HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

PhileinSophia

-18 karma · joined July 23, 2021

Laissez-faire Capitalist -- Not a libertarian, not an anarchist.

Use your mind.

submissionscomments
PhileinSophia··on After Slashing 33% of Workers in 6 Years, Railroads Complain of Labor Shortages
No I don't mean Rawls. Justice, in this context, means giving to each man what he deserves. This includes not punishing men who don't deserve to be punished.

"Society" has no claim on the output of the members of society. Actually, there is no such thing as society above and beyond "the members of society." What you're claiming is that "the members of society" have a claim on "the members of society," but obviously it doesn't manifest itself in a just way otherwise you could only claim what you deserve, or in other words you wouldn't claim anything from anyone else without mutual agreement.

What your statement really means is that one group of people in society "the needy" have a claim on another group "the productive." As a productive "member of society" you are forced at the point of a gun (don't pay your taxes, then defend yourself from being arrested) to support the most worthless scum on earth as long as he has the social grace of being "needy."

Need does not produce food, need does not build houses -- those are productive efforts -- but need is the ultimate claim on the life and labor of all the productive members of society.

If you want to help the needy so much, I will not stop you, please feel free to spend every last penny you have supporting them -- but leave me out of it. I have a right to live my life as much as they have a right to squander theirs.

PhileinSophia··on After Slashing 33% of Workers in 6 Years, Railroads Complain of Labor Shortages
I'm not saying this to be funny, I fully intend this to be taken seriously, the solution is to follow the principle of justice.

The "needy" have no claim on the output of the productive. There is no free lunch, there is no claim to the unearned. The solution is to get rid of welfare entirely, on principle. Anything less leads to this mess eventually.

PhileinSophia··on After Slashing 33% of Workers in 6 Years, Railroads Complain of Labor Shortages
The posts talking about "not paying enough" are completely missing the crux of the issue. There are 12 million people on unemployment, they are unemployed by choice. The government is killing these businesses by making it impossible for them to hire, and it's at the taxpayer's expense.