SpiegS

Never needed to do something with layer2. I used it mostly for educational purposes for my home network. Can you name some real world examples when OSI layer2 filtering is needed?

I've used shorewall for some time. As a matter of fact, installed it on my recent laptop as well (archlinux). But till now I didn't like quite often config file format changes, because of which I needed to figure out how to change current config to match the latest one. PF in this regard was more consistent and more readable and didn't requre to use anything on top of it. Then again - I never needed very complex FW rules.

Basically I like the pf's syntax. As already mentioned - it reads like a prose

Still, nothing beats OpenBSD's pf