HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

PeterHolzwarth

1,043 karma · joined May 22, 2021

"For these causes we declare him traitor and miscreant, enemy of ourselves and of the country. As such we banish him perpetually from all our realms, forbidding all our subjects, of whatever quality, to communicate with him openly or privately - to administer to him victuals, drink, fire, or other necessaries. We allow all to injure him in property or life. We expose the said William of Nassau as an enemy of the human race, giving his property to all who may seize it."

- Granvelle

"I have heard that tomorrow they are to execute the two prisoners, the accomplices of him who shot me. For my part, I most willingly pardon them."

- William of Nassau

submissionscomments
PeterHolzwarth··on Boring Company fined nearly $500K after it dumped drilling fluids into manholes
Fines start small, then get big.
PeterHolzwarth··on Family Mart Designed Cute Teary-Eyed Stickers to Combat Food Loss
So if I grumpily (sorry) understand this correctly, the business wants to make customers feel guilty that the business over-ordered?

The business could have been a little conservative in how many units they ordered, but no, the just couldn't give up on even one potential lost sale, so they ordered too many. The solution, put a sticker on it to try to talk a customer into buying something perhaps they otherwise wouldn't.

PeterHolzwarth··on Cheese Crystals (2019)
The well known Rainier cherry cultivar similarly comes from Washington State University - quite an ag program they have there!
PeterHolzwarth··on AI, Wikipedia, and uncorrected machine translations of vulnerable languages
More specifically, it gets important HN discussions quickly flagged and dropped.
PeterHolzwarth··on I'm drowning in AI features I never asked for and I hate it
I will grudgingly admit that some AI features I encounter are kind of useful.

At work, we of course are all-in on a large wiki (Confluence). It has a feature irritatingly overlayed that treats searches as AI questions the provided LLM will answer. I have to admit it often does a good job answering my effective question directly, vs me going through many semi-related pages trying to find out how to do something.

Ours is a Windows shop, and I find I am using Copilot somewhat more frequently instead of web searches to find answers to "how do I ..." questions related to the commercial tools we use. While the responses are not always perfect, they are often-enough accurate enough to be useful. And, it saves me a lot of time vs digging through, ironically enough, AI-generated slop pages of how to's that take ten feet of page to answer a simple damned question.

PeterHolzwarth··on Seattle Tech Workers Are Fueling a Real-Estate Rush in the Cascade Mountains
It really is strange to cast one's net a bit further than just Seattle for renting or buying: you'll find it hard to spot a reasonable deal surprisingly far from the city itself. Growth really is oozing out all throughout western Washington.

Looking at 1 or 2 bedroom rents for a somewhat, but not too, newer unit shows rent prices that are not terribly far off from the city itself - at distances beyond commute.

I sometimes think people don't understand just how many people have moved to the (very) broader Seattle area in the last 15 years.

Broader Seattle has been a growth area since the early nineties, but this has expanded to far beyond the broader reaches of the area. I know of at least six people who own small second homes on the peninsula (Kitsap), the greater peninsula (Olympic), and up-and-down the broader I5 corridor from Olympia to Marysville/Totem Park.

PeterHolzwarth··on Fastmail desktop app
Kind of like how duckduckgo, a search engine, now has its own "app."
PeterHolzwarth··on [dead]
My goodness, why would you name it that?!
PeterHolzwarth··on America is now one big bet on AI
Low unemployment means there is more competition among employers for workers. This competition takes the form of higher wages.

Higher wages means the price of what is produced goes up: inflation.

This is why central banks try to keep unemployment down to, but very definitely not below, anywhere from 2-4 percent, depending on the country.

This is pretty much an economic law of nature, so to speak.

PeterHolzwarth··on Heroin addicts often seem normal
Most of what you mention isn't actually normal for most people. But it is possible to tailor your info feed to make it seem like it's normal.
PeterHolzwarth··on America is now one big bet on AI
This is deeply, deeply untrue. There is a direct relationship between low unemployment and high inflation.
PeterHolzwarth··on Microsoft 365 Copilot's commercial failure
You misunderstand me: I don't advocate - I'm just expressing what I think is likely for the billion people out there who now have access to these tools. This Hackernews community is a rather rarefied atmosphere. When we step out into the broader public, there is a whole different world going on. Whether we like it or not, that world is what we have to deal with.
PeterHolzwarth··on Microsoft 365 Copilot's commercial failure
I don't know, does it matter? What I mean is that the product only just, in the grand scheme of things, got rolled out. MS isn't under some instant pressure to make loads of cash off this new feature. Year by year, people will just become used to having a tool, part of their OS, that they can ask questions to to get some general information on whatever topic.

It's easy to pick an arbitrary date and point out the lack of profit. But why don't we pick a date a year from now? Or three years. Or five years.

I think over time users will come to assume that their computing device has, as part of the many tools on it, a tool that they can ask about stuff and get general answers.

Is it profitable right exactly now? No. But I suspect it will become completely commonplace in a few years, and not even worthy of note or comment for the average user.

MS isnt some cash-strapped startup that needs to post instant profits right this moment.

PeterHolzwarth··on Microsoft 365 Copilot's commercial failure
I think you'd be surprised at the number of average users who don't think of it as useless. As I've mentioned on comments elsewhere in this thread, remember what we here were talking about a couple years ago: LLM's killing websearch.
PeterHolzwarth··on Microsoft 365 Copilot's commercial failure
I get what you - a HN user - mean. But for the broader planet of Windows users, it just becomes this thing you click to get some general info from on whatever general topic, question, or need comes to mind. I think it is rapidly becoming quit banal - a thing people think of as just being another part of using their computing device. No fanfare; no fireworks; no hand-wringing over rights or privacy or training data: just a thing you click on to ask questions to as part of their normal day.
PeterHolzwarth··on Microsoft 365 Copilot's commercial failure
"The problem is that it doesn’t actually do anything."

I disagree, and I think you'll see what I mean when you shift the frame of reference from "person working at a large company with Office 365 installed" to a couple hundred million average Joe's having access to it at home.

Webs search is now a horrifying wasteland, and people know it. Remember the conversations we all had just a few years ago: LLM will replace web search. That's the key point here - not "replace web search" for the subset of people who have office jobs, but web search for the vastly greater number of people who just have it at home on their computer.

The tech - the products - are good enough for your average person at home who wants a starting point and a structure to work through for something they know nothing about. I think that's actually one of the strengths of the tech as it exists for the winder audience: you don't really need ultra accurate, super precise, info and checklists and guides when you just want to know what to look into to do some decorative tiling on the top of an old table you bought; a way to make sense of and work through a type of pop media you have become interested in; to give you a starting point to work through some new problem you have encountered in day to day life.

That "80 percent vaguely accurate-ish" threshold that LLMs can broadly deliver for a novice is actually good enough for that vast majority of things people deal with that aren't really super-critical. Are you idly curious about some ways to think about how to replant and re-do your back yard greenery? Curious about how to make sense of all the competing numbers and criteria and features when looking to buy your first air-conditioner? Want to take a vague, repetitive, not very well put together response to something your neighbor starting holding forth on on Nextdoor and make it tighter and better expressed?

That little Copilot icon that comes default in Windows legitimately can help you there.

PeterHolzwarth··on Microsoft 365 Copilot's commercial failure
For some, but what about the others? The reddit mentality of "everyone hates LLM AI tools" is just a very loud segment. What about everyone else? What about a random Joe who asks it questions to find some path through figuring out why their computer is acting all wonky? What about the people who don't know the first thing about dealing with their water heater suddenly going south, and ask it some basic questions of how to approach that problem? That is, treating it as an OS-native improvement over a search engine.

The list goes on and on, and we have to take time into consideration: people may have default strong feelings against the tech in question now, but often that's just a default stance. Over time, people will dip their toes in, and make use of it to whatever degree makes sense for them. Don't mistake current vocal criticism for the end all, be all, stance that will last forever: people get used to stuff, use it a bit, or more than a bit, time passes, and the tech slowly melds itself into people's lives in some manner and in some form: MS will wait and observer, and evolve the product to suit that slow change over time.

PeterHolzwarth··on Microsoft 365 Copilot's commercial failure
Boring is a short term thing - I think it's most useful to think about things like copilot AI for all windows users as a longer term initiative. Right now, I think MS is just letting people get used to a basic free tier. They will observe how Windows users put it to use, see to what degree of involvement people have with it, and evolve the product (and its pricing) from there.

Is it raking in cash right now? No. But that's just now. MS can and I feel is thinking longer term. Everyone is on a "Crash Dammit" Economist front-cover mode right, trying to will a crash into existence. Microsoft can think longer term about it - after all, we see younger generations diving in to make use of related technologies. Older demographics will, and are, slowly finding out what to make of the tech that is free with an OS install, and MS will see what kind of business to make out of that over time.

The problem with this broader topic is that people are restricting the time frame of the conversation to Right Now. MS doesn't need to worry about that so much, in the grand scheme of things.

PeterHolzwarth··on Microsoft 365 Copilot's commercial failure
I perceive MS as just being in the "get people using it, accustomed to it, used to it, habituated to using it throughout their day" phase for the default free Win10/11 tier.

That little copilot icon is sitting there in the task tray, clickable and usable. I think people will, to whatever degree makes sense for them, get used to making some use of the basic free tier. Monetization / restrictions requiring some degree of limitations to upsell will eventually come for the currently half-billion or so Win11 users.

I get the point that few are currently paying for it, but there isn't all that much pressure to do so right now. That will come, later.

PeterHolzwarth··on Trump to impose $100k fee for H-1B worker visas, White House says
$100,000 per year.
PeterHolzwarth··on Trump to impose $100k fee for H-1B worker visas, White House says
$100,000 per year.
PeterHolzwarth··on AI tools are making the world look weird
I don't think that is a fruitful line of reasoning, given that the vast majority of the world is not Catholic/Orthodox/Protestant! You should consider digging deeper for underlying causes that go beyond localized religions.

Put another way - that would seem to be an effect, not a cause.

PeterHolzwarth··on AI tools are making the world look weird
I have to ask (and I don't mean this combatively) - given the ongoing realization of the replication crisis, how likely is it that the book you mention reflects a summation of the "too pat" studies about human behavior that, en masse, always seem pithy in an interesting headline, but years later end up being completely bunk?

I've noticed over the years many chains of reasoning - made up of what I believe someone called "cocktail party" pithy takes - that only last as long as you don't dig into the nuts and bolts of them. Pleasant little takes on our psyche and behavior that makes for nice reaffirming thoughts of our views but break down under later analysis.

It feels like we have sometimes accreted an amalgam of these pithy takes based on very small, one off, studies (never replicated) that let us comfortably assemble an affirmation of our broader takes.

This is a rotten thing to say about your book recommendation, given I have never read it (I hope you'll forgive me), but based on the last few years of the replication crisis, do you think, in your heart of hearts, that what you are describing truly does stand up?

PeterHolzwarth··on New research reveals longevity gains slowing, life expectancy of 100 unlikely
You may feel differently when you get there. Be careful of present you making decisions about future you.
PeterHolzwarth··on How do I get into the game industry
I have decades+ in the American games industry. Bluntly speaking: don't join it. There are too many people chasing diminishing, shrinking (relative) job counts; large studios are offshoring more and more of their work; funding has dried up and we don't see the light at the end of the tunnel; there are too many games.

Are you from the UK or Europe? Have at it! American game jobs are quickly relocating to those cheaper places. If you are from the US, the costs have gotten too high and the pressure is massive to reduce those costs: large projects are seeing an increasing percentage of the total number of people on the project be from partners outside the States.

The trend is bottom-up: outsourcing partners are providing cheaper staffing starting at the bottom of the org chart, steadily going up said chart. The growing desire to have a smaller primary-studio footprint means more outsourcing in general. A desire to cut costs means more and more of that outsourcing is going to cheaper locals. Often, the majority of people who work on a game are not from the "parent" company - and a quickly growing percentage of those are not in the States.

The model that we are slowly converging on, bit by bit, is maybe 20-30 percent "home studio" in the States, with the rest being partners from non-American, cheaper areas. The pressure that drives this is massive and inexorable.

Some of this came from the lead up to, and the full stretch of, the covid years: up until just a couple years ago, it was quite difficult for an American studio to hire staff - it was a wonderful time to be looking for a job, and salaries for non-engineers (who were cheaper) rapidly went up.

Now we are in a situation where the costs are just too high, so the pressure has mounted to manage those costs. Outsourcing to cheaper areas is the solution, and the pace is increasing significantly.

Again, if you are an American interested in the games industry: don't do it. It has become deeply unreliable and unstable for anyone who isn't quite senior.

//edit - i have more thoughts. These will be deeply unpopular, but I feel compelled to express them.

A well-intentioned union drive in the popular press (a great idea when focused on bottom-of-the-heap, poorly-treated QA teams) accelerated annoyance with American development teams by studio and publisher leadership, leading to more exasperation-driven offshoring. I don't have a strong opinion on this topic, but I have to admit to myself it is a real issue.

At many American studios, covid-era hiring goals changed in a way that placed value on things other than immediate raw skill - instead favoring a more holistic stance on staffing. This was an approachable concept during ZIRP, when funding was more generous, but has put studios in a tough position in the new era of an absolutely brutal filter of pure output.

A passionately-defended work from home thing means that, just as everyone predicted during covid, studio leadership has realized that if they forego the power of intense in-office collaboration, why not just remote those remote jobs to cheaper places? After all, west coast studios still get a couple hours overlap with UK development teams: get better at slightly out of sync development, and suddenly US-timezone jobs don't seem as massively necessary as they once appeared.

PeterHolzwarth··on James Webb Space Telescope revisits a classic Hubble image of over 2.5k galaxies
HDF was a gogsmacking moment for us all. It is wonderful to see this new technology charge past the depiction barrier and show us even more crazy stuff!
PeterHolzwarth··on Tesla used car prices keep plumetting, dips below average used car
A great reminder of the popular press vs the reality of the market.
PeterHolzwarth··on A laid-off AccentJob hunting for 21 months. Recruiters said "too expensive..."
One could make an argument that the market has shifted, and he is not responding to it. I mean, I get it - no one wants a pay cut. But in an industry that has seen tens of thousands of job cuts, supply and demand does kind of take over.
PeterHolzwarth··on KLM B773 over Atlantic on Aug 6th 2025, passenger's power bank overheated
The long and the short of it:

"... a passenger's power bank overheated and emitted smoke. Cabin crew secured the device enabling the flight to continue to destination for a safe landing on runway 18R"

PeterHolzwarth··on Lawyer argues CoD maker can't be held responsible for actions of school shooter
Too true. I recall a study from some time ago that found that young people with angry tendencies demonstrate an easing of aggression after playin "violent" video games.

As you say, this has been studied so exhaustively since the nineties that I just don't understand how the science has not been included in the discussion for so long.

← PreviousPage 6 of 12Next →