HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SilasX

17,815 karma · joined December 6, 2011

blog: http://blog.tyrannyofthemouse.com

Github: http://github.com/SilasX/

email: sbarta@gmail.com

Location: Austin, TX (left the Bay Area August '18).

Studying infosec to make a new career out of it.

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/silasbarta; my proof: https://keybase.io/silasbarta/sigs/EIsQUp3Ln8z5fOgzWFj9alDI8Ci9Vl4JSgP5OZQcmjU ]

submissionscomments
SilasX··on Coinbase says hackers bribed staff to steal customer data, demanding $20M ransom
Yes, electronic transfer.

Come on, if you’re going to copy someone else’s snark, pick a good one.

SilasX··on How “The Great Gatsby” took over high school
In the YouTube comments for the song "Informer" by Snow ("Informer, <lots of words>, a licky boom-boom now"), someone refers to it as "the final boss of learning English".

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSffz_bl6zo

(Edit: can't find that specific comment, link just goes to the music video.)

SilasX··on How “The Great Gatsby” took over high school
I agree with the suggestion to try it, because I've had similar experiences myself in a different area: history. Even reading the dry Wikipedia articles made the old topics seem much more interesting than I remembered them being in school, and did a better job at communicating the significance.

However, I wouldn't be so optimistic about your experience being universal. As an experiment, I just started re-reading The Great Gatsby. While it's much better than I remember, it still felt like a slog and failed to hook me in a way that such prized "you have to be familiar with this" literature should be. And I still think they could have done a better job communicating what's so good about it.

Relatedly, I only recently learned that some (most?) people actually like iambic pentameter, that it adds to the joy of hearing the lines read. This is a revelation, since it ... doesn't do anything for me. But that fact feels like it's important subtext that could have been communicated, and I could have been pushed in that direction -- that seems like the obvious move. And yet it just wasn't. Sure, they taught that Shakespeare used it, but only as a dry "oh hey this is one thing to note about his works" not in a "oh and this is a big part of its appeal".

There are a lot of missed opportunities for teaching appreciation of literature.

SilasX··on Anti-Personnel Computing (2023)
I'm just ... dumbfounded at why it isn't "anti-personal computing". Like, as a riff on "personal computer/computing".

Related: the scene in Bojack Horseman:

"And this time, it's personnel!"

'Uh, shouldn't the line be, "It's personal"?'

"No, because it's like, he's saying it's an inside job, so, personnel."

SilasX··on US Copyright Office found AI companies breach copyright. Its boss was fired
That's just the usual hand-wavy, vague "it's different" argument. If you want to justify treating the cases differently based on a fundamental difference, you need to be more specific. For example, they usually define an amount of rainwater you can collect that's short of disrupting major water flows.

So what is the equivalent of "digging too much" in a beach for AI? What fundamentally changes when you learn hyper-fast vs just read a bunch of horror novels to inform better horror novel-writing? What's unfair about AI compared to learning from published novels about how to properly pace your story?

These are the things you need to figure out before making a post equating AI learning with copyright infringement. "It's different" doesn't cut it.

SilasX··on US Copyright Office found AI companies breach copyright. Its boss was fired
The problem is, you can say all of that for human learning-from-copyrighted-works, so that point isn't definitive.
SilasX··on US Copyright Office found AI companies breach copyright. Its boss was fired
>My opinion: I think using copyrighted data to train models for sure seems classically illegal. Despite that, Humans can read a book, get inspiration, and write a new book and not be litigated against. When I look at the litany of derivative fantasy novels, it's obvious they're not all fully independent works.

Huh? If you agree that "learning from copyrighted works to make new ones" has traditionally not been considered infringement, then can you elaborate on why you think it fundamentally changes when you do it with bots? That would, if anything, seem to be a reversal of classic copyright jurisprudence. Up until 2022, pretty much everyone agreed that "learning from copyrighted works to make new ones" is exactly how it's supposed to work, and would be horrified at the idea of having to separately license that.

Sure, some fundamental dynamic might change when you do it with bots, but you need to make that case in an enforceable, operationalized way.

SilasX··on Ask HN: What are good high-information density UIs (screenshots, apps, sites)?
I assume the analogy meant, "It's great in theory, but in practice no one does it right."
SilasX··on WeightWatchers files bankruptcy
"Stop drinking" doesn't work for most alcoholics, because they go back to drinking. Simple as.

"Don't commit violent crimes" doesn't work for most violent criminals, because they go back to committing violent crimes. Simple as.

"Stop gambling" doesn't work for compulsive gamblers, because they go back to gambling. Simple as.

"Have superhuman willpower in a domain where I don't feel temptation" isn't a cure, it's unempathetic judgment.

SilasX··on Google can train search AI with web content even with opt-out
Disagreeing with me doesn't mean my criticism is attacking a strawman. That's not what the term means. The websites are, in fact, permitting you to view them, while insisting you not learn anything from the content.

That's not fundamentally different from when employers "explicitly refuse" you learning from your job with them to use at the next one. Sure, they certainly want that, but the law doesn't recognize it as a valid constraint (except for e.g. trade secrets and proprietary knowledge).

SilasX··on Google can train search AI with web content even with opt-out
Yes, that's an important thing to worry about. I'm just not sure that "learning from a website's content how to create other intellectual works without explicit permission from the owner to do so" counts as lying, manipulating, or stealing.
SilasX··on Former Disney employee who hacked Disney World menus sentenced to 3 years
That's not true. They're obligated to make good faith arguments consistent with the legal profession's ethics code, that don't deliberately waste the court's time with rabbit holes, not just throw forth everything that might stick because they duped the right judge. (This came up IIRC when Trump's lawyers made such arguments to dispute the 2020 election results.)

"Disney+'s terms of services categorically shields us from all legal liability" is not a good-faith argument, and, if accepted generally, would create a world no one seriously wants to live in, including those lawyers.

This is especially true when Disney had an actually reasonable, good-faith argument in this case, that the law can't pass on liability for everything a restaurant does wrong, just because you recommend it, especially when the regulation and management of that restaurant is totally out of your control. This would create a horrible world where no one can make a recommendation without thereby becoming responsible for everything that goes wrong at that establishment later.

SilasX··on Why training AI can't be IP theft
That's an unfair reading of my comment.

For one thing, I was replying to your own attempt to do a programmer style legalism, of "welp, you instantiated a copy, therefore it must be copyright infringement, case closed". I was already basing that on the principle you're now appealing to, to say that that isolated fact alone doesn't settle the matter (which is a much lower bar than the broader point that, all things considered, generative AI isn't infringement).

It's great that you recognize that programmer-style legalisms don't work in the law! It just wish you'd had that insight in mind when making your original comment.

Second, to the extent that I endorsed the general argument (generative AI not infringing), I wasn't claiming that the point worked because of some mechanistic technicality, but because of the very broad trend of accepting internal copies for a wide range of saleable data products. That is, in fact, how analogical reasoning works in law: courts compare the case at hand to similar ones.

Is any one point definitive? Of course not. But brushing off all analogies is unjustified deflection. If you think there are more pressing considerations that override the pattern I've pointed to -- like why the "intent, impact, etc" matter here -- great! I'm happy to have that conversation. But you can't just gesture at "legal rigor is hard" as if that's some kind of counterargument.

SilasX··on Intuit, Owner of TurboTax, Wins Battle Against America's Taxpayers
Well, there are two things going on here.

Norquist does oppose efforts by the IRS to (partially) obviate TurboTax by having the IRS do your taxes [1].

Separately, he has the anti-tax pledge you mention. The former is not entailed by the latter, at least in any obvious way.

So the parent is right about Norquist opposing filing simplification, but wrong about it being related to the infamous pledge.

[1] For those asking for a citation, here's a recent tweet: https://x.com/GroverNorquist/status/1912592196894630291

SilasX··on Why training AI can't be IP theft
But what about that kind of scale matters to this particular area? The article spends a lot of time showing the substantive parallels between how humans and AIs learn e.g. in how they never store an exact copy, but a high-level understanding that rarely produces anything verbatim.
SilasX··on Why training AI can't be IP theft
What is that replying to? I was addressing the argument that "well, you stored the work in memory, therefore you infringed copyright". It seems like you agree that that jump doesn't follow, just as I argued?
SilasX··on Why training AI can't be IP theft
>Even if we accept the house-of-cards of shaky arguments this essay is built on, even just for the sake of argument, where Open AI breaks my copyright is by having a computer "memorize" my work. That's a form of copy.

No, it isn't, unless you're also going to call it copyright infringement when search engines store internal, undistributed copies of websites for purposes of helping answer your search queries.

Edit: or, for that matter, accessing a website at all, which creates a copy on your computer.

SilasX··on Why training AI can't be IP theft
I agree that you should call the output copyright infringement (or not) without regard to how you got there. So, if it produces an identical copy of the text, or of e.g. Indiana Jones, that you then distribute it, sure, that is copyright infringement.

But the mere act of using them for training and producing new works shouldn't be! In fact, until 2022, pretty much no one regarded it as a copyright violation to "learn from copyrighted works to create new ones" -- just the opposite! That's how it's supposed to work!

Only when hated corporations did it with bots, did the internet hive mind suddenly decide that's stealing, and take this expansive view of IP rights (while, of course, having historically screamed bloody murder about any attempts to fight piracy).

SilasX··on Trump temporarily drops tariffs to 10% for most countries
For generous definitions of "funny", maybe.
SilasX··on Why Companies Don't Fix Bugs
To repeat my litany of shirking:

1) We don't need software tests because we have a QA team.

2) We don't need a QA team because we can just watch for user bug reports.

3) We don't need to watch for user bug reports because anything that actually matters will show up in the usage or sales stats.

4) We don't need to watch the usage or sales stats because it's redundant with our general financial picture.

5) We don't need to watch our general financial picture because we already have a canary in the form of repo men hauling furniture out of the lobby.

Different companies have different standards for when they start noticing and caring about a bug.

SilasX··on The booming, high-stakes arms race of airline safety videos
Yes! I loved that one! I was singing it afterward. ("Thank you for your attention, this robot rap is over")

I'm impressed that they were able to slip in a jab about the ridiculousness of having to tell you how to buckle a seatbelt.

SilasX··on The April Fools joke that might have got me fired
I'm not claiming to be better than anyone, I just want to know if there's some subtlety I'm missing, or it's just people overplaying regular toilet humor.

If toilet humor is your thing -- more power to ya! I just have a hard time reconciling it with "best joke ever".

SilasX··on The April Fools joke that might have got me fired
Because it's so hard to come up with something inappropriate to do in a work environment?
SilasX··on Why America now eats a crazy number of avocados
Oh dang, the policy discriminates against frozen avocados? Maybe just a filler word.
SilasX··on xAI has acquired X, xAI now valued at $80B
That’s generous. One party is stubbornly missing that the Delaware court’s ruling is weak evidence of a proper valuation having been done, but wants to parrot an irrelevant textbook understanding that obfuscates that conclusion.
SilasX··on The Wright brothers invented the airplane, right? Not if you're in Brazil
This. What held up wheeled luggage was the difficulty of having small, reliable wheels that could bear a lot of weight. You could have big wheels, but that would be impractical here, though not for chariots, wheelbarrows, pushcarts, or rickshaws ... which did exist in antiquity.
SilasX··on Past and Present Futures of User Interface Design
>For all those scenarios, I wish for some kind of microphone/device that could read from subvocalizations or lip movement.

There's a similar issue with those automated phone interfaces that "helpfully" require you to speak what you want, because you have to restart every time a pet or child screams. In those cases, it's better to have "press 1 for <whatever>", but it would also be an improvement to have it only read from your lips, so you wouldn't have to worry about background noise.

SilasX··on US appeals court rules AI generated art cannot be copyrighted
It doesn't sound like you're disputing my core point, that he's

- trying to benefit (financially) from the unrebutted presumption that the picture shows the monkey's self-awareness and understanding that it's taking a selfie

while also

- trying to benefit (in the courts) from the diametrically opposite position that the picture shows no such thing because of how staged it is.

Thus, "trying to have it both ways".

If your point is just that I shouldn't have represented the subtext of his marketing as an actual quote, while it's okay to do that for the argument he made in the courts ... sure, point conceded.

SilasX··on US appeals court rules AI generated art cannot be copyrighted
You missed that the selling point of the picture is the supposed self awareness and intent involved in the monkey taking a selfie?

Yes, of course the author has always wanted the copyright. But the whole reason the picture has value contradicts the basis for that copyright claim. You can’t simultaneously say that you did all the work, and that it’s so cool to see a genuine, self-directed monkey selfie.

SilasX··on US appeals court rules AI generated art cannot be copyrighted
It always felt to me like the photographer was trying to have it both ways there:

"Whoa! Isn't this sooo trippy! A monkey showing self-awareness to take a picture of itself!"

Courts: "Okay, the monkey took it, so no copyright for you."

"No, you don't get it! I put in a ton of work to stage that to the point that the monkey just had to be in the right place at the right time. Hell, a worm could have triggered it!"

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →