HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

MrSkelter

267 karma · joined December 8, 2023

submissionscomments
MrSkelter··on Airbnb is in midlife crisis mode
Hotel suites offer everything you mention.

At hotels you also don’t have to worry about spy cameras, upset neighbors and questionable legality.

I did use AirBnB years ago with my family and it was great. However the quality tends to reflect the country. I have had wonderful experiences in Northern Europe and the worst in San Francisco.

MrSkelter··on Wealthy Americans have death rates on par with poor Europeans
I am a dual national with roots in Europe. A far greater contributor is the lack of avoidable chronic disease in Europe. I know many middle class and above Americans who have ongoing battles with their insurance companies to treat and manage relatively mundane issues. If they apply enough time and money they can usually resolve things though often this requires pausing treatment or changing doctors recommendations.

This does not exist in Europe. What your doctors recommend happens regardless of your income.

There is an image I see when in the US. A homeless person who is crippled and pushing themselves with a stick or one leg in a wheelchair. Lame thanks to lack of treatment. You never see that in Europe. Homeless people exist but they aren’t chronically ill.

This has positive effects for everyone. There is less disease in the environment and it’s easier for people to literally get back on their feet.

It’s a bit of wishful thinking to presume Americans poor health is all lifestyle choices and advertising. It’s the system and a pervasive lack of easy to access treatment at all levels of society.

MrSkelter··on When the physicists need burner phones, that's when you know America's changed
This is a take so misguided it seems like parody.

Reading isn’t just about successfully understanding words. It’s the ability to decipher context, particularly in long texts in which metaphor and subtext are important.

You need look no further than the current crop of VCs and tech leaders who can all clearly barely read. Andreessen, Musk, Zuckerberg all love to point at classic science fiction and modern media while making comments which articulate how completely they have missed the point. When musk says the Cybertruck is “…something Blade Runner would drive” or Andreessen quotes Marinetti as a hero, or Zuckerberg unironically uses “move fast and break things” as a motto it’s clear how little of what they have read they understand.

People today are praising translations of Hitler’s speeches. They do this because they cannot connect the points he’s making to the inevitable outcomes of those attitudes. They lack the ability to see into the text and truly understand it.

That’s why a 3rd grade reading ability is a problem. Zuckerberg and Musk are dropouts. It’s shows.

MrSkelter··on xAI has acquired X, xAI now valued at $80B
Regardless of the faith you have in the courts assessment time has shown the more critical opinion to be true. Solar City was a dead company, none of the promises they made has amounted to anything, they aren’t producing any products or revenue, and the deal has been shown to be self dealing in order to bail out his brother.

Where are the solar roof tiles? What’s happened to the tax payer funded factory in NY?

MrSkelter··on The marketing genius of Bryan Johnson
Johnson is a rich “freak” and his coverage is identical to the attention lavished on other “freaks” who lack self awareness.

He’s a someone who has turned incredible good fortune into a reason to denude all simple pleasures from his life in a quest to extend it.

When he inevitably dies at a mundane age the hours of content he made will document his vanity and hubris.

MrSkelter··on Phyllis Fong, who was investigating Neuralink, "forcefully removed "
Where do you get that from? Huge numbers didn’t vote. Of those who did Trump squeaked by with a small lead but significantly less than 50% of the populace voted for him.

He has no mandate.

MrSkelter··on Phyllis Fong, who was investigating Neuralink, "forcefully removed "
And so?
MrSkelter··on Ask HN: Is onboard audio still good enough compared to dedicated Sound Cards?
Audiophiles are a self selected group. Membership has nothing to do with hearing ability. Most are of an age where they have less than “normal” hearing for a healthy child.

Audiophiles classically deliberately confuse measurable differences with audible ones. This they chase meaningless goals and convince themselves that anything which affects signal affects sound.

None of it would stand up to properly double blind testing. When it’s done things like “the sound of cables” disappears entirely outside incompetent engineering.

Even worse audiophiles tend to prefer distortion which flatters. I.e. exaggerated bass and treble to compensate for components and old ears.

MrSkelter··on Ask HN: Is onboard audio still good enough compared to dedicated Sound Cards?
This isn’t true in professional circles at all. Audio interfaces are external. There is no need to collapse the language it confers no benefit.

Audio interfaces are external because it makes it so much easier to shield them properly. Thus if someone wanted to sell a computer for professional audio work with a sound card there would be a problem.

MrSkelter··on Sweden eyes sending inmates abroad as prisons full due to gang crime wave
You are so close (you being America). Yes. Just pay for a high quality education to tertiary level and beyond for everyone. It would be much cheaper and crime would plummet.
MrSkelter··on US children fall further behind in reading
Large parts of the world don’t use a phonics system and for a long time it didn’t exist.

I am sure a properly performed study which accounted for the time spent on reading, as well as exposure to books, would demonstrate that phonics is no better than any other way of teaching reading.

My children live in a house of books, we have thousands. We read to them daily from soon after birth. They did not read early compared to their friends (though they did memorize some books which made it look as if they were reading pretty young). They didn’t start school until six and spent their early years in a bi-lingual Nordic school system before moving to the US and then Europe once again.

They now read at a very high level indeed, well above their peers. We made zero special effort. They just had access to books and libraries and live in an environment where everyone reads.

MrSkelter··on Black Swan's Taleb Says Nvidia Rout Is Hint of What's Coming
Most people have little use for LLMs. The spike is curiosity plus the system being slammed by corporations and governments doing intelligence. Open AIs impact on their servers could easily overwhelm them.

They will recover and I am sure this is more than user interest. Look at how much is being claimed by competitors already. They are absolutely hammering them right now.

MrSkelter··on One in four 2020 Tesla Model 3 failed the Danish periodic inspection in 2024
The truth is that he lied about almost everything.

He was in the US illegally, didn’t have the qualifications he claimed to (no degree and he was never in a Stanford PHD program, never matriculated there and simply has a letter from a professor he claims is proof he was accepted as a candidate - which it absolutely is not). He failed out of 4 universities. He stole the idea for zip2. He likely sold gems illegally in both Canada and the US - there are huge gaps in his story.

All of this is fairly easy to check up on and people have done the work. https://sethabramson.substack.com/p/the-truth-about-musk-fro...

He has cheated and failed up to an unprecedented degree. Fueled by a venture capital industry who realized that backing a conman selling dreams and lying is more reliable than backing an honest entrepreneur who could fail on merit.

He move to politics is the final act. The wheels have come off his cons, Tesla is failing and has no future evidenced by the total lack of a roadmap of new vehicles.

He intends to exit by making his illegal actions legal thanks to Trump.

It’s shameful how instrumental this community has been in propping up a man who history will remember as one of the greatest conmen of all time.

MrSkelter··on Florida man eats diet of butter, cheese, beef; cholesterol oozes from his body
Most of the supposed magic is simply eating high protein and fat and getting sated.

These diets work for people who will not stop eating until they feel full. As that fullness takes so much longer with processed sugary foods they consume too many calories. It’s very hard to consume 2,000 calories of red meat in one sitting.

The idea eating meat alone is healthy is totally spurious.

MrSkelter··on How shut-down Bay Area tech companies ditch their fancy gear
Very little is 100% wood, mostly because it doesn’t need to be. The best mid century furniture is typically veneered. That said the Stockholm range from IKEA comes with a 20 year guarantee and is vastly better than almost anything sold by supposedly “proper” chain furniture stores. IKEA know a lot about how and why things break and wear.
MrSkelter··on Hunyuan3D 2.0 – High-Resolution 3D Assets Generation
48 images is an incredibly small number for high quality photogrammetry. 480 wouldn’t be overkill. A couple of hundred would be considered normal.
MrSkelter··on Reverse engineering my #1 Hacker News article
TL;DR trending posts on “dumb” Reddit do just as well on “smart” Hacker News.
MrSkelter··on Starship Flight 7
Saturn 5 was landing on the moon for the second time on its seventh flight. We have access to everything that program learned and taught for free. It’s all 60 year old tech. People shouldn’t forget how shockingly tardy and poorly designed Starship is by comparison.

7 flights in and it’s still exploding in a system that will require more than 10 launches for a single lunar flight.

I am sure Musk’s groupies will assemble but the facts don’t care about your fandom.

MrSkelter··on UnitedHealth overcharged cancer patients for drugs by over 1,000%
There is no complexity to the corruption and inefficiency of US healthcare. It has the highest costs and mediocre outcomes. It offers healthcare providers incentives to act even if they shouldn’t and allows insurers to profit directly from denying care.

It’s worse in practice than any system adopted by any peer nation regardless of the wide range of differing approaches to providing universal coverage.

Treating it as some uniquely complicated problem is deceptive. It’s broken because that keeps certain people wealthy and gives employers control over labor.

MrSkelter··on WordPress Is in Trouble
There is no “we” here. It’s a man making arbitrary decisions about pineapple on pizza. There is no plan and the watch and drawn out nature is indicative of someone reacting to events rather than implementing a plan.

I have 20 years in WP and B2. This is tragic. He needs to be removed or the platform will die making a huge repository of knowledge valueless.

MrSkelter··on LA wildfires disinformation reveals limits of fact-checking
Non locals don’t understand the geography. LA is massive and spread out. There are very few straight roads in the Palisades. I would guess zero. You would need to move that seawater many miles in some way that protects the hoses from fire. Not at all simple.
MrSkelter··on Male and female brains are wired differently
Wanting a reasonable discussion of pseudoscience doesn’t make you seem very smart. I’m sure Joe Rogan will cover it.
MrSkelter··on Why is the American diet so deadly?
As a guy your height 225lbs is not “zero fat” unless you are absolutely stacked with muscle. Likely on steroids unless you are a bodybuilder and eat and train like one.

Though he was shorter, natural bodybuilder Sean Connery was 6’3” and 190lbs at the start of his bond run. That’s a useful data point. Not only is he close to an ideal male physique for non bodybuilders, he was also very fit. Ad an inch and a half to him and 35lbs and that’s not “zero fat”.

Similarly I was once depressed and 260lbs. I was definitely obese.

Things are distorted in the US. We consider fat to be morbidly obese and dismiss fatness as normal now. Look at Trump. That’s normal obesity. Loot at Musk. That’s overweight.

MrSkelter··on Air Force Tests Subscale Model of Blended-Wing Body Jet
That’s only true if you assume the volume is kept constant and the width must be used. You could use the additional space for cargo or fuel and keep a narrow central cabin.
MrSkelter··on LLMs are everything that it wrong in computing
I am not sure the Turing test has been passed or understood. Cromulent answers aren’t human ones.

LLMs enable me to write more code than I ever have and in languages I don’t know. It’s a wonder.

That said I grew up with an 8-bit machine buying games on cassette. There were never updates and rarely ever a serious bug.

Yes programs were tiny, but they were also handwritten in assembler. Quality has gone down in software with the advent of modern tools as surely as it has in furniture with the introduction of the table saw.

MrSkelter··on New research suggests that Walmart makes the communities it operates in poorer
Your anecdote isn’t really an argument.

The fact that “people didn’t cry” when a business arrived is totally meaningless when it comes to assessing the impact of a business and its model on a community.

Walmart pay subsistence wages and below. They survive via exploiting governmental support for low income individuals while funneling profit to their billionaire owners. When they become a major part of the local economy the locals lose out.

MrSkelter··on Updates to H-1B
This is a flaw in the system. Candidates from 5-eyes partners should be able to get any clearance necessary. I know from experience that Lockheed has a lot of non US nationals working on secret projects which require clearance. During the F-35 program a ton of Brits were involved, both for the avionics components made in the UK, and as test pilots for VTOl (where Brits were preferred given Harrier experience and their acknowledged skill as the best pilots of that type).

I don’t know why Brits, Canadians, kiwis and Aussies can’t get cleared for you guys. They are getting cleared at every level all the time. NSA, CIA, etc.

MrSkelter··on Updates to H-1B
I was an H1-B in the late 90s. I have been a US citizen for over a decade.

I come from an extremely wealthy Northern European country integral to founding the United States and English is my first language. I was not compelled to emigrate for a “better life”. I gave up a lot to be in the US.

H1-Bs are designed for abuse. There is no shortage of skilled workers. It’s just that immigrants are cheap.

I was hired in my country from a pool of over 500 for one of two jobs. Once accepted it took close to a year to do the legal paperwork. My sponsoring company was paying lawyers $600 an hour twenty years ago to get the work done. Despite being absolutely squeaky clean they easily invested 25k per applicant then.

When I arrived my pay tripled. I was earning 50-60k in the US and had been under 20 before. That was very low in my home country but it was a starting position and wages are lower outside the Us for myriad reasons even though living standards on low wages are higher.

The kicker was that similarly skilled Americans to myself were all earning 6 figures then. The industry I was in had a strong base in NY and the company that hired me was in LA. Their options were to pay 100k plus and relocate Americans from NY, or pay half that and relocate Europeans.

Better yet we were more qualified than the average American (as they got to pick the very best) and we were tied to them by the legal work and thus “indentured”. If we wanted to leave them we had to go home or find more sponsorship.

On arrival my colleague and I immediately realized we were both overqualified and under paid (pre internet this was much harder to discover). We ran rings round the locals. When our visas needed renewal the company “advertised” our jobs by placing printed sheet behind notice boards and claimed that was sufficient. It was a complete con.

Ironically I didn’t last very long. Given my skills and experience I found companies willing to sponsor my ViSAs and green card (which my first company sponsored for me also). So I was able to move around and establish myself.

In short the system has always been abused. The idea is good but as long as companies can choose to pay non competitive rates to immigrants they will do so and lie about the true state of the market. That’s what the system does and the purpose of a system IS what it does. It’s just lowering wages by importing skilled foreigners.

MrSkelter··on Appeal for British oak to recreate Sutton Hoo ship
Even free wood if this spec will cost an enormous sum to deliver from overseas.
MrSkelter··on Will even the most advanced subs have nowhere to hide?
Americas obsession with nuclear propulsion is a large part of the problem. You can’t switch a nuclear power plant off. It’s always making noise and vibrating. These these subs are always noisier than electric units which can be totally off and totally silent, emitting nothing.

It’s politics that demands the glamour of a huge nuclear fleet. For stealth nuclear power which makes noise constantly and is nuts radiation is an inferior choice.

← PreviousPage 5 of 8Next →