HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

OhMeadhbh

2,663 karma · joined July 11, 2023

.

Some things you may have heard me say:

-- "If you find you're shooting yourself in the foot, do not reload."

-- "Videodrome was a documentary."

-- "Instead of saying 'no', ask how the world would have to change so your answer could be 'yes'."

-- "Belief flows towards that which can be monetized."

-- "Money is theft. The economy is a lie."

-- "Reflexive modernity has made Ballard's 'High-Rise' A love story."

Nortel, RSA, Borland, Linden and SiFive. I keep working for companies that don't know how to do an exit.

I don't do X, Facebook or LinkedIn. The closest thing I have to social media is [[ https://www.youtube.com/@OhMeadhbh ]] where I've uploaded a few retro-computing related videos.

Strangely, this is the video I'm most proud of: [[ https://youtu.be/J-tdfUXi9PI ]]

.

submissionscomments
OhMeadhbh··on Why Writing Correct Software Is Hard
One of the reasons I like this community is there seem to be quite a few people who understand what "continuations vs. monads" means. Party on, HN community, you are appreciated.
OhMeadhbh··on Jensen Huang resigns
I felt I needed to offer a comment since everyone else is.

I honestly have no feelings one way or another about this.

OhMeadhbh··on Service degradation on Microsoft 365
Three 9's is .36525 days per year. So if this one is resolved within 8 hours, that's about .999 uptime. (assuming they only have one such outage this year.)
OhMeadhbh··on Service degradation on Microsoft 365
microsoft, apparently.
OhMeadhbh··on Service degradation on Microsoft 365
That would probably cost money or increase complexity, so I'm sure the idea was shot down.
OhMeadhbh··on The Utah Teapot
I was at the same event. I got to hold it. It was a bit of a thrill.
OhMeadhbh··on ADHD Is Not a Superpower

   The article could have used  an abstract, you have to read
   a third  into it  before the text  starts relating  to the
   title.

   But...  It does a decent  job of pointing out diagnoses in
   various DSMs describe sets of symptoms and not etiologies.
   Which is  to say, a "disorder"  in the DSM doesn't  give a
   biochemical explanation for the  origin of a behaviour, it
   just describes  the behaviours (often  using self-reported
   observations of one's own emotions.)

   Given  the way  English-speaking  humans  use language,  I
   would argue that "superpower" is something more akin to an
   innate  ability.   It's  not  //just//  a  description  of
   behaviours.  Superman  is superman  not simply  because he
   leaps tall  buildings with  a single  bound or  because he
   races faster than  a speeding bullet.  The  state of being
   called "Superman"  is dependent  on Kal-El /  Clark Kent's
   path through  phenomenal existence.  (I'm  obviously using
   Superman  as   the  exemplar   of  entities   who  possess
   super-powers.)

   If the  nature of  having a super-power  is innate  to the
   individual  and  the  underlying  hypostasis  of  an  ADHD
   diagnosis  is  dependent   on  descriptions  of  behaviour
   independent   of   any   biochemical   cause   then   yes,
   "superpower" and "ADHD" are not in the same class.

   However...  Gods of Catachresis forgive me...  Language is
   complex and those damn'd  humans often use it imprecisely.
   From  context,  I think  we  can  infer  that "ADHD  is  a
   Super-Power" means  that the behaviours described  by ADHD
   in the  DSM-X are associated with  iteologies which confer
   benefits to the individual.

   Still.  I enjoyed reading the article.
OhMeadhbh··on Apple TV makes sign language interpretation a built-in accessibility feature

   When  I  first  saw  the headline,  I  thought  Apple  had
   launched  an AI  that converts  ASL to  text.  While  that
   would be  great, that's  not what this  is.  In  fact, the
   article   mentions  "the   company   is   not  using   any
   AI-generated interpreters."  I suspect  this is to keep in
   the good graces with  the human sign language interpreters
   they have working at signtime.apple.com.

   Still... happy to see Apple taking #a11y seriously again.
OhMeadhbh··on On Being an Engineer in 2026
I think the author has confused "Software Developer" with "Engineer." The two are related, but distinct.
OhMeadhbh··on Building an OOO RISC-V CPU from scratch
I'm often dismissive of RISC-V posts, but I really loved this one. It does a great job of presenting the material: good graphics, readable text and references at the bottom of the text. I've been focused on smaller CPUs on durt cheap process nodes, but this was great.
OhMeadhbh··on When will this stop? The Raspberry Pi 5 16GB SBC now sells for $385
Absolutely. If your use case isn't in the 80% it's irrelevant. Ignoring the 20% how we got the planar process, the 8008, the Apple ][ and the DynaTAC.
OhMeadhbh··on When will this stop? The Raspberry Pi 5 16GB SBC now sells for $385
Also... https://youtu.be/bXEbZdP6i-0?t=4283
OhMeadhbh··on When will this stop? The Raspberry Pi 5 16GB SBC now sells for $385
Yeah, but the pages that use all the new fangled stuff are pages I don't really use. I'm sort of a fan of text. Whenever I have to launch X and start a modern browser, it sort of hurts my eyes. Whenever I want to do something fun, I launch MacOS 9 on my G3 iBook and monkey around with Hypercard. It runs just fine.
OhMeadhbh··on When will this stop? The Raspberry Pi 5 16GB SBC now sells for $385
"My" as in the one I until recently responsible for. While I enjoy tinkering, I don't need a missile silo communications system in my home.
OhMeadhbh··on When will this stop? The Raspberry Pi 5 16GB SBC now sells for $385
I don't run web browsers on my satellites or missile control systems. Guess we all have different applications. I also run most of my apps from the command line in the terminal. I just don't use the modern web that much.
OhMeadhbh··on Iran was behind cyber-attack on French supermarket freezers, Paris says
I was guessing North Korea. But then again, I'm in the states and I think we're required to blame everything on North Korea these days.
OhMeadhbh··on When will this stop? The Raspberry Pi 5 16GB SBC now sells for $385
You would think... but if you don't have to run the 13 year old computer at full tilt, then the power difference may be minimal. The LEON SoS SPARC clones I used wound up consuming MUCH less power than modern intel cores.

And CPU power consumption is only part of the whole system. And a lot of the system power scales with bus speed rather than inverse CPU age. It's possible recent systems will consume more electrons than older systems.

OhMeadhbh··on When will this stop? The Raspberry Pi 5 16GB SBC now sells for $385
I have a 60 year old computer attached to my Minuteman III and it's doing fine. A 13 year old computer that still works is a computer that still works. And if it's worked 13 years, then it might last another 13 years (unlike the Intel NUC that died after 18 months.)
OhMeadhbh··on When will this stop? The Raspberry Pi 5 16GB SBC now sells for $385
Absolutely. Amazon isn't the go-to place to pick up electronics. I think I picked it because prices there are probably the highest you'll reasonably find for Pi stuff. Though they often have availability when everyone else is out of stock (likely because they have a bit more mark up than most everyone else.)
OhMeadhbh··on When will this stop? The Raspberry Pi 5 16GB SBC now sells for $385
Sure... but... the original $35 RasPi is closer to a modern RasPi Zero 1, which looks like it's selling for $45 - $50 on Amazon.

Modern top-of-the-line RasPis seem more like ARM PCs with fast, efficient multi-core CPUs and GigE. I bought a RasPi 500 at the beginning of the year just to see what it was like and it's my new "email and light web browsing" daily-driver. Though yeah, I probably wouldn't have paid $410 for it.

I bought my original RasPi mostly for the I/O. I wanted to blink some lights, drive some servos. And if I wanted to do that again, I would probably buy a Pico or Zero.

OhMeadhbh··on What is malloc doing, anyway?

   One of  my pet  peeves is  when people,  trying to  make a
   point, use code  that doesn't compile.  I  mean, it's fine
   when you're sketching  out code on a white  board.  But on
   an  article you've  had  time to  prepare,  it's a  little
   annoying.

   Take for instance, this code fragment:

   .. static void *ptrs[1000];
   .. 
   .. int main(void) {
   ..     for (int i = 0; i < 1000; i++)
   ..         ptrs[i] = malloc(16);
   ..     }
   ..  }

   I'm pretty sure what they //meant// to write was:

   .. #include <stdlib.h>
   ..
   .. static void *ptrs[1000];
   .. 
   .. int main(void) {
   ..     for (int i = 0; i < 1000; i++)
   ..         ptrs[i] = malloc(16);
   ..     }
   ..     return( 0 );
   ..  }

   I  understand why  the  author produced  the  code on  top
   instead of the code at the bottom.  The code on the bottom
   includes  features extraneous  to  the conversation.   The
   include  directive  and  return statement  only  serve  to
   distract from the point the author is making.

   If you read far enough down,  you'll see he has links to a
   broken GitHub  repo presumably  with code  fragments.  (or
   maybe  GitHub itself  is  broken today  or  it decided  it
   didn't  like me  trying to  access the  repo from  an AT&T
   fiber line.)

   I'm sure when GitHub decides to behave and serve bits like
   it's supposed to, there will be compilable code so readers
   can understand  the author's intent within  the context it
   was intended to be viewed.

   Which is to say:

   1. It's probably  okay to have only code  fragments in the
      main part  of your  discussion.  Please provide  a note
      that  there is  code which  shows your  snippet in  the
      context  of a  compilable program.   And put  that note
      somewhere near the code fragment.

      Or... consider putting  a note at the  beginning of the
      article saying  something like "Compilable  versions of
      code  fragments  in this  article  are  available at  a
      GitHub  repository  referenced  at the  bottom  of  the
      page."

   2. Do  not depend on  GitHub to hold your  code fragments.
      You do not  know when it will be down  or which readers
      it will randomly decide to block.

   3.  I really  do  think  you should  include  more of  the
      "layout"  code.   When   reading  "The  Address  Space"
      section,   it  was   unclear  where   the  initialized,
      uninitialized and local came from.  I initially thought
      the  author was  using a  version of  C I  had not  yet
      encountered that defined these symbols.

   4.  Since  the code  uses  ``sbrk()``,  the author  should
      probably have  cautioned readers  the code  isn't POSIX
      compliant, but should compile  and run on Linux systems
      using gcc.   There's a  comment about  demonstrating it
      with  glibc, but  I think  that's not  a strong  enough
      warning since you can  compile programs with clang that
      are intended to link against glibc.
      
      I doubt there  are many QNX users out  there who expect
      random code from  the internet to run  on their systems
      without alteration, but it  seems good form to describe
      the environment you are targeting.

      Now I'm wondering if this is expected to work on Darwin
      as well as Linux.

   5.  It  might  be  a  decent  idea  to  order  the  SHOW()
      statements in  the code in "The  Address Space" section
      to follow  the order  of the diagram  at the  bottom of
      that section:

      .. SHOW( "local (stack)", &local );
      .. SHOW( "printf (libc)", printf );
      .. SHOW( "program break", sbrk(0) );
      .. SHOW( "malloc(16) (heap)", malloc(16) );
      .. SHOW( "uninitialised (bss)", &uninitialised);
      .. SHOW( "initialised (data)", &initialised );
      .. SHOW( "main(text)", main );

   6.  In  the  "Chunks  and  Headers"  section,  it  may  be
      interesting to mention what the flags in the allocation
      headers actually mean.

   7. glibc does late fill,  right?  I can't remember.  If it
      does,  it might  be  useful to  mention  in the  Demand
      Paging section since it affects the program logic.
   
   Now that I've yelled at the  cloud a bit, allow me to say,
   I enjoyed the article.  Things I liked:

   1. The author  used the exact strace command  they used to
      produce  the  output  discussed  in  the  text  of  the
      article.

   2. The graphics are quite nice.

   3. Despite grousing about  fragments being fragments, they
      do a good job of illustrating points made in the text.

   EDIT: After complaining about  GitHub not being available,
   it's finally come back.  The web interface is still borked
   for me, but  I can clone the repo mentioned  at the bottom
   of the page and view the local copy of the source.
OhMeadhbh··on The Lisp curse, now coming to your ecosystem
Yes. Lisp's curse is you sort of have to know what you're doing to get the most out of it. If you don't want to learn computer science, there are other programming languages available.
OhMeadhbh··on Behind the scenes at the NeXT Computer office
weird. I had the opposite experience. but I'm comparing 25MHz 68k hardware with 40MHz Sparc. I remember it being at least as fast and no spinny pizza disk pointers.
OhMeadhbh··on Digital minimalism
Yup. I do use a "real" browser from time to time. Mostly firefox w/ a hopelessly outdated version of uBlock Origin and Vanadium on the mobile phone. Firefox is not without its issues, but reader view seems to improve most sites. I'm sure chrome has an equivalent.

I do text browsers because I live my life in a terminal and it's easier than double-clicking on another part of the screen and waiting for the graphical browser to launch. I also only have 16Gb of RAM, so I can only have a few browser windows open at a time.

And yeah... using a mapping site on a text only browser would suck.

OhMeadhbh··on Show HN: Subvocal – Talk to your computer without making noise
In order to read the site contents, you have to have contents to read. Instead there was a graph that moved around a bit when you scrolled down. Then there was a picture of a couple of dudes. Then there was a pair of glasses that rotated when you scrolled down. I generally read text, not pictures of dudes and eyewear.

It needs a sentence or two at the top of the page explaining what the app does and why I should be interested.

I'm viewing the content on a desktop web browser, not an iPhone. Maybe Safari renders this differently. In that case you should have text at the top saying "you need to have an iPhone to view this content."

OhMeadhbh··on Postman silently auto-installs AI plugins and attempts to share all API data
I think if you're using Postman, you don't care about sharing your data with random other people/companies on the intarwebs.
OhMeadhbh··on Nvidia – open-source auto-ontology
I always giggle when software engineers use the term "ontology."
OhMeadhbh··on AI is destroying my CS degree

   What are you going to do with your new-found CS knowledge?
   Are you going  to make the next google?  Are  you going to
   get  a  job  at  the local  insurance  company  processing
   claims?  Teaching yourself without a  degree is a bad path
   if you want to do grad school.

   Maybe you want to understand how software works so you can
   have a  better understanding of the  world and participate
   more fully in society?  Well... I can't argue with that.

   I'm bearish  on using AI  to teach yourself CS  because AI
   doesn't teach people CS.  If  you learn something about CS
   because you're looking at the  output of an AI model, it's
   sort of a side-effect.

   We probably have a very different idea about what "CS" is.
   I think  of it  as an  organized exploration  of notation,
   processes  and  proofs  related  to a  branch  of  applied
   mathematics  whose subject  is  general purpose  computing
   devices.  Asking  an AI "give  me a function  to calculate
   the fibonacci  sequence in rust"  isn't going to  help you
   understand a)  where the fibonacci sequence  came from, b)
   what recursion is (and why  and how it was introduced) and
   c) how  the lexemes  in a programming  language map  to an
   abstract process which when reified delivers the fibonnaci
   sequence.

   I've picked a pretty simple example as a straw-man, mostly
   because I think it //should// be knocked down.  If this is
   what you're  doing to "learn  CS" then more power  to you,
   but you're probably not doing yourself any favours.

   You  probably  can  use  AI with  prompts  like  "generate
   example code that implements  the abstract factory pattern
   and explain how each function  relates to the pattern" and
   get a  fairly decent explanation.  Modern  agents can keep
   enough of a  context you can ask it  some decent questions
   if its examples aren't entirely clear.

   I've  used  and  seen  other people  use  Claude  Code  to
   interatively  generate design  work.   Mostly APIs.   It's
   hardly ever right the first time and Claude Code sometimes
   barfs if  you ask it  to explain  why it did  a particular
   thing.  But it's  mostly decent and in a few  cases it has
   pointed out a few ragged edges I didn't notice.

   But... I learned how to map between human requirements and
   software on my  own.  I don't know if  someone could learn
   expert level design by examining the output of a tool that
   was trained on mediocre code.

   And Claude Code really doesn't understand how to interpret
   my prompts  about TLA+  and Coq/Roq.  It  doesn't generate
   complete  BS.   I'm  thinking   there's  just  not  enough
   training data included.

   In  the old  days, if  you went  to a  decent school  like
   Harvard or  Yale or CMU,  you could be  reasonably assured
   the education  wouldn't be  bad. [[1]]  You could go  to a
   cheaper  state state  school and  get a  decent education,
   though there  was always the  chance you would get  a crap
   instructor or two.

   There's  an idea  that you  can  teach most  people to  be
   effective software developers by  putting them in front of
   a terminal  with a man page  and a c compiler.   I believe
   this is  bullshit.  This technique will  work for //some//
   people, but not as many as sitting you in a class-room and
   having an expert  explain what the important  bits are and
   stepping you through the reasoning of why.

   I think "learning by AI"  may work for //some// people, if
   they  figure  out  how  to ask  the  right  questions.   I
   recommend reading decent books like Gries' "The Science of
   Programming" or Knuth's "Literate Programming."  (You also
   have  to  read  SICP  because  it  defines  a  base  level
   understanding  that all  those  CS  grads have  supposedly
   learned.)

   But I'm  reminded of the  end of the movie  Hidden Dragon,
   Crouching Tiger (spoilers ahead)  where it is revealed the
   antagonist learned kung fu from  a well regarded book, but
   since  they  couldn't  read,   they  only  looked  at  the
   pictures.   They   understood  the   forms  but   not  the
   motivations  for  why  the   forms  were  developed.   The
   antagonist  was  a  formatable  foe,  but  was  eventually
   defeated  because that  minor  difference  in context  was
   sufficient to lead to their defeat.

   I  don't think  you can  learn  to be  an expert  computer
   scientist exclusively by reading  books / papers.  But you
   can come  close.  I  don't think  you can  learn to  be an
   expert computer scientist exclusively by asking AI to give
   you example code, explaining  it and critiquing your code.
   Mostly  because "being  an expert  computer scientist"  is
   less about being a 10x  coder and more about understanding
   the  relations  between  abstract concepts,  notation  and
   symbolic   manipulation,   how   concrete   problems   are
   represented and  manipulated and  how this all  relates to
   concretization using computing machinery.

   AI gives you an answer,  not the understanding embedded in
   the text from which the answer was derived.

   But if you do it right and you ask AI the right questions,
   that understanding can be revealed.

   I think my sense  is that it is very easy  to use AI wrong
   and  difficult(ish)  to use  AI  as  a learning  tool.   I
   sincerely  wish you  well and  would love  to read  a blog
   about your experience.

   1. Do not ask about MIT.  They're beyond salvaging.
OhMeadhbh··on AI is destroying my CS degree

   File under "old man yells at clouds."

   I think it's worth asking what  a CS degree is for.  Is it
   to teach you how to  code and make you obviously hire-able
   by industry?  Maybe  it's to teach you how  to think about
   data and code?   If you think it's the former,  then AI is
   probably going  to be a  problem for you.  If  the latter,
   it's neutral to somewhat good.

   I've  been hiring  CS  grads for  4  decades (yikes!)  and
   there's  definitely  been  a   shift.   Not  all  existing
   programs are  bad.  Not all  young software devs  are bad.
   But...  the  percentage  of  recent  grads  that  seem  to
   understand  what data  processing  systems  are about  has
   definitely fallen.

   Us  old farts  in industry  must share  some of  the blame
   here.   Our industry  seems  to be  pretty  boom or  bust.
   Someone comes in with a stack of money and tells people to
   build { the web | blockchain | AI | virtual worlds | etc }
   and suddenly  there's a  rush.  At the  start of  the gold
   rush, we're not sure how  to build everything that's going
   to be the next google [[1]] so we fill the room with young
   kids  who have  seen  some recent  tooling  and will  work
   cheap.   We  don't  develop  them.  We  want  them  to  be
   compliant drones  dancing to  a tune played  by a  CTO and
   VP/Eng who got their jobs  because they're the children of
   the fund investors who gave the startup a bunch of money.

   And then  we go back  to Universities and tell  them "OMG!
   Your not bar-raising your grads by teaching them __fill in
   the blank__!" [[2]]

   So... I  don't doubt  it looks like  AI is  destroying the
   degree.   But maybe  it's just  making it  hard to  ignore
   previous problems with the uni to industry pipeline.

   And I didn't  mention the Mythical Man Month  once in this
   comment.  I'm getting better.

   1. I'm not  sure too many people want to  be Google at the
      moment, but  over the last 25  years, they've certainly
      done well.

   2. I'm  intentionally misspelling  "you're" because  in my
      time in industry,  I've found only about  15% of people
      would pass a 7th grade spelling test.
OhMeadhbh··on Show HN: Subvocal – Talk to your computer without making noise
Spent 30 seconds scrolling down to try to figure out what this is. Eventually clicked away from the site because it was taking too long to get to the point. I'm sure it's great and I understand it's something to do with glasses and subvocalizations, but consider a one sentence contextualization at the top of the page.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →