HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Mediterraneo10

8,206 karma · joined April 16, 2017

submissionscomments
Mediterraneo10··on Excess Deaths in 2020
> Overwhelmed hospitals would enforce the same.

Not necessarily. There is always the option of triaging COVID victims into palliative care (which can be very fast and administered even by non-specialist personnel) and away from intensive care. While that has never been official policy due to the political optics, there have been claims that it was done on a hospital-by-hospital basis in Italy and Sweden for elderly victims. If the voting public were clearly informed that it was an option they could choose as an alternative to lockdowns, it may well have seen significant support from the population.

Mediterraneo10··on Vegan cheese has quietly but steadily infiltrated mainstream supermarket shelves
Note that the The China Study book a few years ago (and its accompanying cookbooks) brought some people to adopt a solely plant-based diet, but without necessarily referring to themselves as "vegans". Of course, people following such movements may still be a minority of all plant-based-diet eaters, but they are out there if you search beyond fora calling themselves specifically vegan fora.
Mediterraneo10··on Vegan cheese has quietly but steadily infiltrated mainstream supermarket shelves
There is a wing of the ethical-vegan community who disapprove of meat substitutes, arguing that we will never truly do justice to our animal brothers and sisters until we have lost the very appetite for their flesh. So, it is not just those who eat vegan out of health concerns, who are concerned about meat substitutes.
Mediterraneo10··on Vegan cheese has quietly but steadily infiltrated mainstream supermarket shelves
"Cheese product" doesn’t necessary mean vegan. It could be that it contains cow milk, just not to an extent required to legally be sold as "cheese" according to the given country’s legislation.
Mediterraneo10··on DPA blocks facial recognition system in Italy and MP proposes moratorium
> passwords are protected under the 5th amendment

This is not the case, at least, the law is not very settled in that direction. There has been at least one famous case [0] where an appeals court found that a defendant could be help in contempt of court and imprisoned for refusing to provide his password.

[0] https://www.theregister.com/2017/03/20/appeals_court_contemp...

Mediterraneo10··on Flu has disappeared worldwide during the Covid pandemic
This is why a tiny fringe of epidemologists has been calling for social distancing to continue for the next several years at least, even after COVID, because they see this as a chance to wipe out other common illnesses. If a person hyperspecializes in a field like epidemology, there is the risk of the person expecting all government policy to revolve around their specific concerns. Sometimes in interviews those epidemologists simply seem oblivious to the effect this will have on live music, theatre, cafes and restaurants, etc., other times they say that we simply cannot allow ourselves those things any more, because saving lives is more important.
Mediterraneo10··on Where does a candle go when it burns?
There have been occasional grumblings for a couple of years now that the humour of the XKCD webcomic has declined, Munroe just doesn’t seem to have his mind on the job now that he is doing these other projects. However, the what-if and pop-science explanatory stuff is generally of very good quality, so on balance one can’t really complain.
Mediterraneo10··on What Snoop Dogg’s Success Says About the Book Industry
It extends to music as well. Consider the acclaimed jazz label ECM. Some of its recordings of more obscure jazzmen sell only a few hundred copies, not even covering production costs. But a Keith Jarrett record will sell so many thousands of copies that it can subsidize other releases on the label.
Mediterraneo10··on India Is What Happens When Rich People Do Nothing
> India's fundamental problem is that it is overpopulated

In the early millennium, while traveling for several months in India and being shocked at the situation in states like Uttar Pradesh, I would occasionally ask Indians I met if overpopulation was not seen as a problem. The response was often that India’s mighty population is what will let it throw its weight around globally in the 21st century, and claims that India is overpopulated are a Chinese or Pakistani (or both) plot.

I wonder if this belief has only strengthened with the more nationalist government in recent years, and the even greater tension with China.

Mediterraneo10··on Pfizer is testing a pill that, if successful, could cure Covid-19
Freedom to travel. From my European perspective, COVID deaths suck, but we cannot return to hard borders. It risks reigniting old nationalist conflicts and it undermines Europeans’ ability to join together and meet 21st-century global challenges. We need people frequently crossing the border for work, shopping, and leisure, so that they interact with their neighbors. We need young people starting relationships with people in other countries and raising families. While there have been some restrictions on movement in Europe in the last months, they have generally never been too strict. And thankfully they are being lifted now, much earlier than the aforementioned extreme wing of public-health advisors advocates.

Australia’s policy of a hard lockdown followed by strict hotel quarantines worked for Australia, but it wouldn’t work here, and it is always tone-deaf when Australians recommend it as some kind of universal solution.

Mediterraneo10··on Pfizer is testing a pill that, if successful, could cure Covid-19
> There's repatriate flights weekly out of both NZ and AU.

What if you are not taking a "repatriate flight", but rather you are simply an Australia citizen who wishes to travel abroad e.g. to see family or be with a lover? My understanding is that Australia has forbidden its own citizens from freely leaving the country over the last year.

And having to do a strict hotel quarantine upon reentering definitely does not qualify as being able to freely travel, and as I said in my original post above, many people would not stand for it. Most European countries that require quarantine, for example, allow one to do it at home and it is easily gamed.

Mediterraneo10··on Pfizer is testing a pill that, if successful, could cure Covid-19
In the case of Australia and New Zealand, travel has reopened only because both of those two countries managed a successful early lockdown and adopted a "zero COVID" approach. But since most countries in the world did not, those living in the "zero COVID" countries would be prevented from freely traveling to all those countries to see loved ones.

With regard to the proposal that borders stay closed – except for strict hotel quarantine – until some indefinite date a few years from now when COVID has been eradicated not just locally but worldwide and there is no more threat of variants, see, for example, the interviews which Devi Sridhar (one of the main advisors to the Scottish government and a fan of Australia’s approach) gave over the last several months.

Mediterraneo10··on Pfizer is testing a pill that, if successful, could cure Covid-19
Resistance to the COVID approach you admire extends beyond the USA to also many in UK and Europe. The problem is that even if a hard lockdown works and COVID is completely eradicated in one’s local area, that means that the borders have to stay closed lest new cases be imported. But many people have families or lovers across borders, they might even commute or do common shopping cross-border, and the lower and middle classes cannot afford the expensive hotel quarantine required. Tourism-based economies need travelers bringing all that money in.

(One might think that borders would only have to stay closed until local vaccination has been rolled out. However, several of the scientific advisors recommending the "zero COVID" approach à la Oz and NZ, also want borders closed – except for strict hotel quarantine – for some years into the future to prevent variants from arising, or even in perpetuity to prevent the next pandemic from ever starting.)

Mediterraneo10··on Never Pay for Online Dating (2010)
> I'm assuming it doesn't mean being capable of basic sexual activity, because that seems like a given for 90% of potential couples

I would suspect that more than 10% of women complain about a male partner being unwilling to perform oral sex on them, or bad at it, even though this might be very important for them and the main way they can orgasm. Men, too, complain about women’s ability or receptiveness to things they need for satisfying sex.

Mediterraneo10··on Never Pay for Online Dating (2010)
> if you wanted to meet somebody you probably went to a nightclub

I'm sure that I have seen somewhere here before some hard statistics on where partners meet in Western countries – maybe someone still has a link. In spite of the existence of known meat markets, those meat markets are not the source of most of the population’s relationships. Instead, people come together through mundane things like friends of friends, people at work, people in the neighbourhood, classmates, etc.

Mediterraneo10··on Why Governments Fail
> Why is it that people think refusing to wear a mask transforms them into Braveheart, fighting for freedom against oppression?

1) In my country, some of the same scientific advisors to the government on the COVID response, are also criticizing the government for requiring masks to be worn outdoors in deserted streets, even though the science says that the risk of transmission there is negligible. They say that this kind of "hygiene theatre" can ultimately diminish the state's authority to mount efforts that truly matter to stopping the spread. A problem is that the outdoor mask law also appears to discourage outdoor exercise (even if people could exercise in a mask, the psychological barrier is real), and exercise is something public-health experts naturally want to encourage, even during the pandemic.

2) In some countries, the authorities have eased up on restrictions, or kept them on the books but ceased enforcing them, after the broad population flaunted them. Ruling parties are sensitive to what the population is willing to accept, lest unpopular restrictions cost them the next election.

Now put those two facts together, and people refusing en masse to wear a mask outdoors (while continuing to responsibly wear masks in crowded open areas and in indoor spaces like shops and other people’s homes) might be effective in ending a measure that even actual public-health experts say is pointless and oppressive.

Mediterraneo10··on We were promised Strong AI, but instead we got metadata analysis
Google page ranking depends on how long people spend on the webpage, so if you have to wade through longform text, it mistakenly assumes that the content is quality.

Note that most recipe blogs are fake. Someone wrote the original content long ago. Then, someone else hired a copywriter off a freelancing platform to change the words of the text just enough to avoid copyright violation, then put up a new copycat website loaded with SEO and ads. Look closely and notice how the author’s bio says e.g. "Born and bred in Lousiania and I love to share southern cooking", but the text contains grammatical mistakes typical of Eastern Europeans or Southeast Asians.

The ecosystem is already so advanced that new copycat recipe websites are often based on previous copycat recipe websites.

Mediterraneo10··on Feynman, Harassment, and the Culture of Science
I'm not sure Feynman is still safe. For example, there is the matter of his visiting topless bars. A common position today is that women who choose sex work should not be shamed (because that denies their own agency, and in the case of prostitution keeping things underground only helps trafficking), but at the same time the men who visit sex workers should be shamed for objectifying the female body.
Mediterraneo10··on Feynman, Harassment, and the Culture of Science
As the author notes (and as people note on the other front-page Feynman thread today), some of the negative aspects are found in Feynman’s very own autobiographical writings. It is therefore hard to claim that they are overlooked.
Mediterraneo10··on Feynman, Harassment, and the Culture of Science
The author writes, far down in the article after extensively criticizing Feynman, “None of this is to paint Feynman as a villain”. I feel this is disingenuous. Surely the author understands that what most readers will take away from articles like this is “historical figure X who had a great reputation for decades, actually did terrible things [and so maybe he shouldn’t have that great reputation].”

IMO, the only way that a nuanced portrayal of such historical figures could be given, is to write a more general biographical overview of the person and include the negative aspects in there among all the other facets. Not writing an article that focuses specifically on the negative aspects, that does have the effect of, firstly, character assassination, and secondly, shaming people today who continue to admire the figure for his/her overall achievements (because "how could you possibly admire someone who did unacceptable behaviour X to group Y?").

Mediterraneo10··on The Slander Industry
You need more than GPT3-generated text. As the article notes, slander sites often feature photos of specific individuals, taken from their social media profiles or other sources, and sometimes cropped in some way to make the target look even more ridiculous.
Mediterraneo10··on The Slander Industry
I’m kind of surprised at the absence of Scientology from the article. They pioneered slander sites in the early millennium in order to attack their critics, and they had excellent SEO-fu that would usually make the slander sites rank higher than the target’s own site. Because they have branched out into other businesses to bring in money, upon seeing the title of this article I half-expected them to be offering services to third parties in this vein, too.
Mediterraneo10··on InfiniTime 1.0
The PineTime is a very underpowered device that is really only capable of showing messages from a nearby smartphone. It doesn’t even run Linux, it runs a low-footprint firmware. Don't expect to video chat through it.
Mediterraneo10··on Toronto carpenter builds 'tiny shelters' for the homeless. The city isn't happy
Romania has its plethora of (mainly Roma) shantytowns across the country, like Pata Rât which you link. But reasons why no one resorts to tents on a sidewalk are e.g. 1) weather in Romania is more or less the same across the country, unlike California which draws homeless from across the country for its clement weather, and 2) the Romanian authorities are more hands-off with enforcing building codes in Roma settlements, so you can erect actual buildings.

Also, perhaps emigration to Western Europe has served as a safety valve for homelessness. Some down-and-out Romanians can move to Italy or Spain and immediately improve their prospects. Down-and-out Americans, on the other hand, have nowhere to go so easily.

Mediterraneo10··on Suicide has become rarer during the pandemic
> constant covering of everyone's facial expressions (no smiles)

I have noticed little sympathy for this here on HN, as well as in interviews with scientific advisors to my own government (who tell the journalist things like "masks are just a thin little layer of fabric, they have no drawbacks whatsoever!"). Often people point to Asia as a reason people should not feel any unease in a mask, but the smile famously plays a rather different role in Asian body language than in the West.

Mediterraneo10··on Simone Weil and the Need for Roots
Your idealistic vision sounds well and good. But what if you refuse to conform to cisgender- and heteronormativity, but your neighbour is a bigot? What if you are a politically active citizen, but your neighbor’s politics are hostile to yours? (Note that the rise of the Nordic welfare states in fact helped to smooth out some political polarization that was hurting those societies in the early 20th century.) In the past, neighbourly help often was refused to people like that. And what if you are a very introverted person who simply doesn’t want to interact with people outside your comfort zone?

Also, “bored and depressed bureaucrats” and “Kafkaesque rules” is a caricature, it may not be how others perceive their country’s welfare state. Satisfaction in fact may run high.

Mediterraneo10··on Simone Weil and the Need for Roots
Definitely, but the point is that society found a way for neighbours to assist each other, without requiring individual neighbours to know (and carefully maintain friendships with) their individual neighbours. Of course support for this model could possibly weaken over time, but I think many people find the welfare state superior to the old way that took more effort and would only benefit you if you conformed to expectations.
Mediterraneo10··on Simone Weil and the Need for Roots
> I would argue that rental buildings with high turnover rate ... while those owned by their residents

Note that in the Finnish context (at least in the more-populated south), this isn’t a rental/owned distinction. that is, the expectation for privacy also applies to blocks of flats where residents own their flat and may live there for decades.

Mediterraneo10··on Simone Weil and the Need for Roots
But if you live in a successful welfare state, what need have you for help from your neighbours? The welfare state might help you even better, as it can benefit from economies of scale, and it will not demand anything in return from you except, once you are working a normal job, your taxes. Also, depictions of pre-welfare-state help from neighbours often underscore how that help was always conditional: sexual and racial minorities, women with children out of wedlock, people not members of the locally dominant church or political wing, etc. often found their pleas for help rejected.
Mediterraneo10··on Simone Weil and the Need for Roots
Not knowing one's neighbours may seem like a problem to you, but it can be a great thing for others. So many young people who move from close-knit small towns or villages to big cities (especially, but not only, sexual minorities), find it liberating that no one is scrutinizing their lifestyles like back home.

Also, countries like Finland manage to be high-trust and relatively homogeneous societies, while at the same time having strong expectations for privacy in a block of flats, where neighbours might find it uncomfortable and intrusive if you tried to interact with them.

← PreviousPage 9 of 34Next →