HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

RougeFemme

6,542 karma · joined February 21, 2013

Early experience in a couple of start-ups that, alas, did not survive. More experience in mid-sized to large companies. . .non-profit, government, for-profit. . . weapons, communications, HR, healthcare. . .coder, tester, project manager. . .
submissionscomments
RougeFemme··on Consultants vs. Employees: The Real Costs
I guess it depends on the consulting/contracting model, you use, but we get to interview our consultants, so it's easier for us to determine if they have the expertise we need - or we think/hope we need.
RougeFemme··on Consultants vs. Employees: The Real Costs
We use consultants who bill by the hour. They don't charge us for lunch, but other than that, they are considered on the clock. We don't micromanage, so we are charged for any screwing around. . .unless we micromanage and they really overdo the screwing around and as long as they are meeting their milestones, we rarely - if ever - know if/when they are screwing around. It's not worth it to us - financially or mentally - you to micromanage to that level. Ditto for bathroom breaks.
RougeFemme··on Why would anyone choose to work for the Federal Government now?
Granted, the stability gap between private sector and government employment is smaller, but there is still a gap favoring government employment. Also, those folks knew they would be called back; it was just a matter of when. Layoffs in the private sector tend to be permanent - or at least of longer duration. And those folks knew there was a possibility of back pay - non-existent for laid-off employees in the private sector.

For most folks, I doubt that the pros/cons of government employment will change significantly, once the dust settles and they consider the alternatives - especially in areas where the government is the only or major employer.

RougeFemme··on Ethical to ask interview candidates to solve your company's toughest problems?
I think it's completely reasonable. It's no different from asking people at conferences, in classes, etc. And I assume the primary purpose is gauge what the candidate actually knows about the domain, how the candidate goes about solving problems, etc., - not to actually get the perfect solution to your problem, though that would be a bonus.
RougeFemme··on Troubled Obamacare website wasn't tested until a week before launch
How is the spoils system better?
RougeFemme··on Troubled Obamacare website wasn't tested until a week before launch
The NSA recruits at some of the best graduate schools. In some quarters, the joke is that if you have a PhD in math, comp sci or software engineering and you're not teaching or doing post-doc work, you must be working in the black world, which includes NSA.
RougeFemme··on Troubled Obamacare website wasn't tested until a week before launch
At least, as you indicate, there are some who care and work hard and people groaning and performing the tasks of your GS-14. . .but I feel your pain. . .I've worked on both sides of the fence.
RougeFemme··on Troubled Obamacare website wasn't tested until a week before launch
I wonder if the requirements had already been finalized and it's just the "final" signed off documentation that was delivered so late. . .yes, still broken/no process.
RougeFemme··on Troubled Obamacare website wasn't tested until a week before launch
Climb down. . .I'm not accusing anyone of lying or fabricating. And yes, I'm well aware of the prevalence of hubris. I find it hard to believe because, having worked on both sides of the fence, I've never known or heard of any agency of any size, even DoD, doing the integration themselves. They almost always have contractors doing it, though they may manage the contractors and call themselves integrators. I believe they may have referred to CMMS as integrators without giving any thought to the contractor who actually performed the integration - at the contracted direction of CMMS.
RougeFemme··on Troubled Obamacare website wasn't tested until a week before launch
There are certainly problems with the federal civil service, but how could a return to the spoils system be better? And to a large degree, the civil service still operates very much like a spoils system under the hood, despite all the documentation and attempts to the contrary.
RougeFemme··on Troubled Obamacare website wasn't tested until a week before launch
I find it hard to believe that CMMS actually performed system integration, such as it was. I find it easy to believe that CMMS hired a contractor to perform system integration. And just as the individual contractor employees saw issues, there were probably government employees within CMMS who also saw issues. . .and just enough senior executives - government and contractor - to ignore the "naysayers". . .and insist on having their fingers deeply in the pie of such a high-visibility project.

And, of course system integration was not the only project management/technical issue with this project.

RougeFemme··on US Federal Employee Salaries (2012)
Nope, just salary.
RougeFemme··on US Federal Employee Salaries (2012)
My understanding is that the health insurance is still better than what is typically available for private sector employees. The pension system is not nearly as good as it used to be, true, but it does exist, which is not true for most private sector employees.

I've worked both sides of the fence, so I'm not flinging arrows.

RougeFemme··on US Federal Employee Salaries (2012)
Colonels at the Pentagon are a dime a dozen. But a Colonel in the field - away from DC - might be a base commander. When I was a civilian working for the military and participating in/attending meetings, briefings, etc., we didn't even stand for Generals entering the room (which is protocol) unless the General had at least 2 stars. . .and not always then, depending on the level of the brass in the room.
RougeFemme··on US Federal Employee Salaries (2012)
I think the same public/private comparisons for salary, stability, etc. apply in the U.S., at least for some job categories. It's just that, as you said, the private sector pays so well for comparable positions. Salary-wise, I think less skilled position do better with government, but the higher-skilled positions do better in the private sector. If you see a government engineer/scientist/mathematician working alongside a contractor in the same role, the government employee almost always makes less.
RougeFemme··on US Federal Employee Salaries (2012)
I think public employees to the public knowing how much a particular job/role at a particular location on the salary ladder at a particular agency. But unless they share their particular role/ladder location with friends, I don't think they are opting into sharing their exact salary; only their salary range.

The people that I know who work for the federal government simply say "I'm a mathematician at NASA", not "I'm a GS-13, Step 4 mathematician and BTW, I got a bonus of X last year."

RougeFemme··on When valuable employees quit or resign
For those who periodically ask why a start-up needs someone with HR skills, here's a good example. While the HR person may not be needed, the HR person can handle things like release forms, exit interviews, care and feeding of the remaining employees, etc. -- the first 2 may not be required, but "care and feeding" certainly is.

Some CEOs can handle this, but most probably can't, due to time or temperament. Some companies may not need this, but most probably do. . .at least to help with the initial shock and/or readjustment(s).

RougeFemme··on Overdosing on Celebrity Gossip, The News, and Low Quality Information
My spin on that was not that these things should be completely ignored, but that you should be informed and act on them; if you're not going to act on them, don't constantly consume the news about them.

I don't completely agree with that. I do read about those topics; I don't necessarily act upon it, e.g., engage in climate change research but I do use that information to inform my actions, e.g., what I purchase, how I vote, etc.

RougeFemme··on The end of bosses
I liked/agreed with everything in this article except the Sunday test. I get that people need to be compatible in order to work together. I don't get why people need to want to hang out together on Sundays. It all but guarantees that people who are otherwise qualified and compatible with the team Mon-Sat will not be hired. Nothing terribly wrong with that, but why not just hire your techie frat brothers or sorority sisters?
RougeFemme··on The end of bosses
I would think that, no matter how hard a company tries to hire people of the same mindset, temporary hierarchies would develop - not necessarily along the lines of seniority, but along the lines of who had more experience/comfort/knowledge of best practices, etc. regarding a particular domain, technology, etc.

Ideally, the hierarchy would be truly temporary and whatever knowledge/experience/insight caused one person to become the project "shepherd" would be willingly shared amongst the other folks.

RougeFemme··on Living on $5,000 a year, on purpose: Meet America's 'intentional poor'
I did read the article; I don't know you jump to the assumption that they are collecting welfare. If you know otherwise, please provide the citation.

It is possible to live quite frugally. Some of these people are, as the article states, getting help from other people; that doesn't mean they are getting help from the government. BTW, only one person mentioned OWS.

Regarding the Macbook. . .you assumed these people started with absolutely no possessions. I assumed they brought some possessions with them, including the Macbook. Nowhere does she state - or is it impled - that she bought it after beginning her voluntary poverty. Also, even poor people - whether the poverty is voluntary or involuntary - receive gifts. In case of voluntary poverty - where friends and family are most likely not poor - it is quite possible to receive a Macbook as a gift.

I've known people who've done this - and are still doing it. Just as the article stated, most, if not all, of them came from relatively privileged lives and always had the option of returning - or at least moving up from relative poverty.

RougeFemme··on The war on drugs is a broken business model
The Wars on fat, sugar, etc. are also occurring outside of socialized medicine. (I assume that by socialized medicine, you mean, in the U.S.,Medicare, Medicaid, and any other health program explicitly funded and/or provided by a government entity.) These wars are also being fought by private insurance companies, where the healthy subsidize the less-healthy, and the profit motive exists.
RougeFemme··on Where Can the Middle Class Buy a Home?
Building smaller starter homes, with more "basic" decorator options would help, e.g., does a starter home have to have 2.5 bathrooms? The counter-argument, right or wrong, is that builders say that with the proffers they are required to pay, they can't make a decent profit on smaller, more basic homes and that the buying public doesn't want them.
RougeFemme··on Why US government IT fails so hard, so often
And, because of the political clout that these large companies have and the revolving door between senior government and the large companies, government engineers and project managers who are competent and capable are routinely overruled when they try to raise red flags.
RougeFemme··on Why US government IT fails so hard, so often
I think that often, it's not just the interaction between the government and its contractor, but the activities within the contractor as well, though the interaction between government and contractor can certainly exacerbate any existing issues within the contractor.
RougeFemme··on Why US government IT fails so hard, so often
I don't think lack of accountability is what pushed the work out to contractors. And if that is the case, does that mean the accountability "stick" got pushed out to the contractors. I think work got pushed out to contractors from a desire to out-source and because contractors, for various reasons, generally do a much better job of staying abreast of best practices than the government employees. And I say this as someone who has worked on both sides of the fence.

I agree that requirements are a big issue. In addition to the requirements issues you mention, there is the problem with the "business line owners" attempting to unnecessarily dictate implementation details, poorly defining the functional requirements in the first place and ignoring interfacing systems.

RougeFemme··on Could Better Testing Practices Have Prevented the Healthcare.gov Defects?
But isn't the DC contracting community involved in other high availability transactional systems? For example, isn't one of the ACH systems a government or pseduo-government system?
RougeFemme··on Could Better Testing Practices Have Prevented the Healthcare.gov Defects?
I don't think PMP certifications are any worse than any other certifications, though often, as with other certifications, they often aren't worth the paper they are printed on. And I agree that the project managers often have little-to-no technical expertise in the project they are managing; but that's not supposed to be their job. Their job is supposed to be to manage the job that the experts are working on and let the experts do their thing. Although they (PMs) should have at least enough knowledge to understand discussions at a high level, facilitate when necessary and recognize when one of the experts is blowing smoke out his/her ass.
RougeFemme··on Could Better Testing Practices Have Prevented the Healthcare.gov Defects?
Well, you can give them your own business requirements, which should be high-level and state "I need a system that performs these functions for this many people". What you should not do is dictate design and implementation details. That's when you rely on their expertise. . .unfortunately, as you stated, that's rarely how it works.

Also, it would have really helped to have someone - likely not a developer - to bridge the gap and ask the customer "do you really need people to set up user access before viewing plans or you just want that? why?" and then turn to the developer and say "ok, what does that mean technically? what the pros and cons?"

RougeFemme··on Student Entrepreneurs: If Peter Thiel Calls, Hang Up
I agree that working for another company doesn't always make you a good entrepreneur. But I do think that, depending on the size of the company, the dynamics and your role within the company you can learn, for free, a lot about what not to do, particularly regarding the basics of management. And regarding hiring, you can learn, what you actually want/value during the interview and in an employee vs. what you think you want.
← PreviousPage 3 of 14Next →