4,780 karma · joined January 7, 2013
Did you mean to say "... which it is not", or "which it is, thus the boringness"?
There is no incompatibility between proximal and distal, what they call functional, explanations of behavior. Once you have a brain with a reward system, a good way to encourage (discourage) a behavior that is (dis)functional is to make it (dis)pleasurable.
A similar distinction in explanations of human behavior is what anthropologists call [emic/etic](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emic_and_etic). The emic viewpoint is that of the subject themselves; the etic viewpoint is that of the anthropologist (the ethologist in this case). A classical, and beautiful example is Malinowski's description of the [Kula ring](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kula_ring) in Papua New Guinea. Participants in the ring see themselves as exchanging presents; Malinowski showed that there is a further political and economic significance to the ring. The two perspectives are perfectly compatible.
> Yes, broadcasting is a cool thing, but the docs mostly explains 'how' but not 'why' or 'what for'.
I'd say that, even for the 'how', thinking "OK, I have a [1, 1, 2, 2, 1] and a [3, 2, 1, 2, 5] arrays, which means that element-wise multiplication would result in a [3, 2, 2, 2, 5] array" is very useful in reasoning about broadcasting.
Just relying on simple examples and trying to build an intuition for the general case (which is the route favored in the numpy docs, I'd say) doesn't quite work, at least for me.
>So, there’s a total of three types of vectors in NumPy: 1D arrays, 2D row vectors, and 2D column vectors.
I think you can have 'vectors' of arbitrarily high dimension, by adding empty axes, or doing, say, .reshape(-1, 1, 1, 1).
I would also tie this point with the rule for broadcasting that dimensions which do not match need to have a value of one. I'm endlessly confused about broadcasting, and find the explicit rule useful.
I'm sorry this was your experience. My PhD in philosophy was very rewarding, as have been my academic jobs since---with the inevitable ups and downs.
This is the only recording I am aware of that superimposes the relevant lines from those chorales on top of the Ciaccona. It's very informative, I think, and also very beautiful.
I've read Wolfram claim this, but as a conjecture, iirc. Is there a formal proof that in order to predict life patterns we essentially need to run the cellular automaton?