HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

QuantumChaos

130 karma · joined March 29, 2014

submissionscomments
QuantumChaos··on Autopsy of GCC 4.6.3 compiler bug on Raspberry Pi
Very nice. One suggestion, I found the abstract and introduction difficult to understand, and only got the real point by page 3. I would add something clearer in the abstract and/or introduction, such as:

"Static analysis is used to construct alternative versions of the program, that give identical outputs for a given subset of inputs I. The alternative programs are compiled and executed, and we test whether they do actually give the same outputs as the original program, on the input data I. By restricting to a subset I of inputs, a greater variety of alternatives can be produced, than if the alternatives had to be identical to the original program for all inputs."

QuantumChaos··on Strongest chess player, ever
Especially interesting to see everything hardcoded into C++. Quite different from most modern codebases that use a mix of languages, configuration files, etc.
QuantumChaos··on Google to close Motorola smartphone factory in Texas
>Maybe that's just not that important to most people though.

It's not important to me: I'm satisfied that the theory of comparative advantage shows that free trade is good, and protectionism (even in the form of individuals preferring goods made in their own nation) is harmful to all countries. Presumably Google will put a positive spin on anything they do, and make the arguments that are best received by the public, not the most logical arguments.

>I'm sure it was important to the people working there.

Switching from supplier A to supplier B will always be bad for supplier A. Does that mean we should never switch suppliers? Or maybe it means we should always switch supplies (since it's good for supplier B).

QuantumChaos··on MIT economist aims to move the inequality discussion beyond the “1 percent.”
>Meanwhile, wages have been stagnant and debt increasing for everyone who is not in the 1%.

But the article contains graphs showing that wages for people with bachelor's degrees are growing, and wages of people with master's degrees are growing faster.

And I don't really see the logic of your argument: your could say "X may be true, but it distracts us from talking about Y" about literally anything.

QuantumChaos··on Who or What Broke My Kids?
I think the point the author makes is fundamentally correct: the correctness of answers comes from human reasoning, and is subject to discussion and debate. It's not something completely external, and education shouldn't be a game to guess what these external decrees are. As the author says, what should matter is what the student thinks is correct, not whether they think their answer will be accepted as correct.

However, the author uses language that is belittling and rude. I think that teachers who use students as an emotional outlet for their frustrations are very harmful. I would rather see the teacher find another way to get the students to see her point of view, than emotionally browbeating them.

QuantumChaos··on “Let’s, Like, Demolish Laundry”
No, I am equating the profitability of the VC with the profitability on average, of the individual ventures they invest in. That is, the mean profit of the individual ventures.

If the VC is profitable, then the average venture is profitable, and therefore, on average, they have a positive impact on the markets they are involved in.

EDIT: in case it wasn't clear, every use of "average" by me refers to the mean, not median. So 10% vs 90% doesn't matter as long as the 10% is high enough.

QuantumChaos··on “Let’s, Like, Demolish Laundry”
I don't see how a single instance of Amazon misusing their monopoly power, equates to price rises across the board. So far I imagine the overall affect of Amazon has been to reduce consumer prices.
QuantumChaos··on “Let’s, Like, Demolish Laundry”
I will repeat my answer here: Your point is irrelevant because to be profitable really means to be profitable on average (or in the language of statistics, to be profitable in expectation). So a business that may be very profitable 10% of the time, and unprofitable 90% of the time, is equivalent to a business known to be moderately profitable.
QuantumChaos··on “Let’s, Like, Demolish Laundry”
But since profitability is better thought of in terms of averages or expectations, it makes no difference if the companies in question are all moderately profitable, or a few extremely profitable companies, and some non-profitable ones.

If the business fails, then it has disrupted existing businesses for no gain. But if it becomes extremely profitable, then presumably it has made some cost savings in order to be able to do so, and so deserves these profits.

If the average business is profitable, then the investment is justified, both for the investors, and from the point of view of society as a whole.

QuantumChaos··on “Let’s, Like, Demolish Laundry”
How does Amazon empitomise this? What goods have they raised the prices of (and why I say raise, I mean relative to the price before Amazon, not that Amazon merely increased their own prices).
QuantumChaos··on “Let’s, Like, Demolish Laundry”
A big buyout is equivalent to turning a profit, since the buyer will expect to profit from their purchase.
QuantumChaos··on “Let’s, Like, Demolish Laundry”
It's easy to make this allegation, but very hard to substantiate it, since there are many factors that influence profit, and just because a company isn't profitable now, doesn't mean that the only way they can become profitable is by starving out their competition and then raising prices. Can you give a single instance of a venture backed startup actually causing price increases after driving out their competition?
QuantumChaos··on “Let’s, Like, Demolish Laundry”
So why would VC's fund these company's?
QuantumChaos··on “Let’s, Like, Demolish Laundry”
This is based on the unjustifiable assumption that the author knows better than the VC's and other investors. In particular, the author somehow knows that these company's won't be able to turn a profit, even though the VC's and investors surely believe the company will.
QuantumChaos··on “Let’s, Like, Demolish Laundry”
How could they destroy hundreds of small businesses, if they themselves were not profitable?

It seems like you want to have your cake and eat it. You want to criticize these guys for out-competing small businesses, but you also want to claim they aren't really doing good business, that they are just wasting their investor's money.

QuantumChaos··on Getting to work on diversity at Google
>Remember how Google+ had significant uptake in the rich white tech dude demographic? Not a coincidence.

Other people have already said it, but what about Facebook or Twitter?

>If you want the best people working at your company, you should want a group with similar demographics as the customer population, and if you disagree with that, you either believe there is something inherent about certain groups that makes them better or worse at these jobs, which is plainly bigoted, or you believe that there are external social biases which cause the discrepancies.

That is a false dichotomy. If diversity is in itself good, then that implies that there are significant differences between ethnicities [1]. And in that case, it is certainly possible that different ethnicity might be better or worse at particular tasks, in this case coding. And claiming that the view that such differences is inherent, is bigoted, is just name-calling.

[1] Feel free to substitute ethnicity with X, where X satisfies "diversity means having people of different X".

QuantumChaos··on Game Theory Is Counterintuitive
No, because most games only have Nash Equilbria. Nash Equilibrium assumes that everyone is acting rationally, not just the person you are advising.

Some games, like second price auctions (under certain assumptions about people's values for the good, and knowledge of their own and other people's values) have so called dominant strategy equalibria. In this case, you can say how a person should act regardless of how others act.

But these scenarios are the exception rather than the rule.

QuantumChaos··on Thomas Piketty accuses Financial Times of dishonest criticism
Reposting my reply to your other comment in this thread (feel free to continue discussion on either thread).

According to Winship, Piketty's results are wrong/irrelevant for other, independent reasons. But not everyone shares this view, so Winship is clarifying that, for people who were initially convinced by Piketty's analysis, the FT criticism is important. But it is not important for Winship because even without the FT criticism, he has independent reasons to discounting Piketty's analysis.

I hope this explains my "beef" with the use of Winship's quotes.

QuantumChaos··on Thomas Piketty accuses Financial Times of dishonest criticism
you are misreading the context.

According to Winship, Piketty's results are wrong/irrelevant for other, independent reasons. But not everyone shares this view, so Winship is clarifying that, for people who were initially convinced by Piketty's analysis, the FT criticism is important. But it is not important for Winship because even without the FT criticism, he has independent reasons to discounting Piketty's analysis.

QuantumChaos··on Thomas Piketty accuses Financial Times of dishonest criticism
On Scott Winship, see one of my top level comments (I made two top level comments as I only started investigating this after I posted once). Whatever was printed in the article, he has said on Twitter that he does doubt Piketty's conclusions, and also that the FT allegations are significant.
QuantumChaos··on Thomas Piketty accuses Financial Times of dishonest criticism
The article quotes from a critic of Piketty, Scott Winship, but the strange nature of of the quotes (highly selective and including quotes on irrelevant matters) made me suspicious. Here are the latest tweets on the matter by him:

1/Quoted in Bloomberg today re #Piketty but sounds like I side w him on rising wealth ineq & US wealth ineq>Europe.

2/To be clear, I don't. Think his original results failed to make that case, which is why I'm less worked up than some abt alleged probs.

3/But UK--&, I now believe, US--methods need to be explained by #Piketty, else looks pretty bad. Just not CONSEQUENTIAL 4 overall thesis

This is the part of the article that quotes Winship:

> Scott Winship, an economist at the right-leaning Manhattan Institute for Policy Research, and notable critic of Piketty's analysis, said the FT's allegations weren't "significant for the fundamental question of whether Piketty's thesis is right or not". In an email to Bloomberg news agency, he wrote: "It's hard to think Piketty did something unethical when he put it up there for people like me to delve into his figures and find something that looks sketchy … Piketty has been as good or better than anyone at both making all his data available and documenting what he does generally."

QuantumChaos··on Thomas Piketty accuses Financial Times of dishonest criticism
You are right, this is possible. But I am assuming that the Krugman, Summers and other reviewers (at least somewhat) did their homework, and were correct in saying that Piketty's empirical work was unique and important.
QuantumChaos··on Thomas Piketty accuses Financial Times of dishonest criticism
The first quote is exactly the kind of vagueness that could be avoided by specifically addressing what the FT said, which other studies support his conclusions, etc.

The second quote is similarly vague, and the part on ethics is irrelevant.

QuantumChaos··on Thomas Piketty accuses Financial Times of dishonest criticism
On the one hand, Krugman, Summers, and other economists praise Piketty primarily for his unique, groundbreaking empirical work on income inequality.

On the other hand, when FT critique his empirical work, Piketty says that his work has already been superceded by other work that proves income inequality is growing. So nothing the FT can say about Piketty's work will overturn this now well established fact.

So which is it? I'm inclined to go with the former, because those economists focused on Piketty's empirical work and downplayed his theoretical work and policy suggestions. And my own knowledge of economics informs me that detailed empirical work of this sort is not done enough. So I think that while Piketty might consider the empirical part of his book to be a detail, in fact it is a very important matter. All that remains is how valid FT's criticism is, and how much it changes the results.

QuantumChaos··on Fare Dodging Is an Organized Rebellion in Stockholm, and It’s Winning
According to wikipedia, they are a far-left group who "advocate self-reduction, where the price of the service is determined by the consumer. Whereas in other cases this is done in agreement with (at least some) employees of the service provider, in the case of Planka.nu fare-dodgers are encouraged to evade fares without seeking permission."

So I would guess it is mainly a matter of principle (not one that I share). Wikipedia also states "ticket fares in Stockholm have increased dramatically over time. By one measure—single ticket price for a 10-kilometre (6.2 mi) journey—Stockholm has the most expensive-to-use public transport in the world, as of March 2009"

QuantumChaos··on The Best Programming Advice I Ever Got (2012)
I disagree that it is morally wrong to threaten people's livelihoods, or that anything is morally permissible to defend one's own livelihood.

If, by some crazy chance, someone managed to make my job unnecessary, I would just suck it up and get a different job.

I would suggest reading some General Equilibrium theory, which explains why making someone's job unnecessary is actually a good thing overall, even though it might harm that person.

QuantumChaos··on Summers on Piketty
Actually, Dr. Summers does implicitly mention the Fed, when he says

"Probably the two most important steps that public policy can take with respect to wealth inequality are the strengthening of financial regulation to more fully eliminate implicit and explicit subsidies to financial activity, and ..."

When he refers to implicit subsidies, I believe he is referring to some actions of the Fed in bailing out banks. Apart from direct bailouts, the monetary policy of the Fed was a bailout of a financial sector that was "too big to fail". So I don't think Dr. Summers is skirting around this issue.

I would further guess that the author would advocate a return to more conventional neo-Keynsian monetary policy, as opposed to the highly interventionist policies pre and post financial crisis. Which might still not satisfy your desire for "true market forces", depending on what you meant.

QuantumChaos··on To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Year Job
But if that were the case, then schools would simply be forced to pay higher wages for teachers. That, or teachers would be willing to travel further (perhaps in exchange for slightly higher wages).

In either case, the idea that a city can just "break" because it is too expensive for ordinary workers, ignores basic microeconomics.

The laws of supply and demand imply that wages go up to deal with lack of supply of certain professions. Whether that lack of supply is caused by a nationwide talent shortage, or a local high cost of living, makes no difference.

QuantumChaos··on Soylent 1.0 arrives at Ars: We mix it up and slurp it down
Not that I think Soylent is a good idea, but a nutritionist is not a well defined profession or qualification in the way the a medical doctor is.

So if the people involved in this project consider themselves qualified in the field of nutrition, I don't see how that makes them different to anyone else speaking or giving advice on the subject.

A big organization with lots of money doesn't automatically make a group of people a legitimate authority on anything. After all, you can get all sorts of qualifications in things that are clearly quackery, e.g. homeopathy.

QuantumChaos··on Why I Don’t Do CrossFit
Many people have commented on the safety of deadlifts in the article.

I believe that there is a cognitive bias towards attributing injuries to form as opposed to random chance.

Suppose that even with perfect form, there was baseline injury rate (and the injury rate increased beyond this with bad form). It would be very easy to attribute any injury, ex-post, to bad form. Reasons for this might be that a person doesn't want to appear unknowable/unskilled, wanting a feeling of control over their future outcomes, or feeling guilt about not having accomplished their goals.

When I injured my knee doing squats (patellofemoral tracking/pain), I related my symptoms to a doctor friend, who correctly diagnosed the issue, and commented that it usually happens when people try to squat too much weight. I was about to correct him that the weight in itself is not the issue, if perfect form is used. At that point I realized that the bias I described above might exist.

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →