HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

MWarneford

17 karma · joined August 16, 2009

CTO @ http://dubitplatform.com - Developing a virtual world platform. Used for BBC, Cartoon Network, Dorothy of Oz, and others.
submissionscomments
MWarneford··on Declassified Bunker of the USSR
Some of the pictures (http://media.englishrussia.com/112011/coldwar/coldwar003-51....) point to subway entrances. Perhaps it was built via the subway? Or at the same time?
MWarneford··on How Pixar Bosses Saved Their Employees from Layoffs
There's a beautiful coffee table book "The Pixar Story" that talks about the cash Jobs put into Pixar.

The book claims Jobs purchased Pixar for $5M and immediately invested another $5M. When he purchased the company he was also running NeXT. Pixar, like NeXT, was a computer company selling computer hardware. Both companies we're struggling and taking up a lot of Job's cash.

The story goes that Pixar started to produce more 3D animated shorts, these impressed Katzenberg at Disney who agreed to part fund Toy Story. Only to even get to that point, 6 years after Jobs purchased the company, he'd had to invest a total of $60M into Pixar. He was investing close to $1M a month.

Between Pixar and NeXT jobs was nearly broke. Although I suspect his "nearly broke" is a much bigger bank account thank my "nearly broke".

Not sure how true the story is. But that's how "The Pixar Story" tells it.

MWarneford··on Zynga Moves 1 Petabyte Of Data Daily; Adds 1,000 Servers A Week
We develop casual MMOs (think Club Penguin). These are not nearly as complex as a WOW, much closer to Farmville. In our case, like most MMOs, nearly all our messages go back and forth over persistent socket connections, not HTTP requests. Firewalls cause problems and often block persistent connections, but we can get a much much better through put.

For example, we developed a product for Turner on top of our platform. Take a worst case scenario - everyone in the game moves using arrow keys, and they're all moving. A typical room might have 25 people, each broadcasting their location roughly every 0.5 seconds. This location update is broadcast to all 24 other people in the room. So each person generates 2 messages into the server per second, but results in 48 broadcast messages per second. Of course there are 25 people in the room, all of whom are moving. So we have 2 x 25 = 50 messages into the server per second, and 48 x 25 = 1200 out going messages per second.

A typical node of our platform might support 4000 players. If each room supports 25 people then we have 160 rooms. Every second the server needs to broadcast 1200 x 160 = 192,000 or nearly 200,000 messages, and receives close to 8000 messages.

Movement packets are easy. We can route these through the system quickly, but then think about the "slow" requests, such as writes to the game state persistence store (Mongo DB) or slower still, writes to the SQL database.

With 8000 incoming messages, and a typical 64 thread processing pool each thread needs to churn through 125 messages per second. Or one message every 0.008 seconds. Those slow SQL writes might take 0.5 second, during which time 0.5/0.008 = 62 messages have backed up.

Many of our games (and im inferring Zynga's) store huge amounts of persistence / state data. Where has the player been, whats completed, timers, friends, etc, etc. Much more than you'd imagine - and thats not including the analytics data. These slower writes very quickly add up and reduce throughput.

Of course there are lots of things to optimise the number of messages, but this starts to give an idea for how quickly messages back up in a MMO type environment.

If you've bothered to read this far you might be interested in a short blog post I wrote about our casual MMO architecture http://dubitplatform.com/blog/2010/3/4/under-the-hood-dubit-...

MWarneford··on Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal It From Wikipedia
Seriously, this level of attention doesn't seem to be rational anymore.

The guy is trying to build a business that creates jobs, and hes putting some of his own capital on the line to do it. Thats the most important point here - he's making jobs.

The guy isnt selling blood diamonds or anything, at worst he's gaming a search engine. Sure, he's using some wikipedia content to run some tests. But, haven't the same people on here also run tests on their businesses - maybe incomplete features, bugs, overselling, trying to keep up. Thats all part of building something from nothing.

Give him a break - he's trying to create more jobs, but hes from a position where doesn't have to bother.

MWarneford··on Template virtual world (or freemium) business model, spreadsheet included
There is an excel model included in the post, I'd love your feedback to make this model better. I'm hoping that we can help other entrepreneurs who are building freemium businesses understand the relationships between the metrics, and how to build them into a useful model.
MWarneford··on Ask HN: How to estimate (best case) early user growth?
I agree with the general sentiment that traction beats a prediction, however, I think its valuable to understand the relationship between the key metrics before you start.

Thats not to say that your model will match reality, but its certainly valuable to understand the dynamics involved.

I'm working on a series of blog posts that develop a virtual world business model. However, the principles also translate to freemium & social business too.

I recently wrote a post (with google spreadsheet) illustrating how the addressable market size (network carrying capacity) effects the viral growth of your application.

The theory goes that as the network becomes saturated the viral invites, paid acquisition, etc starts to fall on players who have already evaluated your service. Over time the success of your marketing and viral actives decline.

Check out the post at: http://dubitplatform.com/blog/2009/7/30/calculate-how-the-ad...

The google spreadsheet linked in the post illustrates how I've set about modeling viral growth, paid acquisition, ARPU, churn, and so on.

The model applies to any viral application - but its worth noting that products relying on advertisements can expect a significantly lower ARPU, knocking into your paid user acquisition.

You may also find this post interesting: http://dubitplatform.com/blog/2009/7/26/calculate-how-much-y...

It goes through the relationship between ARPU, LTV, and how your viral coefficient effects how much you can afford to spend acquiring a new player.

I think paid acquisition is a under utilized strategy within social networks - Zynga aggressively bought FBK users.

Hope it helps!

MWarneford··on Business plan: how to model visitors per hour from multiple geographies
Agreed. I would also argue that the audience will significantly effect the 'width' of the distribution.

For example, lets imagine we're building a model that will be used to predict the hosting costs for a website for tweens. I think it would be fair to assume that most tweens will be in bed by 9PM, and can only start accessing your site after school from 4PM. Note im in the UK, school finishes around 4ish...

Given that limited visiting window, we might assume that the normal distribution would have a mean around 6:30PM and a standard deviation of around 2, to 2.5 hours.

In this way 68% of our traffic would occur in the 4PM while 9PM - or within one standard deviation from the mean.

MWarneford··on Business plan: how to model visitors per hour from multiple geographies
That would be fascinating, thanks.

Screen shots of daily traffic from different geographies would be amazing. I'm interested to know if the traffic flow is normally distributed for a given geography - or if there is a better approximation.

MWarneford··on Business plan: how to model visitors per hour from multiple geographies
I know its 'crude' to post ones own article, but I'm hoping the community can highlight flaws and improve the spreadsheet in the post.

I'm working to build a template open source virtual world (or freemium) business model. I feel there are too few resources - I'd like to make it easier for entrepreneurs. This is the smartest community I know. So I figured a great place to get the needed feedback!

BTW - my first post, but been reading the site for years, way way before TC first posted http://www.techcrunch.com/2008/03/10/little-known-hacker-new...