HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Oreb

476 karma · joined July 16, 2016

submissionscomments
Oreb··on Programmers and software developers lost the plot on naming their tools
And astrophysics has MACHOs and WIMPs.
Oreb··on Dark Mode Sucks
> Dark mode should be reserved for after sunset and before sunrise.

Isn’t that already how it works in all major operating systems?

Oreb··on From VS Code to Helix
The Helix mode in Zed is promising, but still nowhere near complete, and has a long way to go before it is as user-friendly as the Helix editor. For instance, the nice pop-up display of available commands. When I press “g” in Helix, I get a nice list of all the “goto” commands. This is very useful for discovering new features, and when you have forgotten something. This feature does not yet exist in Zed. And this is just one of many examples.
Oreb··on Space Elevator
How do we know how high pterodactyls were flying?
Oreb··on iPad Pro with M5 chip
This seems like one of those things some people are more sensitive to than others. To my eyes, an LCD or an OLED is just as good as e-ink for reading, except in very bright sunlight.
Oreb··on How to turn liquid glass into a solid interface
Me too. I honestly don’t understand why it provokes so strong reactions. In fact, I find all of the changes fairly minor. I expected something much more radical when Apple announced a major design overhaul. Things look slightly different, but work pretty much the same.
Oreb··on The Sagrada Família takes its final shape
Many churches were in construction for over a century, yes. Today? I’m not familiar with any examples other than Sagrada Familia, and even that one is almost finished. These multi-generation building projects seem to be a thing of the past.

Imagine trying to get funding today for a building project that is scheduled to be completed long after everyone alive today would be dead. I can’t imagine that being possible. It’s a pity: I wonder what wonders we could have built using modern technology over such a long timescale.

Oreb··on iPhone Air
I am closer to the first camp than the second, and I don’t understand why I would need longer battery life. The watch charges very quickly, and there is never a day when I don’t have the chance to charge at some point. I usually do it during my morning shower.
Oreb··on Starbucks in Korea asks customers to stop bringing in printers/desktop computers
Isn’t that how most coworking spaces work already? I’ve worked from a lot of them, and it always worked like that: I check in when I arrive in the morning, and when I check out at the end of the day, I pay for the number of hours I have spent there (often capped to a maximum of 5 hours or so, even if I stay longer).
Oreb··on Open models by OpenAI
That only means that OpenAI have to keep logs of all conversations, not that ChatGPT will retain memories of all conversations.
Oreb··on Valve confirms credit card companies pressured it to delist certain adult games
How did you manage without cash in France? Many places here don’t accept anything but cash for amounts less than 5 or 10 Euros. If I just want to buy a coffee or a baguette, I often need cash.
Oreb··on Helix Editor 25.07
Even as someone who uses both Helix and Zed, I don’t find Zed’s Helix keybindings very useful. There is still too much basic stuff missing. The biggest one to me personally is that the “gw” command does not seem to be implemented.
Oreb··on Kiro: A new agentic IDE
I don’t think “I’m too cool to use an IDE” was the point being made. The point is that having to switch IDEs every time the number one AI coding tool changes would be annoying.
Oreb··on I do not remember my life and it's fine
Me too. I’ve had some very traumatic experiences the last few years, and the emotional scars will never heal. I’m not the same person I was before, and I never will be.

Some people these days are hoping to combat aging and make potentially infinite life extension possible. I find that idea far more terrifying than death. Infinite lifetime would mean that experiences more emotionally and physically painful than I can even imagine would happen countless times. Slowly I would become so messed up by all the accumulated traumatic memories that I would no longer be able to function at all. I would only consent to an infinite or radically extended lifetime if I could also selectively erase memories I don’t want to keep.

Oreb··on Cursor 1.0
What model do you use? I’ve been trying devstral with Zed, and found it rather disappointing.
Oreb··on Cursor 1.0
That “if” doesn’t apply to all of us, though. Not everybody is paid by the hour. I’d love to try something like Claude code, but $100 per month is way too expensive for me, and it probably wouldn’t even give me a single extra dollar of income. I think I’ll just wait for the time when local LLMs will be good enough to be a viable alternative.
Oreb··on Highlights from the Claude 4 system prompt
I’ve used em-dashes in all sorts of online forums for decades. It’s on the Mac keyboard, and there are also tons of tools that automatically convert double or triple dashes to a single long dash. They were never uncommon.
Oreb··on Spaced repetition systems have gotten better
I use Chessbook and mostly like it, but I wish there was a way to configure the spaced repetition parameters. In particular, I find the frequency of reviews too low to retain well, especially for recently added moves.
Oreb··on WSJ: Some Apple Vision Pro Buyers 'Feel Total Regret'
To me it’s one of my best tech purchases ever. As someone who travels a lot, having a large external monitor for my MacBook that I can bring with me anywhere does wonders for my productivity. I also appreciate being able to filter out visual noise by enabling one of the virtual environments; it’s like noise-canceling headphones for the eyes. I routinely experience a level of focus and flow that I was very rarely able to achieve before. It’s my favorite Apple product since the original Macintosh, and I’m excited to see how the product category will develop in the years to come.
Oreb··on Flattening Rust’s learning curve
Have you had a look at Nim? I think you may like it.
Oreb··on Ask HN: Cursor or Windsurf?
Approximately how much does it cost in practice to use Aider? My understanding is that Aider itself is free, but you have to pay per token when using an API key for your LLM of choice. I can look up for myself the prices of the various LLMs, but it doesn't help much, since I have no intuition whatsoever about how many tokens I am likely to consume. The attraction of something like Zed or Cursor for me is that I just have a fixed monthly cost to worry about. I'd love to try Aider, as I suspect it suits my style of work better, but without having any idea how much it would cost me, I'm afraid of trying.
Oreb··on Which year: guess which year each photo was taken
I’ve never seen women wearing that kind of outfits in gyms in Norway or France, but I see it all the time online. Is it an American thing?
Oreb··on 34x34x34 Rubik's Cube
Congrats, that's an awesome average! I wish I was that fast. I don't time myself often, but when I do, I usually end up somewhere around 15 seconds. My efficiency is not bad, but my hands are just too slow.

I agree about beginner tutorials. There are some decent Roux tutorials, but they are mostly not targeting complete beginners. I believe it should be possible to make a Roux-based beginner method that is even simpler than the popular layer-by-layer beginner methods most new cubers learn. If you think about it, it seems almost obvious. If efficiency is not a concern, the first two blocks of Roux have to be simpler than the first two layers of a layer-by-layer approach, since you are solving a subset of the first two layers. CMLL is also obviously simpler than the CFOP last layer. The only thing that remains is the last six edges, and that's simple enough that I think beginners could figure out by trial and error. With the right simplifications (at the expense of efficiency) and good pedagogy, I therefore think Roux is ideally suited for teaching to complete beginners. Unfortunately, nobody has done it yet.

Oreb··on 34x34x34 Rubik's Cube
Sort of. The 3x3x3 and 5x5x5 both have fixed, immovable centers. Red is always opposite orange, blue is always opposite green, and yellow is always opposite white. The 4x4x4 doesn't have fixed centers. When you build the central 2x2 squares on each side (the first step of the reduction method), you have to be careful to have the colors arranged in the correct locations relative to each other. In a certain sense, this is trivial, but it forces you to remember exactly where all colors are on a solved cube in order to solve a 4x4x4 (or other even sized cubes). Odd sized cubes don't have this problem.

Another annoying thing about 4x4x4 compared to 5x5x5 is that you have two possible types of parity issues on the 4x4x4. On the 5x5x5, only one of these can occur.

Nevertheless, if you know how to solve a 3x3x3 and no bigger cube, a 4x4x4 is certainly the easiest next step.

Oreb··on 34x34x34 Rubik's Cube
I generally prefer written tutorials over video tutorials, but cubing related stuff is an exception. Videos are easier to digest.

Here's a good beginner tutorial:

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLBHocHmPzgIjnAbNLHDyc...

Oreb··on 34x34x34 Rubik's Cube
Solving by layers is logical, it's what most beginners learn, and it is kind of how CFOP (the most popular speedsolving method) works. Nevertheless, it's not what I would recommend. The problem with solving layer by layer is that you are sort of painting yourself into a corner from the beginning. After you have finished the first layer, you can't really do anything without breaking the first layer. Of course it is possible (and necessary) to proceed in a way where you keep breaking and repairing the first layer while progressing with the rest of the cube, but the limited freedom of movement still makes the solution process needlessly complicated, and increases the move count.

In my opinion, it's better to start by solving a part of the cube that still leaves you with a significant amount of freedom of movement without breaking what you have already done. There are several ways to do this. My favorite method (Roux) starts by not making a full layer, but just a 3x2 rectangle on one side. This rectangle is placed on the bottom left part of the cube. You still have a considerable degree of freedom, you can turn the top layer and the two rightmost layers without breaking your 3x2 rectangle.

The next step is to build a symmetrical 3x2 rectangle on the lower right side of the cube. This is quite easy to do by just using the top layer and the two rightmost layers, thus avoiding to mess up the left hand 3x2.

After finishing the two 3x2 rectangles (commonly known as the "first block" and the "second block"), the next step is to solve the corners on the top of the cube. This is the only algorithmic step of Roux, you use a number of memorized algorithms. However, the algorithms are shorter and simpler than those for the top layer of a layer-by-layer approach, because the algorithms are allowed to mess up everything along the middle slice (which hasn't been solved yet) and the edge pieces on the top of the cube.

After finishing the top corners, you are still free to move the middle slice and the top layer without messing up what you've already done. Fortunately, this is enough for solving (intuitively!) the remaining pieces. You can finish the solve by using only these non-destructive moves.

The Roux method, therefore, allows you to keep the maximum degree of freedom of movement (without destroying what's already been solved) all the way until the end. This is what allows it to have a very low move count, and what's makes it easy to learn. It also gives you a lot of creative opportunities compared to CFOP and other layer-by-layer methods. Because of the increased freedom, there are more ways of doing things, and bigger scope for clever shortcuts, especially when building the first and second blocks.

Oreb··on 34x34x34 Rubik's Cube
There are a lot of methods, optimized for different purposes. Some are easy to learn, but take a very large number of moves to solve the cube. Some are exactly the opposite: Difficult to learn, but enables you to solve the cube in just a few seconds. Others are optimized for solving the cube in the fewest possible number of moves, but requires so much thinking that they are not suitable for fast solutions. Others again are optimized for blindfolded solving.

My two favorite methods are Roux and 3-style.

Roux is the second most common method for speedsolving. Compared to the more popular CFOP method, Roux is more intuitive (in the sense that you mostly solve by thinking rather than by executing memorized algorithms), and requires fewer moves. Roux is much more fun than CFOP, if you ask me, and for adults and/or people who are attracted to the puzzle-solving nature of the cube rather than in learning algorithms and finger-tricks, I think it's easier to learn. Kian Mansour's tutorials on YouTube is a good place to start learning it.

3-style is a method designed for blindfolded solving, but it's a fun way to solve the cube even in sighted solves. It's a very elegant way to solve the cube, based on the concept of commutators. It takes a lot of moves compared to Roux, but the fun thing is that it can be done 100% intuitively, without any memorized algorithms (Roux requires a few, though not nearly as many as CFOP). It's satisfactory to be able to solve the cube in a way where you understand and can explain every single step of your solution. As an added bonus, if you know 3-style, you can easily learn blindfolded solving, which is tremendously fun, and not nearly as difficult as it sounds.

Edit: If you do decide you want to learn, make sure you get a good modern cube. The hardware has advanced enormously since the 1980s, modern cubes are so much easier and more fun to use. There are plenty of good choices. Stay away from original Rubik's cubes, get a recent cube from a brand like Moyu, X-man or Gan.

Oreb··on 34x34x34 Rubik's Cube
The reduction method means reducing a big cube (NxNxN for N>3) to a 3x3x3 cube by first solving the centers (the central (N-2)x(N-2)x(N-2) square on each face) and the edges (the inner N-2 pieces along each edge of the cube). You are then essentially left with a 3x3x3 cube that you can try to solve by only turning the outer layers (which won't break the centers and edges you solved in the first stage).

The problem with this is that you may end up with a 3x3x3 cube that is not solvable. For instance, you can get a state where the entire cube is solved, except for two edges that need to swap locations. This isn't possible. In group theoretical language, only even permutations are possible. You can swap two _pairs_ of edges, but not just two edges.

When you end up in such an unsolvable 3x3x3 cube, you have to temporarily turn the inner layers of the cube and break apart the centers and edges you built in the first step, and then reassemble them again to a solvable 3x3x3 cube.

Oreb··on 34x34x34 Rubik's Cube
That's not the only way to solve big cubes, but it's indeed the most common way (known as "reduction"), and what most people naturally come up with if they try to solve 4x4x4 or bigger on their own. In addition to what you said, there is also the issue of parity (basically, when you reduce a 4x4x4 to a 3x3x3 by solving centers and edges first, you will often end up with a 3x3x3 cube in an unsolvable state, and you need to figure out some tricks to convert it to a solvable state), but if you know how to solve parity problems on a 4x4x4, you can do it for a cube of any size.
Oreb··on 34x34x34 Rubik's Cube
From a puzzle-solving point of view, these very large cubes aren't that interesting. When you increase the cube size, there are new things to figure out, but only up to a certain point. Figuring out how to solve a 4x4x4 when you know how to solve a 3x3x3 takes some significant work. I think I spent a whole weekend to successfully solve a 4x4x4 the first time I got one, despite being reasonably good at solving the 3x3x3. Solving a 5x5x5 for the first time took just a couple of hours, there wasn't much new to learn. The 6x6x6 was easier still. When I got to the 7x7x7, there wasn't really anything new at all. I could solve it immediately, it just took more time.

Anything beyond 7x7x7 is pretty much the same. It's just more annoying, because the puzzle gets physically harder to handle, and because you have to do the tedious work of counting how many layers away from the centre a piece is. The 7x7x7 is the biggest cube used in official competitions, for a good reason.

The motivation for making enormous cubes like the 34x34x34 is just the engineering challenge, and breaking records. Nobody is going to want to solve such a thing, at least not more than once.

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →