HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

OmicronCeti

235 karma · joined December 21, 2020

submissionscomments
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
What from the article are you staking your comment on? Why do you think that? Hoping for a more substantive response.

Edit: I see you fleshed out your comment more.

OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
Also going to voice my love for Red Mars, I found Green Mars to be much more of a slog to get through, but I really like anything KSR writes. Blue Mars was a nice finale though.
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
Speaking of areology, there is a small subreddit for precisely that field which is quite good: reddit.com/r/Areology
OmicronCeti··on A Recap of the Mars Terraforming Debate
First, I should note that I have a personal bias in that I study Mars for my PhD. I dislike Elon Musk, and I am not in favor of terraforming.

That out of the way, McKay comes off as overly aggressive at times, and wishy-washy in others. It seems contradictory to call Jakosky's model ridiculous and absurd while also claiming we don't have enough data to know for sure. Jakosky is a well-known and respected Mars researcher, and I would much rather trust his 2018 paper over a paper or two written in the early '90s before we had detailed observations of the Martian atmosphere or surface.

At the very least, I appreciate Jakosky planting an empirical stake in the ground for his position.

OmicronCeti··on Directory of Open Access Journals
Yeah most academics dread doing a peer review, because honestly if you actually get sent one that's a good fit, four out of five times the paper is in very rough shape, and the onus is on you the reviewer to point out and correct every problem.
OmicronCeti··on Directory of Open Access Journals
Some journals are trying to capture that space too, many are developing their own pre-print servers for who knows what reason.
OmicronCeti··on Directory of Open Access Journals
>is where can I go to get everything in an individual hobbyist subscription pricing?

No. Many of the journals listed will have some OA papers, while other papers will be paywalled. There are few journals (like Nature) that are entirely free to read sadly.

https://sci-hub.ee/ is the way. Just give it a DOI and you're good to go.

OmicronCeti··on Directory of Open Access Journals
Peer review should always be unpaid. Some journals will give you a $100 discount voucher, but I've never heard of anyone being directly compensated.

My own rule of thumb is that I have to to three peer-reviews for every one paper I publish, since my paper will have three reviewers (usually). That way I can stay at review/submission equilibrium!

OmicronCeti··on Experts Shred Paper Claiming to Identify Mushrooms on Mars
Ah the joy publishing with a poor-quality journal: the reviewers don't care or no nothing about the field, bad research gets rubberstamped, the authors gets to claim it was published, and the journal can just blame the reviewers.
OmicronCeti··on Directory of Open Access Journals
I really like https://www.connectedpapers.com/ for visualizing the connections between papers and topics that go beyond simple cross-referencing.
OmicronCeti··on Directory of Open Access Journals
This site also seems to miscontrue what an APC is, and has always struck me as just papering over the problems in the publishing industry. For example: Some journals are open access (ie anyone can read the papers) and require a $2,500 APC to publish. Other models have a $0 APC and the journal paywalls the article to cover their overhead (and squeeze out disgusting profits)--this would not be open access.

However, these are frequently the same journal! It depends on the author's budget which model it follows.

The final model requires $0 APC and all articles are free to read for anyone (this is probably the HN ideal--as well as my own) but these are virtually non-existent since peer review/editing is time and labor intensive.

OmicronCeti··on Directory of Open Access Journals
I'm currently working on my PhD and I'm familiar with this list and site. In my field at least (geoscience), there are very very few high-quality journals on this list. The available journals basically fall into two categories: extremely specific ("Vadose Zone Journal") or outside the mainstream ("Mongolian Geoscientist").

While I wish it were different, there is basically no incentive to publish in any of the journals in my field unless your research matches one of the extremely specific journals. I hate publishers probably far more than the average person (I love paying $2,500 out of my grant to get a paper published, only for the production team that has been outsourced to India botch the file conversion, put it online without my approval, and ghost me for two months!), but few serious academics in my department would consider any of these.

Prestige can charge a premium, and without prestige your career is a non-starter sadly.

OmicronCeti··on Reddit aims to double in size as social news site invests for growth
>Everyone else is engaging in inane one-line comments and meme posts because the new interface does not encourage substantial, nuanced discussion

How does the old interface (which I use) differ at all in terms of encouraging nuanced discussion? It's still just a box for markdown.

OmicronCeti··on Show HN: Open-source high-res Mars map, in natural colors
The coordinate system changes from equirectangular to polar stereo. The poles just don't get good imagery from the MRO. I work extensively with HiRISE data which is collected from the same orbiter as the CTX data this map uses.
OmicronCeti··on Show HN: Open-source high-res Mars map, in natural colors
They primarily use CTX, but HiRISE has the highest resolution, 0.25-0.5m/pixel.
OmicronCeti··on Mars has right ingredients for present-day microbial life: study
I mean it's on you since you're making the assertion.
OmicronCeti··on Mars has right ingredients for present-day microbial life: study
Please link to any of these 'large structures' otherwise we'll just continue to assume this is being pulled from your ass.
OmicronCeti··on Mars has right ingredients for present-day microbial life: study
Assuming this is even in good faith, can you link any images or data of these supposed structures? I spend hours a day examining HiRISE/CTX imagery and have never seen anything like you're asserting.
OmicronCeti··on Mars has right ingredients for present-day microbial life: study
I'm a PhD candidate studying Mars, happy to debunk any structures you can supply.
OmicronCeti··on Mars has right ingredients for present-day microbial life: study
To be perfectly honest they're not that mysterious. In the Martian science community they're called araneiforms, and the biological origin hypothesis is fairly fringe. Lots of good reading in these papers:

- "The formation of araneiforms by carbon dioxide venting and vigorous sublimation dynamics under martian atmospheric pressure": https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-82763-7

- "HiRISE observations of gas sublimation-driven activity in Mars’ southern polar regions: III. Models of processes involving translucent ice": https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S001910350...

- "How martian araneiforms get their shapes: morphological analysis and diffusion-limited aggregation model for polar surface erosion": https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S001910351...

OmicronCeti··on Statistics Postdoc Tames Decades-Old Geometry Problem
Basically everything quanta writes is so good. They have some of the best science writers around in my opinion, and their efforts to make science and discovery accessible to non-experts and the public is admirable. I highly recommend their podcast that breaks down some of the popular stories, as well as "The Joy of X" which are long-form interviews with leading scientists.
← PreviousPage 3 of 3