HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

MillenialMan

280 karma · joined May 23, 2021

submissionscomments
MillenialMan··on The Problem of Marital Loneliness
In my opinion the issue with pop-psych marketing constructs is that there are kernels of truth embedded within a misleading superstructure. They tend to leave you worse off because the structure (which is wrong, incomplete, misleading) is bundled with the kernels of truth. They also usually purport to be rosetta stones. There are exactly five love languages, and humans happen to each speak a different variety of them? Hmmmmm.

Another example: what if someone feels "loved" when they're bought gifts, but that's because they're materialistic, a gold digger? Likewise if someone wants to be touched because they're more interested in sex than a relationship, and they derive validation from your sexual interest. "It's just their Love Language" is technically correct, but it's the wrong lens to apply to those situations.

MillenialMan··on The Problem of Marital Loneliness
I'm not talking about the thrill of a new relationship. I would define a feeling of old, secure warmth towards your partner of 50 years as romance, and your satisfaction in a 50-year-old relationship is primarily a function of whether you have that. That's the kind of thing that makes someone happy to take care of their wife for 5 or 10 years as she suffers through alzheimers.

But in any case, romance is absolutely the basis of a relationship, otherwise you could marry your best friend. If you don't have it, you're likely to be dissatisfied. Of course it can wane - but that's also why you work to get it back, because if it goes away for good, your relationship is going to suck.

MillenialMan··on The Problem of Marital Loneliness
"The Five Love Languages" is literally trademarked. It's a framework that's designed to sound plausible, like a horoscope. It's not designed to be accurate, it's designed to make you go, "oooooh" and repeat the trademark. "Having relationship issues? Oh, have you heard of the Love Languages®? I read about it the other day..."

If your partner doesn't want to touch you, what's the most likely explanation? That they "don't speak your love language", or that they aren't attracted to you?

Ok, and if you are that partner, but you don't want to lose the relationship, what's an easy response? "I don't want to touch you because I don't find you attractive," or "I'm sorry babe, I do love you, but we just don't speak the same love language"?

The whole thing is very Cosmo. It's designed to sell in the same way as Cosmo.

MillenialMan··on The Problem of Marital Loneliness
I think this is true, but it really comes down to: how much do you and your spouse like each other?

If you both like each other, you'll want to give, and the relationship is probably going to feel mutually fulfilling. If it's not mutual, you won't want to give, even if you force yourself, and you'll resent doing things for them.

Honestly I think all these reframings are a way of avoiding the basic fact that the main source of satisfaction in a relationship is just: how much you're romantically into the other person, and how much they return that. Throw trust in too, since that's sort of separate, but that's the meat and potatoes of the dish. Romance is romance, vast majority of relationship dissatisfaction I see comes from a lack of desire from one person.

MillenialMan··on China declares cryptocurrency deals ‘illegal’
You still need to attach final wallet(s) to the user, but in any case, I assume they would use Monero (or another privacy coin).
MillenialMan··on China declares cryptocurrency deals ‘illegal’
Bitcoin isn't, but Monero is.
MillenialMan··on China declares cryptocurrency deals ‘illegal’
I would think the main thing they're afraid of is that it allows Chinese citizens to operate outside the state apparatus of surveillance.
MillenialMan··on China declares cryptocurrency deals ‘illegal’
All of those things can be tracked and confiscated - crypto is a lot harder. It's volatile, but it's significantly more secure against state actors.
MillenialMan··on China declares cryptocurrency deals ‘illegal’
Drugs are the thing people have a strong incentive to accept crypto for, not pizzas.

All black markets have an incentive to use it - including state actors (e.g. weapons deals). Getting caught laundering Monero is preferable to getting caught selling missiles to the Saudis.

MillenialMan··on Germany’s no-emotion voting guide surges despite campaign of personalities
I would argue the average person is terrible at assessing bureaucratic ability but pretty good at assessing personality, so I think they're better off voting with their gut.
MillenialMan··on Germany’s no-emotion voting guide surges despite campaign of personalities
A few elections ago in the UK, a site like this got popular, where you'd answer a quiz and it would recommend the party most closely "matched" your preferences. A lot of people ended up getting recommended the green party, despite the fact the party is fairly fringe and has no real voting record. Turns out the site was set up by the Green party. Go figure.
MillenialMan··on Adults with history of recreational cannabis use have altered speech production
It's not really something researchers can control. I was commenting on the news release, and it being posted on Hacker News, because that's more of an issue.
MillenialMan··on Adults with history of recreational cannabis use have altered speech production
With such a small sample size, formal methods break down. The sample could be biased. In fact, it's almost guaranteed. The ability to p-hack (even inadvertently) is extremely high. Publication bias is also practically guaranteed. These kinds of issues void significance to a reasonably high degree.

At these kinds of sample sizes, the biggest issues are not going to be included or visible in the study. Unless the reported significance is extremely high, it's not meaningful.

MillenialMan··on London's Oyster card: Are its days numbered?
I think that's an absurd requirement to levy on tourists and oyster cards are a perfectly reasonable solution.
MillenialMan··on Adults with history of recreational cannabis use have altered speech production
The sample size was also 31 users, 40 controls. This really isn't a meaningful result.
MillenialMan··on Court issues permanent injunction in Epic vs. Apple case
I think if you offered the two options to users with even partial differences in price, most users would go for the cheaper option even if they had to do cartwheels to process payments.
MillenialMan··on London's Oyster card: Are its days numbered?
Many banks charge a hefty premium for overseas purchases, and they tend to charge per purchase.
MillenialMan··on Court issues permanent injunction in Epic vs. Apple case
Given the option, I think most customers would absolutely rather use the company's system, if the company offered lower prices for buying through them. Of course, that assumes both systems would be on offer - but if there's market pressure for companies to offer Apple as an option, that may be enough.
MillenialMan··on Many young people diagnosed with Tourette’s after watching a YouTube channel
I was actually quite careful not to say anything like "all trans people desire surgery"
MillenialMan··on Many young people diagnosed with Tourette’s after watching a YouTube channel
Many groups are social pariahs, none have a suicide rate close to the transgender community. Dysphoria by itself is clearly horrible to deal with, that's why people are willing to have double mastectomies in the pursuit of easing their mental pain. A vaginoplasty is incredibly invasive and isn't going to have a meaningful impact on day-to-day social judgement. I really don't buy the claim that it's purely or even primarily about acceptance.

I would also point out that the the trans community themselves are advocating for greater access to treatment, not less. It's really not the same as the gay rights movement. Unlike gay people, treatment is literally one of their objectives.

MillenialMan··on Many young people diagnosed with Tourette’s after watching a YouTube channel
It would probably be upvoted if it was astroturfing. Hacker News doesn't have a huge commentariat, I think it's just a few people with an axe to grind.
MillenialMan··on Many young people diagnosed with Tourette’s after watching a YouTube channel
That's sort of an arbitrary distinction. Both are abnormal presentations that cause significant problems in day-to-day life and consequently have clinics set up to treat the issue. Whether the issue is voluntary for a particular patient is also similarly important in assessing an appropriate treatment modality.

Putting the obvious political agenda aside, I would argue teenage girls faking tourettes is pretty much the same phenomenon as teenage girls faking gender dysphoria. It's not helpful to pretend that faking tragic mental conditions isn't a phenomenon among teenagers.

MillenialMan··on AI movie posters
I think many of the original posters (or stills from the movie) were just in the training data, to be honest.

Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory in particular seems to be a direct reconstruction of features from that movie.

MillenialMan··on Micro-models: purposefully overfit models that are good at one specific thing
Is that overfitting? I thought overfitting was explicitly when your model fits itself so well to the training data that its ability to generalise to your target environment begins to decline. The size of the training set and the performance on it don't really matter, all that matters is that performance in the specific environment you intend to deploy the model in starts dropping. In your case, you're training the models for a very narrow deployment target, and they remain competent.

Couldn't you use this logic to say that AlphaGo is overfit because it can only play Go, not chess?

MillenialMan··on GAN-generated facial images that are capable of impersonating multiple IDs
I mean you train your network to produce images that translate into adversarial 3d surfaces.

You don't need to produce the correct 3d surface if the surface recogniser is neural - you just need to produce a 3d surface that's adversarial. The adversarial surface could be completely unrealistic, like these adversarial images. (Although the adversarial generator could also be trained with "realism" as a constraint.)

Are they able to detect depth independent of the surface of a presented image? That would make it harder, but the point of failure then is just figuring out a way to dynamically fool them. I wouldn't be confident saying that's impossible.

MillenialMan··on GAN-generated facial images that are capable of impersonating multiple IDs
Is this true? I would have thought all you would need is to give it an input that maps to a 3d surface that's adversarial. There's an extra step in the pre-prep pipeline, but the basic technique is the same - gradient descent on inputs until you derive those that are sufficiently adversarial.

All neural nets are vulnerable to adversarial examples. It's a fundamental property they hold, because they're essentially stacked linear models. So (for example) they get more confident about their predictions when given a sufficiently out-of-domain input - adversarial training is essentially just finding paths that trigger an out-of-domain response.

I don't see how an additional transformation before input precludes that.

MillenialMan··on Where are the robotic bricklayers?
There's a build happening at the end of my road at the moment, I can see how this maps onto that. Thanks - this explains a lot.
MillenialMan··on Where are the robotic bricklayers?
This is completely untrue. Contrary to popular belief, sitting at a desk is extremely healthy in comparison to manual labour, which destroys your body over time.

Standing all day is also worse for your back than sitting all day. Even being a shop assistant is harder on your body, and particularly your back, than sitting at a desk. (Alternating, i.e. an office job with a sit/stand desk, is best.)

The primary issue is complete lack of inactivity (a large component just being weight gain), which you can combat by exercising outside of the office.

MillenialMan··on Where are the robotic bricklayers?
People already have the option to not lay bricks. They don't choose it, because they need money.

I get that everyone is going to say, "well then, UBI" but bear in mind in an automated society, power is disproportionately in the hands of the people who own the machines, and they're unlikely to part with their wealth voluntarily.

MillenialMan··on Where are the robotic bricklayers?
I don't really understand this. When I see a small house being built, it will have four or five builders on-site at all times, mostly doing labour (and they're, frankly, extremely slow. It will take months to lay the bricks). If you still need the decisions, can't you cut that down to one, or maybe two? That strikes me as a dramatic reduction in labour cost.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →