HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SECProto

4,222 karma · joined May 25, 2018

submissionscomments
SECProto··on Starship will attempt a launch this Friday
The seal thing is very old news [1] that is pretty irrelevant other than to show Musk will present any regulation in the most unfavourable light if it affects his schedule. I see the exact same thing with contractors around me complaining about the "red tape" of dealing with in-water permits for construction, needing to install erosion and sediment control to protect waterways from runoff, etc.

[1] here's a 5 year old news article with a screenshot from 2013. https://www.teslarati.com/spacex-paints-x-on-western-falcon-...

SECProto··on Gigantic heat caverns in Mustikkamaa have now been filled with water (2021)
> for each € invested in nuclear, we’re actually much better off investing in lower-cost, lower-risk projects and technologies (renewables, electrification, heat pumps, grid upgrades, insulation, storage, etc) that deliver more carbon savings per € spent much more quickly.

Don't get me wrong, I absolutely think all those are key, and need to be focused on immediately. Those help to reduce demand, but (with the exception of renewables) don't help improve supply. If we want to eliminate carbon emissions worldwide, nuclear will be a key component (along with massive renewables). For example, the Japanese grid has been developing various renewables on superdrive since 2011, yet they are only at 20% renewable, with national carbon emissions ~500gCO2/kWh - dramatically higher than when their nuclear fleet was operational. Germany has been pushing renewables for close to two decades, but they closed down their nuclear plants and are similarly at ~500gCO2/kWh. France has had a nuclear-based grid for a couple decades and while it has its own issues, their emissions intensity is ~50gCO2/kWh. Ontario is hydro and nuke, they're ~100gCO2/kWh (some storage and more renewables would help them dramatically reduce emissions from gas, but current conservative premier spent billions scrapping that plan)

> To put this in perspective: you could build on the order of 1000 Mustikkamaa heat caverns for the price of one nuclear plant!

Yes, all you need is 1000 old oil storage caverns already dug sitting there waiting to be filled with water...

SECProto··on The hijacking of rare Japanese KitKats
Yes, I wasn't referring specifically to japanese kitkats - I don't know what's in them, been a couple years. But the use of palm oil has become pretty pervasive and (maybe it's placebo effect) the flavour has declined.
SECProto··on Gigantic heat caverns in Mustikkamaa have now been filled with water (2021)
Yep, the EPR design has had major constructability issues with every site (except the one in China, but there may be a lack of transparency with any issues/solutions that were done with them). EPR2 looks specifically to address the issues they've faced at Hinkley, Olkiluoto, and Flamanville ... we'll see how it turns out, hopefully it isn't just another example of throwing out one set of issues for a different set.

Most large construction projects suffer when there is too great a separation between design and construction. There needs to be feedback from one to the other, and when it takes 30 years to go from conceptual design to operational reactor, that feedback loop just isn't there. One big promise of SMRs is for components to be prefabricated - if you're building multiple of an object, the connection between design and construction will be much closer.

SECProto··on The hijacking of rare Japanese KitKats
sugar instead of HFCS, cocoa butter instead of palm oil. There's definitely better quality in some markets and products than others
SECProto··on Gigantic heat caverns in Mustikkamaa have now been filled with water (2021)
Yep, deep geothermal would be cool, but not as mature. Was specifically advocating nuclear as it is basically a drop in replacement for fossil fuel in existing CHP plants. SMRs might work, though I am somewhat skeptical of anyone proposing "this brand new nuclear tech!" as a solution to difficulties constructing proven nuclear tech - we have decades of examples showing they basically swap one issue for another
SECProto··on Gigantic heat caverns in Mustikkamaa have now been filled with water (2021)
1% reduction from one project seems pretty decent to me. Especially when it's just from reusing pre-existing caverns from oil storage to decrease the district heat emissions.

Heating emissions for a city at 60° North are a big challenge to reduce, and combined heat and power is a huge efficiency gain - the heat is otherwise wasted, and thermal emissions are an environmental issue in their own right.

The emissions could be reduced much further if they decrease the 55% of their generation that comes from fossil fuel fired CHP plants[1], and increased their nuclear capacity from current 27% (unfortunately they had to cancel a plan to build another reactor because their partner was rosatom[2])

[1] https://fi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helen

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_Finland#React...

SECProto··on Illinois Senate approves plan to allow new nuclear reactors
> I'm not an electrical engineer but it sounds implausible for power to be transferred that far without losing a bunch of it in the process, unless you have massive cables.

Read up about Hydro Quebec. They generate gigawatts in Northern Quebec and export large amounts to New England. HVDC is pretty efficient.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydro-Qu%C3%A9bec's_electricit...

SECProto··on Mass producing the most expensive rice cooker [video]
Non metric units are a nightmare! I find them terribly interesting, but if you're looking for an unambiguous unit of measure, the metric system is the way.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mile#Comparison_table

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pint#Other_pints

SECProto··on Mass producing the most expensive rice cooker [video]
I think most of your points have been addressed, but this one..

> a Zojirushi cup isn't the same as an imperial cup

Indeed, a zojirushi cup is 180ml, while an imperial cup is 284ml. Perhaps you meant a US Customary cup, at either 237ml or 240ml? Then there's a whole mess of other measurements people call a "cup" (118ml, 227ml, 250ml...)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cup_%28unit%29

SECProto··on Nuclear Conversion for Starship
It requires the shielding no matter what the transportation method is. If one wanted to build a cycler, conceptually it is somewhat similar to staging a lunar mission with rendezvous in low earth orbit. The construction methodology would be something like the following:

1. Build the base structure of cycler in earth orbit, then transfer it into the orbit you want (i.e. earth-jupiter intersecting). This would be structure, engines, shielding. This might require a couple dozen nuclear thermal boosters, or maybe it has to be phased over two launch periods and assembled in the cycling orbit

2. Assemble in earth orbit everything you want for a manned mission (food, water, landing craft, astronauts)

3. Rendezvouz that material with the cycler on its next orbit (I don't know the timing for earth-jupiter - maybe 12 years after step 1). This is a comparatively small effort, as the shielding and habitable space was already taken care of with step 1

4. live your life for the year or whatever the transfer is

5. Take your landing craft from the cycler to Europa surface

Different crews can hop on the original cycler by repeating steps 2 to 5. Conceptually you would want multiple of these cyclers coming and going, so that a crew can arrive on Europa on cycler A and return on Cycler G, only spending 5 years on Europa instead of 12. Their advantage is that the big heavy mass (sheilding) only has to be launched once, and can be used repeatedly, indefinitely.

SECProto··on Nuclear Conversion for Starship
> That leaves lots of room for radiation shielding and consumables, and makes it the only halfway practical choice for multi-year missions into the outer solar system.

I disagree, one of the types I referenced is cyclers, which are specifically good for the same kind of reason. NERVA is another alternative that becomes similarly easier as you scale it up. All three types would need in-space assembly, so no big issues with any of them that way.

Don't get me wrong, Orion is cool (and the only way to conceivably run an interstellar mission with known technology/physics), but it isn't necessary (or even desirable imo) for interplanetary missions, at least as far as saturn anyway.

SECProto··on Nuclear Conversion for Starship
> The Project Orion design [...] is surprisingly practical, and probably our only way to get humans past Mars.

I don't think this is the general consensus. It is seen as one of the only ways to get humans out of the solar system, but other nuclear rockets[1], and even chemical options[2], could get humans to eg the Jovian moons[3] with TRL's much higher than Project Orion.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NERVA

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interplanetary_spaceflight#Cyc...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exploration_of_Jupiter#Human_e...

SECProto··on Why Japan has blue traffic lights instead of green
Are you referring to reference number 184? I'm looking for a primary source for your statement that midori was the colour standardized in law since the 1930s, because the section I linked about colours explicitly calls out ao and notes the difference in different jurisdictions.
SECProto··on Why Japan has blue traffic lights instead of green
> https://www.xrite.com/hue-test

Fun test! I'd note for others, the quality of your screen can make a difference - I found one of the lines a lot easier on my phone (first try) than on my computer (second try) - though I got perfect both times.

SECProto··on Why Japan has blue traffic lights instead of green
> for a start, the first JP law on traffic lights in the 1930s used midori, not ao.

Have a source for that? This section[1] of the ja.wikipedia article could apparently use your revisions - both kanji are acceptable.

[1] https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E4%BA%A4%E9%80%9A%E4%BF%A1%E5...

SECProto··on Canada ends official time signal
> Canada's largest sub is in a mall

Your joke comment is a quarter century out of date

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_current_ships_of_the_R...

https://www.nsnews.com/local-news/north-van-firm-scraps-west...

SECProto··on Ask HN: What is your experience with Nano-Hydroxyapatite toothpaste?
> The burden is on the flossers to prove the efficacy beyond a secondary link and prove flossing is better in a controlled study

No, you're missing my point - the secondary link is the study of flossing w.r.t. oral health outcomes. The primary (causal) links are whether flossing removes food particles, and whether food particles cause tooth decay (neither of which seems to be under contention here). By just studying whether flossing improves oral hygiene, you're introducing a huge number of variables that are difficult to control for (flossing skill, other hygiene factors like flossing or "rinsing", dietary choices, self reporting errors, etc etc etc).

(edit: to summarize: A causes B, B causes C, but you don't like saying A causes C because people kind of suck at A, and D, E, and F all also cause C which makes studying the relationship between A and C a challenge)

SECProto··on Ask HN: What is your experience with Nano-Hydroxyapatite toothpaste?
If brush my teeth, then I floss, bits of food still come out from between my teeth (they're quite tightly spaced). I don't need an academic study to confirm whether or not the flossing is helpful (unless you're disputing the causal link between food residue and tooth decay)
SECProto··on “Real Water” that poisoned dozens contained chemical from rocket fuel
> Blame the market, not the Whole Foods

I blame the regulations (more specifically, the lack thereof)

SECProto··on Pixel 8 Pro
You've highlighted exactly what the comment you were replying to was talking about, the aspect ratio is much different. The Pixel 8 Pro has a 6.7" screen vs the 6" on nexus 6, despite being 10% narrower.
SECProto··on Fairphone 5 review: The most uncompromising repairable phone yet
"AppleCare+" costs more than my phone over a 2-3 year period, and it sounds like you still have to pay for screen replacement?
SECProto··on Why don’t Americans eat mutton?
Etymologically, English uses different words for animals than the meat, and the food word comes from the french (cow/beef/boeuf, pig/pork/porc, sheep/mutton/mouton). Looking at goat in french, Chèvre, that is used quite regularly to describe goat's milk cheeses, but I've never heard it or a derivative to refer to goat meat. Typical dishes I've seen are things like "curried goat". Wikipedia has some more info, but notably, the article title is "goat meat".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goat_meat

SECProto··on Striking auto workers want a 40% pay increase–the same rate their CEOs’ pay grew
> In four year's time, will their pay be 70% higher than it is today if all demands are met?

No? If a given employee is making $17/hr, and working the union agreed 40 hours a week, they are making $35360. If they get a 40% raise over four years, they will be making $23.80/hr, and working 32 hours a week, giving an annual wage of $39,603.20. This is an increase in annual wage of 12% over four years. The hourly wage is an increase of 40% over four years. No one is getting close to 70%.

> Are you hopeful about a 70% pay increase in four years?

Honestly yes, I think that is in the realm of possibility, as I'm currently pretty underwaged for my industry and experience level. Currently interviewing for a job at a 45% increase. Regardless, as I demonstrated above, your 70% number is, as you put it, propagandha. I certainly feel that the post-2007 UAW hires aren't being compensated adequately for any industry, and the 40% hourly increase they're seeking is quite reasonable.

SECProto··on Striking auto workers want a 40% pay increase–the same rate their CEOs’ pay grew
> Settle in for a wild propaganda-filled fall season

> There is no reality where line workers screwing in the same 3 door bolts all day long are getting what amounts to an effective ~70% pay increase in one year.

Please align your own comments. They are looking for a 40% hourly pay increase over 4 years, and a reduction to a 32 hour work week. These combined work out to an increase of 12% in annual pay, over four years. No UAW hired since 2007 makes more than $17/hour.

If you're looking for more details of what the UAW wants, they are in this article: https://www.cnbc.com/2023/09/13/where-uaw-negotations-stand-...

SECProto··on To make dishwashers great again? (2020)
> So your going to pretend the first part of my comment doesn't exist?

First half of which comment?

> Since it appears your confused as to what the article is about, let me spell it out step by step:

I was replying to your comments, not the article. Your comments specifically asked about machines that had quicker modes. Your comments didn't have any of the details you're now providing. I haven't read the article and don't have any interest in doing so.

SECProto··on To make dishwashers great again? (2020)
You were asking for a machine to wash dishes in an hour with a dishwasher available between 2010 and 2020. This machine clearly fits that bill. Now you want something that is also available now (but not from a store only from the brand's website), and it needs to use an identical cleaning cycle to the normal mode.

You've moved the goalposts so far they're onto an entirely different field here.

SECProto··on Microsoft to kill off third-party printer drivers in Windows
> What about Brother?

that didn't appear to be an exhaustive list. Looking at the Mopria site, I see Brother along with 9 other brands not mentioned.

https://mopria.org/certified-products/

SECProto··on To make dishwashers great again? (2020)
> Not only is it discontinued,

It's well available at retailers in Canada. I could go purchase one this afternoon.

> but it doesn't seem to have info. on when it was introduced. Can you link a model that is confirmed to predate November 2020?

The product manual mentions a revision to the power cord made in September 2020, so that product predates nov 2020.

SECProto··on To make dishwashers great again? (2020)
Not OP, but I googled bosch 800 series, the pics have a "speed 60" cycle: https://www.bosch-home.ca/en/shop-products/SHXM78Z55N#/
← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →