HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

LegibleCrimson

299 karma · joined November 13, 2023

submissionscomments
LegibleCrimson··on This page knows your battery charge level (unless you're using Firefox)
I used to (NoScript, then uMatrix for years), but it is a ton of work. Just blocking problem scripts with uBlock Origin gets you 95% of and way there. The last 5% is a lot of extra effort for seriously diminishing returns.
LegibleCrimson··on Fat OCI images are a cultural problem
I think you meant "former case" rather than "latter case", but even with compiled programs it can be a little more complex, particularly for a dynamically linked program and especially if your program or libraries use dynamic loading. OpenSSL can do some dynamic loading and depend on environment variables and filesystem artifacts in surprising ways as well. If your program uses any hardcoded paths, it gets more complex as well.

I find it pretty easy to write a program to run in a very minimal docker image, but compiling existing software for the same can be quite hard, and legacy libraries and application code make it even harder. For somebody who is just learning to program, they could easily never really learn the right techniques, because the wrong ones really do just work fine for them. Like electron, these things are very wasteful, but they do work pretty reliably.

LegibleCrimson··on Making games in Go for absolute beginners
> The author seems to have been too focused on writing a "classic analogy" that has it's own URL

That doesn't track, given the sources at the beginning. One person wrote the essay, then somebody else started hosting it at that URL. There doesn't seem to be a direct connection between the writer and the URL at all.

LegibleCrimson··on The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess Decompilation
That one I get to a degree, but they've hit a lot of others for less clear benefit.
LegibleCrimson··on The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess Decompilation
Yeah, seems most likely. In the past, they've explicitly taken down distributions of things like the SM64 PC port, but left the decompilation.

Companies don't have to C&D. If something poses very little financial danger, but taking it down presents significant risk of PR harm, it's not worth it. The C&D would cost more than it would save, so it makes no business sense.

Don't ask me why they even bothered taking down fan games, though. They seem to care a lot about art assets in particular.

LegibleCrimson··on YouTube is now blocking ad blockers so I make ads run faster
> Do you still want information on the internet to be freely shareable via video?

Yes. And I'm willing to pay for it in taxes, or directly to creators and hosts, but I'm not going to pay Google after the massive amounts of abuse and anti-competitive behaviors. I will never pay Google.

> Ads are the price.

I don't accept that. Ads as "funding" for "free" content is a myth.

LegibleCrimson··on Fat OCI images are a cultural problem
We absolutely can, it's just easier to start from a distro image, install everything you might need, build the software, and call it a job done.

Multi stage images into a scratch final stage fix this, but you have to care about the problem first, and many people don't. Software with many unpredictable dependencies also makes it harder (it's a lot harder to make a really thin image if your program is python, for instance, than if it's compiled).

Edit: actually reading TFA, it's a really good description of the issue. It focuses on nix, but the problem and difficulties are much more general.

LegibleCrimson··on "Useless Ruby sugar": Argument forwarding
I disagree. In Rust it's extremely useful to be able to tell if your types are correct and the code will compile with the signatures given, and with multiple placeholders, you can iteratively replace them and test them progressively.

I use them heavily during development. Most of my new functions in progress end with an unimplemented!

I'm not sure what advantage at all could be gained by preventing it from compiling, other than to save people who copy code without even looking at it some minor inconvenience.

Edit: I suppose if you really wanted an existing macro to cause compilation to fail, you could use https://doc.rust-lang.org/std/macro.compile_error.html

But I think that's a strange use of it.

LegibleCrimson··on YouTube is now blocking ad blockers so I make ads run faster
I consider pervasive advertisement a moral wrong. I don't have to tell myself anything to know that blocking ads is the ethical thing to do. They are already a moral perversion.

Edit:

I kind of consider it disgusting that watching a video is considered by anybody to be "payment", or that anybody legitimately believes it's somebody's duty to watch an advertisement. The worship of abusive corporations in our culture has gotten insane.

You already aren't understanding us when you come in believing that we're convincing ourselves of anything. We actually do have an ethical and moral map that is consistent with blocking ads, and we don't consider not watching a commercial to be the same thing as theft, or even to be morally questionable.

LegibleCrimson··on YouTube is now blocking ad blockers so I make ads run faster
I pay for plenty of things, but I'm not going to pay an advertising giant for anything. Google is an abusive, greedy company, and I'm forced to pay too many of those in the course of daily life as it is.

When I'm given the choice, I only pay companies that I respect. If they successfully block ad blockers, I'll mute the ads and do something else while they're playing.

I'm fine paying for YouTube as soon as it's not in Google's hands. Until then, I'd consider it an ethical wrong for me to pay for it.

LegibleCrimson··on YouTube is now blocking ad blockers so I make ads run faster
And if I simply mute the ad and do something else until it's over? It's that still fraud?

How about if I download the ad but don't watch it?

Since when is watching an advertisement a moral imperative?

LegibleCrimson··on YouTube is now blocking ad blockers so I make ads run faster
Then they should. They are perfectly capable of actually making YouTube unusable without watching ads.

When they actually force me, I'm perfectly happy to mute my TV during ads and do something else, which is the exact same moral area as blocking ads.

LegibleCrimson··on Despite just 5.8% sales, over 38% of bug reports come from the Linux community (2021)
It seems obvious when you think of the numbers. When you have 100 users, 1% of them has to report a bug for it to get fixed. When you have 100k users, .0001% have to report a bug for it to get fixed.
LegibleCrimson··on Despite just 5.8% sales, over 38% of bug reports come from the Linux community (2021)
Well, yes, but that wasn't the point. It's not a complaint, just disagreeing with the premise of Gen Z being the most technologically competent.
LegibleCrimson··on test, [, and [[ (2020)
I agree. If a POSIX shell script serves your needs, use it. If it doesn't, you shouldn't be reaching for a more powerful shell, but an actual language. I'd reach for Perl before Bash, and I can't stand Perl.
LegibleCrimson··on test, [, and [[ (2020)
That bottom one will also fail. The empty string is not treated as a shell word.

You need double quotes.

LegibleCrimson··on Is it legal to mix cash in a jar? How is Bitcoin mixing any different?
If you have $100 in $10 bills from an unknown source and suspect that it might have come from illegal activity, stick it into a jar where 100 people have each put $100, and then pull out $100 at random in an attempt to disconnect from its potentially illegal nature, that is called money laundering.

If you know that your money is legally obtained and put it in the same jar (for privacy purposes, for instance), you probably know that you are facilitating somebody else's money laundering (but are unlikely to be charged for it).

LegibleCrimson··on Is it legal to mix cash in a jar? How is Bitcoin mixing any different?
It would work the same if you were transferring other non-currency assets as well and trying to mask that it was illegally obtained. Stolen goods get sold all the time.
LegibleCrimson··on Is it legal to mix cash in a jar? How is Bitcoin mixing any different?
Sort of. If one person has been paid in crypto for a contract killing and other participants either know that they are facilitating the laundering of illegally-obtained money or suspect as such, then they are culpable.

I haven't really been paying much attention to the mixer thing and I'm not an expert, but the gist is that if you build a big cash blender with the explicit purpose of masking the origin of money, then you are very clearly and willfully facilitating money laundering. If you participate in this money blender, then you are probably assisting in money laundering. The whole thing is shady by nature.

LegibleCrimson··on 'AI' Is Supercharging Our Broken Healthcare System's Worst Tendencies
Fair enough, and I appreciate the extra perspective.

I wouldn't deny that many of these things have improved. Very little actually gets worse in a literal sense (environmental issues and other negative externalities aside, though they are very relevant as well). The concern is that they tend to get marginally better when they should by all means be getting significantly better, because the lion's share of the benefits feed the ever-widening wealth gap.

LegibleCrimson··on A secret deal let Spotify bypass Android's app store fees
Technically, that one also omits the rest of the letter, which is more measured and less punchy anyway, pointing out that many rebellions themselves are founded in ignorance.
LegibleCrimson··on A secret deal let Spotify bypass Android's app store fees
That doesn't make much sense to me. Modems existed before the AT&T breakup. You can't encode a digital signal for transmission ever an analogue medium without a modem, and a modem seems entirely beside any point of a free internet to me.
LegibleCrimson··on A secret deal let Spotify bypass Android's app store fees
Maybe that "tree of liberty" quote accurately applies to corporate hegemony as well.

The tree of the free market must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of corporate tyrants.

LegibleCrimson··on Seven signs of ethical collapse (2012)
They appear to from the outside. Most of the examples of ethical collapse that I'm aware of weren't entirely clear until after the organization collapsed and the dirty laundry went public. A lot of these would either be actively suppressed or they'd only be clear to people who are inside the organization.
LegibleCrimson··on Seven signs of ethical collapse (2012)
That's the canonical example, but it's not about age in and of itself, but the gap between the CEO that turns them from a person into an idol. It's often an age gap (especially in the past) due to the culturally-entrenched ideal of automatic respect and deference to one's elders, but it can be any gap that makes the direct reports feel like they are somehow inherently beneath the CEO in ways other than corporate rank.

The point of that sign is that the CEO's direct underlings can't even question the CEO's choices.

LegibleCrimson··on 'AI' Is Supercharging Our Broken Healthcare System's Worst Tendencies
I agree 100%. In America the capitalist dream of competition and technological innovation actually driving costs lower for the consumer has mostly just died in almost every category. Any savings are now passed onto a cabal of private equity firms and legislatively-entrenched insurance corporations.

Goodhart's Law is in full force, and the measure of business health, profit, has become the target, rather than consumer welfare and rights. Boy have we optimized for profit at the expense of anything else.

LegibleCrimson··on 'AI' Is Supercharging Our Broken Healthcare System's Worst Tendencies
It's not that black and white. There's more at play than just charges. Things can be better and still shockingly corrupt, with extreme amounts of unjustified overhead. Things are minimally better for any individual patient, while being extremely more expensive, and the insurance overhead has skyrocketed.

The question is a little bit like responding to a complaint about industrialized agriculture's effects on the environment by saying "Would you rather eat sausage from 100 years ago or now?" It's not actually that relevant to the initial complaint, and it reads like it's trying to just terminate the conversation on a loophole. Things can be better and still also be filled with many problems, particularly modern problems that weren't relevant in the time period you're comparing to.

To actually answer the question honestly, it depends on my condition. For the kind of thing I would typically see my GP for, including run-of-the-mill checkups, definitely one from 50 years ago. For any serious medical issues, modern (as long as I can convince the doctors that it's actually serious so they spend more than 30 seconds on investigation).

As far as charges go, per-capita healthcare expenditure is now over 5 times as high as it was in 1980. Are we getting a 5-fold improvement in medical care? When I go to the doctor for anything more than a checkup, 90% of my time is spent waiting, and I spend twice as much time with RNs who repeatedly ask me the same questions, before a frazzled doctor comes in, asks a couple questions, then rushes out, maybe handing me a prescription for antibiotics regardless of what my concern is.

LegibleCrimson··on 'AI' Is Supercharging Our Broken Healthcare System's Worst Tendencies
I think the point is that one of the big hype phrases is that it will decrease costs of healthcare and lower people's bills, but even if you lower the cost, there is no actual incentive to lower patient bills, so the extra value simply goes to owners and investors rather than the end consumer.
LegibleCrimson··on Typst – Compose Papers Faster
> The compiler is open source, and written in rust.

Wow, that's really appealing to me; thanks for pointing that out. I was thinking "well, this looks nicer than LaTeX, and I'm really frustrated with LaTeX, but I really don't want to jump right into a big WYSIWYG thing". Now I'm really interested. Most of the other "replacements" suffer in some big ways (Markdown and RST/Sphinx are great for structured content, but not great for meticulous control over the presentation).

$ cargo install --git https://github.com/typst/typst

...

$ printf 'Total displaced soil by glacial flow:\n\n$ 7.32 beta +\n sum_(i=0)^nabla Q_i / 2 $\n' > file.typ

$ typst compile file.typ output.pdf

And I've got a cool rendered PDF with a math formula!

I'm very keen now to see exactly how flexible, robust, and extensible this is. LaTeX can do basically anything, but you pay for the power in blood. I would love a typesetting system that isn't horribly painful to extend.

LegibleCrimson··on I will always prefer to work from home
> Has anyone ever changed their mind as a result of reading a listicle of complaints?

Maybe they should have, because people were complaining about mandatory office work for no benefit for years, especially when open office plans, and most businesses ignored it entirely until a pandemic forced them to actually evaluate it.

Most people would rather have a choice. Being told that you will be fired unless you bring your company laptop into a loud office and do work uncomfortably that you'd do more effectively and efficiently at home was insulting. You knew there was no benefit for you, the pandemic proved that, and then forced RTO regardless of all evidence and data that your own company published showing no loss in efficiency just makes you lose all trust in management.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →