taken you more than a month

The word 'admit' suggests you had to drag it out of him, that he's hiding slow progress behind a smoke screen of busy work like opening many tickets. That month-long background task wouldn't have had any work done otherwise so it's unfair to call it delayed.

> Until you adopt my old-fashioned approach of single threaded work

That's the problem with people who think they're technical managing the actual workers, they always end up micromanaging and slicing things into shapes that don't fit. The world isn't single threaded and changes usually aren't entirely unrelated.

You should change your management style to simply specifying the business goals you want and asking for as many to be completed as possible. Let your team do what works best.

> The funny thing is you probably consider your approach agile

No, because all those labels just encourage people to pick a style and do that thing regardless of circumstances. In a real project I've got to coordinate everything with someone. I can't push code without a review, I can't code to a team's API without sending them the spec for review, etc. During these times I could facebook like some others do, but instead I "multi-task" by doing other work.

Also, it's not very obvious from simple metrics like number of lines of code committed which work is hard and which is simple fluff which can be fixed without a distraction. A change to a logger might percolate through every method call and appear big and complex despite having been made in seconds by the IDE. If I was implementing a new feature I'd probably want to update the logging style first rather than coding to the old standard, so I'd make the big change (probably covered by another ticket) because I'm already in there and have to test that stuff anyways.

> There's no value until you finish, and I mean done-done.

As I said, there are a lot of down periods in that process. It feels like you think you know some deep secret ("only delivered features count!") that you think you can't get people to acknowledge.

This is actually like day-one stuff in engineering school, that you need to measure benefit of your work in delivered advantages so done isn't done until it's in use. But there's a lot of other stuff as well, such as not delivering something until it's safe to use even if it works in test scenarios.

You should have a discussion with your team about your idea and brainstorm where it fits into a full product development cycle and what has to be considered. I imagine you will find they don't discount it, but they have a wider view of the process than your business focused one, and that they have to balance all of this while also managing your perceptions.

LawTalkingGuy··on Teen-age fentanyl deaths in a Texas county
> "sweet I can buy my black market shit, plus get whatever the addiction center place offers me on top of that."

That's the best outcome. In Canada the legal drugs they gave the junkies ended up being sold by mail to other parts of the country.

LawTalkingGuy··on Teen-age fentanyl deaths in a Texas county
As a part-time resident of two major drug cities I've been looking for that article. I just have to read between the lines and contrast it with the results we get from the same words.

It should be obvious when reading a story about Portugal that they couldn't get the junkie to stay in rehab voluntarily, so obviously they don't mean "no potential of a criminal charge at all".

Whereas in Vancouver they specifically changed the rules so you can buy and do drugs in front of the police, pass out and almost die - get revived and smoke more drugs, and have no charges, no special detainment, nothing.

LawTalkingGuy··on Teen-age fentanyl deaths in a Texas county
That's not how it's used in North America and thus it's not the impression our pundits are trying to give when they use it to reference you.

Here, decriminalized is uncontrolled. You can buy your fentanyl in front of a cop and do it in public. Cops can't arrest you for it. There is a maximum amount but it's huge! Pot is still limited though, and you can be arrested for having more than an ounce but you can't be arrested for carrying enough fentanyl to kill an entire building of people.

This has been done so that there's no way to force people into rehab, so they're a continual source of income for the taxpayer funded "charities" that provide for them.

LawTalkingGuy··on Teen-age fentanyl deaths in a Texas county
Portugal didn't decriminalize anything. They still pick you up against your will and detain you for years while not giving you drugs and forcing you to work. The only semblance of decriminalization is that if you cooperate and don't try to escape they don't give you a criminal record.

They use the criminal justice system and the underlying crime of public use and unsafe intoxication to force you into rehab, which is the very definition of criminalized.

LawTalkingGuy··on Teen-age fentanyl deaths in a Texas county
Don't just do one thing at once. Arrest and charge everyone related to drug trafficking at the same time as forcing every public user of hard drugs to report for testing when picking up their daily dose and enforce it with ankle bracelets.

Then because you're not just putting a bandaid on it you have the funds available to actually get people off the street (and not just into shitty drug hotels) which is one of the biggest obstacles to getting sober.

LawTalkingGuy··on Teen-age fentanyl deaths in a Texas county
"Legalization" is absolutely worse. Millions of dead sooner and with more collateral damage.

You don't have to legalize the drug, simply giving it to existing junkies for free by prescription for a while would allow you to break the cartels. Also, actually do break the cartels like Ecuador is doing, with life sentences or death.

The problem with the methods we've used is that we've used them piecemeal and inconsistently.

Once the pushers are gone you force the junkies into rehab. Then when there's no epidemic you could actually legalize to prevent a black market from returning.

LawTalkingGuy··on Teen-age fentanyl deaths in a Texas county
Nah, getting dangerous people off the street is its own reward.

If they could get high without causing problems I couldn't care.

LawTalkingGuy··on The chat control proposal does not belong in democratic societies
It is an abuse of power when they support laws they know they won't be charged with even if caught. The hypocrisy is also annoying, but not the main problem.

> Also speeding is a bad example since the cops let people off all the time

That's why I said "and surveilled".

LawTalkingGuy··on Disney Eliminates Its Metaverse Division
I see "the metaverse" as the liminal space between actual VR apps (games, business, whatever). If you're between rounds of a VR game you don't want to remove the helmet while waiting and chatting so you'll hang out in a VR-enabled lobby where you see each other in your in-game outfits. Eventually enough games will have VR lobbies that you'll hang out with people in other games' outfits as you all wait for your game to start.

Ditto business. If you're in VR because you're reviewing architectural renderings or whatever, you'll probably keep the helmet on for a few minutes between meetings and as such, seeing your coworkers come out of other virtual meeting rooms and hang around at a virtual water cooler gives you a bit of that hallway conversation that you're now missing, and provides a continuity of experience.

None of this is where the money is though, at least not now. You're still playing a game, or using business software, and that's what you pay for - not the lobby. That's why, I think, Meta and stuff seems so silly. They seem to expect that you're going to want to use it for its own sake, as opposed to it being equivalent to the Facebook UI - something you use to get the real value, not the value itself.

LawTalkingGuy··on Disney Lays Off Ike Perlmutter, Chairman of Marvel Entertainment
> "black people look the same"

Try providing a reference that doesn't say "reportedly" and pass the buck. Ditto the bit about him calling the three execs "the help".

> I dunno who you get your info from

From reading enough of the crappy sites that repeat the claim you posted and yet never point to anyone (even anonymous) willing to personally report it. The thing with false claims is that there is no disproof because there was no story until it was made up.

> Ike Perlmutter was acqui-hired from a toy company,

You make it sound like toy companies employ losers nobody else would want, and that he was just an employee there, and that Disney only kept him because he came with the building.

> chronically only cared about what would sell toys

He's thinking about what would make the most money in total, movies + toys.

> champion of good art against the forces of lazy pandering

Well, 'good art' is what fans want to buy and lazy pandering is just that.

LawTalkingGuy··on The chat control proposal does not belong in democratic societies
It's corruption because they know they won't be punished.

If more laws were objective (like speeding) and politicians were as surveilled as everyone else it wouldn't be an issue.

LawTalkingGuy··on PayPal has restricted our account after we invoiced a key containing “ALEP”
Sue them for aiding and abetting any crime that happens where one of the perpetrators carried a cellphone with their service.

"No, they clearly acknowledge their service is used for crime - they block these other messages."

For bonus points, find a case where blocking the 'weed' message got someone killed. (You order drugs, the guy says 'weed on the way' but you don't get the message so you don't meet him, he thinks it's a setup and gets mad ...)

LawTalkingGuy··on PayPal has restricted our account after we invoiced a key containing “ALEP”
One should assume that while they have your money they'll look for anything to use to keep it. Companies are literally legal devices for diffusing responsibility and hiding what the right hand knows from the left hand to remove the intent from what would be fraud.

They play all the games people here report - support reps who are nearly unreachable and who all refuse to read previous communication so everything starts from scratch, randomly just closing the case, etc.

It'd be hilarious if you could torture a paypal exec with their own company's treatment. Put a wheel lock on their car because you claim a similar looking car was stolen on the other side of the country. Refuse to take the lock off their car until they can explain the origin of the car's brandname. Relock the car immediately after unlocking it because they attempted to drive away too soon. Relock it the next time because they didn't drive away soon enough. Lock all of their cars because there's been "too much activity" on their vehicles.

LawTalkingGuy··on Moviemaking and gamemaking are converging
> at the same time creates a larger pool of poor people.

Paying people so they can lessen infant mortality and such does produce a baby boom.

LawTalkingGuy··on Moviemaking and gamemaking are converging
The OP's words were 'independent contractor'. Someone switched the words to 'gig economy' and started beating on the straw man.

The OP is actually right - contractors have much better treatment than employees. Not only in law, where you can't be told your hours - etc, but also just by the nature of your employment where you have to sell yourself and they desire to work with you or they wouldn't have paid your fee. This isn't the case in industries where they have fake contracting - employment in all but name, but as an actual independent developer or whatever you make more and get treated better.

> you dont want to do overtime making those car models? No problem. We have contact to 10 other people just waiting to do it in your place.

This isn't how contracting works. They give you a deadline for the work and you accept it. They don't know if you're fast or slow as long as you meet the deadline. They don't demand you do more, they offer it.

As an employee you're a machine for them to use? Have you heard the phrase "Drive it like you're renting it"?

> And we will pay them less than we pay you, and then we will pay even less to those who will replace them.

Then they aren't in that first artists range anymore so they take other work.

At some point the work is "Click on all transparent segments of the SpongeBob character, applying to correct color for that body part from this design document." Why would that employ the same artists who, from an empty page, designed those characters and their looks?

LawTalkingGuy··on Unpopular Opinion: Don’t Use a Raspberry Pi for That
I'd never heard of a sloat before. Yeah, that sounds like the kind of thing which could crush someone pretty easily if not done right.

I agree with the hardware safety interlocks, which I guess is why I don't think so much about the software - because I imagine it was programmed by a monkey (perhaps myself, late the previous night) and I don't trust it anyways. It's like a switch an untrained stagehand might hit which needs to be safe regardless.

(I've never made anything to be around a performance, but some of my things could certainly have hurt me or friends if we weren't careful.)

> SPARK2014 the programming language and the dev tools include a verification toolset

This is something that third-party FSM libraries often lack, decent controls and verification.

The cubesats are cool. Usually I can walk over and kick my creations when they need a reset, that's a whole 'nother level.

LawTalkingGuy··on Dutch police collecting demonstrators' personal data on a large scale
> I mean they track you personally. They are always watching. Be careful out there!

Your defensiveness hides some of the only truth in your post. Yes brother, they personally track all of us. Do you think this is good?

Have you thought of asking someone why you answer honesty with scorn and sarcasm?

> the left in {{CURRENTYEAR}} is not defined by these people from the 20th century.

Ho ho. That's like saying communism isn't influenced by Marx because he's dead. If anyone reads any leftist philosophy that's what they're getting. Who do you think the left's thought leaders are then, and how do they repudiate the past wrong-think or do they pretend it's not there?

For instance, if you read some of the earlier American political leaders they were racist and owned slaves, and now their parties repudiate these views and actions. Where are the leftists that disclaim forced collectivism and the rest of the centuries of nonsense, if you want to tell me that the movement changed?

Last I looked though, socialists and communists are still a central part of the movement.

> > more focused on policy than identity

> I think you should look for it. I honestly can't think of anything that would meet your standard.

That's easy - community groups of citizens motivated to fix something. You aren't worrying about a name and national attention and the intellectual legacy of your team, you're just a bunch of parents doing what needs to be done. It gets rarer the further you go from the individuals.

LawTalkingGuy··on Dutch police collecting demonstrators' personal data on a large scale
> Do you feel this is unique to "The left"?

No, the right is defined by the left, but woke is defined by the people who oppose it, etc. It's one of many. Conservative and liberal are a circle jerk where each is an identity and a slur to threaten dissidents with. (Despite Liberal, at least, having deeper roots than are currently meant by those who use it, it's now meaningless in most places.)

The left is perhaps a bit worse than some identities for being communist, and being used to explaining millions of deaths in terms of progress...

Left/right bothers me even more than liberal/conservative though because it's a reductive lens that people try to push onto everyone around despite it having little to no historical impact on most of them.

> You've gone off the rails my dude, and I have no reason to believe you are communicating with a modicum of good faith anymore.

It's a mere search away but that's just it. I could guarantee that you weren't going to go look because you don't want it to be true. It's a giant umbrella of things nobody is really happy with so nobody looks carefully.

Pedophile leanings of left: https://aeon.co/essays/how-the-french-bohemian-elite-celebra...

Actual government policy impact: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2021/07/26/the-german-exp...

I'm not really talking about actual leftists who embrace their ideology but shrill ideologues with identities and how the term is incorrectly used by many, even for themselves. And it isn't that this specific philosophy is bad, though it seems so, but that it's more officially a leftist platform than a lot of what people would think is.

That most supposed leftists wouldn't support this, if asked away from their peers, is the point.

> I think we _almost_ agree here, except that they are both identities and platforms.

Sure, then I'm just saying that leftist, conservative, etc, are all the way at the 'almost entirely an identity with almost no connection to policy' and 'fiscal conservative' is perhaps roughly in the middle, and some sort of hypothetical amazing group may exist which is vastly more focused on policy than identity.

> Keep investigating, just remember, they're watching you, just waiting for you to make a small misstep. They want to take away your freedom. They want to turn your children gay. They track your phone location. Stay vigilant. They are always watching.

That's pretty funny considering you're the one talking about good faith.

And yes, hello. They do track our phones. Congratulations on conflating a huge issue of national security with your identity politics.

LawTalkingGuy··on Dutch police collecting demonstrators' personal data on a large scale
> you can hear arguing between tankies and anarchists

Those people are the legitimate users of the term 'Leftist'. As I was saying, very few normal people would be willing to use a term that lumps them with strident communists who yearn for the good days of the USSR.

It's one thing that some other members of the tribe are commies, but "The Left" was literally coined and adopted by them. (Well, socialists, but no difference.)

The Left fully adopted the post modernist rhetoric of the French philosophers in the 60s and 70s, including actual literal pedophiles trying to remove age of consent laws in order to "queer children before they are stifled by the patriarchy". Again, not something normal people would support if they knew.

The only way this functions is by being so tribal that nobody looks at who else is in the group because they're so busy screaming at everyone outside the group. As proof that it's an identity and not a useful descriptor - your leftist status can be stripped from you and you will be identified as "far right" if you disagree with certain tribal truths.

"The left" is a label people adopt, "the right" is how they label everyone they disagree with. It's a very religious thing, to view all opposition as part of a united collective that wants to destroy you.

> Leftist or Conservative

Conservative what though? That's almost as empty as leftist. As in careful planning, or as in pushing your religion? You have to add 'Fiscal' to conservative before it begins to represent an actual viewpoint instead of a tribal marker.

> it's not meaningless because there are obvious real-world associations between the values in each group.

But vastly less meaning than any actual descriptive. Terms like fiscal conservative, socially liberal, democratic fundamentalist, etc, at least mention the issues a person could believe.

You're free to call yourself whatever you will, but it's undeniable that left/right, conservative, progressive, etc, are so broad that they're identities instead of platforms.

LawTalkingGuy··on We can't all use AI. Someone has to generate the training data
Yeah, currently many models do seem to have copied a few pieces of their source material.

I was translating code with one of the code- models at OpenAI and it spit out about thirty words of someone's code of conduct from Github, almost verbatim. I found the repo by searching what it had produced. That's when I changed my prompts to remove comments, but it stuck with me.

In general though, I think the pigeon-hole principle is relevant. The model is fairly small compared to the training material and couldn't contain much actual full content or it wouldn't be able to contain anything about the rest.

I've heard people talking about using the model to judge similarity of new training data to what it's already seen, mainly to train more efficiently, but also to avoid this.

LawTalkingGuy··on Banks as collateral damage in a class war
Sure, like all risk analysis you weigh benefits against costs. In a general sense I don't think we're far off a decent balance.

The problem is that we seem to have entirely ignored the moral risk where some people (criminals in all but name) continually abuse the same issues. Companies intentionally go bankrupt with a ton of debt rather than trying to minimize debt when it implodes. I've seen companies buy big pieces of equipment just before bankruptcy which were then sold to pay general debts, only a small portion of which went to the seller. Management knew they were likely caput but they didn't act like it.

Mistakes can happen, but in this case it wasn't a mistake and it was incentivized - not just allowed - by our system. At this point it's not a tradeoff, it's a trap that we're stuck in while its being exploited.

If I borrowed your car and my garage burned down with it inside you wouldn't hold a grudge, but if I knowingly parked it in a burning garage you would.

LawTalkingGuy··on Show HN: ChatLLaMA – A ChatGPT style chatbot for Facebook's LLaMA
> there’s a material and significant amount of copyrighted material related to LLaMa which is critical to running it.

Which files from the torrent do you assert are required?

> system’s dependencies on legally protected materials.

Do you think the weights are copyrightable? The dependencies are irrelevant because they weren't in the leak.

> Again, this is not true, that’s property laundering;

Only, if there is actual copyrightable material. And not just an adjacent copyrightable material that is required to use the weights, but the weights themselves because they are what leaked.

If not this is a trade-secret scenario not a copyright scenario.

If there's no copyright on the weights then there's no "laundering" because there's no general restriction on the public using the material once it leaks. If Coke lost its recipe and it turned up online, everyone including Pepsi would be free to use it.

What is certain is that the "no commercial use" clause is irrelevant. The only people the license is binding on are those who accepted it. If the weights are copyrightable then the license is irrelevant to you because it simply hasn't been offered to you. If the material isn't copyrightable then there's no reason to accept the license once it leaks.

> worth noting Facebook has already begun taking legal actions against developers related to LLaMa leak

They clearly have a copyright on at least one file (llama.sh) in that archive so yes, they can make a DMCA takedown claim. That doesn't prove anything you're saying though, about weights and the ability to use them.

LawTalkingGuy··on Show HN: ChatLLaMA – A ChatGPT style chatbot for Facebook's LLaMA
> Weights are irrelevant, what is relevant is any aspect of the system that is subject to the related terms of use and/or copyright.

The leak appears to be essentially just weights. The copyrightability of weights is the central and perhaps only issue.

> it would be up to the courts

That's a non-argument. Everything is ultimately up to the courts despite the letter of the law.

> decide whether the contracts [...] had been breached.

If you didn't sign the contract or induce the breach then it isn't relevant.

LawTalkingGuy··on Show HN: ChatLLaMA – A ChatGPT style chatbot for Facebook's LLaMA
> weights are meaningless without the parts written by humans.

I think this can be true, but that the format of these is well known.

The torrent consists of params.json, consolidated.*.pth, and tokenizer.model plus some .chk files. Notably, there is one script, llama.sh, which is about 2k so even if it was needed, can't be that complex.

> If someone refers to any parts that are protected to write a new interface to the weights it would most likely be violate the law

Not at all. I can refer to pages and words in a book I don't own.

> No, this is property laundering. If intentional, it’s a crime.

Only if the weights are copyrightable. Otherwise it'd hinge on being a trade secret, the best theory I've seen yet, and that basically says the cat's out of the bag once the public knows something.

LawTalkingGuy··on Men paying to have their jaws broken in the name of ‘manliness’
Yeah, generally the pro-X communities convey the benefits more then well enough and downplay the risks.

And there often is no benefit - an anorexic would not be helped by liposuction even though I acknowledge they feel they would.

LawTalkingGuy··on Show HN: ChatLLaMA – A ChatGPT style chatbot for Facebook's LLaMA
> if LLaMa is free from legal claims for commercial use.

That restriction is only in the license though, which was not accepted. So it won't apply, right?

> otherwise, [all?] copyright notices and software licenses would be meaningless, because you could simple launder stolen property

That applies to trade secrets. If I knowingly induce you to leak a secret I can't use it, but if you leak the secret to the public in an unrelated fashion and I discover it, I can. It doesn't apply to copyright, as you note.

> If you’re positive there no copyrighted materials used in deploying LLaMa, then obviously there’s no copyright claim or breach of contract.

There's no breach of contract because there was no agreement. Therefore there's no license to use, so you're right - the copyrightable parts will be a violation. Basically everything except 'data' or machine translations of someone else's works.

And yes, I assume that there's some incidental content, at least, which will be infringing. Even a readme is copyrighted after all. And yes, of course any code which isn't already public elsewhere.

I think the weights themselves are the interesting bit though, and perhaps someone could rerelease them without any incidentals just to clarify the issue.

← PreviousPage 6 of 19Next →