HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SeanKilleen

174 karma · joined March 15, 2012

A mind at work. Trying to be all the human I can be with the time I have. (he/him)

Web: https://SeanKilleen.com Twitter: https://twitter.com/sjkilleen Mastodon: https://mastodon.social/@sjkilleen

--

About Me

* VP of Innovation and Products at SCT Software * Microsoft MVP (one of roughly 120 Dev Tools MVPs in the US) * Organizer of .NET DC * Fun fact: I once led a team to deliver a modernization project that analysts called "more complex than the moon landing". * I'm the lead of the NUnit docs team and (as of Feb 2023) am a member of the NUnit Core Team. * I am a huge fan of the agility & DevOps mindsets. You can find me collaborating for smaller loops almost everywhere I go. I love taking groups from A -> B. * I love teaching and have been a certified instructor for the ScrumAlliance CSD certification and the ICAgile Agile Testing & Automation certifications.

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/seankilleen; my proof: https://keybase.io/seankilleen/sigs/272yKruz_hpcDbhhszQV4rUnwUZIgRoXm4TBQUJpjWA ]

submissionscomments
SeanKilleen··on Microsoft Acquires Calendar App Sunrise for North of $100M
One of my most indispensable apps on iOS. I use it multiple times per day. I hope the excellent integration remains. My guess is that Sunrise will stay on its own or become the next version of Outlook's calendar on iOS (which is fine by me as long as it remains free and usable with my Google Calendar as well.)

Congratulations to the team!

SeanKilleen··on Show HN: Colores – A simple app I built to find color palettes based on words
Neat tool. Thanks for sharing!
SeanKilleen··on Paket: Package manager for .NET and Mono
Visual studio just added support for Bower and Grunt[1]. I'm thinking that might help us separate the ecosystem again -- nuget for server-side, bower/grunt for client-side.

[1] http://www.hanselman.com/blog/IntroducingGulpGruntBowerAndNp...

SeanKilleen··on 4K for $649: Asus' PB287Q monitor reviewed
Thank you. I came here specifically to say just that. I'm trying to do more to say something in cases like these and call it when I see it. That usage was jarring and yes, completely out of place / uncalled for. Glad others feel same. Of all the analogies in the world, that was the choice?
SeanKilleen··on Parallella Pre-Order Shipping Update
Anyone else think they're missing a bit of an opportunity by not calling these messages "parallella-grams"?

I'll show myself out.

SeanKilleen··on Inactive Account Manager
Sorry I didn't see this earlier. A fantastic tool, even if it's filling me with existential dread having to write these messages to my loved ones.

A really elegant solution to the "Dead man switch". I'm glad Google thought to do this. It may be a small thing, but it did really matter to me.

SeanKilleen··on TurboTax Maker Intuit Funnels Millions to Lobby Against Easier Tax Returns
This is probably better left for "Idea Sunday", but I keep coming back to the fact that:

* We have languages for defining business processes & workflows (e.g. BPMN/BPML);

* We have open-source workflow engines (such as Activiti in Java and others all over the language spectrum) that utilize BPMN and terms;

* We have open-source ways of maintaining changes to these things over time.

I know it would be a monumental task, but why not start an open-source org to tackle Tax visibility at Federal and State levels?

With enough civic-minded hackers and accountants (both of which I believe exist), we could begin the process of transcribing the tax code into an interchange format. Then as we begin to see the updates each year, we can track the changes via source control.

Does anybody know if efforts like this have been undertaken anywhere else? Otherwise, I may have found my passion project.

Furthermore, does anyone know anything about the process by which Intuit makes this happen? They clearly have workflows and inputs into them; they had to get there somehow. I'd be interested in any/all knowledge that could be opened up on this.

SeanKilleen··on A Request for a Startup: Gmail 'Waiting For Reply' Tab
Check out ActiveInbox: http://activeinboxhq.com. Been one of their happy customers for a long time now. When reviewing an email, I hit 'waiting' on their action bar, and then they show up as a radar list (their take on multiple inboxes). Loved it so much I paid for it.
SeanKilleen··on Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former colleague needs our help
Happy to donate.

The button was a little hard to see for me on the site (particularly on mobile).

The URL that the button sent me to (I forget whether Paypal makes this useless or not, but I'm hoping it works):

https://www.paypal.com/us/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_flow&SESSION=Q...

SeanKilleen··on Introducing Paper
Quick suggestion: a reminder that this app is coming. Rather than tell me to share it, remember that February 3 is days away and I'm not really inspired to put it on my calendar. would have been great to see a request to get notified on launch via my choice of social network / e-mail.
SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
Hey there! Thanks for commenting. I think I commented on this aspect in a few other places on the thread, but while I glossed over the IT troubleshooting steps in my blog post, I've been in IT for 10+ years in the roles of support, sysadmin, and developer. I _of course_ did some troubleshooting. Two different PCs with internet connections that worked completely reliably both had different issues, and they were both in known stable states at the time. On each, I'd tested the internet connection, speed, etc. Nothing else was wrong with my internet connection at the time, at least in terms of things like loading web pages, downloads, and streaming HD video. In the first case, the speed seemed to drop to zero and then timeout. In the second, case the file took a long time to download and then came out corrupted anyway. I'm not saying these things don't happen; but I'm saying that, if it's a company's bread and butter, it would make more sense to put as many safeguards in place to make sure that after 12+ hours, a corrupted file doesn't happen.

Also, I'm aware that a few dropped packets can be an issue. This is why I used Backblaze's advertised downloader application -- I got the impression that it would provide better stability, checking, etc. to ensure that the zip file did not get corrupted.

I also mention the external HDDs in my post, but my point is that I pay them so that I can restore my files conveniently, not so that I can be upsold to a $189 drive. Normally, I would drop the cash, but after just spending several hundred dollars on a new motherboard, I figured I would use their download mechanism, which is offered. I think I'm allowed to have a reasonable expectation that it would work.

With all that said, this is for sure not some "grab your pitchforks!" moment. I'm doing this partly to call attention to my own stupidity at putting my faith in one cloud backup provider, and also to highlight that Backblaze's process for restoring could likely be a little bit smoother, given that this is when users would like things to be absolutely foolproof. I remain a fan of Backblaze's CEO who was responsive when support wasn't, and of the company itself which has done great things like open-sourcing its hardware.

I've since been in contact with support again and I will be sure to update my post once the matters are resolved.

SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
One other note: I think it's important to say that I'm a HUGE fan of what Backblaze does in terms of open-sourcing their storage box designs and how they accomplish things. I think that's a noble thing to do, and have always thought highly of them for that.
SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
Haha, nevermind, I'm an idiot. Just hadn't considered that the sheer amount of content would knock it off rather quickly (which makes sense, given that this is not nearly worth the focus that some other topics are.)
SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
A question, because I'm unfamiliar with the way HN works in this regard. My article was #2 on the front page for a brief spell.

Now I look, and it's nowhere to be found.

Is this by design? I don't need it to be on the top page and this isn't about the page views, I'm just not sure how it would disappear. Did a moderator somewhere frown upon it?

SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
I appreciate this comment. And you have a great point that I could have waited longer to post this. I've never posted to HN before with any sort of results; my goal wasn't really to rush this out there. It just seemed like a conversation that was worth having, and I didn't think through the fact that it would look like a very ranty customer before posting it here. Your perspective has been very helpful in that regard.

As a (minor) side note, regarding the download speeds, the bottleneck wasn't my speed I don't think (though I do have Comcast and so I'm sure the mileage varies). Right now I'm pulling 56mbps down and even when when my laptop was dealing with slow internet it was still 13-15 mbps.

SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
Agree 100%. In the future I plan to do this with both my local and cloud personal backups. (I would always do this with any business-related backup; I don't know why I my standards be lower for my personal data.)
SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
By "not being sure if it was Chrome", I mean that by any user's standards, I had closed and re-opened the application several times.

The first issue (downloads not working) was on an otherwise-fine laptop that I checked to ensure could do other bandwidth-sensitive tasks (streaming HD video, etc.) it was only the Backblaze site and downloader that showed 0-3kb/sec and then failed.

I could have done a lot of weird configurations, but just to be clear, in this situation, I did not. On the first download that didn't work, I was restoring to a laptop that I had just booted up and had not performed any configuration on. In the second case, I was downloading a 6GB file to newly restored system that I'd rebuilt from scratch, and I'd tested all of the components (including the network connection, disks, etc.) prior to considering the rebuild complete. After that and all of the updates, it had run in a stable condition for some time before I attempted the download.

I agree that the customer is not always right. But also note that I am not claiming that backblaze is evil. I'm claiming that this process and my experience makes me question their model as well as my own idiocies.

And I also should note that while I might not seem that adept in this scenario, I've spent years as an IT support person, systems administrator, and developer. Which is not saying I'm right all the time or to bolster my case, just to note that I didn't do _no_ troubleshooting before I wrote the post.

SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
I understand this concept. I also would not describe me as "decrying" Backblaze at all, nor saying that restoring backups is fundamentally broken. It's broken for me _right now_, and I think the UX and approach could be better.

I've been in IT for 10+ years, and while force killing chrome worked, it was a genuine surprise, given that every other site (including bandwidth-sensitive) activities performed fine. On that one, I should have dug deeper. Rather than closing and reopening the windows, I should have killed the processes sooner. I'm willing to give them a pass on that.

I'm more concerned about waiting 12+ hours for a 6GB restore that then can't be extracted and restored, even when I used their downloader to ensure better results.

These issues also happened on two different machines, both of which work fine in every other respect.

SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
A fair point. Yes, I've tested and restored things before. However, those were normally smaller footprints and not the entirety of my data. Given the rest of the public's generally good experience with them that I could find (and kept seeing), I felt fairly confident that my data is safe (which is to say, I might not be able to get to it easily, but it's not going to disappear into thin air either).

I'm thinking given prior experiences, other users, etc. that my experience currently is the anomaly (and hoping so).

SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
Haha, I appreciate the defense. At the same time, I understand the economical aspect of the service, and there is a measure of "you get what you pay for."

To be fair, I wouldn't call Backblaze hacks by any means, but I understand your point about the business responsibilities of companies and not giving them a pass just because they're a price-friendly SaaS.

SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
Yep, you weren't. Glad to know I wasn't the only one. Speeds varied for me, though the transfer did take much longer than the estimates. And that makes sense, given that I'm sure it's a ton of bandwidth to deal with all of those multiple restores. All the same, setting some expectations in those situations would be helpful, too.
SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
A good point: "mission critical" is an overstatement and I should phrase that differently. "Critical" to me means personal value (i.e. family photos), and not necessarily in terms of timeliness (i.e. business related).

And to clarify, I don't expect personal attention. Contacting the CEO was because I thought there might be a legitimate problem with a server and support hadn't responded, and writing this blog came after I'd attempted to follow up with support but hadn't heard back for over 8 hours.

I've stated this elsewhere on the thread but I'm by no means out to shame Backblaze. I think there are some UX points worth revisiting, and I may be looking at another provider, but I'm not trying to damn the company. I think it's a discussion worth having on how they might do things better (and also how I might do things better).

SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
I agree with your point to a certain extent -- I've spent many years in IT Support as well. With that said:

* I went out of my way to avoid Pitchforks, merely calling attention to an issue and also ensuring I blamed myself enough * A 6GB download took 12+ hours. How many times am I supposed to wait for critical data that long to have it fail, and what happens when I try my 340 GB restoration, wait weeks, and it fails? * I think there are many potential better ways of doing it -- breaking into chunks and verifying each chunk as it is downloaded, any sort of check before the application says "complete", a little more finesse than merely using 7-Zip, etc. There are ways the experience could be improved is the point I'm making, since as customers this is the part where Backblaze really earns its keep.

I have no desire for pitchforks, which is why I pointed out that the CEO was extremely helpful and that I'm hopeful the problem will be resolved.

This is not an attempt to shame / dump on Backblaze; if they resolve the problem I'll very much still recommend and use them. However, both sides of the issue (my idiocy/negligence and Backblaze's areas for improvement) seem to be worth discussing.

SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
Could you elaborate? Same reasons in that you had slow or broken restorations?

Also curious: have you had to restore with CrashPlan, and if so, how has that process differed?

SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
From what I gather, my situation may be the anomaly. Still concerning though. I'm still processing a 340 GB restore in the hopes that this one will go better. We'll see.

Your success has me hopeful!

SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
Wired connection during both attempts (even on the laptop). But you're right and it does go without saying.
SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
I agree, and I would add to that: "as long as you also have a local source." That was my failure here. Had I backed up to a local source, the slow restore times / issues would be marginal at best. So there are two lessons from my perspective: Backblaze needs to get its restore scenarios fixed for folks like me, and I need to get my shit together as far as a back up strategy. Good lessons to be learned for all I think.
SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
Precisely the point I'm making. It was hubris and laziness and I'm surprised that I let myself go that long. In a follow-up article I discuss an overview of what I'll be doing going forward: http://www.seankilleen.com/2014/01/my-newest-backup-system-p...
SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
Correct. They appear to basically zip the data using 7-zip and then transfer it, but I'm not sure what sort of hashing/checking they do to make sure the file makes it to me successfully.

Very possible that the next time I download the 6GB file it will work. But given how long it takes to do that, 1) I'd like to know it will work and 2) tougher for me to consider utilizing the free option of doing this for all ~400 GB of data.

SeanKilleen··on "It's the (Backblaze) restores that fail."
I wanted to post this here to bring attention to what happens when trusting a cloud backup provider with your data, as well as to spur Backblaze to hopefully pay more attention to this part of their business model.

Again, while I say it in the post, I think it's important to state again that the CEO has been great in allowing a dialog via Twitter. This is not a post meant to diss Backblaze as much as it is to share concerns and put the thought out there for consideration.

As the CEO Mr. Budman notes in the Storify link, they no doubt do hundreds of successful restores every day. But when I have two working systems fail for Backblaze restores but nothing else, it's still a cause of concern for me personally.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →