1,965 karma · joined September 4, 2008
EDIT: To be fair, I wouldn't be surprised either if there was a dedicated circuit that sensed change in luminous energy that bypassed V1. I'd google but I'm on limited wireless right now.
Here's an article that's informative, but doesn't quite answer the question: http://phenomena.nationalgeographic.com/2014/03/13/how-light... It talks about the blue light pathway that David Berson discovered in intrinsically photosensitive ganglion cells. This was surprising because, while this was before my time, I think most people thought that it was the rods and cones that were photosensitive, containing proteins called opsins that transduce light into neural signal. Rods and cones can be considered input cells, ganglion cells sit above the retinal circuitry can can be through of as output cells that perform computations from their inputs and pipe that information down the optic nerve, which eventually leads to primary visual cortex located at the back of your skull. Though there are plenty of opportunities for side branching minor paths.
I too agree that the universe objectively exists separately from our minds. However, there are many facts about the world, most of them banal. The ones that are useful to us or make the world feel more understandable regardless of their ultimate truth are the ones that resonate. In particular, art often expresses emotional truths about ourselves and our relationships to others. "We're all doomed." "We're all saved." These have little objective reality but can powerfully affect us at the right moment.
> IMO, if things like novels and poems are considered art then it can be communicating truths, but truths that are difficult to communicate in explicit, theoretical terms.
You're absolutely right. I think that things like novels and poems are located a little farther towards the center on the spectrum I mentioned than something that purely communicates feeling (like an abstract painting). I think the reason they are so successful is that they deliver one or more logically digestible messages along with a feeling. It often seems that people aren't convinced by logic, but rather by a shift in how they feel about something.
> This bit wasn't entirely clear to me and I thought it could be fleshed out a bit more.
Again, you're absolutely right. I felt that way too but I ran out of steam at the time. I think I have the energy to expand on it now. :) What I was trying to say was that your motivations shift based on how you feel, and the more powerful the feeling, the potentially larger the shift. Something is out of balance if you're feeling something very strongly. You'll be motivated to correct that imbalance, and in the process consider a different course of action.
I talked to a friend that had taken a course on AI and minds at MIT and he said he considered emotions a filter on decision space.
> It might fit under that but, as I said above, I think it can be used as a means to communicate truths. Eg to broaden someone's perspective on the world
I haven't quite figured out what a truth is yet. It's definitely a kind of message that emotionally resonates. I sort of sense that the framework I proposed could be worked to encompass them, but I haven't done enough thinking on it yet. In this article I was focusing very narrowly on the extreme case of pure feeling to distill important truths about it, but the middle ground is where most of the important stuff happens. Simple models are good for investigating complex phenomenal since you can see exactly how they work and break down.
I'd be happy to hear your ideas!
While it doesn't cover all of art in a philosophy of art sense, it covers what I think most people think of when they think of art. Maybe you'll find it helpful (or better yet maybe you'll teach me a lesson).
1) Questioning the legitimacy of the electoral process without evidence. This could turn the US into a powder keg if he keeps it up past election day.
2) Rejecting nuclear non-proliferation and the stability of international alliances, paired with a volatile and immature temperament, could lead to the nuclear clock ticking to midnight.
3) Proposing the blacklist people based solely on a religious test. I'm not religious, but if there was one thing I learned in Hebrew school, is that we must never again allow this.
4) Obliquely threatening his political opponent with violence and directly threatening to jail his political opponent. Does this sound like a candidate from a first world country?
That said there are other criticisms, for instance: Are thinking and feeling really an axis or are they two independent traits? Are there other useful axes not included?
While I sort of cringe at the idea of using this for assigning people jobs, there area few people in my life that fit some of the type narratives fairly well and it helped me understand their motivations a bit better, which did legitimately help my relationships with them.
Good thing that offline web apps will start making most native apps obsolete in a few years.
Thanks for the link, these little devices are super interesting!
EDIT: If you want to see my back of the envelope calculations you can check out the second half of this article I wrote: https://medium.com/@willsilversmith/the-future-requires-unit...
You do have some points, but your examples aren't so good.
1. In your test example, the students didn't know the course material, they just thought they did. They don't actually qualify for an A+. 2. In the scene of the accident, the rule there is in place because there is an incentive to leave the scene of the accident. Ideally, someone who didn't know the law would get a less harsh penalty than someone who did (so intent matters).
In the case above, there is something special happening. The rights of citizenship are on a much higher more protected plane than other rights (as other fundamental rights, voting, residency, amongst others are derived from them). We are allowed to use strict liability for leaving the scene of an accident because it's a shitty thing to do regardless of the law and because while it does affect the fundamental rights of liberty, it is based on something that the person did to deserve a punishment.
In the case of citizenship, if they technically qualify and act as though they do, that should be enough to at least give them the option of taking it retroactively. It's too fundamental for the most simplistic interpretation of bureaucratic rules to suffice.
If you're in Boston, give Aeronaut Brewery in Somerville a try (https://goo.gl/maps/bm22XaBvFPQ2). I have something of an interest of it, but I (unsurprisingly) recommend them.
IPA is a reaction against that flavor profile. You'll be starting to see new flavors come about as people (like yourself) become tired of IPAs.