HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

LawTalkingGuy

194 karma · joined August 11, 2022

submissionscomments
LawTalkingGuy··on Databases on Kubernetes is fundamentally same as a database on a VM
In the pet model you fix the problem and patch the rest of the pets. In the cattle model you fix the problem and thaw a new herd.

What's the practical difference?

LawTalkingGuy··on Money Laundering and AML Compliance
> They offered me $1 million in cash to fly with $100m at a time to Tortola.

Dump the cash out of the airplane on the way and claim it never happened.

LawTalkingGuy··on I changed my mind about nuclear waste
> if you go with an expensive power source people and industries will have a reason to move somewhere cheaper.

The other options aren't cheaper, you just aren't being sued for the damages they caused (yet).

Creation and decommissioning of solar and wind are quite polluting, natgas is a byproduct of the dirtier fossil fuels, and geothermal and hydro are only practical in a limited number of areas.

> So what does it matter whether the nuclear plant gets $50 from me from my power bill ...?

Because treating dirty power production as just a business, like a muffin shop, isn't appropriate for society. We're making poor decisions for the group because we make them individually, buying dangerous gasoline today rather than saving to build clean power.

LawTalkingGuy··on I changed my mind about nuclear waste
> But nuclear has a terrible problem: it's not really economical.

Against what honest option? If fossil fuel plants had to charge to cover the deaths from pollution they'd be blistering expensive.

It could just as easily be said that nuclear power is the only source we can truly afford.

> The business model of nuclear is just broken in modern times.

Right, because it's not really a business. Power is infrastructure.

LawTalkingGuy··on The Online Safety Bill: An attack on encryption
> > by international definition, not refugees.

> Which international law do you think does that?

I used the term 'international definition' intentionally. I'm speaking about the common definition of the word not including people in the situation of crossing multiple large friendly countries to go to another as refugees at that point. The immediate threat to life and limb is over and now others are in more dire need.

And yet, it's not as simple as entry to the first country either, because we can both acknowledge that if someone escaping from Syria crosses the border into Iraq or Lebanon that they should keep on walking until they find an actually safe place.

But the point is that you're talking to people, using emotional terms, but trying to use legalistic reasoning to make them do something they feel is not only needed but benefits the wrong people. They're using their eyes and judging the conditions of the refugee claimants and finding them wanting.

> > emotional appeals won't make go away.

> caused by their demonisation in the public eye and as such will be fixed by emotional appeal.

I have a feeling that this has already been tried and that there's probably some misalignment preventing that from working - maybe making it backfire. Maybe that you may feel that this isn't a valid political opinion on the values of the refugee system but a comment on the race of the claimants or something...?

Thankfully in my country many of the questionable refugee claimants are the same racial group as many current legal immigrants and this is defusing that would otherwise be a nasty race-baiting angle to the debate.

Otherwise, I would ask what more demonization you think is needed other than for them to be shown to be jumping a queue meant to save lives?

> their status legal status means they are by default actively prevented from working and covering their own costs

If they really are fleeing for their life we can cover the costs and would be glad to.

LawTalkingGuy··on The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/OpenAI content moderation
> There’s no such thing as “both sides are bad”. Centrism is a lazy and uninformed view of the world.

No, there's no such thing as "your side is also bad so my side therefore is not".

But both sides can easily be wrong. You don't need to draw false equivalences to condemn two sets of people at once.

LawTalkingGuy··on The Online Safety Bill: An attack on encryption
> every government elected with a minority of the votes under FPTP ... illegitimate and undemocratic

The social contract isn't to be "only be ruled by a strict majority" but to agree to be ruled by the party who wins by any workable system.

LawTalkingGuy··on The Online Safety Bill: An attack on encryption
> the asylum seekers themselves are in any way decent or good or deserving of support

I think the many generally feel the same way about refugees but just that a lot of the people arriving are not validly refugees. People boating out of France to the UK are, by international definition, not refugees. They've already escaped persecution in their home countries.

My parents jumped a border while emigrating to avoid a war so I empathize but I wish we could discuss the topic without emotionally loading it by calling people asylum seekers when they are not or implying that others don't care about people in general. There are resource and fairness issues that emotional appeals won't make go away.

LawTalkingGuy··on ‘Confirming we are cleared to land?’ Who said what at Austin
Had they all quit that would have been fine - nobody can force you to work. But they chose to not work and keep their jobs.

> The laborers who held the skills needed

So did many other people. They conspired to break the law by arranging to violate their employment contracts in a group so as to cause undue difficulty to their employer and they held public infrastructure hostage to prevent anyone else operating it.

> Reagan's actions have had a profoundly disturbing effect on the American middle class

The death of unions is a lot broader of an issue than RR killing the ATCU, and generally much deserved. Unions exist to save lives where the law isn't capable but for every plausibly relevant situation like air-traffic control or deep mining there are a hundred overreaches like trying to unionize Amazon warehouses.

As society and work got safer in general it became less important to have such an option as the right to blockade someone's property and dictate who they can hire.

LawTalkingGuy··on ‘Confirming we are cleared to land?’ Who said what at Austin
This is clearly bad law. Not only is it unknowable and unenforceable, but it serves to reduce oversight if actually followed. Society is better off when we pay attention to how it runs and this type of law directly criminalizes that.

And it shows a basic misunderstanding of government, if it's paid for by your tax money it clearly involves you.

This is what the USA has over almost every other country - an acknowledgement that ultimately the people charter the government not the other way around.

LawTalkingGuy··on The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/OpenAI content moderation
Beating reporters, pulling motorists out of their vehicles, throwing molotov cocktails at occupied buildings, etc. All politically motivated violence aka terrorism.

Are you really defending that based on who does it?

LawTalkingGuy··on The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/OpenAI content moderation
It was a protest in a park, nobody could keep anyone else out.

And does that apply equally to Antifa?

LawTalkingGuy··on Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fake “manager” titles
The classification fraud is a crime. It's also tax fraud because you're understating proper income partly to avoid paying taxes on it.

This is far from simply offering a low wage from the beginning.

LawTalkingGuy··on The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/OpenAI content moderation
Here's a transcript that seems fairly accurate to the video interview I saw contemporaneously: https://www.politico.com/story/2017/08/15/full-text-trump-co...

His own words: "you had people – and I’m not talking about the neo-Nazis and the white nationalists, because they should be condemned totally – but you had many people in that group other than neo-Nazis and white nationalists, okay? And the press has treated them absolutely unfairly. Now, in the other group also, you had some fine people, but you also had troublemakers and you see them come with the black outfits and with the helmets and with the baseball bats – you had a lot of bad people in the other group too."

There are many good reasons to dislike Trump but you weaken them by association when you repeat the false accusations and misrepresentations.

LawTalkingGuy··on A novel PayPal scam
If they know your number or if you say who you are or if they gave you a unique callback number it confirms that they reached you and they can step up the scam.
LawTalkingGuy··on The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/OpenAI content moderation
> They do find antisemitism on the left and the center of the US political spectrum - just more on the right.

You know who says that? The same US intelligence agencies that conspired to censor twitter and who said the hunter biden laptop wasn't real. Who actually supports Israel? Consistently the US right and the Republicans.

The Canadian government leaned heavily into this fabrication early in 2022 for the trucker protest. They called it white-supremacist (despite videos of the crowd dancing to Banghra with visibly Sikh truckers - one of the largest minorities in Canadian shipping) and accused the event of being anti semitic because one of the organizers blogged something silly about Jews in banking years before. During this time a leftist government consultant tweeted “You know all those loud mouthed bags of human feces, aka the Jewish White Supremacists; when we liberate Palestine and they have to go back to where they come from, they will return to being low voiced bitches of thier (sic) Christian/Secular White Supremacist Masters.” and it was ignored until the prime minister was finally forced to acknowledge it.

The are thousands of calls on Twitter for the jews the be pushed into the sea and none of them are from conservatives.

"Far right" has become a term for things the left says but doesn't want to own.

LawTalkingGuy··on S.F. apartment rents fell again
> vkou: "poor urban planning, poor transit, horrific traffic, high costs of all services, and insane rents for shitty apartments"

> also vkou: You mean "totally different stuff"

No. The first things, not the second set of things. Do you feel a need to be this way?

> The goalposts sure have shifted over the past decade

Yeah, that stuff was charming when that's all it was. It was old and crowded and expensive because nothing was modern or planned to be upgraded. How quaint.

> The reality is that [Chesa] wasn't the cause

Yeah, like I already said. But he doubled down on it long after it was clearly stupid and killing people, and he did it ideologically which meant he'd never see facts even if his nose was rubbed in them, and that ideology was based on missing his parents as a child because they were in prison for murdering police and security in an armored car heist. It combines to make him the spokesman for toxic progressivism.

> tons of petty crime (Most metrics of which peaked in the 2016-2019 period, by the way

Everyone in SF knows that's because they don't take reports of petty crime now. They literally don't even log calls - the same way poop on the street became.

LawTalkingGuy··on The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/OpenAI content moderation
I think OpenAI chose those preferences, that ChatGPT would simply write the same message for both if they hadn't.

I too don't mind the model reflecting the reality of opinion, even if that isn't politically correct, but I care about a company which cares enough to add potentially problematic warnings and maybe account blocks based on their views of what is politically correct. I worry about having an app or developer account blocked because of messages some user types in a support chat box. (OpenAI: "We will terminate API access for obviously harmful use-cases, such as ...")

I think they found the correct balance on their API pages where they simply warn that the model is culturally biased and not to rely on it for certain critical things. (OpenAI: "As we discuss in the GPT-3 paper and model card, our API models do exhibit biases that will be reflected in generated text.") Sadly, they then proceed to fall on their sword to apologize for this.

LawTalkingGuy··on S.F. apartment rents fell again
Because all of that was part of SF's charm as well. The crime is not. It's community destroying.

Chesa certainly didn't invent the problems, prop 47 and other nonsense is typically Californian, and SF "deserved" Chesa in a way for harboring stupid anti-enforcement policies elsewhere, but he took to the job with gusto and enjoyed blaming things on racists and conservatives when people complained. He spent a year yammering on about how he was fighting anti-asian hate and then a largely asian coalition got rid of him - showing how little even the target of his "benevolence" thought of him.

He specifically took the position of DA because he planned not to do the job. He was "looking for alternatives to prison and incarceration" which is not the job of a DA. His job was to prosecute criminals and let others decide on policies.

Yeah, he shit on SF.

LawTalkingGuy··on How to smooth and spread A* paths for an RTS
It's for non-server machines which will be running other things like the user's browser. You won't get the same performance on the shared cores so sometimes it's better to just run on the free ones, and without checking/adjusting it's just easier to use n-2 cores.

In a production environment you do want to eliminate the other processes.

LawTalkingGuy··on Show HN: I made a video game to help reduce stress and anxiety
Something can reduce anxiety and yet not cure "the APA definition of Anxiety Disorder" or whatever. Also, whether something is a cure is always a personal question. Even if petting kittens is a proven cure it's not going to work for you if you're allergic to them.

For pancakes, definitely we'd need a study. They're not commonly accepted as being able to reduce anxiety.

LawTalkingGuy··on Nature photographer John Fielder donates life’s work to public domain
You're shadow-banned since https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33846088
LawTalkingGuy··on Steve Wozniak used to tip from printed sheets of $2 bills
> Yes, trying to hurt somebody's ego would indeed be a pretty good example of humiliating them.

If someone's ego is tweaked when they find they're wrong then perhaps that's a helpful thing to do.

> Look, if you think that the bound booklet of $2 bills is a fun gag, there's a humane and lighthearted way to do it. ... if somebody seems even a bit uncomfortable

They're for tips. If someone is uncomfortable they don't have to take them.

> It was all about showing his superiority over this sad loser working a 10-hour shift in a suit, who thought he knew a thing or two about counterfeit money. Well, he wasn't all that, and Woz sure showed him who the smartest guy in the room was.

That guy had already tested the bills and knew they were legit. If he was honestly curious how Woz got the bills he could have just asked. Instead he decided to fish around for anything he could try to rat out an innocent person for.

> No unsuspecting person would have this interaction in the first place.

But their cases would be identical from the PoV of the security guy. Some thing would "seem off" and the employee would follow them around or harass them over some legit thing that he didn't like and maybe even call the police about it.

If they think that some customers are playing games they might be a bit more on their toes and think about what they're doing, so as to not be caught in a prank. That will have a good impact on innocent people they interact with.

> [Scenario with fake bug report] then finally the customer smugly says that there never was a bug. ... made everything up. ... It's a hilarious gag, what a prankster!

That's nothing like this scenario. To try to correct it, Woz was happily using their app on his phone when an employee noticed what looked like an error. They stopped him and called him a hacker, tried to trick him into admissions, and when they finally reported and tracked down what he was doing it was just hitting back at the right time to avoid an interstitial, or whatever. The joke is that he was trying to say "it's fine" the whole time and everyone assumes he's a hacker so nobody listens, finally ending up with egg on their face when they wasted their own time.

> And you were paid for this work, no harm done, right?

Well, some to the company. I assume they'd say "maybe in the future, don't go wasting time pestering customers for something that we already knew didn't impact us." It's a teaching moment. It could save them from a lawsuit in the future if that guard thought he had the right to detain people.

> No. Fuck that. I would be furious at having my time wasted like that. And this is what Woz did. Not just once, but probably dozens of times. That's just outright sociopathic behavior,

You're overreacting. This is a perfect example of someone I'd feel needed to be pranked, because it sounds like you're ready to snap on anyone you think is mocking you and you're vastly more likely to do it to someone innocent than either a criminal or a prankster.

LawTalkingGuy··on Steve Wozniak used to tip from printed sheets of $2 bills
Not of intending to trick them into thinking he was anyone other than himself.

The main issue is that he's not at the Department of Defense HQ presenting his Department of Defiance ID, claiming to be with the government but intending to present the joke as an excuse if it fails. In this case he wasn't trying to claim to be government to get out of anything so it's pretty obvious that it's a joke.

> 18 U.S. Code § 1028 (4)knowingly possesses an identification document (other than one issued lawfully for the use of the possessor), authentication feature, or a false identification document, with the intent such document or feature be used to defraud the United States;

He wasn't using the fake part of the ID, just his real name, and it's obvious that it wouldn't have done him any good to do so because there's no legal exemption for laser safety officers. It's pretty obvious that there was intent, this was a conscious act, but also that there was not intent to defraud.

LawTalkingGuy··on Steve Wozniak used to tip from printed sheets of $2 bills
"Baiting" the security guy has only as much weight as his unnecessary investigation. They knew the bills were fine but he came to investigate anyway and he didn't just ask "Hey, how'd ya get those bills?" but tried to be sneaky. He was also salaried and got paid for the interaction so he wasn't a victim in the slightest, except perhaps to his ego.

The nasty act here, and possibly criminal, was the security guy calling the Secret Service and reporting on someone he knew wasn't actually guilty of anything.

> It is an ugly story ...

Of tedious security people inflating themselves by bothering normal people.

> it's not an isolated occurence! He clearly does this all the time

Thankfully, if these people go unchallenged then when they go off it's on a random unsuspecting person. He's prepared and can take it in stride.

The mistake was to engage with the SS agent without his lawyer. He pretty clearly wouldn't have been arrested but because he essentially volunteered for this fishing expedition they'll perform it.

LawTalkingGuy··on Two of the UK's water companies are still using dowsing to find leaks
fwiw, both bloodletting and trepanning have legitimate modern forms.

In this case, where many for-profit companies were practicing dowsing it makes sense to ask if it might have worked. Probably, I agree, not because it fundamentally works, but as others in this thread have suggested - because practitioners unconsciously recognize the external signs of leaking pipes. This could match the the studies - actual randomized dowsing wouldn't work but standardized dowsing of the usual failing pipes could be easy.

LawTalkingGuy··on Show HN: ML paper podcast generator using GPT and Tortoise-TTS
I'm borrowing your podcast prompts and one issue I get is that Bob bounces between an asker of questions and a co-announcer. I'm currently adding a bullet point to your instructions which seems to be working so far.

  Only Alice has read the facts beforehand, Bob should never mention anything Alice hasn't said first.
I'm playing with this for popular science articles and am using a two-stage process, one to extract the textual claims from the article and another to rank them for the inclusion into the podcast. I found that just "summarize this" boiled down the wrong things - that there were discoveries not what they were for instance.

  Please make a bulleted list of all factual claims in this article, do not summarize or include any opinions or non-objective claims.
and then

  Combine similar or duplicate facts. Rate the facts by importance, objectivity, and checkability, and pick the top six for inclusion into a podcast for already semi-informed viewers.
When fed an article about the JWST, produced these and others:

  The two ancient galaxies were found billions of light-years behind a giant galaxy cluster called Abell 2744.
  -Importance: High, the location of the galaxies helps to understand the structure of the universe
  -Objectivity: High, this is a factual claim that can be confirmed by the telescope's observations
  -Checkability: High, the location of the galaxies can be verified through scientific data and observations.

  The two galaxies existed just 350 to 450 million years after the Big Bang.
  -Importance: High, this information tells us about the timeline of the universe and when certain galaxies formed
  -Objectivity: High, this is a factual claim that is supported by scientific data and research
  -Checkability: High, the age of the galaxies can be verified through scientific observations and data.
So far I'm just using the rankings myself to manually pick the facts to discuss but I'm going to prompt it to discuss them itself in context.
LawTalkingGuy··on AWS Purity Test
> Reduction of a S/O to a sex-provider

Nothing in the joke said "only". By that logic, all single sentences are reductionist.

You're intentionally using emotionally laden words.

Also, the difference between a BFF and an significant other generally is the sex.

> you are (wrongly) assuming that this one person is the only person who dislikes this type of joke

Making everyone happy isn't possible and it's generally not even worth trying because some people just dislike everything. If they're overly dramatic about the "harm" it usually means there isn't any, that they just like controlling discussion.

> just because something is common or widespread, doesn't mean it should be normalized or treated as "the best that it can be"

Nobody did that. They said that in a sense of "and yet you're not dead yet."

Generally humor like this is only bad if it unreasonably hurts someone and "all SOs" are not a class who can be hurt by humor. Nobody is being maligned.

LawTalkingGuy··on Show HN: I made a video game to help reduce stress and anxiety
No, that's not a condition, that's a symptom. I don't need a study to say that pancakes reduce hunger.
LawTalkingGuy··on My husband was right about DVDs
My point in this is that the official word on high and filtering down to all levels is that transwomen, males who claim to be women, are female and I think I've shown that regardless.

But yes, I did have the names wrong. The White House's Lesbian day of Visibility was with Richard Levine and Charles Clymer, the two male "lesbian females" at the table. https://ovarit.com/o/GenderCritical/90533/tims-charles-charl...

This is Dylan Mulvaney who met Biden https://ovarit.com/o/GenderCritical/94756/disgustingly-shall...

Thanks for the correction.

> With regard to female sexual health panels this also appears to be a fabrication.

"Rachel" Levine is the assistant health minister so that's every day for them.

> Dylan says she has tampons for other women, in separate other videos she talks about changes to her body.

"Her" body. Exactly.

> You're operating from a place of discomfort and then working backwards toward rationalisation,

It is very uncomfortable watching women being beaten https://www.gulf-insider.com/us-transgender-activists-attack... simply for asserting their rights to single-sex spaces.

I am very uncomfortable watching institutions that my daughter appreciated, such as girl guiding, being appropriated by crazy gun-toting men https://www.womenarehuman.com/women-interviewed-by-police-fo... and for the women who complain to be targeted by false reports and doxing.

I'm horrified watching politicians give women's identities and rights away to men if they claim to be women https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2018/feb/01/labour-to-c...

I would be as uncomfortable watching Rachel Dolezal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rachel_Dolezal being appointed presidential advisor for Black affairs.

← PreviousPage 9 of 19Next →