HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Paul-Craft

3,070 karma · joined April 11, 2023

submissionscomments
Paul-Craft··on Bitwarden Authenticator
Just use your Commodore 64 instead: https://www.gadgetany.com/news/now-the-commodore-64-is-a-two...
Paul-Craft··on Modern C Porting
Glad to see the Gentoo folks working on porting some of these ancient code bases. I still see a good bit of C99, and sometimes even C89 when I poke around in source packages.

Even more importantly, it's good to see them documenting the process to their usual high standards. Once again, Gentoo distinguishes itself nearly without peer in that area. Only the Arch wiki even comes close to Gentoo's standard.

Paul-Craft··on Despite sticker prices, the real cost of getting a degree has been going down
Whoops, I noticed a mistake!

> One of them actually dropped out of ~~college~~ high school(!), then went on to get hired at Netflix at 23 years old, back when they were only hiring senior engineers.

Paul-Craft··on Despite sticker prices, the real cost of getting a degree has been going down
I agree with your thesis, but I don't think there are 5 colleges or universities in the US that actually truly teach people how to think critically, with genuine curiosity. I despise people who are smart and educated, but not the least bit intellectually curious. The sad part is that the entire US education system is literally designed to beat the curiosity out of people, at least until you start talking about graduate schools.
Paul-Craft··on Despite sticker prices, the real cost of getting a degree has been going down
As a self-taught SWE myself, I agree with your observations. Two of the most talented engineers I've ever met were self-taught. The interesting thing about the two people I'm thinking of is that, besides being self-taught, neither one of them actually even went to college. One of them actually dropped out of college, then went on to get hired at Netflix at 23 years old, back when they were only hiring senior engineers.

Me, I have a degree in math, but 97% of what I know is stuff I picked up either on the job, or because I found it interesting. Besides those that picked up CS as a major when it was a hot field, I'm betting that some of them get the love of tech beaten out of them by their college experience. I certainly know more than one science major who felt that way after graduating. (Not me, though. I'm weird, and I still love math just as much as I always did. Maybe even more.)

Paul-Craft··on The Secret That Colleges Should Stop Keeping
I have some regrets about my choice of undergrad school, but it isn't because I went someplace cheap. I could have gone to one of the multiple state schools that would have given me half off just for being born somewhere.

Instead, I went to a school that was in my home town. I learned things when I went to college, but that school was objectively the wrong choice. Not only did it cost double what the state school would have cost[0], I missed out on the reason young people ought to go to college in the first place: a once in a lifetime chance to spend 4 years hanging out and making friends with high achieving people who would go on to shape the face of the world.

Granted, one of my college friends ended up as a senior researcher studying cancer, and another went on to work for Mozilla, but I'm pretty sure in my class of ~300, there weren't too many CTOs, VPEs, star researchers, etc. Simply going to a bigger school would have been a better choice; going to a school that was both bigger and better than my undergrad institution would have been the best choice.

I guess that's what you get when society expects a 17-year-old to make what may be the single most impactful life choice they'll ever have. ¯\\\_(ツ)_/¯

That said, going to a small liberal arts college had its advantages. I learned a lot. Some of that stuff I learned, I've even gotten to use once or twice. But, looking back, if I could send my past self a message back in time, I'd tell me to go somewhere else. I may not have been much better off financially if I had met someone in college at 20 who talked me into partnering up on some insane business venture or something, but that experience would have been priceless.

--

[0]: This was even after I got a scholarship that reduced my estimated family contribution to 2/3 of what the sticker price was, on top of being able to stay at home and save money that way.

Paul-Craft··on Private antitrust cases are going through the courts
The direction of political discourse hasn't been toward "radicalization" per se. Democrats have only moved slightly to the left of where they were in the early 1970s, but the majority of that movement has taken place since 2011. Republicans, OTOH, have been moving rightward at a steady and near-constant pace since 1971, though they did start shifting faster around 2001. This has lead to Congress becoming significantly more conservative over time. Keep in mind, the Democrats would be considered just slightly left of center in most European countries.

https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2022/03/10/the-polar...

TL;DR: there's no "radicalization" taking place in the Democratic party. It's the Republicans that are driving it.

Paul-Craft··on Law firm restricts AI after 'significant' staff use
Yes, and as I recently learned, there's an awful lot of law that only exists inside the heads of district court judges and law clerks. An argument that might win the day in one courtroom might fall flat in the next county over.
Paul-Craft··on Mystery brain disease patients in New Brunswick say they welcome investigation
There have been sufferers ranging from age 18-85, and it affects both men and women in approximately equal numbers. Both of those things are highly suggestive of some kind of environmental cause. If this were an episode of House, a lot of peoples' homes would be getting broken into right about now.
Paul-Craft··on Subway crime plummets as ridership jumps significantly in congestion pricing era
I can think of way better reasons to avoid Wyoming.
Paul-Craft··on Subway crime plummets as ridership jumps significantly in congestion pricing era
That seems to have been going around for, oh, the past 47 minutes or so.
Paul-Craft··on Open Deep Research
Yeah, that's what I was thinking: just throw the whole lot inside a Docker container and call it a day. Unless you're dealing with potentially malicious code that could break out of a container, that should isolate the rest of your machine sufficiently.

Alternatively, PyPy is actually fully sandboxable.

On Linux, you can also use `seccomp.` See, for instance, https://healeycodes.com/running-untrusted-python-code

Paul-Craft··on Fiwix: Small Unix-Like Kernel
This one is just a hobby (won't be big and professional like gnu), after all. ;-)
Paul-Craft··on Why is it so hard to find a job now? Enter Ghost Jobs
The difference is there aren't hundreds of people applying to some random company's "opportunistic hiring" post, meanwhile the req gets reposted every 2 weeks like clockwork (possibly with a lower salary and more duties), just to see what it would take to get a "reasonable" number of "qualified" applicants.
Paul-Craft··on Tinylangs: Programming languages in 50 lines of Python
I don't love the "simple" lexer for PL/0. Specifically, I don't think this

> m = re.match(r"(?P<num>[0-9]+)|(?P<op>[-+*/()<>=])|(?P<ws>\s+)|(?P<kw>begin|end\.|end|if|then|while|do|var|!|\?|call|procedure)|(?P<id>[a-zA-Z]+)|(?P<semi>;)|(?P<asgn>:=)|(?P<comma>,)", code)

can be called simple. APL's is similar but less complex.

Notably, however, the BASIC and LISP interpreters are* delightfully simple throughout.

Paul-Craft··on The Case for Hypochondria
So you're saying you think the lives of people who are not "functioning members of society" are not meaningful? I guess I need to ask you to define your terms then, because I disagree based on what I'd define "meaningful" and "functioning member of society" to mean in this context.
Paul-Craft··on The Case for Hypochondria
Let me shoot back with another cultural phenomenon: there's been article upon article over the past couple of years especially about how young people just plain have it rougher than their parents did starting out. Suppose this is true. Isn't it then individually rational to pursue some strategy other than working as hard as possible?
Paul-Craft··on The Case for Hypochondria
I agree with this. I do google symptoms myself on occasion, but I always try to make sure that what I see online reflects what's actually going on with me to the extent possible, and I don't freak out when one of the possibilities ends up being, for instance, "cancer," because it's relatively unlikely that I have cancer, and a lot of things end up being symptoms of various cancers.

Here's a great example: I had some weird calluses show up on the very sides of my thumb pads and on the ventral aspect of the first phalangeal joint of each of my index fingers. The areas in which these calluses showed up was exactly mirrored on each hand. I googled a little bit and found a whole lot of nothing, but I did find a reference to calluses and esophageal cancer. I clearly do not have esophageal cancer. I have none of the symptoms so it's just a wildly improbable diagnosis.

What I did was show them to a friend of mine who's a family med doctor. I have an agreement with all my doctor friends that I will not ask them personal medical questions beyond "hey, is this weird and should I go see someone about it?" My friend said those were extremely weird places to have calluses given that they weren't the result of some activity I'd recently taken up using my hands (and they weren't).

Eventually, I ended up in a dermatologist's office where they diagnosed hyperkeratotic hand eczema. Given I have asthma, allergies, and I've had eczema issues in the past, that's a reasonable diagnosis.

And when I went to a doctor, I didn't say "I googled this and these things came up." I said "I have these weird calluses. I don't know why they're there because I haven't started any new activities recently so I'm a little concerned about them."

Paul-Craft··on The Case for Hypochondria
The question we should be asking isn't how easy is it to diagnose the X most common conditions. The question should be given someone goes to a doctor, what's the probability that their condition will be misdiagnosed. And further, what is the lifetime probability that someone will be misdiagnosed? Those numbers, I would wager, are significantly higher than the probability that anyone will be misdiagnosed with diabeetes, heart failure, obesity, arthritis, or hearing loss.

Note, however, I've left off depression. This one actually does get missed somewhat frequently by primary physicians, in part because they don't think to screen for it, or they don't screen for it at an initial visit. Primary specialists tend to look for physical conditions first before moving on to mental health conditions. Continuing with the article's theme about women being misdiagnosed frequently, here's an abstract that notes depression in female patients being misdiagnosed at a rate of 30-50%: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S02779....

So lets keep in mind that reliability of diagnosis of individual conditions, however common they may be, may have relatively little to do with the overall lifetime probability that someone will be misdiagnosed at some point in their life.

Edit: Some even more shocking mental health misdiagnosis statistics from https://justpoint.com/knowledge-base/everything-you-need-to-...

    > Misdiagnosis rates for major depressive disorders were at 65.9%, 
    > Misdiagnosis for Bipolar disorders was at 92.7 percent, 
    Panic disorder was at 85.8%, generalized anxiety disorder was 71.0 percent, and 
    > Social anxiety disorder was 97.8%.
Given that 1 out of 2 people will develop a diagnosable mental health issue in their lifetime according to https://hms.harvard.edu/news/half-worlds-population-will-exp... this suggests a fairly high rate of overall misdiagnosis.
Paul-Craft··on The Case for Hypochondria
What exactly is "wrong" with not being a "functioning member of society" because of a disability?
Paul-Craft··on Pierre Cartier Has Died
Here is a lightly touched-up machine translation of what's visible of the article before the paywall banner for those who don't read French:

> Mathematician Pierre Cartier, 92, died on August 17 in Marcoussis (Essonne). Though he never won the Fields Medal or the Abel Prize, the most famous awards in the discipline, nor was he ever appointed to the Academy of Sciences (he refused his election), this voluble and talkative scientist nevertheless marked his field in another way.

> Between 1955 and 1983, he was one of the pillars of the Bourbaki group, a semi-secret assembly of mathematicians born in 1934 to rebuild the discipline and unify it. “It was Bourbaki’s great period. Books published then are still very current," believes Frédéric Patras, research director at the CNRS at the University of Côte d'Azur, a student of Cartier. "He was the incarnation of Bourbaki." Pierre Cartier had estimated that he devoted a third of his time to this activity in the service of the community, writing or correcting nearly 200 pages per year.

> Endowed with a great memory, he thought he was the only one to have the overview of dozens of published works. His commitment went so far as to want to self-dissolve the group, fifty years after its birth, arguing that the same age limit should be applied to the collective as to its members. The group survived its departure and continues to publish texts, but with less echo than during this prosperous period.

> “My method is my character”

> Pierre Cartier also holds the “record” for presentations at the “Bourbaki seminar” during which the speaker summarizes for specialists the progress of various branches of mathematics. The archives list 40 between 1953 and 2012. This number testifies to the great culture of mathematics, which is also its strength. His career began in algebraic geometry, the art of relating geometric shapes to functions describing them, and continued in group theory, a key concept for describing structures underlying various abstractions. In these fields, concepts still used bear his name, such as divisors or Cartier operations.

Paul-Craft··on Ask HN: Weirdest Computer Architecture?
No instruction set computer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_instruction_set_computing
Paul-Craft··on More isn't always better: death and over-treatment as a downside of agenticness
My God.

Personally, I think I might call it at this point if it were me. I literally would not let an animal live like this. The only thing that tips me from disgust over to profound sadness in this story is that Jake is making these decisions himself. I would also be lying if I weren't feeling a good bit of morbid curiosity, observing his dying process through his own words.

Paul-Craft··on Cosmic simulation reveals how black holes grow and evolve
From the Users Guide:

> The code is written in standard ANSI C, and should run on all parallel platforms that support MPI. The portability of the code has been confirmed on a large number of systems ranging from a laptop to >1 million threads/cores on national super-computers.

Paul-Craft··on The Seal Failure in the SRB That Doomed Challenger (2021)
Challenger did not explode because of a "seal failure." That tragedy was entirely preventable. At least one of the engineers raised the alarm, saying that because of the recent cold weather, they couldn't guarantee that the O-ring would perform properly. But, the big wigs disregarded that warning, and seven people paid for that mistake with their lives.

No, it most certainly was not a seal that failed. It was an organization that failed. Unfortunately, it's harder to fix an organization than it is to design an O-ring that won't become brittle from sitting out a few hours on a cold night.

Paul-Craft··on AI speech generator 'reaches human parity' – but it's too dangerous to release
You're right, of course. Unfortunately, however, we're all just actors in a giant, multi-player, iterated Prisoner's Dilemma here. If I decide not to pursue human-level automated speech generation, or I end up developing it and don't release because it's "too dangerous," someone else will just come in behind me and take all that market share I could have captured.

It's like we're stuck in some movie that came out in 1994[0], or something. Except, in this version, everything is gonna up sooner or later, anyway. Might as well profit from it along the way, right?

Le sigh.

---

[0]: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0111257/

Paul-Craft··on AI speech generator 'reaches human parity' – but it's too dangerous to release
Huh. Today, a college kid without even any underlying knowledge of the math can train their own GPT-2-level language model as a semester project.
Paul-Craft··on Lacking official sources, some Texans use Whataburger app to track power outages
Eh, why not? We've already got the Waffle House Index, why not the Whataburger Indicator? lol

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waffle_House_Index

Paul-Craft··on Ask HN: Has anyone been fired for ignoring in-office mandates?
> The organization is also actively monitoring and blocking bonuses and promos for those who are not fully ignoring the mandate but are not meeting the full expectation.

That's what they're saying, at least. My easiest promotions have all been from changing companies; to give up a job because I (hypothetically might) get offered another is a luxury I can't afford right now. And, I'd bet better than even money that there's going to be a lot of "not in the budget" syndrome going around near the holidays.

In other words, them saying that they're actively monitoring, blah blah, might actually be a subtle and distant crack of the whip. The real story is that the job market for highly paid professionals is still absolutely fucker. Employers, of course, know this, and will take any opportunity to capitalize on it, even at the expense of their best workers. It's not 2-3 years ago, when people could peace out at the drop of a hat, because a job would roll in soon enough just by making a LinkedIn post and sending out a handful of resumes.

Paul-Craft··on Rye: A Hassle-Free Python Experience
Very interesting! I will definitely try this out.

Out of curiosity though: is there anything like this that exists, but less Python-specific?

← PreviousPage 3 of 30Next →