HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

MentatOnMelange

217 karma · joined August 22, 2016

submissionscomments
MentatOnMelange··on Pete Hegseth appoints Elon Musk to US taskforce on future of warfare
If Elon Musks wants to help the US military, all he has to do is start paying taxes and compete for government contracts based on merit rather than gladhanding politicians.
MentatOnMelange··on AI tools generated nearly $1B in extra costs, Blue Cross insurers say
Is this really a bad thing? It isn't a cost, this is an extra billion dollars in revenue for hospitals.

This means the hospitals can hire more doctors/nurses, expand their hours, buy new medical devices, etc etc. Unlike when insurers use AI to deny coverage, which wastes the time of patients and hospital staff dealing with endless, needless busywork appealing.

MentatOnMelange··on Dutch central bank moves share of gold from U.S., Canada to London
https://www.kitco.com/news/article/2025-02-11/unseen-forces-...

A year ago the opposite was being reported on. No clue of the relative numbers, but its telling none of the stories about this are providing the long-term data.

MentatOnMelange··on The US Escalates Its Assault on Brazil's Free-to-Use Digital Payments System
I recently figured out buying a pack of gum at the closest grocery store and using cash-back at the register is actually a cheaper way to get cash than the ATM outside the store charging $3 for a withdrawal.

I dare anyone to tell me with a straight face that this is a well-run, efficient system we have going. Profit-seeking in capitalism is meant to incentivize new ideas and greater efficiency. Currently though its mostly incentivizing throwing a wrench in any solution that leads to less profit. The tail is wagging the dog.

MentatOnMelange··on Polymarket apologizes for allowing wagers on fate of U.S. pilots downed in Iran
Thats my point, the law has not caught up to new forms of gambling. The fact its legal to bet on whether another human being will live or die is not due to society condoning it. It's because when laws against such barbaric practices were implemented, nobody imagined they'd need to worry about people gambling on bad things happening to other human beings.

This is in part how creating laws is supposed to work. You legislate things when either something bad is happening or is likely to begin happening soon. When something new is comparable to existing unethical practices, the fact we have to update the laws is not an excuse for it being legal. Its just that the alternative is making laws based on whims or conjecture of what might happen.

MentatOnMelange··on Polymarket apologizes for allowing wagers on fate of U.S. pilots downed in Iran
Just because gambling in general is legal doesn't mean every possible gambling event is legal. If someone got caught hosting a dog fight, they don't get off the hook because gambling is legal. I can't think of a single reason why such laws against unethical or violent gambling shouldn't extend to human suffering as well.
MentatOnMelange··on The Wyden Siren Goes Off Again: We’ll Be “Stunned” By What the NSA Is Doing
You realize that without the door it would be even more obvious whether the stall is occupied?
MentatOnMelange··on How Warhammer became one of Britain’s biggest companies
I agree completely, the game would get boring if things didn't constantly change. It was more-so the way they'd go about it, not the general sales strategy. Perhaps I should have said overpowered, typically they'd intentionally overcorrect so a unit would go from too weak to way too strong.

It didn't help they had 2 very different philosophies in the creative/design department. For example if an army was getting a revamp, competitive players would pray Gav Thorpe wasn't in charge of it. Whereas other people loved how he made the game more fun and goofy.

MentatOnMelange··on How Warhammer became one of Britain’s biggest companies
I used to play warhammer when I was younger and am honestly astounded gamesworkshop is still in business let alone one of Britain's biggest companies. At least in the 00s and 2010s, they were the epitome of a greedy corporation squeezing blood from a stone.

Sales were down? Increase the prices of everything. Something not selling well? Change the game rules to make that it more powerful (or conversely, hype it up constantly so people only realize it sucks after they buy it). And of course constant changes so it was likely any models you bought would eventually become uncompetitive due to new, flashier, more overpowered things released.

Basically every bad business practice we see now was Games Workshop's wheelhouse. And while this may come across as bashing on them, I'm psyched to hear the company is thriving because their games are immensely fun and its impressive they've avoided stagnating or run out of ideas. It gives me hope for the software industry because if an in-person, expensive niche hobby could survive through social media and the pandemic, tech can bounce back from the current enshitification and short-term profit seeking.

If you have the money and enjoy lots of lore/worldbuilding and complex strategy games, Warhammer is a fantastic hobby I'd recommend checking out

MentatOnMelange··on [dead]
When Biden tried to forgive everyone's student debt, the supreme court ruled it exceeded his constitutional power.

So how on earth could the government legally garnish peoples wages for private debt?

MentatOnMelange··on European military personnel arrive in Greenland as Trump says US needs island
Trump has been very open in his admiration of Andrew Jackson and emulating him. Its no mystry what would happen to the Greenlanders if Trump took Greenland.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trail_of_Tears

MentatOnMelange··on European military personnel arrive in Greenland as Trump says US needs island
Imagine how much better things would be if we did have that discussion. Lets not make the same mistake twice
MentatOnMelange··on European military personnel arrive in Greenland as Trump says US needs island
We had the capability to capture Iraq and Afghanistan too. Occupying a territory is the actual hard point. For one, Greenland is in the middle of nowhere compared to everywhere else the US has to keep eyes on, whereas its in the back yard of Canada and the UK.

More importantly though, its an incredibly cold and unhospitable place thats inhabited by 50k people whose little kids have more arctic survival skills than US special forces and who really, really don't want us there. Unlike Afghanistan, you can't patrol the skies nonstop with drones either due to the cold.

Basically, this isn't a choice between owning Greenland or keeping all our allies. Its a choice between keeping all our allies vs getting bogged down into the ultimate guerilla war and suddenly having nothing but hostile neighbors to the north.

MentatOnMelange··on European military personnel arrive in Greenland as Trump says US needs island
I don't think you can capture a >800k square mile island in the same way you can kidnap a dictator.
MentatOnMelange··on Why almost no homes burned in LA have been rebuilt since last year's fires
Wouldn't they just burn down again?.. if this were any other properties besides high-priced real estate, people would be up in arms at the thought of government prioritizing rebuilding homes in wildfire zones.
MentatOnMelange··on A plea for Silicon Valley to enter politics
Thank you for this comment! I am not a resident of California, I just read the news and the complaints I hear from people who do live there tend to sync up. I still have very little sympathy for the calls to outrage but thats a much more reasonable perspective.
MentatOnMelange··on A plea for Silicon Valley to enter politics
So apparently the mass homeless crisis, forest fires, mismanaged water rights, declining schools, healthcare being taken away... all of that was just background noise until suddenly the state has crossed a line expecting fair returns for people who profited from the state the most?
MentatOnMelange··on Major Streaming Services Try to Take Pirate Sites Down Globally via Indian Court
A while back there was some investigative report on a private intelligence agency based in India that revealed a lot of dirty laundry on an international scale. Nothing too scandalous but it shone a light on a company that wanted to stay in the shadows. Based on an Indian court ruling, even American media sources had to take the story down. Worldwide.

Regardless of whether you think these kinds of orders are justified, allowing 1 country's court to restrict speech worldwide is a pandoras box. Nobody will be happy with the longterm implications of doing this.

MentatOnMelange··on Most of Iran Shuts Down as Government Grapples with Protests and Economy
I believe their currency is under the direct control of the politicians/clerics running the country, and the government doesn't seem too concerned with the country. So its plausable they could be bribed to change monetary policy.
MentatOnMelange··on Suddenly Everyone Is Scared to Dance at Concerts and Clubs
I think drinking is declining for the same reason as dancing... any situation involving relaxing in a social way has gone from "what do the people around me think of me?" to "how could someone make what I'm doing look stupid to get upvotes/likes on social media?"

edit: It deserves mentioning the level of drinking involved in socializing was never a good thing and I think everyone is more aware of the dangers now.

MentatOnMelange··on I'm graduating with a Computer Science degree but I don't know how to program
This title really needs a (2010) added.. the question/answer is from 15 years ago
MentatOnMelange··on Australia's social media ban in chaos as youths flock to Chinese alternatives
This is a strong argument in favor of hardware-based verification. Just force everything in the app store to verify whether a iphone is "child-locked" in some way. Also makes it much harder to bypass by users. And of course no risk of having your personal information exposed by data breaches that way.
MentatOnMelange··on Solution to US debt crisis is severe austerity triggered by a fiscal calamity
The alternative, letting the deficit grow while continuing to cut taxes, hasn't worked out either though
MentatOnMelange··on Solution to US debt crisis is severe austerity triggered by a fiscal calamity
Its amazing to me how many people find the thought of societal collapse more palatable than raising taxes on corporations and capital gains.
MentatOnMelange··on Donald Trump privately invested in companies that benefit from his policies [pdf]
My first reaction was almost "what else is new" but truth is that republicans and the left have mostly been in agreement about stopping politicians using insider information to play the market.

This kind of thing only becomes the new normal if we let it.

MentatOnMelange··on US Army to buy 1 million drones, in major acquisition ramp-up
I'm struggling to find an academic source to provide any level of detail beyond confirming this basic fact, but Germany and Britain's economic ties before WW1 were actually not too different. They were rivals but also major trading partners.

I won't try to shoehorn the past into the present, but for the very specific point about intertwined economies, it has in fact happened before.

MentatOnMelange··on New Report says UC students unprepared [pdf]
"Between 2020 and 2025, the number of students whose math skills fall below middle-school level increased nearly thirtyfold, reaching roughly one in eight members of the entering cohort."

How is this even possible? Its insane to me that they've giving high school diplomas to people with middle-school level math skills, let alone college.

MentatOnMelange··on Palantir CEO Says a Surveillance State Preferable to China Winning the Al Race
America becoming a surveillance state means China has won. If not in terms of global power, then certainly in terms of their ideology vs ours.
MentatOnMelange··on Federal Judge Survey: Warns of Judicial Crisis, Faults SCOTUS Emergency Orders
The supreme court sets the ethical tone for the entire judiciary, since they're the final say in court rulings and usually (not always) highly respected jurists. In terms of a code of ethics, this survey is like jaywalking while there's a riot happening.
MentatOnMelange··on Top US billionaires' collective wealth grew by $698B in past year – report
People are able to take out loans using their stock as collateral. Why sell when you can borrow against them for tax-free hard cash?
Page 1 of 3Next →