HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Obi_Juan_Kenobi

2,308 karma · joined July 22, 2014

submissionscomments
Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Towing a Tesla at 70 MPH replenishes battery at fast charger rates
Yes, there's no claim of free energy or perpetual motion here. The author even discusses approximately how efficient the charging is in the video.
Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on CRISPR Editing in Primates
> PhD over the next 6 years.

Bruh

If you shoot for 5 it might take six. If you shoot for 6 it will take 8. I know you can't read too much into such a short comment, but do some serious introspection. You're setting off like every alarm bell for someone that's about to get absolutely hosed by a doc program.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Lithium battery costs have fallen by 98% in three decades
> Mining, and refining is pretty efficient at this point

Hardly. Nickel goes through a rube-goldberg process of extraction, smelting into pure nickel, made into a sulfate, transported around the world, remade into a nickel carbonate, and finally input into cathode manufacture.

The supply chain simply isn't set up for batteries yet. Nickel metal powder is the best form to transport, and likely the best input for cathode manufacture as well. But the industry formed around the sulfate which was a mature market from other industrial use.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Vitalik escalates ETH 2.0 merge as miners plan a 51% attack
The ice age mechanic remains one of the most significant and overlooked aspects of Ethereum. It's really good.
Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Elon Musk’s $100M Gigaton Scale Carbon Removal Prize
Energy use is proportional to the revenues gained from mining.

Revenues are based on the block coinbase reward and transaction fees from transactions (txns) included in the block. The coinbase reward is currently a large majority of mining revenue, but this will decrease over time according to the coinbase halving schedule every ~4 years.

Since block capacity is arbitrarily limited to 1MB, txn throughput is limited. Therefore, all txns contribute to txn fee competition. There is a transaction fee market where users must outbid each other to ensure their txns are incorporated into the blockchain in a timely manner.

The net effect is that txn demand does contribute to mining rewards and ultimately the energy used for mining. But it is a very small effect at present:

* Txn fee competition only rarely kicks in. The network operates most of the time without substantial mempool backlog. https://jochen-hoenicke.de/queue/#0,6m This does change with market activity, and we are certainly looking at more txn fees overall in the future.

* Coinbase rewards dominate mining revenues, so the effect is proportionally small. As these rewards decrease in the future, txn effects will have bigger effects.

The upshot of all of this is a shift into a 'mature' paradigm of blockchain security funding. It's a pretty big shift and easily the biggest unknown in the future of Bitcoin. More and more, the focus will be on scaling and whether the opposing goals of affordable transactions and miner revenue (and therefore network security) can be balanced. There are also interesting technical issues such as whether txn-fee dominated revenue will present new malicious actions. Namely, whether miners can withhold blocks to gain advantage, plaguing the network with reorgs and further centralizing mining.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Powerpaste, a hydrogen technology for small vehicles
Engines combustion is designed to occur as a propagating flame front in the cylinder initiated by the spark plug. Great efforts are made to ensure that this is precisely what happens.

The alternative is a detonation, i.e. engine knocking. This causes a spike in cylinder pressure and will quickly destroy an engine. It is for this reason that engines are absolutely not trying to burn fuel as quickly as possible.

This is a difference of detonation vs. deflagration. Whether you consider both of these to be forms of explosions is a semantic issue.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on IBM has cut its blockchain team down to almost nothing – sources
I would not consider it a solution to mistrust, but rather a way to obviate it altogether.

Bitcoin is simply a way to achieve consensus about value that is secure and decentralized. Many people consider it a currency, and certainly that is true, but I think it best to consider it a network, or even better, a form of communication. You can 'speak' on the Bitcoin network in very powerful ways. You can broadcast transactions and transfer value with extraordinary security and robustness. Statements like this, without Bitcoin, require enormous effort: legal systems, governments, and ultimately armies.

This result is obviously not a technical one, but a social one. It is mediated by technology, but the rules and incentives of participation are social. You trust Bitcoin 'speech' because you understand what motivates network participants and conclude that fraud is phenomenally unlikely.

But a society that uses Bitcoin is not suddenly without trust, or even diminished in trust. It simply no longer requires trust for certain things.

____

> Societies with higher levels of trust tend to do better than others

Trust, in this sense, could be considered as a resource. More trust lets you do more things. But if you don't require trust for a function, that trust may be used for other purposes. It is in this sense that trust can be considered a liability: you have to 'spend' trust to achieve an end, and thus must maintain its supply.

A society that cooperates well can achieve more, but may also be more vulnerable if that trust should wane. To whatever extent trust and cooperation are self-reinforcing, I think history has plenty of examples of such systems collapsing to make this a worthwhile consideration.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Electric vehicles close to ‘tipping point’ of mass adoption
Simple: most people charge at night.

Sure, fast charging will add some day-time demand, but it's not much. Cheap night-time pricing keeps the charging demand off-peak.

More even demand curves make generation more economical. It becomes trivial to upgrade distribution where needed.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on SpaceX Starlink Mission #17 [video]
Payload cost >>>>>> vehicle cost, in almost all instances.

This is the actuaries factoring in what they see as less risk.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on SpaceX Starlink Mission #17 [video]
They are only visible while transitioning to their operating orbit.

They will have an effect on astronomy, but not visual observation.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Starship SN9 damaged in an accident in the high-bay
That's the problem with 'seems like'
Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on AirPods Max
Heck, even $40 true-wireless earbuds are now quite decent. They're reliable and sound quality is perfectly fine for what I want from it.

Considering the tiny batteries make these disposable items, it's pretty compelling.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Less than half of Americans know that alcohol is a carcinogen
That strikes me as a bad-faith interpretation of the history of this issue.

The reason for belief in the protective effect of alcohol consumption comes from data, not corporate propaganda. Many observational studies, conducted by a wide variety of institutions and government agencies, and consistently arrived at the conclusion that alcohol's effects on all-cause mortality (ACM) are dose-dependent, but these effects do not necessarily converge on the origin. That is, as dosage is reduced, eventually ACM dips >1 for low levels of consumption, before returning to the abstinence baseline. I.e., mild drinking is protective. There is no plausible or coherent way to suggest that these observations were due to industry influence given the wide variety of data sources, investigators, and institutions involved.

The problem with this data is one that is common to wide variety of health issues; it's very hard to observe small effects. Most of our data and understanding actually comes from relatively extreme effects; the worst smokers and drinkers, large radiation exposure, major occupational health risks like asbestos, etc. That gives us great information about the what effects these onslaughts have, but only for these extreme populations.

The next logical step is to observe less dosage/exposure and try to establish the nature of dose-dependence e.g. linear vs. some power law. The problem, however, is that experimentation is unethical, so you have to continue to rely on observational studies. But observational studies necessarily have confounding factors that can be extremely tricky to address. Furthermore, there is no authoritative way to determine whether these factors have been addressed or not.

So, despite the best and most sincere efforts of investigators, the data 'near the origin', i.e. the effects of low dosage/exposure to a potentially harmful thing, is extrapolation, not interpolation as one might believe intuitively. Even small errors - the kind that are endemic to observational studies - are amplified when considering these ranges.

The result of this is persistent controversy about issues broadly related to hormesis. The true impact of radiation releases from events like Chernobyl and famously uncertain for this same reason.

Specifically regarding alcohol, the most recent attempts to control the confounds has lead some to declare that the protective observation has been eliminated. I certainly agree that, as a health recommendation, this is the conservative interpretation and should be taken used to make health decisions. But as far as the data itself is concerned, I'm not so convinced. I still think the "J" shaped dose-response has not been adequately explained, and there are valid mechanistic hypotheses that warrant continued consideration.

But if you would like to carry on a cynical world view that neatly blames all that ails on evil corporations, by all means.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Apple Silicon M1: A Developer's Perspective
Magsafe seems less an issue now.

With a true 'all day' battery, you'll probably only plug it in at a desk where tripping or knocking things over isn't an issue. While travelling, you just charge it at night or when you aren't using it. Much more like smartphone usage.

How many people are aching for a magsafe phone charger?

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on New bike chain claims to be faster, more durable
Bike chain teeth do not have straight sides or a convolute profile. They are wedges that act as ramps for the rollers. As the chain wears, it is no longer possible for the rollers to all sit at the base of the teeth. Instead, to account for the increased pin-pin distance, they begin to ride 'up' the teeth at the point of first engagement. You can easily see this when looking at a worn cassette used with a stretched chain. The tooth profiles become sharply hooked as the roller wear works in from the 'side' of the tooth. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EFYuxlJXYAA89-b.jpg Note that the lowest point of the profile remains at the original base of the tooth, and then is angled up.

In a worn chain, the rollers engage high up, and then work their way down (under high load) until seated at the base. In the unworn condition, engagement begins at the base of the tooth where the forces are better spread over the roller.

In point of fact, the forces are spread out over more teeth when worn. The first tooth engagement might begin 3mm high, then 2.5mm, then 2mm, etc. over ~6 teeth. Whereas the fresh chain might manage 2 or 3. But the wear and friction of the worn chain is much higher as you have a great deal of motion under high load as the loaded rollers creep down. The unworn chain has perhaps higher loads, but the roller is essentially seated and immobile at the base of the gear for this.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Arecibo telescope, on the brink of collapse, will be dismantled
The Virgin Islands and Anguilla are a big problem for a PR launch site. Even commercial shipping/fishing activity downrange can present a big problem for launches, let alone populated areas.

The lower latitude is a minor help, but it's not huge. Higher elevation is entirely negligible; orbit is about going sideways fast, not going up.

The logistic challenges of operation away from manufacturing and engineering talent in the US would far outweigh any advantages.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% protection
Because RNA is not a stable molecule. At lower temperatures, it's less likely for a given bond to reach the Gibbs free energy of activation, thus preventing degradation.

In a biological context, the vast majority of RNA use falls within the 'central dogma' of DNA -> RNA -> Protein. It is merely an intermediate, albeit one with important and complex regulatory processes.

In RNA viruses and other contexts where stability is required, the RNA is stabilized by its environment, namely by associating with special proteins.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on American Airlines Is Quietly Bringing Back the 737Max
737MAX is not nor never has been dynamically/aerodynamically unstable. Full stop. No airliner is permitted to be unstable by FAA regulations. At no point in the flight envelope will the aircraft pitch up into a stall without pitch-up inputs, thus it is not unstable.

MCAS was used to augment flight stick characteristics, namely to simulate a linear relationship between flight-stick input force and pitch-up/AoA. This was, and always has been, about single-certification and pilot UX, not anything about the stability of the airplane. Having stick forces be somewhat lower than expected at high AoA does not make the plane unstable. The linear relationship is considered ideal, but many planes such as the 757 have a similar non-linear relationship. MCAS is not anti-stall.

Granted, this has widely been mis-reported. The real issue is that the MCAS system was made dramatically more powerful, and thus dangerous, over the course of development. Without a concomitant change to the reliability of MCAS inputs (namely the AoA sensors), this resulted in disaster.

https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/as-th...

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Lithuania is paying people to trade in polluting cars for escooters and ebikes
You can, and indeed many direct-drive hub systems include this, but it's not a range issue. It's more to save some brake wear. In a 'best case' scenario of many steep hills, such a system will extend range perhaps 5%. Much less in normal use.
Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Lithuania is paying people to trade in polluting cars for escooters and ebikes
Yepp seats are extremely common now. Nearly all cargo/utility bikes have compatible racks and often feature the child seats installed.
Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on What Bitcoin’s White Paper Got Right, Wrong and What We Still Don’t Know (2018)
Bitcoin has had a higher value than the current price only 6 weeks in nearly 12 years of existence.
Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Tesla Earning Result 3Q 2020 [pdf]
I genuinely cannot see how anyone can even consider that anything less than 90% of new vehicle sales will be electric in 10 years. The economics are so overwhelming .. it's not a prediction anymore, it's just reality. There are >160 giga-factory-scale projects in the works. Everything about batteries get cheaper and better, while ICEs get more expensive and complicated as we grapple with the reality that they're killing us. Not to mention future petroleum costs.

Even without any cell technology innovation, scale alone is getting us to initial cost parity (and obviously lower TCoO). But the cell technology is coming. Roadrunner alone demonstrates that. The real question is about electric aircraft that would depend on solid state, lithium-air, etc.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Vertically aligned carbon nanotubes triple the density of lithium batteries
An electric airliner would be able to operate at much higher altitudes, and thus much more efficiently.

Looking only at energy density is naive.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Tesla hacker reveals what driver-facing camera is looking for
Operating a motor vehicle on public roads is just about the most compelling reason one should have to sacrifice privacy like this.

People have, on the whole, emphatically demonstrated their complete inability to drive responsibly. ~40k deaths, hundreds of thousands of serious injuries, and nearly a trillion dollars in costs every year. Overwhelmingly due to driver error and negligence.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on My wife recently passed away. I used my time off to build her a giant bookshelf
They're easy to replace, and decent ones last a really long time.

If you undervolt them slightly, the chips will basically never fail.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Compact nuclear fusion reactor is 'very likely to work,' studies suggest
That's the breeding option, making tritium from lithium. Lithium can absorb a neutron and become helium and tritium.
Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on California to Require All New Vehicles Be Zero-Emission by 2035
There's like a 2% chance that ICE sales will be more than a single-digit percent of the market by 2035.

Yawn

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Smoke has caused temperature forecasts to go crazy
Diffuse light has a tendency to increase yield by decreasing the shading effect on lower leaves, so it largely cancels out. It is also fairly easily to saturate photosites in full sun. Heat/water are more limiting in these contexts.

It's really not an issue.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on One in ten medical treatments are supported by high-quality evidence – study
That is not an accurate summation of the evidence. 11 publications were used to analyze the efficacy of dental floss, a some dozens more for other inter-dental cleaning methods.

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/jcpe.12363

Characterizing this as 'absence of evidence' is incorrect; the specific issue has been investigated by several independent investigators and consistently fails to find evidence of efficacy. Even with much higher sampling and statistical power, if any effect was observed, it would likely be well below anything that could justify flossing as a health recommendation, especially over IDBs.

Obi_Juan_Kenobi··on Chess is taking over the online video game streaming world and it will change
It doesn't get high viewership, but as a cultural moment for the site, it was huge. Chess posts regularly topped LSF for several weeks, and they remain strong.

It was popular enough that it drew a strong reactionary movement of people complaining about chess posts. You can argue about clickbait, but the view counts (not that #30 is shabby at all) don't do it justice.

← PreviousPage 2 of 29Next →