HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ShannonAlther

312 karma · joined April 27, 2017

submissionscomments
ShannonAlther··on Ask a Female Engineer: Thoughts on the Google Memo
You didn't just add emphasis, you changed the original text from "leftist" to "leftists" and failed to indicate this, which is dishonest.
ShannonAlther··on Ask a Female Engineer: Thoughts on the Google Memo
'Page' argues that because Damore didn't mention that men score higher on aggression and lower on cooperation, this is evidence of motivated reasoning.

Counterpoint: Damore only lists personality traits that lead to interest in engineering, thus leading to an imbalance in the talent pool from which Google hires. Rarely is an extremely high propensity for agreeableness a motivating factor for getting an engineering degree at Stanford.

ShannonAlther··on Ask a Female Engineer: Thoughts on the Google Memo
As many people have pointed out before, making the hiring process blind doesn't do what you seem to think it'll do. There was a famous study (can't find it right this second on mobile) where researchers found that the ratio of black hires to white hires decreased when their resumes were submitted with all identifying information scrubbed.
ShannonAlther··on Skip grep, use awk
There was an awk/perl thread yesterday too.
ShannonAlther··on Americans Are Wary of Being Alone with the Opposite Sex
Not at all. I'm just positing that to interact with someone means risking social interaction that you don't want – serial harassment, for example. The only surefire way to never be securely harassed is to never talk to anyone.

You shouldn't do that, of course. But one-on-one meetings are extremely useful in many lines of work, and are also a time when you're likely to be accosted. This whole article is about how a ridiculous fraction of people polled think co-ed one-on-one meetings aren't kosher.

ShannonAlther··on Americans Are Wary of Being Alone with the Opposite Sex
Unfortunately, potentially compromising situations are the best way to get things done. If you want to avoid other people, you're going to be spending a lot of time at home by yourself, so to speak.
ShannonAlther··on Generating convincing audio and video of fake events
The point wasn't about outdated morality. It could just as easily be a doctored video of Theresa May stabbing a man to death in cold blood.

I think you've focused too much on the specific examples I gave. Consider a faked video of your SO committing adultery, or a faked video of you committing a crime that's used to convict you, or a video of Merkel saying Putin has erectile disfunction or something.

You can't just analyze these videos for inconsistencies; at some point, the technology becomes more powerful than human ability to discern whether it's real. Then what? What do we do once video evidence becomes unreliable?

(By "shocked into silence" I mean, "stunned by how asinine/insane/pointless/cruel that just was".)

ShannonAlther··on As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail
I strongly suspect that Europe would be spending more money on defense particularly against Russia and maybe China if America weren't backing them.

America also contributes to international military endeavors more than any other countries, like the UN peacekeepers. I'm not an expert by any means.

And really, you can't think of countries with more moral responsibility for the planet's current state? Not China, not the Soviet Union, none?

ShannonAlther··on As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail
That power stems from military spending, though. Not only that, America spends so much on its military to compensate for the fact that most of its allies spend significantly less on theirs; without the so-called pax Americana the world would look very different.
ShannonAlther··on Generating convincing audio and video of fake events
The issue, unfortunately, is that if I were to generate a video of Mike Pence doing something X-rated with another man, there's no conceivable way the scientific method would help. I mean, if he were a closeted homosexual, would you really immediately discount it as faked just because the evidence was against it? That happens to conservative American politicians all the time.

Worse, the current president has set a new bar for saying outlandish things. Every time he opens his mouth I am literally shocked into silence. The number of things I genuinely cannot imagine him saying is shrinking rapidly. If you were to see a video of Trump walking up to a podium like Obama did when he announced Bin Landen's death and saying very solemnly that bombs were about to be dropped on Russia, would your first thought be "Preposterous! There's no way the man would do that; it must be a clever hoax."

Not to mention that if this technology becomes exceptionally user-friendly it could be used to destroy lives in myriad ways. Where is your science now?

ShannonAlther··on Americans Are Wary of Being Alone with the Opposite Sex
One thing I've noticed about American culture, versus the other countries I've been/worked in, is that it's highly litigious. I suspect that one of the reasons people feel uncomfortable is the threat of lawsuit (or being buried in a corporate landslide triggered by policies designed to avoid lawsuit). This in addition to the finger-pointing at older Evangelical attitudes in the article...
ShannonAlther··on Awk vs. Perl (2009)
+1 for "architecture astronauts", you made my day.
ShannonAlther··on Facebook Hits 2 Billion Users
Facebook is non-rivalrous but is is excludable (that is, one user of Facebook does not 'take up a slot' preventing any other users from using it, but you can be prevented from using it if you don't 'pay', i.e. follow the TOS).

In general, public goods are things like air, languages, street lights, and national defense. Facebook (as far as I know) is not critical to your safety or survival, so you'd have a devil of a time trying to convince anyone that it's a public good.

As a litmus, I would wager that the odds of Facebook or any other website becoming a public good before the internet are nearly zero, so once it happens to the internet, we'll come back to it.

ShannonAlther··on Brooklyn’s Latest Craze: Making Your Own Electric Grid
The article even mentions that the utility provider ConEd in Brookyln offers green energy, so there's almost no point in LO3's services.

Not that I'm an expert in electrical grids, but I'd rather the actual grid coordinate a changeover to renewable sources, because these actors just sound like they're selling a scam that'll end with a class-action lawsuit someday.

ShannonAlther··on Awk vs. Perl (2009)
I find Perl extremely useful for making prototypes really quickly, and never learned how to use Awk because I only started with Perl in the first place a year or two ago. I'm sure it's just a matter of preference.
ShannonAlther··on “Let her speak please”
"Are you saying we should fix when people geek out about a topic and ramble?"

"It may be uncomfortable, but it's the only way to make cultural progress."

And you've really only explained what tacit rules are and how they're enforced, but we knew that already so bully, I guess? The guy talked over her because he was excited and therefore not thinking about the consequences.

ShannonAlther··on “Let her speak please”
Yes you did, but then you said that the solution is to reform society so that informal social rules are never broken. And I'm saying that unless you want to make those rules into laws, or something like laws, it's not doable.
ShannonAlther··on “Let her speak please”
You're using a different definition of 'offensive' than I am. Also, note that no societies we regard highly have outlawed talking over people. Unless your plan is to modify institutions to reduce offensive behaviour you won't have much luck.
ShannonAlther··on “Let her speak please”
"Prevent all potentially offensive behaviour" is not a valid solution. What constitutes offense is subjective, and furthermore the topic at hand is sexism.
ShannonAlther··on Stop trying to ‘be original’ and be prolific instead (2016)
But wealthy people DO have access to better internet (speed and quantity) and have more leisure time to enjoy media. Also you can do other neat things, like pay for your childrens' education. THAT is a list that goes on for a while.

And the statistically average American is barely treading water. I realize that the average European is better off, but that's not relevant to America right now.

ShannonAlther··on Introducing Business Chat [video]
As of 5 June 2017, 5:00 pm UTC-4, there was no video. I predict this is going to be a unifying reviews/information tool for the Apple ecosystem.

But I hope it's also a competitor for Slack.

ShannonAlther··on Stop trying to ‘be original’ and be prolific instead (2016)
Hyperbole about stress-induced medical problems aside, money is quantifiably good. A man who makes 10x your salary can take 10x more vacations to the south of France, justify taking more time off work to spend with his family, doesn't have to worry as much about monetary concerns like loan payments or health problems, and so on. It's not just "impressing your friends", having a nice car can be a joy in and of itself, but I'm always weirded out by people who say they don't want social status.
ShannonAlther··on The long, slow, rotten march of progress
For most systems the bar for meaningful contribution is too high - the average trucker who has trained to code cannot participate in automating transportation, for instance.
ShannonAlther··on We plan to have Chrome hide ads that do not comply with the Better Ads Standards
The internet wasn't designed with a mechanism to force clients to pay hosts for server time, unfortunately.
ShannonAlther··on The long, slow, rotten march of progress
Normally I don't like Sam Kriss' writing, and here it's because of the civil war comparison that just feels ham-fisted — that said, one can appreciate how "learn to code" is not the universal solution (especially when it's just thrown out as a conversation-stopper).
ShannonAlther··on WebAssembly: Mozilla Won
Mozilla claims that Servo's parallelization will improve performance, and that Rust's features will improve security.
ShannonAlther··on First robot cop to join Dubai Police by May, official says
I'm skeptical that the robot will work as well as one might expect, but the real gem in this article is that Dubai is building a DNA bank. Let's see how that pans out.
ShannonAlther··on The US has forgotten how to do infrastructure
I'm not American, sadly. I'm from Ontario. You're right, it's not literally impossible but it's way more effort and time than it would be worth.
ShannonAlther··on The US has forgotten how to do infrastructure
If I had the choice to go live in Manhattan and not have a car vs. live somewhere else and be obligated to own a car I would choose Manhattan in a heartbeat. Unfortunately, I can't do that (and even if I could, most people cannot).
ShannonAlther··on The US has forgotten how to do infrastructure
Counterpoints:

* Slowdowns, sure, but many drivers also exceed the limit, and the walking:driving ratio is still massively lopsided.

* Pedestrians are not immune to red lights.

* While there are certainly pedestrian shortcuts that are faster than driving, this is definitely not the case for most combinations of start and end points. Far more often, while the pedestrian might gain distance, the car is still literally 10x faster.

* In fact, unless you live in an extremely dense city, it's highly unlikely that there will be a grocery shop, book store, electronics retailer, Italian restaurant, furniture store, etc. less than 5km from your house. Plus all of the people who you might want to visit, your school, place of work, and so on.

* A bike is not walking. Most bikes are for one person, so if you're in a group they're not much use.

* Carrying purchases home is a pain. I should know, I did this for two years.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →