HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

LeFantome

2,162 karma · joined August 14, 2020

submissionscomments
LeFantome··on Linux From Scratch ends SysVinit support
> Freedesktop wants to kill X11

There is a difference of opinion. Freedesktop wants to "stabilize" X11. That does mean that they do not want to evolve Xorg. However, it does not mean that you cannot keep using it or that they are going to take it away. In fact, it is still being maintained and will be for a long time.

You can interpret the rejecting of patches and banning of developers as political. However others see the rejection and banning as protecting the stablity that is the goal.

If your goal is for Xorg to evolve and not to stabalize (fair), you may prefer Xlibre as a project.

Phoenix looks pretty cool too.

KDE Plasma and GNOME are trying to kill X11. Or, at least, they do not want to maintain support for it in their projecs. And COSMIC did not bother to add support for X11 at all. That will probably be the trend on desktop Linux.

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
The K3 is launched now.

Single core performance is about what you say. But multi-core performance is much better. The K3 scores higher than a 2017 Macbook Air for multi-core on Geekbench 6.

And the K3 can take 32 GB of DDR5 and run a decent-sized LLM, which is not something you are doing on an a 5-10 year old laptop. In addition to the vector instructions, the built-in video codec acceleration and hypervisor stuff make for quite a modern feature-set.

The K3 is still too slow to be a desktop system for most people but there are some of us who would already be ok with it.

As for pricing, it is hard to find info. But it seems like around $200 may be possible for the Jupiter2.

https://milkv.io/jupiter2

The Framework 13 K3 mainboard will be more:

https://deepcomputing.io/dc-roma-risc-v-mainboard-iii-unveil...

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
DeepComputing has announced a SpacemiT K3 based Framework laptop mainboard.

https://deepcomputing.io/dc-roma-risc-v-mainboard-iii-unveil...

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
Indeed. With Ascalon, we will exit this year with RISC-V chips as fast as anything available from ARM themselves (eg. not Qualcomm or Apple Silicon).

The SpaceMIT K3 launched yesterday and Milk-V is advertising an SBC based on it (Jupiter2). It has single core performance about the same as a Pi 4 but with multi-core performance of more than double the Pi 4. And at 60 TOPS, it has the AI performance of a Jetson Orin Nano.

That is this year. The next ring to reach for will be true desktop level performance.

As RISC-V becomes truly useful, volumes will go up and prices will go down. With a dozen interesting players designing and building RISC-V chips, the pace of innovation is not going to slow down. I honestly do not know how ARM is going to keep up.

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
And so it was...

https://milkv.io/jupiter2

LeFantome··on Xfwl4 – The Roadmap for a Xfce Wayland Compositor
In my view, this project itself shows some of the reasons why Wayland is the right path forward.

On X, we had Xorg and that is it. But at least Xorg did a lot of the work for you.

On Wayland, you in theory have to do a lot more of the work yourself when you build a compositor. But what we are seeing is libraries emerge that do this for you (wlroots, Smithay, Louvre, aquamarine, SWC, etc). So we have this one man project expecting to deliver a dev release in just a few months (mid-2026 is 4 months from now).

But it is not just that we have addressed the Wayland objection. This project was able to evaluate alternatives and decide the smithay is the best fit both for features and language choice. As time goes on, we will see more implementations that will compete with each other on quality and features. This will drive the entire ecosystem forward. That is how Open Source is supposed to work.

LeFantome··on Xfwl4 – The Roadmap for a Xfce Wayland Compositor
It is refreshing to see somebody else notice that the complaints about systemd and Wayland are philosophically incompatible.

Systemd is creating the same kind of monolith monoculture that Xorg represented. Wayland is far more modular.

Regardless of your engineering preferences, rejecting change is the main reason to object to both.

LeFantome··on Xfwl4 – The Roadmap for a Xfce Wayland Compositor
Systemd does not have to force Wayland as it is already going the other way. Both GNOME and KDE are requiring systemd now.
LeFantome··on Richard Stallman critiques AI, connected cars, smartphones, and DRM
I am not an American but I am quite sure that HIPPA regulates the data, not the profession. You can be managing school bus routes and, if you reveal the wrong information about a special needs child, it can be a HIPPA violation.
LeFantome··on December in Servo: multiple windows, proxy support, better caching, and more
In both of the cases people criticize the Ladybird founder for, he was explicitly asking to avoid conflict. If you do not have time to read up on it, maybe temper these accusations with that knowledge.

He was first branded as a fascist when a non-contributor to SerenityOS submitted a bug or a pull request to change male pronouns to something else. Kling asked to keep the project contributions and discussion technical and not political. That is it. His crime was the classic “asking me not to be political is political” drama.

Next, and admittedly worse, he said something related to Charlie Kirk like “I hope more people engage with words and not fists”. Since Charlie Kirk was a massive douche, people do not like implying that there was anything good about him. While I get this, the idea that this comment confirms Andreas Kling to be a fascist is, well, a bit fascist for my taste.

Kling is famous for starting his videos with “Hello friends”, he has hundreds of good natured videos online, he is very open and humble of his experiences with drug addiction, and he lives in a country that is almost exclusively left wing by US standards. He seems far better behaved than his critics. I am going to have to see a bit more evidence than the above to start boycotting Ladybird over his politics. But that is just me I guess.

LeFantome··on December in Servo: multiple windows, proxy support, better caching, and more
I am running the latest version of Firefox, but I said it was better than version 60 of Firefox (years old). I am certainly not suggesting that Ladybird is more feature complete than modern Firefox. Ladybird is pre—Alpha.

But the fact that Ladybird scores over 500 and you are getting 546 in Firefox tells us how advanced Ladybird is getting.

When I tried Servo a month ago, it was scoring around 400.

LeFantome··on December in Servo: multiple windows, proxy support, better caching, and more
Ladybird is further ahead than Servo, at least with what it can render and how correct it is. But Ladybird is a lot slower at this point.

One reason of course is that Ladybird wrote its own JavaScript engine while Servo uses SpiderMonkey.

Ladybird scores over 500 on https://html5test.co which is better than Firefox 60. And Ladybird is not too far behind Safari on the Web Playform Tests (ahead of Servo).

I wish both projects well.

LeFantome··on 80386 Multiplication and Division
As somebody that was around at the time, this is not at all a stretch.

First, Linux was created FOR the 386. Linus Torvalds had one and wanted to unlock its power.

As you say, Windows 3.0 is certainly no stretch.

That leaves only Windows 95. The minimum spec at launch was a 386 with 4 MB of RAM. Realistically, you needed 8 MB to do anything.

Here is an article from 1993 saying that manufactures are beginning to drop the 386 from their product lines. That is, this is when people stopped being able to buy 386 machines brand new.

https://books.google.com/books/about/InfoWorld.html?id=2zsEA...

The 486 was the dominant chip in 1993 but there were still a lot of 386 machines being sold to that point when.

When Windows 95 shipped, people would certainly have been trying to run it on those machines.

When Windows 95 was released, people famously lined up to buy it like they were getting tickets to a rock concert. It was not just sold with new hardware. Back then, it was normal for people to pay money to buy a new operating system to run on hardware they already owned.

Of course Windows 95 certainly helped sell Pentiums. Pentium would have dominated new sales but a typical PC in service in 1995 would have been a 486 and there were still plenty of 386 machines in use.

LeFantome··on 30 Years of ReactOS
I am responding to you from Ladybird. It is indeed coming along quite well.

Interestingly, if you run https://html5test.co in Ladybird, you get a score of over 500. This is better than Firefox 60.

LeFantome··on 30 Years of ReactOS
ReactOS has delt itself a massive blow by hiding so much of their progress.

The project has insisted on creating Windows Server 2003. Probably very little of the software you want to run works on Windows Server 2003. Certainly no modern web browser will.

There has been some movement in recent months though. They have a 64 bit version. They are implementing NT6 APIs. They are implementing UEFI. They are looking at WDDM drivers. The have synced with Wine 10.

If ReactOS can produce a version that can run a modern browser and maybe a half-way recent Office suite, I think a lot of people would change their mind about the potential.

If they can support modern GPU drivers, it is possible they could even gain some traction in that space. Lots of work to do but not impossible.

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
I hesitate to say this as you seem very knowledgeable but you are missing some pretty massive facts that destroy your argument here.

There are already literally billions of RISC-V chips in the wild. Qualcomm alone has shipped a billion or more. They wrote an article back in 2023 where they disclosed that they had already shipped 650 million of them by that point. Andes Technology has said that there are 2 billion chips using their IP. A recent industry report suggested that RISC-V could represent 25% of the global SoC market by 2030. That is based on growth trajectory, not speculation.

RISC-V is not some obscure ISA that cannot get any traction.

There are a dozen or more credible competitors designing modern 64 bit RISC-V CPUs. Most of them have shipped silicon. Some have shipped multiple generations. Has any ISA ever had so many independent companies independently creating core designs (not designs from a single source like ARM)?

Tenstorrent alone likely made $500 million dollars in 2025. Easier to confirm is that they closed a $650 million funding round.

NVIDIA has announced CUDA support for RISC-V. I do not remember them doing that for SPARC, or POWER, or SuperH.

The current RISC-V standard, RVA23, includes advanced instructions for things like vectorization and virtualization. Many large, important industry players are involved in designing future extensions as well.

RISC-V is an officially supported platform in many mainstream Linux distributions including aggressively commercial ones like Red Hat Enterprise Linux but also foundational ones like Debian and its derivatives (like Ubuntu).

GCC and Clang have excellent support for RISC-V. FFMPEG just released hand-written vector optimizations for RISC-V. Again, can we say this about any of the platforms you mentioned?

It's a pretty inescapable fact on the ground that RISC-V has an absolute mountain of support in the industry. And starting this year, multiple vendors will be shipping cores faster than you can license from ARM.

Honestly, what universe are you living in?

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
> As far as I know, there's still no real RISC-V equivalent to Raspberry Pi

The SpaceMIT K3 is rumored to be announced at FOSDEM (January 31, 2026)

https://www.reddit.com/r/RISCV/comments/1qdvw4l/k3_x100_a100...

Also at FOSDEM, mainline support for Orange Pi RV2 https://fosdem.org/2026/schedule/event/VF9CHG-mainline-suppo...

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
Do not lose faith...

https://fosdem.org/2026/schedule/event/VF9CHG-mainline-suppo...

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
Sadly yes. This should all be behind us soon.
LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
[EDIT: I may be the one with the reading comprehension problem. I think they are saying that ARM having better tooling is a wrong. I agree. I leave my comment to own my shame.]

Did you even bother to click the link that this story was about?

The Milk-V Titan supports UEFI, ACPI, CPPC, and SMBIOS. The board is otherwise bog standard PC architecture from the PCIe to the form factor (ITX). You can boot multiple Linux distros on it out-of-the-box. They are pushing support into the Linux kernel mainline.

The Titan supports RVA22 + virtualization (the H extension) which you could also frame as RVA23 minus the vector extension. Another way of saying RVA23 is to say that it is RISC-V with the same feature set as X86-64 v4. Why did I have to say "v4" when talking about x86? Because of the myriad of extensions offered on x86-64 that differ between v1, v2, v3, and v4.

Honestly, what the hell are you talking about?

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
Holy swerving goal-posts Batman.

Ok fine. Here is a link to a completely open design:

https://github.com/tenstorrent/riscv-ocelot

And here is a high-performance evolution of it that you can license. They would be happy to take your check today. https://tenstorrent.com/ip/risc-v-cpu

Silicon will be available in a few months.

And just for you, it is not Chinese.

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
> no uses RISC-V anyway

Here is an article from a company called Qualcomm from two years ago saying that they had, at that time, already shipped 650 million RISC-V cores.

https://www.qualcomm.com/news/onq/2023/09/what-is-risc-v-and...

I notice that the three benefits they flag for RISC-V are: flexibility, control, and visibility.

I wonder how they felt about "control" after ARM tried to stop them from commercializing the value of their Nuvia acquisition? I wonder if it had anything to do with their next big acquisition being RISC-V based instead?

I also wonder, why on their Oryon page does Qualcomm never meanion ARM. Not even once. Even to the question, is Oryon x86, they do not answer that it is ARM. Why not?

https://www.qualcomm.com/processors/oryon

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
The idea that a chip takes more "personnel" than an operating system or a codec is wrong. An individual can make toys of either software or hardware. "Real" ones take dozens or hundreds of people. There are 5000 people involved in the Linux kernel. That is design, not production. Production (manufacturing) is what is free in software.

The Linux kernel may be "free" but it represents millions of man hours (or years) of engineering. Creating a viable RISC-V chip would be easier.

Creating the AV2 video codec cost money. I assure you. There is a reason that the Alliance for Open Media is a list of Fortune 500 companies and not a bunch of individual developers.

I have worked in industries dominated by a single chip supplier that made the chips that everybody used. Video surveillance is a good example. It would have been much cheaper for the major players in that industry to fund the collaborative development of chips they could all use and that could maybe be "tweaked" to add differentiated value for the largest players. It would save them money. It would give them more control (even more valuable).

I assume you know what a "chiplet" is. RISC-V is going to change things. In my view, you are focused on the wrong constraints.

We are both saying that money matters. We are simply coming to different conclusions about what that means.

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
> faster than Pi4 but slower than Pi5

It may actually be faster than a Pi5.

The benchmark is well tuned for ARM64 but not so well adapted to RISC-V, especially the vector extensions.

You may still be right of course. The SpaceMIT K3 is exciting because it may still be the first RVA23 hardware but it is not exectly going to launch a RISC-V laptop industry.

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
You are right to be cautious.

Ryzen 5 is not Zen 5. So I am not predicting Zen 5 level performance for Ascalon.

I am expecting Zen 3 level performance which is to say about as fast as laptops from 2017 to 2020 or so. That is better than what I am typing on now.

So, not crushing Apple Silicon just yet but "usable" for the first time. Instead of "there are no RISC-V chips as fast as a Raspberry Pi", it will be "Intel is still faster". It may not even be that ARM is faster anymore. It will be more of a chip by chip comparison. At least people will have to admit that it is a race.

I am not looking for RISC-V to be "best in the world" in 2026. Rather, I want to stop hearing that it will never get there. After Ascalon, you will not be able to make the blanket statement that RISC-V is not good enough. It will be good enough in some markets and not in others. It will have a seat at the table.

And I want to be able to use RISC-V. Ascalon bring RISC-V into "good enough for me" territory.

And RISC-V will only get better. It is getting better faster than other chips are. My thesis is that this will continue (though that is certainly a bold prediction).

Even just looking at Tenstorrent, Babylon is not far behind Ascalon. And there is SciFive. And there is Andes. And there is SpaceMIT. And there is Alibaba. And there is Qualcomm. And there are companies I do not know about yet. And there are nation-states. There is a pretty big tidal wave headed for ARM (and maybe even AMD/Intel).

First they laugh at you. And then you win.

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
I am so excited for Ascalon.

It is not that I expect that Ascalon is going to be faster than Apple Silicon or cheaper than ARM. The price/performance is still likely to be such that these kinds of threads will be dominated with critics still saying that other options are better. Many will continue to wonder what the hype is about.

But what I fully expect and hope for is that Ascalon will put to rest the idea that RISC-V is some sort of toy platform or that it will be decades if ever before it can compete. Specifically, people will not be able to say that there are no RISC-V chips that can even compete with a Raspberry Pi 5.

After Ascalaon, it will not be fringe to propose that RISC-V makes sense for some use cases. Few will see RISC-V as a competitor to Intel, but many more will understand that RISC-V is a viable competitor to ARM.

And for us RISC-V supporters, Ascalon/Atlantis may be fast enough to actually use on the desktop. I have Intel based laptops that I still use daily that may not be any faster than Ascalon. That means that, for me at least, Ascalcon will already be fast enough. That is, if I will be able to afford it or even able to buy one. Fingers crossed.

I can dream of an Ascalon or Babylon based Framework mainboard.

Regardless, the rubicon will have been crossed. RISC-V will only get cheaper and faster after Ascalon. And, while x86-64 and ARM64 will too, there will be many, many RISC-V suppliers. There will be governments directly backing RISC-V research. The better RISC-V gets, the more players there will be and the more momentum the ecosystem will get.

My thesis is that it will be hard for ARM and Intel to stay ahead of all these other players. Certainly it will be hard to out-compete them all in every market. Which means that RISC-V will not only become viable but start to lead. And that is a radically different world than the one we live in now.

RISC-V is the hardware equivalent of the Linux kernel. And we know how that turned out.

Again, fingers crossed.

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
> please feel free to downvote

Not sure why anybody would downvote your comment

> RISC-V doesn't make sense to 99% users at this stage

Not sure about the exact percentage but your basic point is valid. Adding "at this stage" makes it hard to argue with you.

> ARM is cheaper for 99% use cases

It may be 100% of use cases today. Facts are facts. You probably need to add "at this stage" again though.

> ARM ... has far more choices on the market

Very much so. Again, today...

That said, it is worth noting that almost all ARM "choices" are licensing the same small number of core designs from ARM. Already there are beginning to be enough RISC-V suppliers that some users may like the RISC-V options better in some niches (see automotive and some edge AI for example).

> ARM ... has ... much better performance

Absolutely. But that may not stay true for long. RISC-V CPUs will appear this year that equal or exceed CPU designs from ARM themselves in performance (eg. Ascalon). And we will see where things go from there. It will be a while before RISC-V beats Apple Silicon of course. And even once RISC-V gets there on performance, ARM may lead on price/performance for a while. That is, until RISC-V volumes start to equal or exceed other ISAs...

> greater software ecosystem and tooling

On the Open Source side at least, this is already a weak point. You can get multiple Linux distributions for RISC-V today, including from critical players like Ubuntu and Red Hat. The Linux kernel has a tonne of dedicated RISC-V support. Even though there are hardly any RISC-V chips with vector extensions in the wild, you already see Open Source packages adding support for these extensions. Both Clang and GCC have great RISC-V support. There are already x86-64 emulation layers for RISC-V. Ecosystems like QEMU support RISC-V. Even niche projects like Haiku OS support RISC-V. And on the hardware side, RISC-V players like Tenstorrent are advancing Open Source tooling and toolkits like crazy. The ecosystem is great now and getting better every day which, given the complete lack of real RISC-V hardware on desktops and servers, shows you how excited the industry is for RISC-V and how much support it is going to get.

Remaining gaps in ecosystem and tooling will close quickly. Starting with the board that we are discussing here, Titan, RISC-V is entering an era of being good enough to actually use. Linux and the universe of software associated with it are going to support RISC-V rather robustly. And while some RISC-V suppliers will follow the ARM path, many RISC-V suppliers are being good about getting support into the Linux mainline.

I expect ecosystem and tooling to be better for RISC-V than for ARM in general (though both will be great).

> For 99% users, the only real "benefit" RISC-V can bring to the table is the _false_ feeling that "I am different"

> _false_

False.

Here we disagree. But again, it may mostly be about the percentage. Because most users just want something that runs their software at the highest speed for the lowest price. And see above for how we agree that it will be a few years yet before people that do not otherwise care about RISC-V will find it the best option based on simple price/performance (though I do think that day will come).

But there are many "real" benefits to RISC-V.

Perhaps the biggest benefit is that it is an ecosystem that cannot be truly dominated by a single player or even by a small few. I wish RISC-V suppliers great success, and many will find niches that make them rich. But the amount of market power they can ever wield is limited by competition. I for one want this to be my future and I cannot wait to get on the train.

This is just my opinion but I think RISC-V is very well designed. I want to build software for the platform. I want to use assembly language on it. It seems much more pleasant than x86-64 and even ARM. This is a big benefit to me.

Similarly, RISC-V as an ISA and an ecosystem will be uniquely scalable. The same basic ISA can be used on the smallest micro-controllers or the most complex AI supercomputers. And it can be used in the support chips every step of the way. The expertise that I acquire using RISC-V will be broadly applicable over space and time.

And, while this is a prediction, RISC-V will have longevity. Suppliers can go out of business. RISC-V is not a supplier. Once it takes hold, it is not going anywhere. Many an ISA has dominated the computing landscape only to be abandoned and forgotten. RISC-V was inspired by MIPS (the ISA) and MIPS workstations used to cost as much as a small house. But now MIPS (the company) is a RISC-V supplier. x86-64 may seem unassailable but ARM has certainly kept it out of many niches and now ARM is starting to be credible on desktops and servers. x86-64 could go away (especially if Intel failed--not impossible). And ARM is very vulnerable to RISC-V (if you ask me). But for RISC-V to go away, there would have to be yet another totally open ISA that the entire world rallied behind. That is not how things generally work. Like Linux, RISC-V is destined to become a natural monopoly in my view and to be with us a very, very, very long time.

And, for now at least, RISC-V is just more interesting. Companies like Tenstorrent are doing really interesting things. Universities are doing interesting work and sharing it with the world. Those two things came together just the other day when RISC-V vector extensions were added to BOOM. It is a fun space to watch and it will be a fun space to be a part of.

And just like every school teaches software in Java, every school is going to teach programming and electronics with RISC-V. It is going to be the default technology in the future. And that means that it will be the go-to for start-ups as well. RISC-V will be the go-to technology for innovation.

Finally, what I will end with is that the real inevitability of RISC-V has nothing to do with users. Companies will choose RISC-V. But not to save a few bucks on ISA licensing like everybody imagines. That may be a benefit but it does that amount of cost is not going to drive most decisions. But the more critical issue with licensing is control.

Take the situation with ARM and Qualcomm. Qualcomm wants to release its own high-performance silicon to compete with the likes of Intel and Apple. They licensed the ARM ISA to do this. And then ARM tried to stop them from releasing this technology over a license dispute. Yes, it was over money (which matters) but the much bigger deal is that ARM (a supplier to Qualcomm) tried to dictate how Qualcomm can run its business. Qualcomm recently bought a prominent high-performance RISC-V designer. I think these facts are related.

If you bet your business on ARM, you better hope that ARM likes your strategy. If they do not, they may try to stop you. Why would Qualcomm want to create a business around ARM if ARM is going to represent a strategic risk like this? Why would Amazon or NVIDIA? Building the same business around RISC-V eliminates that risk. You do not have to ask permission for whatever you do with RISC-V. Nobody can file an injunction on a RISC-V supplier for using RISC-V.

This is why China is so into RISC-V. Even for them, it is not really to save on license costs. It is about reducing legal and geopolitical exposure. US sanctions led to ARM refusing to work with Chinese suppliers like Huawei. The US cannot sanction RISC-V as a technology. Fast forward to today and there are now many, many companies around the world rethinking their exposure to US based technology companies. There is a reason that RISC-V International is based in Switzerland even though RISC-V was invented in California. Europe is investing in home-grown RISC-V solutions. So is India. Tenstorrent came from Canada. Andes is out of Taiwan. It is not just China.

So, no need to downvote. But if you really think RISC-V has no benefits, the next 5 years are really going to confuse you.

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
Well, today it is only Ubuntu 25.10 and newer that require RVA23. Almost everything else will run on plain old RV64GC which this board handles no problem.

But you are correct that once RVA23 chips begin to appear, everybody will move to it quite quickly.

RVA23 provides essentially the same feature-set as ARM64 or x86-64v4 including both virtualization and vector capabilities. In other words, RVA23 is the first RISC-V profile to match what modern applications and workflows require.

The good news is that I expect this to remain the minimum profile for quite a long time. Even once RVA30 and future profiles appear, there may not be much pressure for things like Linux distributions to drop support for RVA23. This is a lot like the modern x86-64 space where almost all Linux distributions work just fine on x86-64 v1 even though there are now v2, v3, and v4 available as well. You can run the latest edition of Arch Linux on hardware from 2005. It is hard to predict the future but it would not surprise me if Ubuntu 30.04 LTS ran just fine on RISC-V hardware released later this year.

But ya, anything before RVA23, like the RVA22 Titan we are discussing here, will be stuck forever on older distros or custom builds (like Ubuntu 25.04).

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
I am a pretty big RISC-V booster but RISC-V is going to cost way more for a while. It is simple economics of scale.

The license cost of the ISA is not that much per chip. It is not nearly enough to equal the extra cost per unit that is going to be added to any upcoming RISC-V chip due to the small production runs compared to x86-64 or ARM.

On the microcontroller side, we are seeing what you are saying. RISC-V has taken over the microcontroller world and chips are being produced in the billions. Scale, combined with the lack of licensing, means that you can get RISC-V microcontrollers for a couple of bucks.

The other thing is that there will still be license fees for RISC-V. You are not paying RISC-V International. But somebody designed the RISC-V chip and board you are buying and they will want to get paid. Instead of paying ARM, you will be paying SciFive, or SpaceMIT or Andes, or Tenstorrent, or UltraRISC (for the Titan board this story is about).

But compare this to ARM where your choices are licensing from ARM or purchasing hardware from Qualcomm or Apple. Or compare to x86-86 where there is only Intel and AMD to choose from. There will be dozens of RISC-V suppliers and competition will drive innovation up and prices down.

Of course, you can of course always design your own! Or use an Open Source design. No license fees required. But the chips you will actually want to use as a consumer will probably come with licensing fees.

But 3-5 years from now, things may be different. I hope and believe that RISC-V will be successful. As RISC-V chips with competitive performance appear, volumes will go up and we will see the same pattern we have seen in microcontrollers. Many of the niches that are currently filled by ARM will start to be filled by RISC-V. This will include the SBC space and the server space for sure. We may see tablets and phones. With luck, it will also start to fill the periphery of the laptop and desktop space. Prices will be higher at first and then come down.

RISC-V is inevitable. And the competition that will bring will pay dividends to all of us.

LeFantome··on RISC-V is coming along quite speedily: Milk-V Titan Mini-ITX 8-core board
Get your virgin bar girls here…

https://github.com/OpenXiangShan/XiangShan

← PreviousPage 10 of 32Next →