Edit: I see you fleshed out your comment more.
235 karma · joined December 21, 2020
Edit: I see you fleshed out your comment more.
That out of the way, McKay comes off as overly aggressive at times, and wishy-washy in others. It seems contradictory to call Jakosky's model ridiculous and absurd while also claiming we don't have enough data to know for sure. Jakosky is a well-known and respected Mars researcher, and I would much rather trust his 2018 paper over a paper or two written in the early '90s before we had detailed observations of the Martian atmosphere or surface.
At the very least, I appreciate Jakosky planting an empirical stake in the ground for his position.
No. Many of the journals listed will have some OA papers, while other papers will be paywalled. There are few journals (like Nature) that are entirely free to read sadly.
https://sci-hub.ee/ is the way. Just give it a DOI and you're good to go.
My own rule of thumb is that I have to to three peer-reviews for every one paper I publish, since my paper will have three reviewers (usually). That way I can stay at review/submission equilibrium!
However, these are frequently the same journal! It depends on the author's budget which model it follows.
The final model requires $0 APC and all articles are free to read for anyone (this is probably the HN ideal--as well as my own) but these are virtually non-existent since peer review/editing is time and labor intensive.
While I wish it were different, there is basically no incentive to publish in any of the journals in my field unless your research matches one of the extremely specific journals. I hate publishers probably far more than the average person (I love paying $2,500 out of my grant to get a paper published, only for the production team that has been outsourced to India botch the file conversion, put it online without my approval, and ghost me for two months!), but few serious academics in my department would consider any of these.
Prestige can charge a premium, and without prestige your career is a non-starter sadly.
How does the old interface (which I use) differ at all in terms of encouraging nuanced discussion? It's still just a box for markdown.
- "The formation of araneiforms by carbon dioxide venting and vigorous sublimation dynamics under martian atmospheric pressure": https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-82763-7
- "HiRISE observations of gas sublimation-driven activity in Mars’ southern polar regions: III. Models of processes involving translucent ice": https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S001910350...
- "How martian araneiforms get their shapes: morphological analysis and diffusion-limited aggregation model for polar surface erosion": https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S001910351...