HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

PhaedrusV

240 karma · joined October 27, 2018

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/phaedrusv; my proof: https://keybase.io/phaedrusv/sigs/u1A7hCAeLV0OyUb4ExY0GNu4KKqrqYniDRejZr3ofLw ]
submissionscomments
PhaedrusV··on Ask HN: Are you homeschooling your kids? Why?
I haven't read that one, but Gatto is well worth a look. He has several books, but IMHO "Underground History" is by far the most interesting. He was a former NY State and NYC Public School Teacher of the Year, so knows of what he speaks.

If you want to get a no-cost idea of his viewpoint, read his "I quit, I think" letter, published on the op-ed page of the WSJ.

https://www.educationrevolution.org/blog/i-quit-i-think/

PhaedrusV··on Ask HN: Are you homeschooling your kids? Why?
I'm 34, and I think the number of conversations I've had where homeschooling came up could be counted on 2 hands, and all were entirely voluntary on my part. I was homeschooled 1st-12th. Any sense of not fitting in was gone by sophomore year of college, and I hear it's pretty normal for freshman to feel that way.
PhaedrusV··on Ask HN: Are you homeschooling your kids? Why?
It's partly whether the parents take the time to make sure the kids are socialized, and partly selection bias. A lot of parents decide to homeschool their kids precisely because the kids are having a tough time in school socially, whether it's from bullying or from mild or severe developmental disorders. In my experience, a much higher percentage of homeschoolers enter homeschooling with dyslexia or autism than you see in the typical public school classroom.

A lot of parents choose to homeschool specifically because they don't want their child pidgeonholed and pipelined into special needs classrooms.

PhaedrusV··on Ask HN: Are you homeschooling your kids? Why?
Will be. Was homeschooled myself. Several reasons:

1) I'm responsible for the raising and education of my children, and I'm not going to outsource the bulk of that to strangers.

2) Less time-consuming. From talking to my friends who have 2+ children in school it sounds like they spend about 1 hour per day on average driving their kids around to and from school (not counting extra-curricular activities, parent teacher conferences, homework help, etc...). My mom says her steady-state time expenditure was around 40 minutes per day for all 3 of us, mostly grading math and papers.

3) Way better outcomes. Homeschoolers average at the 87th percentile in national standardized testing, and homeschoolers whose parents make less than $35K still average in the 85th percentile. (http://www.topmastersineducation.com/homeschooled/) On the anecdotal level, I'm a former USAF pilot-turned drone guy, my brother is a successful artist, and my little sister is working on her PhD in Aerospace Engineering when she's not kicking all our asses at fantasy football.

4) Better socialization. Yeah, I said better. I admit that I'm less used to spending time with people my exact age than most of my peers, but I interact much better than they do with people younger than me and people older than me. Funny thing, it turns out once you're out of college, most of the rest of your life will be spent with people who aren't your exact age. Homeschooling prepares you for that way better than public schooling.

5) "The Underground History of American Education", by John Taylor Gatto. Just read it. It'll blow your mind, and it's well-supported. TL;DR, our school system was modeled on the Prussian system designed to build an army that could beat Napoleon's troops. It's designed to create obedient myrmidons who don't know how ignorant they truly are. Don't worry, I'm sure your school was different.

← PreviousPage 3 of 3